XXXIII .
The Rev. Wm. Stukeley M. D. F. R. S. to the President , concerning the Causes of Earthquakes ~ .
AMONG all the Appearances of Nature , which are the Subjects of the Inquiries of the Royal Society , none would more sensibly affect the Minds of contemplative Persons than that of an Earthquake ; especially to us in this Country , where they so seldom happen .
Read April 5 .
1750 .
When I had the Honour last Thursday * to lay my Thoughts upon it before the Society , I found that some worthy Members had not fully entered into my Way of Reasoning ; nor with that Seriousness so awful a Subject required : Therefore I judged it necessary to treat upon it in a more diffusive manner ; and with some further Considerations relating to that Argument .
Among the numerous Accounts received here , and Observations upon the Manner of it , I judged it became the Society to inquire into the Cause of so extraordinary a Motion , of which we could not have formed a proper Idea , had we not repeatedly both seen and felt it .
The Notions of the Ancients are sufficiently known ; nor have the Moderns any-way improved upon them , any further than by some chemical Mixtures .
The vulgar Opinion goes no deeper than some Caverns , not far below the Surface of the Earth ; wherein are engendered Vapours , ExP ppp plosions , ~ This Paper is printed by the Author in a Pamphlet in 8 vo .
London , 1750 .
* See this Trans p. 641 .
plosions , Fermentations , and Fires from inflammable Minerals , that cause these Convulsions of the Surface .
I shall not pretend to deny , that there may be such Vapours , Fermentations , Rarefactions , and inflammable Substances , and actual Fires , in the Bowels of the Earth , and that there may be some Caverns under-ground , as well as we find some few aboveground , Pool 's Hole , Okey Hole , and the like , in mountainous Countries .
We know there are hot Springs running continually , and Vulcano 's frequently belching out Flames and Smoke ; and to these , most probably , some smaller Earthquakes are owing .
But these Matters are very rare , much rarer than Earthquakes , both as to Time and Place .
Vesuvius in Italy , and in that Part of it abounding with Mines of Sulphur ; AEtna in Sicily ; some on the great Andes Mountains in America , and the like .
The Scarcity of them , in my Opinion , is so far from being a Proof of the general cavernous State of the Earth , that it strongly proves the contrary .
How many thousand Acres of Coal-Mines , StonePits , and the like , do they daily work in England , and have done for Ages ?
I have been myself 100 Yards deep in a Salt-Rock .
I have walked half a Mile lengthwise , directly into the Earth , and under the Bed of the Ocean : But we never hear , from the many Hundreds of Thousands of Workmen in this kind , of the cavernous State of the Earth .
On the contrary , by their hard Labour they confess it far otherwise .
Nor have we any Reason , in England , to believe there are great Mines of Sulphur , and inflammable Minerals : Nor , if there were , could they burn , and cause Convulsions of the Earth , unless there were proper Cavities , and Conveyances of Air ; as in Coal-Pits , when set on fire .
But even from these Coal-Pits , when fired , do we ever find any thing like an Earthquake produced ?
Nor did we observe , in these two last Earthquakes , any Fire , Vapour , Smoke , or Smell ; or any kind of Eruption in the least , in so great a Struggle of the Superfice , as affected a Circle of 30 Miles in Diameter .
Indeed this Consideration alone , of the Extent of this Surface , is sufficient to overthrow any Supposition of Earthquakes being chiefly owing to subterraneous Vapours .
For it cannot possibly be imagined , that such can have so immense a Force , as to act upon that Compass instantaneously , all at once , and never break Ground , so as to be discoverable to Sight or Smell .
Many Accounts we have of a little Fire-ball bursting in the Air , at a great Distance , and instantly propagating a sulphureous Smell all around it for Miles .
If the Motion of a Superficies of 30 Miles Diameter was owing to Fumes and Vapours , we ought reasonably to find some great Discharge of them , like a Coal-Pit fired : The Operation of it ought to be Hours and Days in Continuance , not instantaneous : And the Evaporation of such a Quantity of inflammable Matter requires a long time to evacuate itself .
There is another Argument , which , in my Opinion , utterly overthrows these Suppositions ; and that is , a due Consideration of Springs .
