XX .
Extract of a Letter from the Abbe Nollet , F.R.S. &amp;c. to Charles Duke of Richmond , F. R. S. accompanying an Examination of certain Phenomenon in Electricity , published in Italy , by the same , and translated from the French by Mr. Watson , F. R. S. Paris , March 5 .
1750 .
May it please your Grace , IF your Grace shall have done me the Honour to have perused the Treatise I sent , entitled , Recherches sir les Causes particulieres des Phenomenes electriques , your Grace will have seen my Doubts touching the Reality of certain Facts published in Italy , and which have not succeeded any-where else .
I will not dissemble , that the Desire of knowing how far these Things were true , has been one of the principal Motives of my Journey ; and if your Grace has been desirous to have learned the Fruits of my Inquiries in this respect , you need only look over the Memoir sent herewith , which I beg your Grace afterwards to present to the Royal Society .
I well know how much that learned Body interests itself in relation to the Subject of this Memoir ; and , as one of its Members , I think it my Duty to communicate the Result of my Labours .
As I correspond with Mr. Watson , who is well versed in these Matters , it may not be disagreeable to him to put these Papers in a Condition to be laid before the Royal Society .
I have Read March have made the whole Tour of Italy , which has enabled me to make many Observations relating to Natural Philosophy .
I have made some Experiments at the Grotto del Cani , near Naples , which take off a good deal , in my Opinion , of the Marvellous of that famous Phenomenon .
I propose to myself the Honour of transmitting them upon some future Occasion , as my Letter is already too long .
The Eructations from Vesuvius were very great when I was there , and were the Prelude to three Earthquakes , which happened just after my Departure , and which I was fortunate enough not to be Witness of .
The Lagunes of Venice , and the Waters of the Mediterranean Sea , appear luminous every-where in Summer , in dark Nights : I have discovered , that this Light proceeds from a very small Insect , which multiplies prodigiously .
I have heard all my Life , that the Water of the Ocean appears sometimes luminous : It may possibly proceed from the same Cause , and I should be very glad of a particular Inquiry into this Fact .
I have the Honour to be , with the most inviolable Attachment , My Lord Duke , Your Grace 's Most humble and obedient Servant , The Abbe NOLLET .
An Examination of certain Phenomenon in Electricity , published in Italy , by the Abbe Nollet , Fellow of the Royal Society , of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , and of the Academy del Instituto at Bologna , communicated to the Royal Society by his Grace Charles Duke of Richmond , &amp;c. F. R. S. Translated from the French by W. Watson , F. R. S. ELectricity , after having excited every-where the Emulation of the Ingenious , after having filled us with Wonder by an infinite Number of Phenomenon more singular and more admirable one than another , seems , within these few Years , to have shown itself equally surprising , but more useful , in Italy , than it had done in England , France Germany , &amp;c. where , for these twenty or five-and-twenty Years , so great a Progress had been made .
We have heard of nothing less than the Cure , or the almost sudden Relief , of Distempers of every Kind , and of purging all Sorts of Persons in a manner of all others the most proper to avoid the Repugnance and Disgust we naturally have to medical Potions .
Even that Disease which we are most desirous of concealing , was not by these means without its Remedy ; the Mercury being volatilized , and carried , by the electric Matter , into the Body of the Patient , tinged his Skin of a leaden Colour , and procured him a certain Cure by a copious Salivation .
The Manner in which this was done was not less to be wondered at than the thing itself ; Persons afflicted with inveterate Gouts , Rheumatisms , Fluxions , Tumours , &amp;c. were relieved therefrom by being electrized for a few Hours , and often a less Time was sufficient .
Sometimes the rubbing a Glass Tube only , or at other times a Glass Tube lined with some Medicine appropriated to the Disease of the Patient , was employed .
These Medicines , to exert their Operation upon the Patient , passed thro ' the Glass ; and this they were very certain of , as they saw them sensibly diminish in their Quantity , although the Glass containing them was stopped as close as though sealed hermetically .
To promote Stools , it is only necessary that a Person should be electrized for six or eight Minutes , holding in his Hand a Piece of Scammony or Gamboge ; the Effects were as certain , as though these Drugs were taken internally .
Besides , if a Person was desirous of being persumed from Head to Foot , nothing more was necessary than being electrized with a Glass Vessel lined with Balsam of Peru , Benjamin , or some such Drug ; and from this Electrization the Odours were perceptible for two or three Days , even so much as to incommode those to whom these Smells were disagreeable .
Effects no less wonderful than these were published every Day , by Writings printed , and printed again * , or * The first of these Works is a Letter of M. Pivati , an Advocate at Venice .
