A Letter from Mr. Richard Dunthorne , to the Rev. Mr. Cha .
Mason , F. R. S. and Woodwardian Professor of Not .
Hist. at Cambridge , concerning the Moon 's Motion .
SIR , IN the Preface to my lunar Tables , I hinted , that one Use of publishing those Tables would be , the assisting of Persons desirous farther to rectify the lunar Astronomy , by enabling them more readily to compare the Newtonian Theory with Observations .
Read Feb. 5 .
1746 7 .
Cambridge , Nov. 4 .
1746 .
Since the Publishing those Tables , I have spent some Time myself in that Comparison ; and here send you the Result , that you may communicate it to the Royal Society , if you think it deserves to be made public .
As the Motion of every secondary Planet must partake of the Errors in the Theory of its primary , I thought proper , before I undertook the Examination of the lunar Numbers , to compare those of the Sun with Observations .
I compared several Sets of Mr. Flamestead~s Observations , after the Method he himself teaches , in Prolegom .
Hist. Caelest , p. 133 , &amp; seq. which , for many Reasons , I think the best Method hitherto used ; and , with the Concurrence of a Gentleman well skilled in these Matters , determined the mean Motion of the Sun at Greenwich , the last Day of December at Noon , Anno 1700 , O. S. ~ 20~ 43~ 40~ of its Apogee , ~ 7~ 30~ 0~ , and the greatest Equation of the Sun 's Centre 1~ 55~ 40~ ; which , I am fully persuaded , are very near the Truth .
The Theory of the Sun being thus settled , I proceeded to examine the Elements of the lunar Astronomy .
I began with Observations of lunar Eclipses about the Equinoxes , when the Apogee of the Moon was in the Sun 's Quadratures ; because at those Times I could conceive the Moon 's Motion affected with no Inequality , but the annual one , called by Newton the first Equation , and the elliptic one , called Prosthaphaeresis : From a Comparison of such Observations I obtained the Moon 's mean Longitude , which came out 1~ , at least , greater than in the Tables , and very nearly as Newton has it in the last Edition of his Principia .
I went on to examine the Place and Motion of the Apogee , and Theory of the Increase and Decrease of the Eccentricity , as well as the greatest and least Eccentricities themselves ( from the best Observations , and best situate that I could procure ) all which agreed so well with the Tables , about the Sun 's mean Distances , that I dare venture to make no Alteration therein : Indeed I think the 6th Equation does not so well account for the Variation of the Motion of the Apogee , and Change of the Eccentricity , tricity , according to the greater or lesser Distance of the Sun from the Earth ; and therefore I set myself to compute what Change this Difference of the Sun 's Action upon the lunar Orbit would introduce in the Moon 's Place in every Situation of the Sun and lunar Orbit ; and found , after many tedious Computations , that the Sun being in Apogee , this Change , where greatest , would amount to about 4~ , and to 4~ 16~ , when the Sun is in Perigee .
In other Distances of the Sun from the Earth , this greatest Change is proportional to the Difference of the Cubes of the mean and present Distances ; and in every Situation of the Moon , and of her Orbit , the present is to the greatest Equation nearly as the Sine of the Excess of the Moon 's mean Anomaly above twice the annual Argument to Radius .
It increases the Moon 's Longitude , when the Sun is in his ~ Apogeon ~~ less ~ Semicircle , and that Excess Perigeon greater than 180~ ; and diminishes it when otherwise * .
In fine , I compared the Theory of the Moon , as to her Longitude , with several Observations , as well in the Octants and Semi-Octants , as in the Syzygies and Quadratures , and found such an Agreement when the above Corrections were made , as seemed rather to be wished than hoped for , considering the many Inequalities wherewith the Sun 's Action disturbs the Motion * If this Equation be increased and diminished in a direct Ratio of the Moon 's horizontal Parallax , it will become more exact .
And I think , if it were always diminished by a fourth or perhaps a third Part , it would agree better with Observations .
Motion of the Moon , and the Defects to which the best Observations I have hitherto met withal are liable .
I have compared 100 observed Longitudes of the Moon with the Tables ; viz. 25 Eclipses of the Moon , all , except the sirst , taken from Flamstead 's Historia Caelestis , the Philosophical Transactions , and the Memoirs of the Royal Academy of Sciences ; the two great Eclipses of the Sun in 1706 and 1715 ; 25 select Places of the Moon from Flamstead 's Historia Caelestis , and 48 of those Longitudes of the Moon computed from Flamstead 's Observations by Dr. Halley ( as I suppose ) printed in the first Edition of the Historia Caelestis .
