XII .
A Letter from Arthur Dobbs Esq ; of Castle-Dobbs in Ireland , to the Rev. Mr. Charles Wetstein , Chaplain and Secretary to His Royal Highness the Prince of Wales , concerning the Distances between Asia and America .
SIR , I AM extremely obliged to you for the Trouble you have taken , in corresponding with Professor Euler * upon the Russian Discoveries Eastward from Kamschatka , and communicating to me the Accounts he had of Behring 's last Voyage , and of his Discovery of the Lands North-East of Japon ; which the Professor could only have inaccurately , not having seen any Journal to fix the Latitude and Longitude of the Countries he then discovered : But since Professor Euler , swayed by the Opinion of Captain Behring , seems still to believe that the last Land he discovered is joined to California , which Country is now known to be Part of the Continent of America , and not an Island ( in which Fact of its being continuous to California I differ still in Opinion from him , ) for , if that were a Fact to be depended upon , I would candidly own , that there could be no Passage from the North-West of Hudson's-Bay to the Western Ocean of America , without sailing near 700 of Longitude ; the Distance of the North-East Cape of Asia from the North-West of Hudson's-Bay , in a Parallel almost as far North as the Polar Circle , before the Passage can Read April 9 .
1747 .
* See Trans. No. 482 , p. 421 .
can be made to the Pacific Ocean ; which might therefore be very reasonably called an impracticable Passage , as it could not possibly be made in one Summer , if at all ) ; and since Professor Euler has been so kind as to give me Captain Behring 's Reasons for supporting his Opinion , which are principally from the small Distance he supposed it was , from the Coast he discovered , to the Western American Coast at California ( which he imagined was much nearer his North-East Cape of Asia than it is in Fact ) ; I must therefore , in return to the Professor 's Goodness , in communicating to me all he has known in that Discovery , beg Leave to give you this further Trouble of communicating to the Professor my Reason for still dissenting from Behring 's Opinion , that the Land he discovered last was Part of the Continent of America , or continuous with California ; and if he find the Reasons for supporting my Opinion make it more probable , that there still may be a large Opening betwixt these new-discover 'd Countries and California , I am sensible it will give the ingenious and learned Professor great Pleasure , to think we may yet hope for a Passage by Hudson's-Bay to the Western American Ocean , without being obstructed with Ice after passing Hudson's-Sreight .
The Professor imagines I might have been led astray , by not considering , that the North-East Cape of Asia is much more Easterly than has been laid down in any former Charts ; which is now known accurately , by the Eclipse of the Moon observed by Captain Behring at Kamschatka .
I have an Abstract of his Journal by me , upon his first Discovery in 1728 , and 1729 , when he observed that Eclipse , and the Calculation of the Longitude from it ; and stand by his Longitude he has fixed ; and allow that his North-East Cape is in the other Hemisphere ; reckoning Eastward , either from Fero , as the first Meridian , or from London ; which last I shall follow .
Behring fixes his North-East Cape 1260 7~ East Longitude from Tobolski ; and Tobolski is 860 East from Fero ; so the Cape is 2120 7~ East of Fero , or about 1940 East from London .
By Captain Middleton 's Observation of Jupiter 's Satellite at Churchill River in Hudson 's Bay , that River is 950 West from London ; which , added to 1940 , makes 2890 ; consequently the North-East Cape of Asia is 710 distant from Churchill , to complete 3600 ; which , in the Latitude of 650 , computing 8 Leagues to a Degree of Longiude , of which 20 make a Degree of Latitude , the Distance betwixt that Cape and Hudson 's Bay would be 568 such Leagues .
From the known Longitude of the North Cape of Japon in 400 Latitude , which is pretty exactly known , from the Observations made by the Jesuits at Peking , and is about 1500 East from London , and from the best computed Longitude of California in 400 North Latitude , it lies in 1300 Longitude West from London , making together 2800 , leaves 800 for the Distance of California from Japon ; allowing 17 Leagues to a Degree of Longitude in 400 North Latitude , the Distance would be about 1360 Leagues : By the same Calculation California must be at least 7 or 800 such Leagues from the North-East Cape of Asia ; so that , in so great a Space there may be very great Countries or Islands * , without supposing the new discovered Country continuous to California , and might well allow of an open Chanel or Sea , from 50 to 100 Leagues wide , between the discovered Coast and California .
By the Account given to Professor Euler , Behring sailed Southwardly to the Isles of Japon , and from thence sailed Eastwardly 50 German Miles , about 250 English Miles ; which makes about 80 Leagues , of 20 to a Degree .
At that Distance from Japon he discovered Land , which he coasted North-West ; still approaching towards the North-East Cape , without going ashore , until he came to the Entrance of a great River ; where sending his Boats and Men ashore , they never returned , being either lost , killed , or detained by the Natives , which made his Discovery incomplete ; his Ship being stranded , and he afterwards died in an uninhabited Island .
As no Latitudes nor Longitudes are fixed by this Account , I must believe he sailed from Kamschatka South-East , perhaps more Southerly than to 50~ Latitude ; and there found Land North-East from Japon ; otherwise , by coasting it North-West , he could never approach the North-East Cape , which is , at least , 40~ Longitude East of Japon ; and if he made Land 80 Leagues East of Japon , he must have sailed North-East to make the North-East Cape .
I have therefore Reason to believe this Coast was Part of that he saw in his first Voyage , where he lost his Anchor ; and is the Coast Gama discovered , and the Dutch afterwards called the Company 's Land , East of the Streights of Uzicez , which is at least 7 or 800 Leagues * The Japonese , in their Maps of the World printed in Japon , have laid down in this very Tract two Islands as large as Ireland , with the Names to them , as appears in that Map bought by Dr. Kempfer in Japon in 1686 ; now in Sir Hans Sloane 's Museum .
Leagues West of any known Land of America , and above 1000 near the Latitude of Japon : So that , if I should allow 700 Leagues for Countries or Islands East of his new-discover 'd Coast , there might still be a Passage of 100 Leagues for the Southern or Pacific Ocean to communicate with Hudson 's Bay , and to cause such great Tides and Currents , as are found on the North-West of Hudson's-Bay ; as also a free Passage for the Whales , which are seen in all the Openings North-West of that Bay , and are caught there in Numbers by the Eskemaux Savages : For , as these do n't go in by Hudson 's Straight from our Atlantic Ocean , it cannot be presumed that they should go up by Japon towards the North~ East Cape , and from thence go 70~ , or above 560 Leagues , to Hudson 's Bay , and be there in the Month of June , and , after staying until September , return again the same Way to the Southern Ocean , to pass the Winter .
Now , as Behring only coasted at a Distance , he could not possibly know whether it was a Continent , or great Island ; the last of which seems the most probable : However , a few Months now , if our Ships return safe , will give us a Certainty on one Side or the other ; altho ' I am sanguine enough to believe~ they have by this time sailed through , and discovered this so much wished for Passage .
These , Sir , are the Reasons I have still to expect Success in the Attempt I have promoted ; and , if you think it may give any Satisfaction to Professor Euler to know the Reasons that support my Belief of a practicable safe Passage , be pleased to communicate it to him , with my Compliments for the Trouble I have given him by you , and accept of my best Acknowledgments for your Favours .
I am , with the greatest Regard and Esteem , SIR , Your most obedient humble Servant , Arthur Dobbs .
Castle-Dobbs , Feb. 10 .

