XI .
A Dissertation on those fossil figured Stones called Belemnites ; communicated in a Letter from Mr. Emanuel Mendez da Costa to Martin Folks , Esq ; Pr .
R. S. SIR , THE Origin and Nature of the Belemnites having lately been greatly controverted , I have taken the Liberty to address to you the following Thoughts on that Subject ; and beg , Sir , if you think them worthy your Regard , you would lay them before the Royal Society , as a due Testimony of the great Respect I have for that Learned and Illustrious Body .
Read Jan. 29 .
1746-7 .
The Belemnites is a Fossil of different Magnitudes and Colours , ever regular in Shape , which is either cylindric , conic , or thereunto approacning .
Numbers of them have , on one Side only , a Chap or Seam running their whole Length ; others have it in Part ; and in others it is not at all to be observed : It consists of a talcy Matter , with an Intermixture of Spar or Crystal , disposed in Striae from or near its Centre to its Circumference , and is made up of Crusts enclosing each other , the innermost whereof is as regu are as the ourermost .
Sometimes , tho ' seldom , in comparison to the Numbers of the Belemnites , in the Centre is a Cavity ever conic , whatever the external Shape of the Belemnites be .
This conic Cavity is at different times empty , or else filled , either with a solid Body of mineral Matter , Crystal , Stone , Pyrites , etc. or with a regular jointed conic Body , called by Lithologist the Alveolus of the Belemnites ; which , tho ' constantly regular and jointed , is nevertheless found composed of various mineral or metallic Substances .
The Alveolus above-mention 'd , tho ' not fully proved such , yet seems , by the Assent of most of the present Naturalists , to be a Body of marine Origin ; a Shell the nighest related to the Nautilus Kind : It is concamerated , and even in some is discovered another great Characteristic of the Nautilus Kind , I mean the Gut or Siphunculus .
Therefore , taking this Body for granted to be of marine Origin ( for what Reasons , or of what Kind , is not my present intended Subject to prove ) it remains to discuss , Whether this Body became accidentally lodged in the Belemnites ?
or , Whether the Belemnites itself is also of marine Origin , and a Part dependent on its Alveolus ?
Various have been the Opinions of Lithologists concerning the Origin of the Belemnites ; some have even asserted them of the Vegetable Kingdom ; others , that they are Teeth or Horns of Fish , Appendages of Shells , Bodies cast in Shells of the Tubuli Kind , or the very Shells themselves , Spines of Echini , or a kind of strait Nautilus .
The three last Opinions are what I shall strive to confute , as they seem somewhat probable , and are now the most prevailing ; and prove the Belemnites to be a natural Fossil or Lapis sui generis .
I desire no Recourse to the Subterfuges used by others , but hope , Sir , you will agree with me in the Axiom , that all Belemnites are of one and the same Origin .
That the Belemnites are not Teeth or Horns of Fish , I shall refer you to the Letter your late learned Member Dr. John Woodward wrote on that Subject to Mr. Bourguet , of Switzerland , wherein he fully proves the Erroneousness of those Opinions .
But a further Argument against their being Teeth , which that learned Naturalist has not touched upon , is , that no Belemnites have that natural Varnish or Polish , which always covers the Teeth of all Animals ; whereas the greatest Part of those fossil Bodies , which we know to be such , as the Bufonitae , Glossopetrae , etc. are found with that same Varnish or Polish .
As for their owing their Form to being moulded in Shells , it will appear contradictory to Reason , when we consider , 10 .
Their Constitution to be ever as regular as their Figure ; and , 20 .
That their inner Layer or Nucleus is as equally regular as the outer Crust or whole Body ; which Particular could never have happened , had they been moulded in Shells ; as is evident , by the Turbinitae , Conchitae , and other Bodies , which owe their Figures to that Cause .
That the Belemnites are not Spines of Echini , let us first consider , that no Kinds hitherto discovered have been ever found to have Spines analogous to these Bodies ; nor indeed has any marine Shell whatever such a Texture .
The immediate Subterfuge for an Answer to this Objection is , that the Kinds of Shells unknown to Mankind are far more in Number than those yet discovered .
I allow it ; but think that cannot be an Argument in the present Case , since no one single Species is yet discovered with such , nor even any Genus , which have Spines analogous to the BelemF ff nites .
nites .
Nature bears an Analogy through all her Works ; and though all the Species of any one Genus is not known to any Man , yet that Analogy nevertheless capacitates us to judge of those undiscovered by those we know .
Thus we find of the Echinus Kind , all the Species now known are ever found near the Shores ; consequently , are not subject to be cternally hidden from us ; as is undoubtedly the Case of the Cornua Ammonis , and Conchae anomiae .
They are no pelagian Shells , as those are ; Bays and Harbours are the Places where they are sish 'd ; their Structure even evinces the Reasons for it .
We may therefore with Probability conclude , that all the Echinus Kind are of the same Nature , and have the same Way of living ; that they only inhabit such Places , and that none are pelagian Shells ; consequently might have been discovered .