They are as follows : 25 Eclipses of the Moon , and 2 of the Sun , compared with the Tables corrected as above .
Place of Ob Apparent Time at ~ Place M. AnM .
AnAnn .
~ 's ~~ om A. D. servation .
Greenwich .
observed .
om .
~ om .
~ ~ .
~ .
~ .
h~~s~~~s~s~s~s~~~~~ ~ 1652 Septem .
7 .
6 21 35 11 25 25 51 2 20 62031 25 26 10 +0 19 ~ 1670 Sept. 18 .
14 36 48 06 13 29 31600 01/ 2 06 16 ~+38 Greenwich 1678 Octob. 19 .
8 21 54 16 47 9417 161/ 2 2216 46 38 0 31 1682 ~ .
11 .
10 58 52 53 47 37 25 6 281/ 2 1 14 53 46 14 0 49 Paris ~ Dec. 11 .
10 47 631 11 20 5 24 187 16 31 13 ~+1 47 ~ 1685 Nov. 30 .
10 35 30 2 19 40 05 13 11 261/ 2 5 25 2 19 39 46 0 14 Dublin 1686 Nov. 19 .
11 13 11 28 11 57 52 10 121/ 2 4 41/ 2 28 11 28 0 29 Greenwich 1689 Sept. 18 .
14 30 37 06 32 8314 24 10 806 34 16 +28 1690 March 14 .
9 56 30 64 37 11 8 25 9 18 3 151/ 2 64 37 28 +0 17 1696 May 6 .
12 207 26 53 14 10 18 3 11/ 2 8 28 7 26 53 40 +0 26 Paris 1699 March 5 .
7 13 ~5 25 32 27 8 16 8 27 315 25 32 14 0 13 New England 1703 Decem .
11 .
18 29 830 49 56 5 23 11 241/ 2 5 23 30 48 51 15 ~ ~ 1706 May 0 .
21 13 57 1 20 46 44 10 12 6 22 761 20 46 32 0 12 Greenwich Octob. 10 .
7 10 00 28 0 20 3 22 5 27 11 25 0 27 58 47 1 33 1707 April 5 .
13 39 06 26 18 33 9 17 11 9536 26 19 ~+0 36 1708 Sept. 18 .
9 10 25 06 39 23 312 12 8706 39 ~04 1712 ~ .
12 .
7 34 042 57 47 6 24 1 171/ 2 7 251/ 2 42 58 37 +0 50 Paris 1713 Nov. 20 .
15 27 30 29 58 21 539 21 3 17 29 56 56 1 25 ~ London 1715 April 21 .
21 11 51 12 0 22 10 36 121/ 2 6 22 1 11 59 36 0 46 Paris 1717 March 15 .
15 7466 23 50 8 26 8 221/ 2 2 27 66~~0 19 1719 August 18 .
8 22 46 11 5 42 81 29 10 28 4 20 11 5 42 39 +0 31 1722 June 17 .
13 46 10 96 47 43 11 29 5 81/ 2 10 25 96 47 33 0 10 1724 Octob. 20 .
15 40 40 1900425 251/ 2 11 22 18 58 50 1 10 1729 Febr. 2 .
8 42 55 4 25 13 39 7 16 3 25 9 14 4 25 14 40 +11 July 28 .
13 00 10 16 15 28 19832 15 10 16 16 26 +0 58 1731 June 8 .
13 47 51 8 28 9 58 11 19 4 27 10 11 8 28 ~ 45 1 13 ~ Nov. 20 .
0 40 25 2 10 3 54 53781 24 2 10 0~2 58 25 Places of the Moon , computed by myself from Flamstead 's Observations , compared with the Tables .
Apparent Time at ~ 's true Place M. AnM .
AnAnn .
~ 's Place Diff. from A. D. Greenwich .
observed .
om .
~ .
om .
~ .
Argt .
computed .
~ .
h~~s~~~s~s~s~s~~~~~ 1684 March 13 .
8982 28 48 40 8 25 2 25 11 19 2 28 50 44 +24 1693 March 6 .
7 22 48 3 16 43 12 8 17 3 111/ 2 11 73 16 44 0+0 48 Octob. 11 .