It was first printed at Lucca in 1747 .
and some time after reprinted at Venice , always with the same Title , Della Elettricita , Lettra del chiarissimo Signor Francisco Pivati , &amp;c. This Letter was translated into French , and printed at Paris .
In 1748 .
there appeared another Treatise , printed at Bologna , entitled , Observationi fisico-mediche intorno alla Electricita , da Gio .
Giuseppe Verati publ .
profess .
nella universita e nella Academia dell Scienze del instituto academico Benedettino .
In the same Year 1748 .
there was printed at Verona a or by particular Letters and Memoirs in Manuscript addressed to the Ingenious all over Europe .
They were also confirmed by respectable Witnesses , and by such as were capable of imposing them upon Persons the most guarded against the Exaggerations , which never fail accompanying the Relations of interesting Novelties .
The Importance of the Facts themselves , and the Appearance of Authenticity which attended them , demanded that they should be considered ; and indeed they roused every-where the Attention of those Philosophers , who had for any time turned their Thoughts to these Enquiries .
Every one of them was desirous of repeating what Mr. Pivati said had been done at Venice , Mr. Verati at Bologna , and Mr. Bianchi at Turin ; and to begin them , as the Experiment seemed more simple , they attempted at first the Transmission of odoriferous Substances through the Pores of the Glass , the first Foundation of Intonacatores ~ , so called by Mr. Pivati ; and which we shall , in the Progress of this Paper , call medicated Glasses ; and they little Treatise concerning medical Electricity , entitled , Lettra del Signiore Canonico Brigoli sopra la Machina Elettrica .
Afterwards , in 1749 .
there was published at Venice a new Treatise , considerably larger than the first , in which we find not only the Author 's own Experiments , but also those of Mr. Bianchi of Turin , and of some other Persons who had taken Pains with this View .
This last Work is entitled , Reflessioni fisice sopra la Medicina Elettrica .
It is principally in this Volume that the Facts of which we are now treating are mentioned .
~ Mr. Pivati has given this Name to the manner in which he prepares hollow Cylinders of Glass in filling them , or lining them , with some Drug , the Virtue of which , he pretends , will transude with the electric Matter .
they endeavoured to purge Persons of all Ages , and of both Sexes , by making them hold in their Hand , while they were electrized , Scammony , Gamboge , Aloes , and such-like .
But it was very extrordinary , that of all the Persons who were engaged in these Experiments , no one could succeed ; and , from a sort of Shame , each of them expected , that some one would complain of his Want of Success : But this was retarded , as yet , by the Haste with which Mr. Winkler * sent to the Royal Society , and to some ingenious Men in France , the Result of his own Experiments , which well agreed with those of Italy , and upon the Credit of which he had made them .
For my own Part , I will speak without any Restraint : When I found my Attempts were fruitless , I without any Difficulty communicated it to all the Phisosophers with whom I corresponded : I desired them to let me know if they had been more successful than my myself , and to acquaint me how they had proceeded , that I might conform myself thereby .
I was much more willing to confess my Inability , and to learn from others the Method which must of Necessity be observed , than to be deprived longer from seeing those Phenomenon which ought to result therefrom .
Instead of Instructions , which might conduct me to the Success I wanted , I received nothing but such Confessions as mine : From these I saw , that all Methods had been tried ; and that nothing remained to be done , but either to believe every thing upon the Faith of others , or to doubt , without Hopes *A celebrated Professor of Philosophy at Leipsick , who has written a good deal concerning Electricity .
Hopes of being better informed .
The first of these two Cases was directly opposite to the Law I had determined to abide by , when I first engaged in the Study of experimental Philosophy ; and the other was putting a great Violence upon myself .
But from this Moment I formed my Project of travelling ; and , among the different Motives which made me undertake the Journey to Italy , I must confess one of the most pressing was , the Desire of seeing succeed , in the Hands of those who had said they had , those Phenomenon in Electricity , towards the Verification of which I had made so many fruitless Efforts .
I formed to myself a great Pleasure in seeing Balsam of Peru , Benjamin , Camphire , Cinnamon , &amp;c. pervade an electrized Glass , which I had taken care to stop myself ; to see People purged by the Palm of their Hands ; to see an old gouty Man , as the Bishop of Sebenico* , clap his Hands together , strike the Ground with his Feet , and walk freely , after an Electrization of two Minutes : But what still more piqued my Curiosity was , to learn , if possible , why the Italian Electricity should enjoy these Prerogatives , to the Exclusion of that of every other Country .
If this Singularity was as real as it appeared to be , it was a new Wonder more difficult to be explained than any other ; and of which I proposed to sludy attentively the Circumstances , to endeavour to find out the Cause .
