VIII .
A Letter from Mr. James Simon , of Dublin , to Martin Folks , Esq ; Pr .
R. S. concerning the Petrifactions of Lough-Neagh in Ireland : To which is annexed a Letter from the Right Rev. Dr. George Berkeley Lord Bishop of Cloyne to Tho. Prior , Esq ; .
SIR , IN my last I mentioned some Petrifications I had sent in a Box to Solomon Dayrolles , Esq ; F.R.S. to be delivered to you , and presented to the Society : I mentioned , at the same time , that I had made some few Remarks and Observations on these kind of Petrifications , commonly called Lough-neagh Stones ; I hinted , that , if the bad State of my Health would permit me , I would send you these Remarks , which , tho ' my great Heaviness and Dizziness continue , I have drawn up , during some favourable Intervals ; and beg Leave to lay them before you , that you , and some of your Friends , may examine them strictly , and be kind enough to redress the Mistakes , however numerous .
I search for the Truth , am willing to improve , and will most thankfully receive Advice .
To proceed : Read Feb. 9 .
1746-7 .
Most of the ancient Writers , that have treated of Ireland , have made mention of the peculiar Qualities of Lough-neagh of turning Wood into Stone ; some of them ( a ) have gone so far as to say , that it would turn that Part of the Wood which was in the Mud into Iron ; the Part in the Water into Stone , whilst the Part above Water remained Wood .
Some later Writers , particularly Messieurs William Molyneux , Francis Nevill , and Edward Smyth , and from them the late learned Dr. Woodward , ( b ) the Author of the Notes on Varenius 's Geography , and others ( c ) , seem rather to think , that this petrifying Quality doth not lie so much in the Lake itself , as in the Ground near or about it .
Mr. Edw. Smyth ( d ) , who enlarges the most on this Subject , and seems to have led the others , and drawn them into his Opinion , tells you , ` ` That no Experiment or Observation yet made , that he could hear of , could prove that this Lough has really the Quality of petrifying Wood , or that the Water doth any way help or promote the Petrification .
' ' He there gives you an Example of a Gentleman of Worth and Credit , ` ` who had fixed two Stakes of Holly in two different Places of the Lough , near that Place where the Upper Bann enters into it , and that the Parts of the Stakes which ( a ) Boetius Hist. Gem .
et Lap .
( b ) Catal. of English Fossils , Part II .
p. 19 .
( c ) Sir James Ware 's Antiq .
by Walt .
Harris , p. 227 .
Edit .
1745 .
folio .
( d ) Afterwards Bishop of Down .
See Phil. Trans. No. 174 .
which had been washed by the Water for about 19 Years , yet remained there without any Alteration , or the least Advance to Petrification .
' Another Reason for his doubting of this Quality is , ` ` That tho ' it is reported that the Water hath this Virtue , especially where the Black-Water discharges itself into the Lake , yet that , as it seems evident , from the Nature of liquid Bodies , that any Virtue received in one Part must necessarily be diffused thro ' the Whole , at least in some degree ; therefore ( saith he ) there is good Reason to believe , that the Water is wholly destitute of this petrifying Quality : ' ' But a few Lines lower he tells you ( a ) , ` ` That he had sufficient Ground to conjecture , that other Wood as well as Holly had been petrify 'd about this Lough ; because some Fishermen , being Tenants to a Gentleman from whom he had this Relation , told him , that they had found buried , in the Mud of this Lough , great Trees , with all their Branches and Roots petrify 'd ; and some of that Bigness , that they believed they could scarcely be drawn by a Team of Oxen ; that they had broke off several Branches as big as a Man 's Leg , and many bigger , but could not move the great Trunk , ' ' I suppose Mr. Smyth ( or the Gentleman his Friend ) saw these Branches , and was thereby convinced of their their real Petrification , as he was by the Bulk of those Trees of their being Oak , and not Holly ; ` ` because , says he , no other Tree in that Country , these excepted , grows to that prodigious Bigness ; at least it is certain , that Holly never grows to that Bigness .