18 12 34 3 28 34 23 24 2 27 5 15 3 28 38 21 +4 19 1694 Febr. 27 .
10 29 16 4 27 27 31 8 10 3 12 9 20 4 27 26 48 0 43 August 23 11 13 54 11 0 19 11 25822 21 11 0 21 41 +2 30 1694 Septem .
15 .
5 34 13 8 27 1 34 2 27 6 10 3 11 8 27 1 41 +07 Septem .
21 .
10 50 31 11 22 47 41 339 31/ 2 3 17 11 22 49 16 +1 35 Decem .
13 .
62 53 06 28 43 5 25 8 261/ 2 6006 29 58 +1 15 1695 Febr. 8 .
3 55 22 15 14 37 21 9 71/ 2 7 22 15 12 14 1 49 July 9 .
5 56 14 722 42 0 20 3 14 027234+0 22 Septem .
8 .
8 30 26 10 30 12 2 20 5 21 1 24 10 2 59 50 0 22 1696 January 16 .
17 29 2754 20 6 29 2 29 5 201/ 2 756 11 +1 51 March 4 .
98 13 4 12 2 24 8 16 11 8734 12 0 59 1 25 1697 February 18 .
6 29 47 2 20 52 29 828 19 5 10 2 20 51 71 22 19 .
7 22 57 34 18 16 839 21/ 2 5 11 34 17 54 0 22 Septem .
15 .
7 54 ~ 10 1782 28 3 211/ 2 11 9 10 15 38 1 30 1698 Septem .
8 .
11 2 35 11 12 15 62 21 3 24 9 23 11 12 15 27 +0 21 Novem .
27 .
3 49 54 10 11 33 39 592~03 10 11 31 13 2 26 1699 March 5 .
12 8 23 5 28 15 59 8 16 8 291/ 2 315 28 16 11 +0 12 1701 Septem .
28 .
6 55 23 9 27 13 17 3 10 99689 27 12 49 0 28 1702 Octob. 16 .
6 16 49 10 3 25 41 3 28 8 111/ 2 5 13 10 3 26 27 +0 46 1703 Septem .
13 .
11 58 50 11 28 50 30 2 25 8 28 33 11 28 53 30 +30 Octob. 6 .
6 28 39 9 27 1 44 3 18 743 23 9 27 0 38 16 1706 Octob. 10 .
11 11 10 11 11 15 3 22 60 11 25 11 10 17 0 58 1714 Septem .
6 .
6 34 793 44 13 2 18 3 17 0093 45 24 +1 11 48 Places of the Moon , computed by Dr. Halley , from Flamstead 's Observations , compared with the Tables .
Apparent Time at ~ 's true Place M. AnM .
AnAnn .
~ 's Place Diff. from A.D. Greenwich .
observed .
om .
~ .
om .
~ .
Argt ~~ h~~s~~~~~s~s~s~~~~~ 1689 Novem .
16 .
11 59 026 12 43 4 29 610026 14 ~+1 57 Decem .
9 .
610 11 28 48 54 5 211/ 2 3 21 0 201/ 2 11 28 48 40 0 14 10 .
6 46 35 0 12 46 49 5 221/ 2 440 211/ 2 0 12 47 14 +0 25 12 .
8 26 33 1 12 13 85 241/ 2 5 01/ 2 0 23 1 12 10 39 2 29 13 .
9 24 30 1 27 38 36 5 251/ 2 5 14 0 24 1 27 36 16 2 20 16 .
12 42 03 15 14 54 5 281/ 2 6 24 0 27 3 15 15 48 +0 54 1690 January 4 .
33 46 11 11 12 59 6 17 2 24 1 14 11 11 13 8+09 6 .
4 30 15 08 13 31 6 19 3 201/ 2 1 16 08 14 36 +15 10 .
7 59 22 26 11 20 6 23 5 141/ 2 1 191/ 2 26 10 37 0 43 12 .
10 8 49 375 21 6 25 6 121 1 21 373 59 1 22 13 .
11 14 03 22 36 28 6 26 6 251/ 2 1 22 3 22 35 19 19 b February 2 .
2 25 39 03 57 24 7 151/ 2 352 10 03 56 91 15 5 .
4 51 10 1 16 31 33 7 181/ 2 4 26 2 121/ 2 1 16 34 15 +2 42 7 .