I am sensible there are some Species of fossil Echini ; as , the most common conoid or pileated Echini , the common Echini galeati , the Echini clypeati , and some Kinds of the Echini ovarii , &amp;c. which tho ' we are certain that they have been marine Shells , yet those particular Species are not known in the Sea : But then several other Species of that same Genus are .
The Case of this is quite different , since not one single Species of such a Genus has ever been found .
The excessive Bigness and Thickness of Numbers of Belemnites described by Authors , viz. of near two Feet in Length , and above two Inches in Diameter in the thickest Part , others of three Feet long , and others as thick and long as a Man 's Arm ; not to enumerate those only under a Foot Length , and of proportionable Thicknesses , concludes Echini of a vast Bigness , to have a Number of such Spines to move .
The Varieties of the Belemnites , how can they quadrate to the Spines of one Genus of Echini only ?
Solid Belemnites , Belemnites with a single Crust , or like a Tube , with a conic Cavity only ; that empty , or otherwise filled with a solid Mass , or with a regular jointed Body , as the Alveolus Belemnites of various Magnitudes and Thicknesses , etc. can all these Varieties be imagined to belong to one Genus of Shells , which we suppose to exist to maintain a favourite System ?
The Number of Species of Echini discovered are numerous ; and the Spines of all those agree in having a hollow Axis , which runs proportionably from their Basis to their Apex , quite different to the Belemnites : And for their Constitution , a foreign Naturalist , a Member of the Royal Society , Mr. Klein of Dantzick , who has professedly wrote on this Subject , could only find of two Kinds , viz. those of a porous Constitution , which he observed only to belong to one Genus ; and those of a solid shattery Substance , like a talcy Spar not striated ; which is the most general , and is exactly the same Constitution as all the fossil Spines , or Lapides Judaici are .
Further , the Lapides Judaici have , at some times , been found adhering to their Papillae or Tubercles , and with Fragments of their Shells ; whereas no Naturalist has ever known to be found fossil either the Shells , or the Fragments of such a Genus of Echinus ; not even any Remains proportionable to such large Spines .
In whatever manner the greater Part of such Shells may have perished ( which is unlikely , if we consider their Texture and Strength ) , some must have escaped , when the Spines are found in such excessive Numbers every-where , and always perfect and regular ; whereas the fossil Spines , or Lapides Judaici , as they are called , as likewite the Echini or Shells , and all the fossil Bodies of marine Origin , are found broken and shattered in all kinds of Manners .
As for their being Shells of the Tubuli Kind , my Reasons against it are ; Were the Belemnites such , they must be all tubular more or less ; or otherwise must have suffered some Degree of Petrifaction to fill up their Cavities .
The Unreasonableness of that Argument is demonstrated by all Belemnitae being of one and the same Texture and Constitution ; tho ' Numbers are solid , and Numbers are tubular , in different Degrees .
Now one Kind of Petrifaction , or any other Change in the Earth , which they might have undergone , could never have given so regular a Texture and Substance , and cause such different Effects as Solidity and Tubularity .
And if , on the other hand , we allow it to be inconsistent , as it is , to form the Idea of a Shell of the Tubulus Kind , by a solid Body , without that Body having suffered some Change in the Earth , while buried in it , we must either deny all solid Belemnites to be such Tubuli , and run to Subterfuges , by owning them to be natural Fossils ; or else allow a great Inconsistency , to uphold a wrong System .
That the Belemnites are not a tubular Case , which is Part of , and covers a Shell of the Nautilus Kind , as is its Alveolus .
The Variety of Circumstances already alleged of the Belemnites serve to demonstrate the Improbability also of this Opinion , as it has done of the other two .
The Numbers of Belemnites of all kinds , so plentiful every-where , and the Consideration of how few are furnished with Alveoli .
Numbers , I am sensible , have conic Cavities ; but that those Cavities never did contain Alveoli , is evident ; that the Sides of the said Cavities are even , and without any circular or other Impressions , which a Belemnites that has ever contained an Alveolus must have ; that Body being in close Contact to all Parts of the investient Belemnites , must consesequently impress it with its Concamerations ; which Impressions must be therefore found on the Sides of the Cavities of all Belemnites which ever contained them .
As for asserting , that all the Alveoli , which are now found loose , were originally lodged in Belemnites , it cannot be ; without inferring also , that all Belemnites which are now devoid of Alveoli , contained such formerly ; which , by some external or other Agent , have been forced out and loosened from them .
To consider such an Agent , we must also conclude its Force to have been exceeding great , to loosen out the Nucleus of a Body in close Contact with all its investient Parts ; and strengthened further to it by Ridges and Grooves , such a Force must have compressed , shattered , and otherwise broken and destroyed the Belemnites that contained them ; which is contrary to Observation .
Further , forcing out the Alveolus might perhaps easily have happened to the conic Belemnites ; which hath a Basis of a larger Diameter than the Middle , where the Alveolus is lodged ; but we cannot conceive the same by the cylindric , fusiform , and other Belemnites , of which the two Ends or Extremes terminate pointed ; while the Middle , where the Alveolus is lodged , is thick and swelled .