' ' But how Mr. Smyth came to be convinced , that that these Trees were Oak , and not Holly , and yet was not convinced of the petrific Quality in some Parts of the Lough , tho ' these Trees were found petrified in its Mud , is amazing to me : For , if a Team of Oxen could scarcely draw them from thence , it was as hard , in my Opinion , to draw them from any adjacent Ground ( where they must have grown , lain , and be petrified ) into the Mud of the Lake , where they were afterwards found : For it must be supposed , that either these Trees grew on the Banks of the Lake , and , thro ' Age , or any other Accident , fell into the Water or Mud , and were there petrified ; or that , with great Labour and Expense , they were brought into it from some adjacent Ground , after their actual Petrification , which is hardly to be supposed .
Mr. Smyth ( a ) tells you farther , that ` ` Two Gentlemen of the North ( of Ireland where this Lough lies ) had told him , that they had seen the same Body , partly Wood , and partly Stone ; but the only Reason for thinking so , being the Diversity of Colours , which might well enough proceed from several Degrees of Petrification , we may properly think ( a ) Ibid. ut supra .
think them deceived ; for they made no Experiment on that Part which they reputed Wood .
The Bark is never found petrified , as I am informed by a diligent Inquirer ; but often something rotten about the Stone , answerable to the Bark .
' ' Mr. Smyth I think contradicts himself no less in his last Supposition than he did in the first .
His Friends assured him , that they had seen one or more of the Lough-neagh Stones partly Wood and partly Stone ; but they were deceived , he says : The Diversity of Colours , by which they judged one Part of the Stone by its Colour to be Wood , and the other Part likewise , by its Colour different from the other , to be Stone , were no more than different Degrees of Petrification .
What are we to understand by these different Degrees of Petrification ?
by this something rotten about the Stone often found ?
if not , that some Part of the Wood was actually turned into Stone , some other Part in a Degree less petrified , and some other Part not petrified at all , as these Gentlemen assured him : The Diversity of Colours , Seeing and Feeling , was enough to convince them , and to determine the Point .
As to his Assertion , That , because the Water of this Lake has not every-where , and in every Place , that petrescent Virtue , it must therefore be a good Reason to doubt of its having that peculiar Quality in some particular Places , I think it may be denied for these Reasons ; 1st .
Because a Spring , tho ' ever so much impregnated with petrific , mineral , or metalline Particles , issuing out in some particular Place of the Lake , can no more communicate its petrifying Virtue to the Waters of the whole Lake , than the River Thames its Sweetness to the Sea , and make all its Water fresh .
Secondly , Because that if this lapidescent Quality was equally diffused thro ' the Water of the whole Lake in a Degree sufficient to turn a whole Tree , or any of its larger Branches into Stone , in all Parts of the Lake without Exception , that petrescent Virtue must act equally on all the Plants or Vegetables whatsoever that grow in the Lake , and upon all other Bodies , Gravel , Sand , Mud , and Clay , that are in , or are daily brought into it ; and , at last , by a general Aggregation , Agglutination , and Attraction of these different Bodies together , the whole Bottom of the Lake , nay the whole Lake itself , by the different Degrees of Coalition of Particles , must become a solid Body ; unless you would suppose , that this petrific Quality has no Power on any other Matter but Wood , which is contrary to Experience , Rushes , or other Plants , having been found petrified on the Shores of this Lake , as also Shells , Clay , and Sand petrified in different Shapes , of all which I have Specimens .
The Earth , says the great Robert Boyle ( a ) harbours different Kinds of petrescent Liquors , and many of them impregnated with one sort of Mineral or other .
' ' There are no Springs , no Waters , but are more or less impregnated with such mineral and saline Particles ; which appears from the most limpid ; which , after Evaporation , still in the Residuum , ( a ) R. Boyle , of the Origin and Virtues of Gems .
siduum gives some Particles of Salt together with some stony and mineral ones .
I have found by Experience , that petrifying Springs are generally impregnated , some with calcarious and Particles of other Stones , and others with ferrugineous and vitriolic Particles .