6 48 17 2 15 58 14 7 201/ 2 5 24 2 141/ 2 2 15 59 13 +0 59 8 .
7 51 54 30 56 20 7 211/ 2 682 151/ ~ 30 56 31 +0 11 10 .
9 56 26 40 55 24 7 24 762 17 4~ 55 10 23 11 .
10 52 31 4 15 42 16 7 25 7 20 2 18 4 15 41 49 0 27 14 .
13 19 31 5 28 12 40 7 28 922 21 5 28 11 44 0 56 19 .
17 3 55 82 23 ~83 11 12 2 251/ 2 82 21 17 29 21 .
18 45 37 8 27 1 25 850 10 2 271/ 2 8 26 59 62 19 1690 Febr. 22 .
19 37 40 99 21 32 860 24 2 28 99 23 26 +1 54 March 7 .
5 50 38 2 26 22 50 8 18 6 12 392 26 25 20 +2 30 11 .
9 43 23 4 24 31 45 8 22 883 13 4 24 33 15 +1 30 12 .
10 33 958 31 54 8 23 8 22 3 14 58 33 11 +1 17 ~ .
11 18 30 5 22 16 37 8 24 9 51/ 2 3 15 5 22 17 26 +0 49 14 .
12 2 18 65 44 39 8 25 9 191/ 2 3 151/ 2 65 45 18 +0 39 25 .
20 54 ~ 10 24 54 20 9 61/ 2 2 21 3 251/ 2 10 24 53 20 10 b April 7 .
7 48 46 4 20 809 19 85464 20 9 18 +1 18 8 .
8 36 30 53 59 40 9 20 8 19 47540 34 +0 54 9 .
9 22 05 17 34 42 9 21 92485 17 35 40 +0 58 10 .
10 5 19 60 54 50 9 22 9 16 4960 55 35 +0 45 11 .
10 47 56 6 14 089 23 9 29 4 10 6 14 2 13 +25 12 .
11 30 56 6 26 55 56 9 24 10 121/ 2 4 11 6 26 56 55 +0 59 13 .
12 17 31 79 41 19 9 25 10 26 4 12 79 42 20 +11 14 .
13 407 22 16 09 26 11 91/ 2 4 121/ 2 7 22 17 34 +1 34 15 .
13 52 44 84 45 10 9 27 11 23 4 131/ 2 84 44 47 0 23 18 .
16 26 47 9 11 43 52 10 01 31/ 2 4 16 9 11 44 53 +11 20 .
18 5 47 10 6 30 55 10 2204 18 10 6 33 2+27 22 .
19 37 30 11 286 10 42 27 4 20 11 28 45 +0 39 24 .
21 6 38 11 29 14 33 10 63 23~/ 2 4 211/ 2 11 29 14 30 03 May 14 .
13 30 30 8 25 6 53 10 251/ 2 07588 25 8 48 +1 55 b 22 .
19 41 40 06 50 26 11 31/ 2 3 23 5 15 06 49 43 0 43 June 3 .
62 13 5 22 31 45 11 15 8 19 5 25 5 22 32 6+0 21 Septem .
1 .
6 48 53 92 27 42 2 131/ 2 11 15 8 12 92 31 20 +3 38 8 .
12 16 42 01 44 51 2 21 2 22 8 18 01 44 18 0 33 1691 February 23 .
3 55 10 1 19 39 56 863 16 1 18 1 19 40 45 +0 49 March 11 .
18 27 51 97 30 58 221/ 2 10 231/ 2 2297 30 23 +0 18 Septem .
22 .
8 51 3 10 19 26 24 34 11 16 7 19 10 19 28 32 +2 8 a , The Time of the Middle of this Eclipse here set down is from the Beginning and End ; but Hevelius says he could not observe the Beginning exactly .
Several intermediate Phases compared together show the Middle to have been about 4~ sooner ; to which the Moon 's Place computed is os .
6~ .
14~ .
3~ .
and Diff. + 34~ .
b , b , b , The Moon 's Places , observed on Feb. 2 .
April 7 .
and May 22 .
are computed by myself , from the Observations ; there being manifestly Errors , either of the Computation or Press , in those printed in the Hist. Caelestis .
Several observed Latitudes of the Moon , which I have compared with the Tables , show them to be very near the Truth , both in the Motion of the Nodes , and also in the Quantity and Variation of the Inclination .
I am , SIR , Your humble Servant , Richard Dunthorne .

