IV .
A Letter from Arthur Dobbs Esq ; to Charles Stanhope Esq ; F. R S. concerning Bees , and their Method of gathering Wax and Honey .
Castle-Dobbs , Oct. 22 , 1750 .
SIR , SINCE my View of doing Good , by making Discoveries of the Great World has been disappointed , upon my Retirement into this little Corner of it , [ Ireland ] amongst other rural Amusements I have been contemplating the Inhabitants of the Little World ; particularly that most useful and industrious Society of Bees ; and have had Time to revise the curious , ingenious , and entertaining Account given by M. Reaumur , of that inimitable Insect , with his curious Remarks and Reasoning about them ; since he has been indefatigable in his Experiments and Observations about them , as well as of most other Insects , I think it the Duty of every Person , who has had Time to make any Observations , which may contribute to come at the Truth , and complete his Natural History of Insects , to throw in his Mite towards it .
Read Nov. 8 .
1750 .
I had Leisure and Opportunities many Years ago , to make some Observations about Bees ; and all that I made confirm his general Theory , as well from his microscopical Observations , as those made by means of glass Hives ; in which he had much greater and better Opportunities to make Observations than I have had : However , as there are two Things , in which my Observations are different from his , I think think it but Justice to the curious and learned World to mention them ; that M. Reaumur , in case he be alive , and still able to follow his Observations , or , if he is not , that some other curious Person may make future Remarks , to know whether those I have made are true : As I must own myself diffident of my own Observations , when they differ from so accurate , minute , and careful an Observer , as he has shown himself to be throughout his whole Theory of Insects in general , and more particularly of the Society of our Garden-Bee .
I therefore beg Leave to lay the few Remarks I have made before you , Sir ; that if you think there is any thing in them worth communicating , you may lay them before the Royal Society , of which you are a worthy Member ; or communicate them to M. Reaumur , if he be still alive , and follows his Observations ; that , in case my Observavations are found true , he may so far alter his Remarks ; and if they are not confirmed , I shall willingly submit to his future Observations .
The only two things in which I differ from M. Reaumur , are , that I apprehend he says , the Bees range from Flowers of one Species to those of another Species , whilst they are gathering one Load ; so that the Farina , or crude Wax , loaded upon their Legs , is from different Species of Flowers ; which is contrary to what I have observed .
The other thing that I differ with him in is , that he says the Wax is formed in the Bee , from the crude Wax , or Farina ( so far I agree with him ) : But by his Observations , he says , after Digestion it is discharged upwards by the Mouth ; whereas , by my Observations , it is the Foeces , Husks , or Shells of the Farina or crude Wax , after Digestion , discharged by the Anus .
As to the first , I have frequently follow 'd a Bee loading the Farina , Bee-Bread , or crude Wax , upon its Legs , through a Part of a great Field in Flower ; and upon whatsoever Flower I saw it first alight and gather the Farina , it continued gathering from that kind of Flower ; and has passed over many o her Species of Flowers , tho ' very numerous in the Field , without alighting upon or loading from them ; tho ' the Flower it chose was much scarcer in the Field than the others : So that if it began to load from a Daisy , it continued loading from them , neglecting Clover , Honeysuckles , Violets , &amp;c. ; and if it began with any of the others , it continued loading from the same Kind , passing over the Daisy .
So in a Garden upon my Wall-Trees , I have seen it load from a Peach , and pass over Apricots , Plums , Cherries , &amp;c. yet made no Distinction betwixt a Peach and an Almond Now M. Reaumur , in his Memoir upon the Bee 's making Honey , mentions Aristotle 's Observation of the Bee 's loading or gathering from one Species of Flower without changing ; not quitting a Violet to gather from a Cowslip ; which he says is not justly founded ; for he has observed frequently a Bee on a large Border gathering from Flowers of different Species .