Those of the stony or calcarious Kind , I have observed , when they drop on Wood , or other Vegetables , act on them for the most part by Incrustation , having different Degrees and Periods for their respective Incrustations and Coalitions , which yet stick close to one another : They seldom turn the Wood into Stone ; but , sticking to the Wood , Plants , &amp;c. coagulate on it , and by degrees cover it with a Crust of a whitish Substance of different Thickness , whereby the Wood is immerged or wrapped in a stony Coat , which , if it be broken before the Wood be rotten , you will find it in the Heart of the Stone or Incrustation , as is seen in those Petrifications at Maudlin Meadows in Gloucestershire , at Hermitage near Dublin , and many other Places : Or , if the Wood be rotten , you will find a Cavity in the Stone , which very often is filled by a subsequent Incrustation or Petrification ; the stony Particles then taking the Place of the rotten Wood .
Sometimes indeed , these Waters , permeating the Pores of the Wood either longitudinally or transversely , insinuate themselves therein , fill them up with their stony Particles , swell , and , by their burning or corroding Quality proceeding from the Lime-Stone , destroy the Wood , and assume the Shape of the Plant , the Place whereof they have taken .
These kind of Petrifications generally ferment with Acids and Spirit of Vitriol , and , by Calcination , may be reduced to Lime .
Ferrugineous or metallic petrifying Waters mostly act by insinuating their finest Particles thro ' the Pores and Vessels of the Wood , or other Vegetables , without increasing their Bulk , or altering their Texture , tho ' they greatly increase their specific Gravity : And such is the petrified Wood found in or on the Shores of Lough-Neagh ; for it doth not show any outward Addition or Coalition of forcing Matter sticking to or covering it ( except in some Places , where a thin slimy Substance , taken notice of hereafter , is sometimes observed ) , but preserve the Grain and Vestigia of Wood ; all the Alteration is in the Weight and Closeness , by the mineral Particles pervading and filling the Pores of the Wood : These Stones , or rather Wood-Stones , do not make the least Effervescence with Spirit or Oil of Vitriol , nor Aqua-fortis ; which shows , that they are impregnated with metalline Particles , or stony ones , different from the calcarious Kind ; and may be the Reason why the petrified Wood , mentioned by N. Grew ( a ) , made no Ebullition , at which it seems he was surprised ( b ) .
These Stones I could not reduce into Lime by the most intense Fire , nor , ( a ) Reg. Soc. Mus. p. 270 .
( b ) This contradicts an Observation of Mr. John Beaumont ( Phil. Trans. No. 129 .
p. 731 .
) , That mostly mineral Stones will stir with Acids ; whereas all those that I have tried , whether English or Irish , did not at all stir with Acids .
nor , with proper Ingredients , procure a Vitrification or Fusion ( a ) .
Altho ' Mines have not perhaps been discovered near the Lough , I have Reason to believe that there are such in its Neighbourhood , from the great Quantity of Iron-Stones found on its Shores , and Places adjacent to it , and from the yellowish Ochre and Clay to be met with in many Places near it .
Of these Iron-Stones , which are very ponderous , outwardly of an ocherish-yellow Colour , and inwardly of a reddish brown , I have calcined many , and do find the Powder of all to yield strongly to the Magnet .
Gerald Boat ( b ) mentions an Iron Mine , in the County of Tirone , not far from the Lough , and such others at the Foot of Slew-Gallen Mountains .
That Mines are generated and found in the Bowels of Hills and Mountains , is obvious to any that have the least Knowledge of Metallurgy ; and that Springs also proceed from Mountains , is no less obvious ; therefore should a Spring happen in the Bowels of any of these Mountains to run thro ' a Vein of Mineral of any kind soever , it will wash and dilute some Parts of such Mineral , impregnate itself with the unctuous , saline , and metallic Particles of such Mines , and convey them along with its Water ; and if in its Way , whether under-ground , or at its issuing out ( a ) Stones of the calcarious Kind turn to Lime by Calcination , and ferment with Acids ; but other Kinds , such as Slate , Fire-Stone , Free-Stone , Rag , Grill , &amp;c. will do neither , as Experience has hitherto testified .
( b ) Not .
Hist. of Ireland , Dub .