To force an Alveolus out of such shaped Belemnites , it is evident , that the narrow Ends of the said Belemnites must be quite forced open , broken , and shattered , before a broader and more capacious Body could be forced through , especially to such a brittle shattery Fossil as the Belemnites is .
The evident Facts to the contrary of this are also too common to insist on , since all these Belemnites are ever found regular , perfect , and entire .
Further , let us consider the Alveoli which are now found in Belemnites , they are very seldom if ever found as mere Shells , but ever differently changed or petrified .
They are moulded of Stone , Pyrites , Crystal , etc. Now it can never be argued , that the contained Bodies can ever be so differently changed or petrified in their Covers or Shells , and those Covers or Shells which admitted such different petrifying Particles to undergo no Change or Petrification whatsoever .
Another Proof against this Opinion , is the diverse Forms of Alveoli now discovered by Naturalists , as conic , cylindric , curved , spiral at the Apex , &amp;c. whereas all Belemnites which have Cavities have none but conic ones .
These cylindric , etc. Alveoli are now found in Pomerellia in Poland , in the Marble of the Island of Oeiand in the Baltic Sea belonging to Sweden , and in the Marble of Sweden ; in Gothland in Masses of Building-Stone ; in Ingria , in several Parts of Prussia , etc. and are commonly of an immense Bigness , to several Feet in Length , and proportionably thick , yet not perfect .
For such Alveoli , which are only Nuclei , we must suppose immense large Belemnites ; and such we have never heard of , so with Probability we may conclude none such to exist .
I do not doubt the Growth of this Error , of the Belemnites being a Part of its Alveolus , to have been caused by too rash Conclusions , and too little an Insight into the fossil Kingdom ; which has propagated that Assertion of the Alveoli being found only in the Belemnites ; which Experience daily contradicts , since we find them loose , as well as imbedded in many other fossil Substances , as in Marble , Stone , etc. as has been above observed .
These are the Arguments which I allege , Sir , for the Improbability of the said Opinions .
I could advance a Number of other Proof ; but as I have already extended my Letter beyond a due Length , I beg Leave , before I conclude , only to offer some few Reasons for their being a natural Fossil , or Lapis sui generis .
The very View of a Belemnites sufficiently evinces its mineral Origin , and shows it evidently composed of two fossil Substances , a Talc , and a Spar , or bastard Crystal ; whereof the former is the Basis , and from which Principle I do not hesitate to attribute its striated Texture .
Most of the talcy Bodies are of a fibrous Nature , and several are composed of Crusts enclosing each other , in the same Manner as the Septa of the Ludus Helmontii , some of the Asbestos kind , the Haematites Crusts , etc. of the Stalactites lactites Tribe there are several , which so entirely approach the Texture and Constitution of the Belemnites , that were their Shapes a little more regular , the most experienced Lithologist might easily be deceived : And I remember , when abroad , to have seen such , of a prodigious Bigness , which , tho ' I was then somewhat conversant in the fossil Study , I could not help taking for Belemnites .
I do not therefore wonder , that Petrus Assaltus , in notis ad Metallothecam Mercati , p. 282 , and Langius , Hist. Lap .
figurat .
Helvetiae , p. 133 .
should judge them a native figured Fossil , formed in the Earth , of the Stalactites kind , if that Term for the Belemnites might with Propriety be used .
The Cavities of Stalactites in some measure illustrate , and are adequate to the Cavities of Belemnites ; they are placed in as various Positions , and are only different from them by not being exactly conic .
As for the regular Figure of the Belemnites being excepted against , I believe few Fossilists will argument that , when we see as perfect regular Figures in the fossil Kingdom as in any other Parts of the Creation ; as witness the Salts and Crystals of all Kinds ; the rhomboid , hexagonal , columnar , and other Selenites ; the cubic , octangular , dodecaedral , and other Pyrites ; the quadrangular Pyramids of Tin , the Rhombs of Iron , Cubes of Lead , and infinite other native Fossils , which would take up Time to enumerate , and which are far more perfect Figures than the Belemnites are .
Chemical and other Trials and Tests ( which I hope to have the Honour to lay before you in some future Letter ) demonstrate a greater Certainty of its mineral Origin .
As for that marine Body the Alveolus , I cannot think otherwise than that it is of the Nautilus Kind ; and which , at the Concretion or Formation of the Belemnites , became accidentally lodged in its Cavity , in the same manner as all other marine Bodies became lodged in the various fossil Substances we now find them in .
I beg , Sir , to remark , that the searching into the Origin of this Body is not merely curious , but of great Use ; since , if its Origin is fully asserted , we are then better capacitated to search into the Properties and Uses of this Stone , which I do not doubt are many , and which we could never have attained to , without first having examined this principal Part of its History .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient , humble Servant , Emanuel Mendez Da Costa .
London , Dec. 27 .
1746 .