If M Reaumur only means , that , when the Bee gathers Honey , it takes it indifferently from any Flower , I can say nothing against it ; but , if he intends it to mean the Bee 's loading the Farina upon its Legs , then my Observation directly contradicts it .
What further confirms my Observation is this , that each Load upon the Legs of a Bee is of one uniform Colour throughout , as a light Red , an Orange , a Yellow , a White , or a Green , and is not upon different Parts of the Load of a different Colour ; so that as the Farina of each Species of Flowers , when collected together , is of one uniform Colour , the Presumption is , that it is gathered from one Species .
For , if from different Kinds , Part of the Load might be of one Colour , and Part of another .
Another Observation to confirm the same Fact is , that Bees , in the Height of the Season , return to their Hives with Loads of very different Magnitudes , some having Loads as great as small Shot , whilst others have very small Loads ; it cannot be conceived that this Difference is from the Inactivity or Sloth of the Bee in collecting its Load , but rather from the Scarcity of the Flowers , upon which it first began to load .
Now , if the Facts-are so , and my Observations true , I think that Providence has appointed the Bee to be very instrumental in promoting the Increase of Vegetables ; but otherwise , might be very detrimental to their Propagation ; and at the same time they contribute to the Health and Life of their own Species .
From the late Improvement made by Glasses , and Experiments made , in observing the Works of Nature , it is almost demonstrable , that the Farina upon the Apices of Flowers is the Male Seed ; which en tering the Pistillum or Matrix in the Flower , im pregnates the Ovum , and makes it prolific .
It is often necessary to have Wind and dry Weather to wast this Farina to the Pistillum , and from Flower to Flower , to make the Seed prolific : And we find in wet Seasons , that Grain , Nuts , and Fruit , are less prolific , by the Farina 's not being properly conveyed to the ` Pistillum ; and also in very hot dry Weather , from clammy Honey-Dews , or , more properly sweet Exsudations from the Plants themselves , which clogs the Farina , and causes Blasts and Mildews .
Now , if the Farina of specifically different Flowers should take the Place of its own proper Farina in the Pistillum , like an unnatural Coition in the animal World , either no Generation would happen , or a monstrous one , or an Individual not capable of further Generation .
Now if the Bee is appointed by Providence to go only , at each Loading , to Flowers of the same Species , as the abundant Farina often covers the whole Bee , as well as what it loads upon its Legs , it carries the Farina from Flower to Flower , and by its walking upon the Pistillum and Agitation of its Wings , it contributes greatly to the Farina 's entering into the Pistillum , and at the same time prevents the heterogeneous Mixture of the Farina of different Flowers with it ; which , if it strayed from Flower to Flower at random , it would carry to Flowers of a different Species .
Besides these visible Advantages , it may be of great Benefit to their own Species and Society ; for , as this Farina is the natural and constant Food of the Bees , during one Half of the Year , and from this digested , as it is accurately observed by M. Reaumur , is the Bouillee and Jelly formed ; which is lodged for the Food of the young Bees , until they become Nymphae : It is also necessary that Stores of it should be lodged in the Ce ls adjoining to the Hon y for their Winter Provision ; without which Mr. Reaumur observes they would be in Danger of dying of a Looseness , their most dangerous Malady .
It seems therefore highly reasonable to believe , that different Kinds of Farina may have different physical Qualities : So that , by making Collections of the same kind in each Cell , they may have proper Remedies for themselves against Ailments we have no Knowledge of , which otherwise they would not have , if they were filled at random from all Kinds of Flowers .
These further Advantages , directed to them by Providence , seem to add Weight to my Observations , and are a presumptive Proof that they are true .
The only thing , besides the former , wherein my Ob servations differ from Mr. Reaumur , is in the Manner the Wax is made and emitted by the Bee .
I absolutely concur with him , that the Wax is formed by Digestion in the Bodies of the Bees , and is emitted by them , and then becomes Wax ; and that it is almost impracticable to form Wax any other Way , unless the Wax extracted from the Myrtle-berries in America by boiling be an Exception from it .