1726 .
out of the Cliffs of a Mountain , of the Sides of a River , or of the Lake in Question ; or whether it rises under Water , in the middle of such a River or Lake in any particular Place , and in its Course meets with Wood , Vegetables , or any other lax Bodies ( lodged in the Mud or Gravel ) , whose Pores , by the natural Heat of the mineral Steams , or any other Accident , being open and duly prepared , these metallic Moleculae and saline Particles will penetrate thro ' , insinuate and lodge themselves in the Pores and Vessels of such Wood , &amp;c. fill them up , and , by degrees , turn them into Stone ; ( a ) ` ` There being some of these Juices lapidescent of so fine a Substance , yet of so petrifying a Virtue , that they will penetrate and petrify Bodies of very different Kinds , and yet scarce , if at all , visibly increase their Bulk , or change their Shape and Colour .
' ' That such Springs there are , hidden under the Water or Mud of this Lake , I hope will appear probable , from what has been said , and perhaps evident , from the Account I have since received , that , in the great Frost of 1740 , the Lake was frozen over so as to bear Men on Horseback , yet several circular Spaces continued unfrozen .
But how the several Attempts , made , as mentioned , by Messieurs Molineux , Nevil , and Smyth , to procure Wood half-petrified ( by fixing Stakes of Holly in the Lake , which received no Alteration ) proved unsuccessful , the Reason I think is plain , because they were not fixed in the proper Place , viz. the Course or Vein of the ( a ) Rob .
Boyle , of Gems , p. 124 .
8vo .
the Spring , where nothing but Chance could have directed them .
This petrified Wood is often found in different Places on the Shores of the Lough , but generally in greater Plenty when the Water has been disturbed by great Storms ; which makes it impossible to fix on the particular Place where the petrifying Juice most prevails ; except a Tree , or any large Piece , should be found so fixed as to resist the Force of the Waves .
Mr. Smyth ( a ) makes this further Observation : This Virtue is certainly , if not only , in the Ground or Soil , he judges ( says he ) for these Reasons ; That there are many Stones turned up daily , especially at their breaking up new Ground , which we cannot in any Probability think were brought thither ; they are often found at two Miles Distance from the Lough , seldom farther , in great Numbers , and very deep in the Ground ; and a Gentleman ( on whose Credit I received the Information ) saw a Stump of a Tree dug out of the Ground at a small Distance from the Lough , which , by handling of it , he found to be petrified .
He assured me , the Roots and all were Stone , and altogether like those Stones that are ordinarily found , and go by the Name of Lough-Neagh Stones .
This Gentleman was of Opinion , these were Lapides sui generis , till this Observation convinced him : And that these Stones were once Wood , is , I think , very certain ; for they show the plain Vestigia of Wood ; they likewise burn , and cleave : ( a ) Philos. Trans. ibid. ut supra .
cleave : Filings of this Stone thrown into the Fire emit a fragrant Smell ; and they cut kindly with a Knife , tho ' not so easily as other Wood ( a ) That this petrific Quality is in some peculiar Parts of the Lake , I have endeavoured to prove ; that it is or may be in some peculiar Places of the adjacent Ground , I grant ; tho ' , as yet , I could not procure any of those Stones found in the Ground , with Wood continuous .
Such as I have , or have seen , are of the white Whetstone-kind , and seem to be Holly or Ash , petrified by some strong nitrous and stony Particles ; for , in a Solution of it in Aqua fortis and Oil of Vitriol , it leaves no Tincture , but the Liquor growing muddy , like Pipe-Water after great Rains , therefore shows , that they are not so strongly impregnated with metalline Particles , as those Stones found in or on the Shores of the Lake .
I need not add any more , to show how mineral Springs may petrify Wood , or any other Vegetables underground ; but as to whole Trees found petrified and buried within a small Distance from the Lake , I should think that the Lough might have been formerly broader than it is at present , or perhaps hath lost on one Side what it has gained on the other ; by which means , what is now dry Ground was formerly under Water , and the other Side vice versa : If so , such Trees as are found under-ground might have been petrified in that Part which was overflowed , and is now dry Land .
Mineral ( a ) An Answer to this , see in the Description of the City of Down , p. 162 .
