IX .
Observations upon so much of Monsieur le Monnier the younger 's Memoir , lately presented to the Royal Society , as relates to the communicating the Electric Virtue to Non-electrics ; by Wm. Watson , F. R. S THE World is much obliged to Mons. le Monnier for the many Discoveries he has made of the Power of Electricity ; though the Reason of my troubling you with this Paper at this time , is my differing with that Gentleman in the Conclusions which he deduces from several of the Experiments contained in his Memoir lately presented to the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , his own Extract of which was lately communicated to the Royal Society .
* Read Jan. 29 .
1746-7 .
One of the Questions proposed to be examined is , In what manner the electric Virtue is to be communicated to such Bodies as yet have it not , and which are not capable of acquiring it by bare Friction only ?
~ Monsieur le Monnier observes hereupon , ` ` That no other Manner is known , by which the electric Virtue may be communicated , besides the near Approach of a Body actually possee 'd of the same : That the Rule laid down by Monsieur ~ See These Transactions , No. ~ , p. 291 .
Monsieur du Fay , That Bodies never receive Electricity by Communication , unless they are supported by Bodies electric in their own Nature , does not always take place ; and that it is liaole to great Exceptions : ' ' For , first , in the I eyden Experiment , the Phial filled with Water is strongly electrified by Communication , even when carried in the Hand , which is not a Body electric by Nature .
' ' To this I answer , that Monsieur du Fay 's Rule is confirmed by all the Experiments yet made public , and even by that of Leyden quoted by our Author , or what is usually called that of Professor Muschenbroeck .
For , in this Experiment , is not the nonelectric Water contained in and supported by the glass Phial , which is electric in its own Nature ?
Its being carried in the Hand is no more than its being placed on any other non-electric Body , and therefore is no Proof against the general Position .
It is well known , that if the Phial is made non-electric by wetting its Outside , so as not to leave some Inches perfectly dry , between its Mouth and that Part which is wetted , the Water and Phial part with the Electricity as fast as they receive it , unless it is stopped by another Electric per se .
But of this I treated at large , in a Paper I lately did myself the Honour to communicate .
Secondly , our Author mentions , ` ` That all Bodies , which are electrified by means of a Phial of Water fitted to a Wire , and which has already received a great deal of Virtue by Communication ; all Bodies , he says , placed in any curve Line , connecting the exterior Wire and that Part of the Bottle , which is below the Surface of the Water , acquire Electricity without being placed upon Resin , Silk , Glass , or the like : That thus a violent Concussion may be given to 200 Men all at once ; who holding each other by the Hand so form the Curve just mentioned , when the first holds the Bottle , and the last touches the Wire with the End of his Finger ; and this equally , whether they are all mounted upon Cakes of Resin , or stand upon the Floor : That the Electricity has in this manner been carried through a Wire of the Length of 2000 Toises , or near 21/ 2 English Miles ; Part of which Wire dragged upon wet Grass , went over Hedges , Palisado 's , and over Land newly ploughed up .
' ' The Experiments in the second Argument do noways invalidate Monsieur du Fay 's Rule ; for the Success of them depends upon keeping whatever forms the curve Line mentioned by our Author , whether it consists of Men or Wire , in a nonelectric State : And if whatever forms this curve Line acquires any Degree of Electricity more than its original Quantity , which it is well known may be done , by being placed upon originally Electrics , the Effect of the Shock is proportionably lessened .
Thus if a Man , standing upon Electrics per se , applies his Hand to the Phial of Water , suspended by a Wire to the electrified Gun-barrel as usual , this Person will acquire Electricity , which will be sufficiently perceptible in him , by his attracting light Substances held near his Body , or by his firing inflammable ones , when properly presented to him ; if , I say , a Person thus electrified , by applying one of his Hands to the Phial , touches the electrified Gun-barrel with a Finger of his other , let the Phial be ever so strongly electrified , he feels but a slight Stroke ; and this Stroke is greater or less , in proportion to the Difference of the Accumulation of Electricity in the Body of the Man , and that of the Water in the Phial .
Thus we know from Experiment , that though a considerable Quantity of the Electricity , in impregnating the Phial of Water therewith , pervades the Glass , yet the Loss thereof this Way is not equal to what comes in by the Wire : Therefore we will , for the sake of a more easy Method of Explanation , suppose , that the Phial , when electrified in the most perfect manner , contains a Quantity of Electricity equal to 10 ; that the Man 's Body , by standing upon Wax , and touching the Phial with one of his Hands during its Electrification , contains a Quantity equal to 7 : Upon his touching the Gun barrel with a Finger of his other Hand , he will receive a small Stroke only equal to 3 , the Difference of the Electricity of the Water and that of his Body : And if he touches the Gunbarrel again , without removing his Foot from the originally Electric , the Stroke will be scarcely perceptible , on account of his Body being nearly of the same Degree of Electricity with the Water in the Phial .