If we would form any tolerable Idea of the Nature of Springs and Fountains perpetually flowing , and that ( generally speaking ) from the Creation of the World , we must needs conceive , that GODALMIGHTY has laid their Pipes and Canals in the Earth , like as he has planted the Veins , Arteries , and Glands , in an animal Body ; and that likewise they are more and more ramify 'd , as they nearer approach the outward Shell of the Earth .
The Workmen in Coal-Mines , and the like , never fail to meet with the Veins of Springs everywhere : They that dig for Wells seldom fail of finding Water every-where .
The Colliers are obliged to drain , at very great and continual Expense .
A Circumstance not very favourable to subterraneous Fires .
Now it is apparent enough , that the Hypothesis of Vapours , and subterraneous Fermentations , Explosions , and Eruptions , being the Cause of Earthquakes , must absolutely ruin the whole System of Springs and Fountains , where-ever it has once been .
But this is quite contrary to Fact ; even where an Earthquake has been repeatedly ; for Instance , from home .
On Wednesday , April 6 .
1580 .
about 6 in the Evening , just such another Earthquake was felt in London , and around it , as these two we have seen .
Another , exactly similar , in 1692 .
In all these 4 no Houses thrown down , nor any Springs disturbed thereby : No sensible Eruptions or Smells .
These Considerations I apply only to this little inconsiderable Space of a Circle of 30 Miles Diameter .
But what is that to the Appearance of some Earthquakes we read of in History ?
In the Year of our Lord 17 .
no less than 13 great and noble Cities of Asia minor were destroyed in one Night .
The Fact is so notorious , that some Persons here present have seen a vast Block of white Marble , now standing near Naples , being the Pedestal of a Coloss Statue of Tiberius the Emperor , having carved on it , in Basso relievo , the Genius 's of all those Cities , with their Names ; which were rebuilt by that Emperor .
Without going so far , we may see another Evidence of it , a Coin of that Emperor struck upon it , with this Inscription , CIVITATIBUSASIAERESTITVTI S. I have one of them in large Brass , which was found at Colchester .
The Compass of this Earthquake may be reckoned to take up 300 Miles in Diameter .
How can we possibly conceive the Action of any subrerraneous Vapours to produce such an Effect , as instantaneously to demolish all these Cities ?
And that such an Accident should never happen after ?
How comes it to pass , that the whole Country of Asia minor was not at the same time destroyed , its Mountains renversed , its Fountains and Springs broken up , and ruined for ever , and its Rivers disannull 'd ?
Instead whereof , we find nothing suffered , but those Cities ; no kind of Alteration in the Surface of the Country , which remains the same to this Day .
From these Considerations therefore , I cannot persuade myself easily to enter into the Opinion of Earthquakes generally arising from pent-up Vapours and Eruptions .
I know there are many strange Relations of Effects of subterraneous Fires , told by Authors that deal pretty much in the Marvellous , and whose Minds were prepossessed with those vulgar Notions .
My Conceptions of the Matter are derived from the more general Appearances , and what we have seen and felt ourselves .
After we have treated this Argument in a superficial View , we must go a little deeper .
If we would consider things like Philosophers , let us propose to ourselves this Problem ; Where is the Power to be placed , that is required to move a Surface of Earth 30 Miles in Diameter ?
To answer this , consult the Engineers , and those that make Mines in the Sieges of Towns .
They will acquaint us , that the Effect of Mines is produced in Form of an inverted Cone : And that a Diameter of 30 Miles in Base , will require an Axis of 15 or 20 Miles to operate upon that Base , so as to shake it , at least .
So that the Vapours , and whatever Power we propose to operate upon that Base , according to the foregoing Hypothesis , in order to form the Appearance of an Earthquake , must be 15 or 20 Miles deep in the Earth .
But what Mind can conceive , that any natural Power is able to move an inverted Cone of solid Earth , whose Base is 30 Miles in Diameter , and Axis 20 ?
Or , was it possible , would not the whole Texture of that Body be quite disturbed and shattered ; especially in regard to its Springs and Fountains ?
But nothing like this is ever found to be the Consequence of an Earthquake , tho ' fatal to Cities .
Apply this Reasoning to the Earthquake of Asia minor ; and this vigorous Principle must lie at least 200 Miles deep in the Ground .
Enough to show the Absurdity of it .