The Argument is confuted by the desired Proof .
Mineral Steams or Exhalations , being highly saturated with stony and mineral Particles , are often found to have a petrifying Virtue , as is seen at the Bath called Green Pillars ( a ) in the City of Buda in Hungary .
If such Steams should , in certain Places , find or force their Way thro ' the Sand or Pores of the Earth , they may operate on Wood , &amp;c. buried in the Ground , permeate its Vessels , and , by degrees , turn it into Stone ; and such , I apprehend , is the most probable , if not the only Reason , that can be assigned for those Petrifications of Wood found in Sand , as mentioned by Boyle and Plot .
It may be observed , that the finer the lapidific Particles are , the more beautiful and natural the Petrification will appear ; such is a petrified Root of the Flag or Iris sylvestris in my Possession , which is solid Stone at the Bottom , the Pith being turned into a white or sparry Substance , and the growing Knots of the Root , tho ' petrified , preserving their Skin brown , and somewhat flexible .
This Phenomenon indeed has been lately solved in the Description of the County of Down , p. 162 .
The Lusus Naturae , or Sportings of Nature , is a general Solution , too often brought in , and comes in very a propos to answer Queries concerning Petrifications , such as Wood , Shells , Worms , &amp;c. If the Shells , or other like petrified Bodies ( found in Marble or Lime-Stone ) which preserve the most exact Resemblance of the Fish or Body they represent , were not formerly a real Fish , Shell , Worm , &amp;c. how comes it ( a ) Philos. Trans. No. 59 .
p. 1049 .
it that such Shells and other Bodies are found unpetrified in Marble , Lime-Stone , Rock , Marl , or any other Stone ?
The Right Reverend Dr. Robert Clayton , Bishop of C logher , hath shown me in his Collection a Piece of Italian Marble , where petrified Shells are seen , and others no way petrified , but that may be crumbled to Dust with the Fingers .
I have a Stone ( which I found lately in the River Liffy at ChapelIzod ) of the Lapis vermicularis Kind , the Surface whereof , on one Side , is covered with a Number of small petrified Worms or Plants ; Part of which , slicking and continuous to the stony ones , are still soft and flexible .
To return to the Lough-Neagh Petrifications ; I received last Summer , 1745 .
from my worthy and ingenious Friend the Reverend Mr. Richard Barton , about 30 of these Stones , found on the Shores of the Lake , some in the Water , some in the Mud , some in the Sand , and others in a yellowish Clay .
That they were petrified in the Lake is probable , but whether in the Water , Mud , Sand , or Clay , is no matter ; for certain it is ( to use Mr. Smyth 's own Words ) , that they were not brought hither from any Distance , such as 2 , 4 , 6 , 8 Miles , after being dug out of the Ground , and then thrown and dispersed on the Shores of the Lake : And besides , the Difference in the Colour of these Stones , those found in the Lake , and those found in the Ground somewhat distant from it , is such that they cannot well be mistaken one for the other .
Those found in the Ground are white , and of a looser Texture ; those found in or on the Shores of the Lake are black , closer , and heavier .
That these last were petrified by a mineral Spring , appears from the few following Observations .
They do not ferment with Acids , Spirit and Oil of Vitriol .
The Solution of this Stone in Aqua fortis gives a beautiful red Tincture , and in Oil of Vitriol leaves a Tincture of a brown dark Red .
The woody Part of these Stones in Aqua fortis also gives a red Tincture , tho ' somewhat paler ; and , when taken out of the Liquor ; shows red Spots in its Pores , which I take to be Particles of Iron and Sulphur : These Spots , when the Wood began to dry , became black ; and the Wood , when dry , turned of the Colour of a deep red Jesuit's-Bark .
In some of these Stones , several curious Veins , of a red and bluish Colour , are very remarkable , being intermixed with black and white Striae .
Having broken some of these Stones , I found in the Inside a kind of white , and several Clusters of small white and black angular Crystals , which thro ' the Microscope appear transparent , and of different Shapes , but mostly hexagonal .
I discovered such Crystals in some of the woody Part of these Stones .
