III .
Of the various Genera and Species of Music among the Ancients , with some Observations concerning their Scale ; in a Letter from John Christoph .
Pepusch , Music .
D. &amp; F. R. S. to Mr. Abraham de Moivre , F. R. S. SIR , IN Compliance with your Request , I here send you some of my Thoughts on the various Genera and Species of the Greek Music , Read Nov 13 .
1746 .
bear printed with sic .
What they were , and how far the Doctrine of the Ancients in this respect is reconcileable with the true Nature of musical Sounds , are , you know , Questions which have not a little perplexed the Learned .
That musical Intervals are founded on certain Ratio 's or Proportions expressible in Numbers , is an old Discovery .
Nobody is better acquainted with these Proportions than yourself ; and I am not a little obliged to you for the Light you have herein given me .
It is well known , that all musical Ratio 's may be analysed into the prime Numbers 2 , 3 , and 5 ; and that all Intervals may be found from the Octave , Fifth and Third Major ; which respectively correspond to those Numbers .
These are the Musicians Elements , from the various Combinations of which all the agreeable Variety of Relations of Sounds result .
This System is so well sounded on Experience , that we may look upon it as the Standard of Truth .
Every Interval that occurs in Music is good or bad , as it approaches to , or deviates from , what it ought to be on these Principles .
The Doctrine of some of the Ancients seems different .
Whoever looks into the Numbers given us by Ptolemy , will not only find the Primes 2 , 3 , and 5 , but 7 , 11 , &amp;c. introduced .
Nay he seems to think all Fourths good , provided their component Intervals may be expressed by superparticular Ratio 's .
But these are justly exploded Conceits ; and it seems not improbable , that the Contradictions of different numerical Hypotheses , even in the Age of Aristoxenus , and their Inconsistency with Experience , might lead him to reject their Numbers altogether .
It is Pity he did : Had he made a proper Use of them , we should have had a clearer Insight into the Music of his Times .
However , what remains of the Writings of this great Musician , joined to my own Observation and Experience , has enabled me , I hope , to throw some Light upon the obscure Subject of the ancient Species of Music .
By the Manner in which Euclid and others find the Notes of their Scale , it must have been composed of Tones Major , and Limma 's .
Hence the seven Intervals of one Octave would be thus expressed in Numbers , 9/ 8 , 256/ 243 , 9/ 8 , 9/ 8 , 256/ 243 , 9/ 8 , 9/ 8 .
Some modern Authors have from this inferred the Imperfection of the Greek Music .
They allege we here find the Ditonus , or an Interval equal to two Tones Major expressed by 81/ 64 , instead of the true Third Major expressed by 5/ 4 .
As there can be no Question of the Beauty and Elegance of the latter , the former therefore must be out of Tune , and out of Tune by a whole Comma , which is very shocking to the Ear .
In like manner the Trihemitone of the Ancients falls short of the third Minor by a Comma ; which is also the Deficiency of their Hemitone or Limma , from the true Semitone Major , so essential to good Melody .
These Errors would make their Scale appear much out of Tune to us .
This I readily grant ; and add , that it appeared out of Tune to them ; since they expressly tell us , that the Intervals less than the Diatessaron or Fourth , as also the Intervals between the Fifth and Octave were dissonant and disagreeable to the Ear .
Their Scale , which has been called by some the Scala maxima , was not intended to form the Voice to sing accurately , but was designed to represent the System of their Modes and Tones , and to give the true Fourths and Fifths of every Key a Composer might choose .
Now if , instead of Tones Major and Limma 's , we take the Tones Major and Minor , with the Semitone Major , as the Moderns contend we should , we shall have a good Scale indeed , but a Scale adapted only to the concinnous Constitution of one Key ; and whenever we proceed from that into another , we find some Fourth or Fifth erroneous by a Comma .
This the Ancients did not admit of .
If , to diminish such Errors , we introduce a Temperature , we shall have nothing in Tune but the Octave .