By M. Reaumur 's Observations , he forms his Opinion , that after the Bee has fed upon the Farina , or Bee-Bread , and it has passed through the first Stomach ( which is the Reservoir where the Honey is lodged , from whence it is discharged upwards by its Mouth into the Cells ) it is conveyed into the second Stomach ; and yet , when there , great Part of it continues in its spherical or oval Form , still undigested , as viewed by him with his Glasses ; and consequently must be conveyed further , before it be thoroughly digested , and the Particles broke ; yet this he supposes is reconvey 'd upwards through both the Stomachs , and is emitted by its Mouth ; and forms his Judgment from his Observation , that the Bee , when working , and finishing the Cells , nips with its Teeth the Wax , where it is too thick , or wrong laid ; and has observed a Motion of its Tongue as it were smoothing or laying on more Materials , which he thinks must be then discharged from the Stomach by its Mouth .
What makes me disagree with him in his Opinion and Observations , is from the Remarks I have made , that the Faeces of the Bee discharged by the Anus , after the Farina is digested , is the true Wax .
We may with Truth believe , that the Farina , which is the male Seed of all Vegetables , consists of a Spirit or moving Principle , floating in a sweet Oil , surrounded by an exterior Coat or Shell , in which is that Monade that impregnates the Grain or Fruit , and makes it prolific ; that , upon Separation or Digestion , this Spirit and Sweet Oil becomes the Nourishment of the Bee ; which Spirit is of the same Nature with the Animalcules in semine masculino of Animals , and becomes the animal Spirits in the Bee and other Animals ; and perhaps the true Honey is the sweet Oil included in the Farina : And as all Vegetables abound with these vegetable vivifying Atoms , since , from many , every Bud is capable of increasing each Species , so the true Honey breaking through its Shell by great Heat , occasions those HoneyDews observed in hot Weather upon the Leaves and Flowers of most Vegetables ; which is no more than an Exudation from the Leaves and Blossoms of these Vessels that break with the Heat ; besides those that appear on the Apices of Flowers , which afterwards impregnates the Fruit .
Of this inward Substance of the Farina , diluted with Water , after Digestion , is formed the Bouillee and Jelly , which the Bees discharge upwards by the Mouth , into the Cells , to nourish the young Bees until they become Nymphae ; whilst the Husk or outer Coat is discharged by the Anus , and becomes the genuine Wax .
I have frequently , when Bees have been swarming , had them alight upon my Hands and Cloaths ; and many , at different times , have discharged their Faeces thereupon : This I have taken off , and found it of the Consistence of warm Wax , with the same glutinous adhering Quality , not crumbling like the Farina .
I have also distinguished it by the Smell to be Wax ; but it had a heavier stronger Smell , as it was fresh and warm from the Bee .
What further confirmed me in this Fact , was from my Observation of the Bees when working up their Comb in a glass Hive ; where I have constantly seen ( and must believe it impossible not to be observed by so accurate an Observer as M. Reaumur ) that several Bees , soon after one another , have by hasty Steps , walked along a Comb then forming , for the Length of two or three Cells , bending their Tails to the Comb , and striking it with a wriggling Motion from Side to Side , in a zigzag Way ; which I was convinced was discharging their Faeces , or the Wax , against the Border of the Cells , as they ran along , and repeated it as long as they had any to discharge , and then quit it ; which is the Reason why the outward Border of the Cells is so thick and strong : And immediately afterwards , other Bees came along the Cells , and with their fore Feet raised up the Borders like Paste , and thinning it , whilst other Bees were ripping off with their Teeth , and pruning away any irregular Excrescences , so as to make the Divisions of the Cells vastly thinner than the Borders or Edges , which were always thick and strong , from the discharging the Faeces or Wax upon them .