One Piece of a white Stone I calcined in a Crucible for 24 Hours , but could neither reduce it to Coal or Lime .
The Powder yielded faintly to the Magnet .
This Stone was found in the Ground at some Distance from the Lake .
One Piece of a black Stone , found in the Lake , I likewise calcined for 24 Hours , and could not reduce it to Coal or Lime : The Powder yielded briskly to the Magnet .
I calcined one Piece of another Stone , about one Inch thick , for about 4 Hours , in an intense Fire , until it grew as red as it could be , when I took it out of the Crucible .
I observed several Veins ( not discernible before ) of a ferrugineous Matter , about 1/ 10 of an Inch thick , and when reduced to Powder , it applied strongly to the Magnet .
In other Stones I found some Veins of Wood , about one and two Inches thick , no way petrified , tho ' the Stones were every way so outwardly .
Some of that woody Part I also burnt in a Crucible ; it emitted a bluish Flame , as if impregnated with Sulphur , and had the strong Smell of burning Charcoal .
When burnt to a Coal , and reduced into Powder , it faintly yielded to the Magnet .
How Wood happens to be found in these Petrifications , sound and untouched , is somewhat surprising , and to account for it not very easy .
It may be attributed to this , that the Texture of the Wood is not every where equal ; especially where Knots happen , that Part is much harder and closer than any other ; and if the perrescent Particles should be once stopped , they will fix there , coagulate , and go no further ; by which means that Part of the Wood will remain free from Perrification , while the rest will be turned into Stone ; or the Pores of the Wood may happen in some Places , and in the very Heart of it , to be so full of a resinous Matter , that it will keep out the petrific Juices , and hinder their further penetrating into them equally : To this may be attributed the strong Smell of this Wood when burning ; and the more so , as I suspect that most of this petrified Wood was Fir , there being a good deal of that kind found daily in Turf-Pits near the Lake ; some not above twenty Yards Distance from it ; and the last Piece of Wood and Stone continuous that I have received , appearing by the Grain to be of that kind of Wood .
Lastly , the petrific Juices may happen to be so strongly impregnated with Salts and Metal , or any other mineral Particles , that they will immediately swell and fill the minutest Pores of the Wood , and , by a sudden Coalition , hinder their further penetrating into it ; which seems to appear clearly from some Cavities in one of these Stones , which I suppose to have been Worm-Holes , and which were no way filled by the petrescent Liquor which was stopped round it ; all the Sides of this Hole being overlaid with small brown Crystals , occasioned by the Evaporation of the aqueous Parts , and their being stopped and soaked by the neighbouring Stone or Wood .
The woody Part of these Stones , as I have observed , will burn to a Coal , and emit a Flame : That Part intermediate betwixt the Stone and Wood , and which is but partly petrified , being harder than Wood , and softer than Stone , will grow red in the Fire , emit a kind of Flame , or rather Sparks of Fire , but doth not consume , and is properly what Dr. Grew* calls incombustible Wood .
The stony Part doth not burn , tho ' it grows as red as Coal .
I calcined another of these Stones , weighing 1 oz. 13 penywts .
121/ 4 gr. ; after burning 4 Hours it weighed but 1 oz. 10 penywts .
81/ 4 gr. and lost 3 penywts .
4 gr. ; which proceeds , I soppose , from unpetrified Veins of Wood in the Heart of the Stone , which were destroyed by the Fire , as in the Crucible it emitted now-and-then a bluish Flame , as Brandy doth when burning .
This Stone , when taken Ss2 out * Mus. R. S. p. 269 .
out of the Crucible , and cooled , had the Colour of Iron , when heated in , and cooled from the Forge .
Part of another Stone , which , by visible Veins of Ore , appears to contain a good deal of Iron , I likewise calcined for four Hours ; the Powder yielded most surprisingly to the Magnet ; so that it appears , that the Opinion of Nennius , Boetius , and other ancient Writers , was not absolutely destitute of Foundation .
The white Wood-Stones are generally found in the Ground at 2 , 4 , 6 , and 8 Miles Distance from the Lake , and sometimes very deep in the Earth .