A Cone of 300 Miles Diameter at Base , and 200 Miles Axis ; I dare be bold to say , that all the Gunpowder made since its Invention , put together , would not be able to move it .
How much less would pent-up Vapours ?
And , could it be admitted as a thing possible , will any one be persuaded , that such a subterraneous Tumult , of so vast an Extent , will be no-ways injurious to the internal System of Springs and Fonntains ?
We may as well imagine , that we may stab a Man 100 times , and never touch a Vein or Arrery .
In an Age when Electricity has been so much our Entertainment , and our Amazement ; when we are become so well acquainted with its stupendous Powers and Properties , its Velocity , and instantaneous Operation , thro ' any given Distances ; when we see , upon a Touch , or an Approach , between an Electric and a Non-electric , what a wonderful Vibration is produced , what a Snap it gives , how a lambent Flame breaks forth , how violent a Shock ; is it to be wondered at , that hither we turn our Thoughts , for a Solution of the prodigious Appearance of an Earthquake ?
It is every body 's Observation , that there never was a Winter like the past , for Warmth and Dryness , Thunder and Lightning very uncommon then ; for Coruscations in the Air , justly thought to be electrical ; especially for that called Aurora australis ; the Wind continually South and South-west , and that without Rain , which is unusual .
This State of the Atmosphere had continued 5 or 6 Months , before the first Earthquake : Is it not hence reasonable to conclude , that the Earth must , especially in our Region , be brought into an unusual State of Electricity ; and , consequently , wanted nought , but the Approach of a non-electric Body , to produce the Snap , and the Shock of Electricity ?
That the Earth was in that vibratory and electric State , we have further Reason to conclude , from the very extraordinary Forwardness of all the vegetable World with us .
Every one knows , that , at the End of February , all sorts of Garden-stuff , Fruits , Flowers , Trees , were as forward as , in other Years , in the Middle of April .
Conformable to which , Experiments abundantly show us , that electrifying of Plants quickens their Growth ; for the same Reason as in Animals it quickens the Pulse .
Any solid Matter is capable of being put into a State of Electricity ; such as iron Guns ; and the more so , by reason of their Solidity : And in proportion to it is the Greatness of the Snap , and of the Shock ; and a kind of lambent Flame issues out of the Point of Contact ; and likewise somewhat of the sulphureous Smell .
So that if both Flame and Smell were discernible in an Earthquake , it is to be found , without going to the Bowels of the Earth .
As to the immediate Cause of this wonderful Appearance of an Earthquake , I hinted that it was owing to a non-electric Body coming near or touching the Earth , when in its electrify 'd State ; which may be a Shower of Rain : And the learned Dr. Childrey observes , that Earthquakes always succeed Rain .
A sudden Tempest of Rain , in the Time of a great Drought .
At the same time that the Force of Electricity in Solids is as the Quantity of Matter , we see most evidently , that Water is equally forcible in strengthening and conducting it , and that in proportion to its Quantity : Which very much justifies my Observation , that most frequent Earthquakes have fallen upon maritime Places .
And I find the same Observation is made before me by Acosta and ` Dolittle , who wrote on that in 1692 .
and others .
In the dreadful Catastrophe of Port-royal , it is notorious , that its Violence was chiefly near the Sea : And even in those so lately felt by us , they were sensibly more violent toward the River , than further from it .
And in that Earthquake in England , in 1692 .
( which was very much like that we are treating of ) there were no Houses thrown down , nor Persons killed ; but it reached more particularly Sandwich , Deal , Dover , Sheerness , Portsmouth , and the maritime Parts of Holland , Flanders , and Normandy .
In this that happened last Sunday at 6 in the Evening at Bath , it was felt particularly at ` Portsmouth , the whole Isle of Wight , and Jersey .
If we look into ancient History , we find , in the 197th Year before Christ , an Earthquake shook terribly the Isle of Rhodes , damaged many Cities , and some were swallowed up .
17 Years before Christ , many Cities in the Isle of Cyprus were destroyed .
6 Years before Christ , the Isle of Coos was most vehemently afflicted .
During the Peloponnesian War among the Greeks , the Isle of Delos was afflicted , and the most beautiful Temple of Apollo thrown down .