M. Reaumur has very justly observed , that , besides the three transparent smooth Eyes , which the Bee has placed in a Triangle betwixt the Antennae on the Top of its Head , the Bee has also on each Side of its Head an Eye , or rather a Multitude of Eyes , formed by a Number of distinct Lens 's surrounded each with short Hairs , which are confirmed to be Eyes , both from Swammerdam , and his own Experiments to determine it ; and that , notwithstanding these Lens 's are lined with a dark opaque Substance , yet they assist so much their Vision , that , when darkened by Paint laid over them , the Bees could not find their Way to their Hive , tho ' at a small Distance , but soared directly upwards ; nor could they find their Way when the three smooth Eyes were darkened .
But there is one Observation , which I do n't find he has made , which may have determined the Garden Bees to make almost all their Cells imperfect Hexagons .
The Observation is this ; that these opaque Eyes on each Side of the Head , consist of many Lens 's , each of which is a perfect Hexagon ; and the whole whole Eye , when viewed in a Microscope , appears exactly like a Honeycomb : Now , as the Eyes composed of these hexagonal Lens 's , are in full View to the other Bees , does it not seem that Providence has directed them so as to be a Pattern set before them , for the Bees to follow in forming their Combs ?
Is it nor also reasonable to believe , from the Disproportion of the Convexity betwixt the three smooth transparent Eyes , and the Lens 's of the dark rough Eyes , that they are appointed for different Purposes ?
why may it not be thought that the Lens 's are great Magnifiers , to view things nigh at hand , and by many Reflexions to convey Light into the dark Hives , where Light is still necessary ; and that the three other Eyes are to observe Objects at a great Distance , so as to conduct them abroad to Fields at a Distance , and back again to their Hives ?
I agree with M. Reaumur in the Form and Use of the Fang or Tromp of the working Bee , and of the Use of the Mouth within the Teeth of the Bee ; so that it does not suck , but laps or licks with its rough Fang or Tromp , like a Dog .
But I have never observed the Bee nipping or breaking open the Apices of Flowers , to let out the Farina , when it is not fully blown or open ; but have often with Pleasure observed the Bee gathering the Farina upon its Fang , by licking it off the Apices , and laying it upon the first Pair of Legs , which convey it to the second Pair , and these lodge it upon the Pallet of the third Pair , with surprising Briskness ; so that , by the time the second Pair has lodged it upon the third Pair , the Bee has gathered more , and lodged it on the fore Legs ; so that all are in constant Motion .
From the curious Observations made by M. Reaumur , upon the Structure and Behaviour of the Queen or Mother Bee , the Drone or Male Bee , and the working or Mule Bee , which is of neither Sex ; from the Queen Bee 's being so exceedingly prolific , as to lay from 30 to 40000 Eggs of working Bees in a Season ; besides the Eggs of 800 Male Bees , and of eight or ten Queen or Mother Bees ; and from the Coldness of the Male Bee , who so long resists the Caresses of the Queen or Female Bee ; and also from the indefatigable Labour and Oeconomy of the Working Bee , to nourish the young Bees , make up the Combs , and lay in Stores of Farina and Honey for Winter .
I think very good Reasons may be given why the Queen should have a Seraglio of some Hundreds of Male Bees ; and why the working Bee should destroy the Males , when no longer necessary to impregnate the Eggs of the Mother Bee .
It is evident , from the Oeconomy of the Garden Bee , that Providence has appointed that they should share their Store with Mankind , by making them so industrious in every Climate , as to provide , in tolerable Seasons , a Store of Honey and Wax , double of what is necessary for their Subsistence during the Winter , and of Combs for the Queen 's laying her Eggs in Spring , before new Work can be made .