The black ones are always found in the Water , or on the Shores of the Lough ; sometimes at the Mouths of Rivers or Rivulets that empty themselves into it ; but those with Wood continuous have not yet been found above 20 Yards Distance from the Water of the Lake ; that is , where the Water reaches in the Winter , or at other times .
Some of these Stones are outwardly covered with a thin white Substance , which hath run thro ' the Pores of that Part of the Stone that was exposed to the Air , and not covered by the Water , Mud , or Clay ; and on some others it is rather an Incrustation of that white Substance , which I take to be the slimy , unctuous , saline Parts of the petrescent Juices that filled the outward Pores of the Stone , or coagulated on it .
This white Part scraped , and put into a Crucible in a violent Fire , could not be reduced to Lime , tho ' it grew red as Coal .
This Powder calcined appeared thro ' the Microscope quadrangular , like Grains of Salt ; which makes me suspect , that these Petrifications contain , besides metalline , a great deal of saline Particles , whose Sides being strongly attracted to each other , and closely joined , hinders the Fire from expanding the Pores of these Stones , and their being reduced to Lime .
This black Stone , when broken , appears thro ' the Microscope very beautiful , and like Cloth of Silver , the Pores and Vessels of the Wood being filled with white minute Crystals .
Of these Stones I have some with Wood outwardly continuous ; others with Wood inwardly ; one , the least Part whereof is Stone , the rest Wood ; another vice versa ; another entirely Wood , except a thin Coat of Stone on one Side , which appears to be the very Bark ; one Stone which at one End distinctly shows the annual Ringlets of the Wood ; one that shows the Wood , before it was petrified , had been bent , and partly broken , the Fissure being filled with a sparry Matter , and appears plainly from the present Appearance and Position of the Fibres of the Stone .
Some of these Stones strike Fire with a Steel , and others , by a strong Collision , emit a Train of Sparks .
Some of these Stones show the Grain of Holly , Ash , and Fir .
I have but one Piece of Oak petrified , easily distinguished by its Grain ; it shows the very Knots of the Wood where young Twigs were cut ; and has a Hole made thro ' it before it was petrified .
As for these Stones being fit for sharpening or setting of Razors , &amp;c. the black ones are rather too hard , and the white ones too soft .
The Whetstones or Hones , vulgarly so called , which are sold for Lough-Neagh Stones , are none of these , but of a soft gritty kind , and found near Drogheda .
When these Stones with Wood continuous are taken out of the Water , Mud , or Clay , the woody Part dries , cracks , and falls away ; which is the Reason why few can be well preserved ; and besides , every body , unwilling to trust their Eyes , will touch and scrape the Wood , and , by these means , destroy the most curious Part of the Stone .
The curious Gentleman above-mention 'd , who hath already begun , and intends , at his Leisure , to take an accurate Survey of the Lake , will , I hope , be able to give a more just and satisfactory Account of its petrifying Virtue than I possibly can ; my Design in the present Attempt being only to pave the Way , and induce others to make further Experiments in search of Truth , and for improving natural Knowlege .
My Habilities do not answer my Good will ; therefore I hope Defects in the Performance and Language of a Foreigner , will be excused .
I should be very proud , that these few Remarks could deserve your Approbation , and of your Friends ; and shall be glad to hear of its Success .
SIR , Your most humble , and obedient Servant , James Simon .
P. Dublin , June 10 , P. S. I had lent the above Papers to the Bishop of Cloyne , from whom I received them Yesterday , with the original Letter to Thomas Prior , Esq ; of which follows the Copy .
A Letter from the Right Rev. Dr. George Berkeley , Lord Bishop of Cloyne , to Tho. Prior , Esq ; in Dublin .
Dear Sir , I HERE send you back the curious Dissertation of Mr. Simon , which I have perused with Pleasure ; and tho ' Variety of Avocations gives me little Time for Remarks on a Subject so much out my Way , I shall nevertheless venture to give my Thoughts briefly upon it , especially since the Author hath been pleased to invite me to it by a Letter .
Cloyne , May 20 .
1746 .
The Author seems to put it out of Doubt , that there is a petrifying Quality both in the Lake and adjacent Earth .