So that here we see that the Violence of the Shock , to be felt by whatever forms the curve Line , depends upon its being , in the most perfect manner , free from any Degree of Electricity more than the original Quantity ; which is contrary to the Opinion of our Author .
Thirdly , Monsieur Monnier tells us , ` ` That the Water of the Bason of the Thuilleries , whose Surface is about an Acre , has been electrified in the following manner : There was stretched round half the Circumference of the Bason an iron Chain , which was entirely out of the Water ; the two Extremities of this Chain answered to those of one of the Diameters of the Octagon : An Observer , placed at one of these Extremities , held the Chain with his left Hand , and dipped his right at the same time into the Water of the Bason ; whrist another Observer , at the opposite Side of the Bason , held the other End of the Chain in his right Hand , and a Phial well electrified in his left .
He then caused the Wire of his Phial to touch an iron Rod , fixed upright in a Piece of Cork that floated near the Edge of the Bason .
At that Instant both Observers felt a violent Shock in both their Arms .
The same Fact was again confirmed by Experiments made upon two Basons at the same time , that it might appear distinctly , that the electrical Effluvia did really pass along the Superficies of the Water .
' ' The Water of the Bason in this Experiment was no more electrified than the Wire which dragged along the Ground , &amp;c. was in the former .
When I was first informed , without being acquainted how , that an Acre of Water had been electrified , I was amazed , and told the Gentleman who acquainted me therewith , that if my Idea of Electricity was in the least true , such an Effect could not be produced , without electrifying the whole terraqueous Globe from a larger Mass of Matter .
And indeed , when I heard Monsieur le Monnier 's Paper read~ I easily saw the Deception : So that , instead of electrifying the whole Quantity of Water contained in the Bason , the Electricity passed only through so much of it as formed a Line between the iron Rod fastened in the floating Cork , and the Hand of that Observer which was dipped in the Water .
These Experiments still more and more establish the Account I lately laid before you of the Electricity 's always describing the shortest Circuit between the electrified Water and the Gun barrel ; or ( which is the same thing ) the Wire of the electrified Phial .
And this Operation respects neither Fluids or Solids , as such , but only as they are non-electric Matter .
Thus this Circuit , in the preceding Experiment between the Phial and the Wire , consisted of the two Observers , the iron Chain , the Line of Water , and the iron Rod in the floating Cork .
Fourthly~ Monsieur le Monnier mentions , ` ` That it has been confirmed , by repeated Comparisonds , that a Bar of Iron , placed in the above-mention 'd Curve , does not at all acquire more Electricity when it is suspended in silken Lines , than when it is held in the bare Hand : Whence it appears to him , that , in this Case , the contiguous nonelectric Bodies do neither partake of , nor absorb in any way , the Electricity which has been communicated .
' ' The curve Line before-mention 'd , let it consist of whatever Non-electrics it will , unless the Whole thereof be properly supported , the communicated Electricity cannot be accumulated : So that the susE ee2 pending pending one Part thereof in silk Lines cannot be supposed to produce any Effect .
This Gentaleman further observes , ` ` That the Phial of Water fitted to its Wire does not receive the least Degree of Electricity , if its Wire , suspended by a silk Line , is applied to the Globe in Motion , or if that Phial is placed upon a dry glass Stand .
' ' This Monsieur le Monnier takes to be directly contrary to Monsieur du Fay 's Rule ; especially as the Phial cannot be replete with Electricity , unless , while it is exciting , some non-electric Body touches the Phial below the Water .
That the Phial of Water receives no Degree of Electricity in this Case is not strictly true : It receives as much as any other Mass of Matter of the same Bulk would , under the same Circumstances .
For we find , that we cannot highly electrify the Water , unless the Electricity from the Globe be directed through the Water and Phial to the Non-electric in Contact ; in which Passage a great Quantity thereof is accumulated , by its not pervading the Glass so fast as it is furnished by the Wire ; and therefore we find , that when the Water will contain no more , the Surcharge runs off by the Wire : So that this Experiment , no more than those which precede , contradicts Monsieur du Fay 's Opinion ; the Thinness of the Glass permitting it , not wholly , but partially , to stop the Electricity .
This Matter is explained further under Experiment the first .
I differ from this ingenious Author with Reluctance , inasmuch as I greatly honour him , not only for his Discoveries upon the Subject of Electricity , but also for the Pleasure and Improvement I received in my reading his learned and curious Observations in Natural History , made in the Southern Parts of France , where he accompanied Monsieur Cassini de Thury in measuring a Degree of the Meridian .
These Observations are published with Monsieur Cassini 's Book : But as the reverse of several of the Opinions delivered in his Memoir is experimentally found to be true , and as the Discovery of Truth , and carefully separating it from Deception , should be the only Aim of our Philosophising , I take the Liberty of laying before you my Opinion thereon .