Soon after , the City of Lacedaemon was totally destroyed .
A. D. 79 .
three Cities in Cyprus were overthrown .
A. D. 182 .
the City of Smyrna was ruined .
Constantinople has often suffered ; particularly in 1509 .
13000 People overwhelmed .
A. D. 1456 .
in the City of Naples 40000 People were destroyed .
In 1531 .
at Lisbon , 1400 Houses were thrown down , and near as many shattered .
In the Time of Valens the Emperor , a terrible Earthquake happened in Crete , whereby 100 Cities were destroyed .
But Instances enough , to show what I aimed at , that maritime Places are most subject : Which is no contemptible Argument in Favour of Electricity ; when both the Solid of the Earth , and the Quantity of the Water , concur to make the Shock exactly , as in common electrical Experiments .
The Gardener in the Temple Garden observed the Sound to roll from the Water-side toward TempleBar , before the ceasing of the Nodding of the Houses ; just as the electrical Snap precedes the Shock .
Others , that write upon Earthquakes , commonly observe , that the Noise precedes the Shock .
But it is obvious it must be quite the contrary , did the Concussion depend on a subterraneous Eruption .
We may well enough expect , that bursting Vapours , and subterraneous Explosions , should disperse every thing that happened in their Way into the Air : But , in my Apprehension , it is not possible for us to imagine any thing to produce such a Vibration as we felt , but Electricity .
Several People felt Pains in their Joints , Rheumatism , Sickness , Head-ach , Pain in their Back , Colic , hysteric and nervous Disorders , for the whole Day after , and longer ( especially weak Constitutions ) , exactly as upon Electrification ; and to some it has proved fatal .
Upon this Principle alone can we account for the Fishes leaping out of the Ponds ; or a sort of Thump felt at the Bottom of a Boat .
Nay , we are told of Earthquakes felt at Sea , far distant from Land : Which are easily solved by an electrical Shock impressed upon the Water : But we cannot easily see Vapours and Fires residing at the Bottom of the Ocean .
From electrical Vibration alone can we account for that Observation of Springs and Fountains being no-ways damaged after an Earthquake .
I doubt not but they run more plentifully at that time ; just as the Blood circulates quicker upon Electrification .
From Electrification only can we account for this Particular .
The Walls of Westminster Hall are of no mean Thickness ; yet those that sat with their Backs to it , during the Shock , all relate that it seemed to push toward them with great Force .
So in that of 1692 .
at Deal , the Wall of the Castle , which is of an extraordinary Thickness and Strength , shook so much , that the People living in it expected it would have fallen on their Heads .
For thus the Force of the electrical Shock is proportionate to the Quantity of the Solid .
And were Fumes and lambent Flames seen to issue out of the gaping Ground on these Disasters , as Relations tell us , we justly may pronounce them to be purely the Effect of Electricity .
It must be accounted no inconsiderable Argument in Favour of our Hypothesis , that the Northern Regions of the World are little subject to Earthquakes , in comparison of the Southern ; where the Warmth and Dryness of the Air , so necessary in Electricity , is common .
Notwithstanding that we have a Vulcano in Iceland , yet we hear not of Earthquakes frequent in that Latitude of the Globe .
But whether our Conjectures upon this important Affair be well founded or no , it certainly becomes a Christian Philosopher , whilst he is investigating material Causes , to look up to the moral Use of them ; for , in reality , every thing in the whole World was ultimately made for that Purpose .
And of all the great and public Calamities which affect us Mortals , Earthquakes claim the first Title to the Name of Warnings and Judgments ; none so proper to threaten , or to execute Vengeance : Nor has any other those annexed Terrors , so much of the unusual , the unavoidable , and the horrible Apprehension of being crushed to Death , or buried alive .
I cannot but insist upon my former Observation to be just , that Earthquakes proclaim themselves to Mankind in this Light ; because peculiarly directed to great Cities and maritime ; abounding with Wealth and Luxury .
It would be childish to make a long Recital of Particulars from History ; for had we no other sort of Notices of Earthquakes ?
Look upon those two Shocks we have felt .
We own , that Hamstead-Heath , and Finchley~Common , and Kennington Common , may have been affected with it ; yet it is notorious , that London was the Centre ; the Place to which the Finger of GOD was pointed .