What he remarks on the unfrozen Spots in the Lake is curious , and furnishes a sufficient Answer to those , who would deny any petrifying Virtue to be in the Water , from Experiments not succeeding in some Parts of it ; since nothing but Chance could have directed to the proper Places , which , probably , were those unfrozen Parts .
Stones have been thought by some to be organised Vegetables , and to be produced from Seed .
To me it seems , that Stones are Vegetables unorganised .
Other Vegetables are nourished and grow by a Solution of Salt attracted into their Tubes or Vessels .
And Stones grow by the Accretion of Salts , which often shoot into angular and regular Figures .
This appears in the Formation of Crystals on the Alps : And that Stones are formed by the simple Attraction and Accretion of Salts , appears in the Tartar on the Inside of a Claret-Vessel , and especially in the Formation of a Stone in the human Body .
The Air is in many Places impregnated with such Salts .
I have seen at Agrigentum in Sicily the Pillars of Stone in an ancient Temple corroded and consumed by the Air , while the Shells which entered the Composition of the Stone remained entire and untouched .
I have elsewhere observed Marble to be consumed in the same manner ; and it is common to see softer Kinds of Stone moulder and dissolve merely by the Air acting as a Menstruum .
Therefore the Air may be presumed to contain many such Salts , or stony Particles .
Air , acting as a Menstruum in the Cavities of the Earth , may become saturated ( in like manner as above-ground ) with such Salts , as , ascending in Vapours or Exhalations , may petrify Wood , whether lying in the Ground adjacent , or in the Bottom of the Lake .
This is confirmed by the Author 's own Remark on the Bath called the Green Pillars in Hungary .
The insinuating of such Salts into the Wood seems also confirmed by the Author 's having observed minute hexagonal Crystals in the woody Part of the Petrifactions of Lough-Neagh .
A petrifying Quality or Virtue shows itself in all Parts of this terraqueous Globe , in Water , Earth , and Sand ; in Tartary for instance , and Afric , in the Bodies of most Sorts of Animals , it is even known that a Child hath been petrified in the Mother 's Womb .
Osteocolla grows in the Land , and Coral in the Sea .
Grottoes , Springs , Lakes , and Rivers , are in many Parts remarkable for this same Quality .
No Man therefore can question the Possibility of such a thing as petrified Wood ; tho ' perhaps the petrifying Quality might not be originally in the Earth or Water , but in the Vapour or Steam impregnated with saline or stony Particles .
Perhaps the Petrification of Wood may receive some Light from considering Amber , which is dug up in the King of Prussia 's Dominions .
I have written these hasty Lines in no small Hurry ; and send them to you , not from an Opinion , that they contain any thing worth imparting , but merely in Compliance with your and Mr. Simon 's Request .
[ Added from a Letter to Dr. J. Fothergill , dated Dublin , Aug. 8 .
1746 .
] And yet , before I have done , I must needs add another Remark , which may be useful for the better understanding of the Nature of Stone .
In the vulgar Definition , it is said to be a Fossil incapable of Fusion .
I have nevertheless known Stone to be melted , and when cold to become Stone again .
Such is that Stuff , by the Natives called Sciara , which runs down in liquid burning Torrents from the Craters of Mount AEtna , and which , when cold and hard , I have seen hewed and employed at Catania , and other Places adjacent .
It probably contains mineral and metallic Particles ; being a ponderous , hard , grey Stone , used for the most part in the Basements and Coinage of Buildings .
Hence it should seem not impossible for Stone to be cast or run into the Shape of Columns * , Vases , Statues , or Relievo 's ; which Experiment may perhaps , some time or other , be attempted by the Curious ; who , following where Nature has shown the Way , may ( possibly by the Aid of certain Salts and Minerals ) arrive at a Method for melting and running Stone , both to their own Profit , and that of the Public .
I am , Dear Sir , Your most humble Servant , G. Cloyne .
* To confirm what the Bishop says , I remember when I was in the College in France , that I went to see a Relation of mine , a Friar , at Fontevrand , where he showed me in their Church two Pillars of Stone , about 60 Feet high , all of one solid Piece , which he said had been run .
J. S.