We see then the Scale of the Ancients was not destitute of Reason ; and that no good Argument against the Accuracy of their Practice can from thence be formed .
It was usual among the Greeks to consider a descending as well as an ascending Scale ; the former proceeding from acute to grave , precisely by the same Intervals as the latter did from grave to acute .
The first Sound in each was the Proslambanomenos .
The not distinguishing these two Scales has led several learned Moderns to suppose , that the Greeks , in some Centuries , took the Proslambanomenos to be the lowest Note in their System ; and , in other Centuries , to be the highest .
But the Truth of the Matter is , that the Proslambanomenos was the lowest , or highest Note , according as they considered the ascending , or descending Scale .
The Distinction of these is conducive to the Variety and Perfection of Melody ; but I never yet met with above one Piece of Music , where the Composer appeared to have any Intelligence of this kind .
The Composition is about 150 , or more , Years old , for four Voices ; and the Words are , Vobis datum est noscere Mysterium regni Dei , caeteris autem in Parabolis ; ut videntes non videant , et audientes non intelligent .
By the Choice of the Words , the Author seems to allude to his having performed something not commonly understood .
I shall here give you an Octave only of the ascending and descending Scales of the diatonic Genus of the Ancients , with the Names for their several Sounds , as also the corresponding modern Letters .
Ascending .
Descending .
A Proslambanomenos g 9/ 8 8/ 9 B Hypate Hypaton f 256/ 243 243/ 256 C Parhypate Hypaton e 9/ 8 8/ 9 D Lychanos Hypaton d 9/ 8 8/ 9 E Hypate Meson c 256/ 243 243/ 256 F Parhypate Meson b 9/ 8 8/ 9 G Lychanos Meson a 9/ 8 8/ 9 a Mes G Where you see the same Greek Names serve for the Sounds in the ascending and descending Scales .
In the Octave here given , four Sounds , viz. the Proslambanomenos , Hypate Hypaton , Hypate Meson , and Mes , were called Stabiles , from their remaining fixed throughout all the Genera and Species .
The other four Sounds being the Parhypate Hypaton , Lychanos Hypaton , Parhypate Meson , and the Lychanos Meson , were called Mobiles , because they varied according to the different Species and Varieties of Music .
I come now to determine the Question , What these different Genera and Species were .
You know , that by Genus and Species was understood a Division of the Diatessaron , containing four Sounds , into three Intervals .
The Greeks constituted three Genera , known by the Names of enharmonic , chromatic , and diatonic .
The chromatic was subdivided into three Species , and the diatonic into two .
The three chromatic Species were the Chromaticum molle , the Sesquialterum , and the Toniaeum .
The two diatonic Species were the Diatonicum molle , and the Intensum ; so that they had six Species in all .
Some of these are in Use among the Moderns , but others are as yet unknown in Theory or Practice .
I now proceed to define all these Species , by determining the Intervals , of which they severally consisted ; beginning by the Diatonicum intensum , as the most easy and familiar .
The Diatonicum intensum was composed of two Tones , and a Semitone : But , to speak exactly , it consists of a Semitone Major , a Tone Minor , and a Tone Major .
This is in daily Practice ; and we find it accurately defined by Didymus , in Ptolemy 's Harmonics published by Dr. Wallis .
The next Species is the Diatonicum molle , as yet undiscovered , as far as appears to me , by any modern Author .
Its component Intervals are , the Semitone Major , an Interval composed of two Semitones Minor , and the Complement of these two to the fourth , being being an Interval equal to a Tone Major , and an enharmonic Diesis .
The third Species is the Chromaticum Toniaeum .
Its component Intervals are , a Semitone Major , succeeded by another Semitone Major ; and , lastly , the Complement of these two to the fourth , commonly called a superfluous Tone .
The fourth Species is the Chromaticum Sesquialterum , which is constituted by the Progression of a Semitone Major , a Semitone Minor , and a Third Minor .