From the vast Number of Eggs which the Queen lays in a Season , it is absolutely necessary that she should have a great Store of Male Sperm , to impregnate her Eggs ; and as the Eggs are not sensibly large in her Body for 6 Months after her Coition with the Males , who die , or are killed , in August , and she does not begin to lay from that time till February or March ; it is therefore necessary that she should have a great Store of Male Sperm within her , to impregnate all the Eggs she lays from that time , until June or July , when young Drones or Males are hatched , who are not designed for her Use , but for the young Queens , who go off with the Swarms , or for the young Queen who succeeds the old one in the old Hive ; since the Drones are great Feeders , and no Workers ; and are of no Use , but to give a sufcient Store of Sperm to the Mother-Bee ; as the working Bees have so many Enemies to deprive them of their Store , they ca n't be maintained during the Winter , even if their Life should last so long ; and as it is probable each Male has but one Act of Coition with the Queen , as they are so cold , and take so much caressing before they act , and , by M. Reaumur 's Observation , die soon after the Act is over , when , probably , their whole Store of Sperm is exhausted in that Act , as soon as the Queen has got as much Sperm lodged in the proper Reservoir , as is sufficient to impregnate all her future Eggs , the Males are no longer of Use ; and if those who have acted , die , those who have not , being of no further Use , are killed by the working Bee , out of Oeconomy to save their Winter Store , when , probably , by Nature they could live but few Days more ; as we find the Silk-worm Moth dies soon after the Eggs are laid , as well Males as Females .
It seems therefore necessary that the Queen should breed so many Males , as , by one Act of Coition from each , may impregnate all her Eggs , and that the working Bee should dispatch them , as soon as that is over , and a Store is lodged .
There are two Vessels described by Swammerdam in the Mother-Bee , whose Plate M. Reaumur has given in his Memoirs ; one of which is placed betwixt the two Lobes of the Ovarium , which he supposes to be a Bladder to contain Air ; the other is a spherical Vessel , seated close by the common Duct , in which the Eggs fall from the Lobes of the Ovarium , which he supposes is to ooze out a Juice to moisten the Eggs in their Passage .
I take one of these , but most probably the last , to be the Reservoir and Repository of the Male Sperm , wherein it is lodged from the Act of Coition , until the Eggs are enlarged , and pass thro ' the adjoining Duct from the two Lobes of the Ovarium .
Since the Preservation and Increase of Bees are evidently beneficial to the Public , I approve very much of M. Reaumur 's Instructions in driving Bees from a full Hive into an empty one , in case it can be done time enough to have new Work , sufficient for the Queen to lay her Eggs in in Spring ; since they can be fed at very little Expense , if Care be taken to keep them in a middle State of Stupefaction , neither too hot nor cold , during the Winter : But I approve much more of his castrating or sharing the Combs with the Bees , by taking the Combs best stored with Honey , and leaving those wherein are the Nymphae and Beebread ; but think in taking the Combs a safer and easier Way may be taken , than he directs : His Method is to stupefy the Bees with Smoke , to oblige them to croud together in the Crown of the Hive , and then turning up the Hive , and cutting out the Combs filled with Honey .
Now I think , that turning up the full Hive , and setting an empty Hive upon it , and driving the Bees into it , is preferable to smoking : For then a very few Bees will remain in the full Hive ; and those few may be stupefied , and the Bees in the empty Hive being put on a Table , the Combs may be taken out and selected at leisure , without Hazard ; and afterwards the empty Hive may be turned up , and their old Hive set over them , so that they will go up without Scruple into their former Hive , and repair their Work , by making new Combs : And if the Queen had not quitted the old Hive , as is often the Case , then they would return to their Queen , and the Society would not be lost , as is sometimes the Case , in driving into an empty Hive .
These , Sir , are the few Remarks I have made on revising M. Reaumur 's curious Observations on Bees , which I thought incumbent upon me to send you , to lay before your Learned Society , if it may contribute towards finishing the Natural History of Bees .
I shall take up no more of your Time , than to assure you , that I am , with the greatest Regard , SIR , Your most obedient , and most humble Servant , Arthur Dobbs .
Aaaa2 V.