This is mentioned by Ptolemy , as the Chromatic of Didymus .
Examples among the Moderns are frequent .
The fifth Species is the Chromaticum molle .
Its Intervals are two subsequent Semitones Minor , and the Complements of these two to the fourth ; that is , an Interval compounded of a Third Minor , and an enharmonic Diesis .
This Species I never met with among the Moderns .
The sixth and last Species is the enharmonic .
Salinas and others have determined this accurately .
Its Intervals are , the Semitone Minor , the enharmonica , Diesis and the Third Major .
Examples of four of these Species may be found in modern Practice .
But I do not know of any Theorist who ever yet determined what the Chromaticum Toniaeum of the Ancients was : Nor have any of them perceived the Analogy between the Chromaticum Sesquialterum and our modern Chromatic .
The Enharmonic , so much admired by the Ancients , has been little in Use among our Musicians as yet .
As to the Diatonicum intensum , it is too obvious to be mistaken .
Aristoxenus and others often mention the Tone as divided into four Parts , and the Semitone into two ; thereby making ten Divisions or Dieses in the fourth .
And this is true , if we consider these Sounds in one Tension ; that is , either ascending or descending : But , accurately speaking , when we consider all the Dieses or Divisions of the fourth , both ascending and descending , we shall find thirteen ; five to each Tone , and three to the Semitone Major .
But then it is to be observed , that some of these Divisions will be less than the enharmonic Diesis : For , if we divide the Semitone Major into the Semitone Minor , and enharmonic Diesis , ascending , for Instance , E , ~ E , F , and then divide in like manner descending , F , b F , E , we shall have the Semitone Major divided into three Parts thus , E , b F , ~ E , F ; where the Interval between bF and ~E is less than the enharmonic Diesis between E and b F , and between ~E and F , as is easily proved .
Now , if we suppose these small Intervals equal , by increasing the least Division , and diminishing the true enharmonic Diesis , we shall then have a fourth divided into thirteen equal Parts ; and , consequently , the Octave divided into three such equal Parts ; which gives us the celebrated Temperature of Huygens , the most perfect of all .
From this it appears , that the Division of the Octave into 31 Parts , was necessarily implied in the Doctrine of the Ancients .
The first of the Moderns who mentioned such a Division was Don Vincentino , in his Book entitled L'Antica Musica ridotta alla moderna Prattica , printed at Rome , 1555 .
folio .
An Instrument had been made according to his Notion ; which was condemned by Zarlino and Salinas , withM m2 out out sufficient Reason .
But Mr. Huygens , having more accurately examined the Matter , found it to be the best Temperature that could be contrived .
Tho ' neither this great Mathematician , nor Zarlino , Salinas , nor even Don Vincentino , seem to have had a distinct Notion of all these thirty-one Intervals , nor of their Names , nor of their Necessity to the Perfection of Music .
I must observe to you , that I received , some time ago , a Manuscript from Florence , where a Musician of that City had rightly named these Intervals of the Octave .
I found their Names , you know , many Years ago .
In Huygens 's Temperature the Tones are all equal : But , in a true and accurate Practice of Singing , they are not so .
And I must add , that the Tone divided in every Species must be the Tone Minor ; for the Division of the Tone Major is harsh and inelegant .
So that , in the Division of the fourth , it is to be observed , that in every Species , the Tone Major must either be an undivided Interval , or make Part of one .
You may perhaps wonder how the foregoing Doctrine can be found in the Writings of the Ancients , since the Distinction of Tones into Major and Minor is no where mentioned in their Writings .
But it is to be observed , that though the Terms do not occur , yet the Thing itself was not unknown to them .
I own , they have not expressed themselves fully ; yet , from the Whole of their Writings come to our Hands , I think the Doctrine before laid down may be well supported .
But , as it would require some time to put this in a just Light , I must defer it to another Opportunity .
I am , &amp;c.