If I have had the Trouble of passing the Alps , to search out the Truth , it is neither to conceal it , nor yet less to disfigure it with Falsehood ; and I will re* See Mr. Pivati 's Letter , printed at Lucca , p. 37 .
late , with a Liberty truly philosophical , all that have heard , and all that I have seen : But if , in doing this , I shall find myself obliged to contradict some of the Facts published by some Persons known in the Republic of Letters , I protest that it is without Prejudice , on my Part , to the advantageous Idea I may have of their Candour or Abilities ; and I sincerely wish , that the Reader may consider them in the same manner .
If he is judicious , he will willingly concur with me ; because , in an Enquiry so obscure as this of which we are now treating , an ingenious Man , with a very just Intention , may take what is false for that which is true .
I arrived at Turin about the Beginning of May 1749 .
and one of my first Cares was , to visit Mr. Bianchi , a celebrated Anatomist , and the first Author of purging by Electricity .
I related to him all that he had written to me upon this Subject ; and I begged of him , that all the Experiments , which had neither succeeded with me , nor a great many others , might be repeared between us , and under his Direction .
His Complainsance easily granted what I desired : We set about it ; and Pere Garo , a Minim , and Professor of Philosophy in the University , caused to be carried to the Place where we determined to make our Experiments his electrifying Machine ; which is exactly like that which I have described in my Essay , Page 19 .
Fig. 2 .
The Experiments of the First Day .
Upon the 21st of May , about Four o ' Clock in the Afternoon , the Weather cool , but uncertain , Mr. Bianchi having procured a Lump of Scammony , and another of Gamboge , each of which was about the Size of an Hen 's Egg ; I took the former in my Right-hand , and having applied my Left near the Surface of the Glass Globe , and standing upon a Cake of Resin , I was electrized fifteen Minutes without Interruption .
This Day the Electricity was indifferently strong .
After me , a young Man , aged Twenty-two , and of a pale Complexion , was electrized ; whom , a few Days before , I had taken into my Service .
They then electrized a young Woman of about Sixteen or Seventeen , of a weakly Constitutioh ; but who , at that time , was tolerably well .
After that M. Beccari , Professor of Philosophy in the University , aged about Thirty-five , of a dry Habit , was electrized .
They then electrized a Servant belonging to the House where they made the Experiments , aged about Twenty-four , who did not appear to be indisposed .
They also made the same Experiment upon another Servant , a strong Man of Forty , or thereabouts ; and each of these Persons was electrized the same time as I had been ; that is , fifteen Minutes successively .
I did not perceive in myself any Effect , which I could attribute to the Electricity ; no extraordinary Motion or Pain in my Bowels ; and it was the same with M. Beccari , with the Servant aged Forty , and with the young Woman .
But the young Man of Twenty-two , being interrogated after the others , said , that he had had in the Night two Stools , and some Complaints of the Colic .
The Servant of the House , who was asked the same Questions , declared , that he had had a very large Stool , as though he had taken a Purge .
These two last Depositions were , as the others , taken upon the Spot ; and I began to consider them as important , when I learned , from the Confession of the last , that he had taken , for some Days , a Decoction of wild Succory , for an Indisposition which he had not spoke of till then .
The young Man who said he had had two Stools , rendered his Testimony more than suspicious , by certain Singularities* which he was desirous of adding some Hours after ; and since that time he has conducted himself in such a manner , as to prevent my having any Confidence upon what he said .
What I have just now mentioned to have found in these two Servants , one of which kept me ignorant some time of his having taken Broth with Succory ; and the other having testified such a Love for the Marvellous , that one ought in Prudence to suspect every thing he said ; This , I say , made me very delicate in the Choice of the Persons who I was desirous should be admitted to our Experiments .
I declared that I was not willing to receive thereto either Children , Servants , or People of the lower Class ; but only that reasonable People should be admitted , and of an Age sufficient to leave nothing to be feared of the Truth of what they might depose .
The * This young Man made himself very happy in relating to every body , that he had been electrized ; and that he had been purged thereby , as though he had taken Physic : And added , that , an Hour after his Electrization , having had the Curiosity of visiting his Wife , to see what would be the Consequence , he had communicated this lectricity to her , and that she had been purged as well as himself .
The Second Experiment .
The Day after we had made our first Set of Experiments I was again electrized fifteen Minutes successively , as I had been the Day before , holding in my Hand a large Piece of Scammony ; and after me there went successively through the same Trial Dr. Scherra a Physician , Mr. Verne Demonstrator of Anatomy , the Marquis of Sirie , the Abbe Porta a Professor in the University , the Preceptor to the Children of the Marquis D'Ormea , and the Preceptor to the young Messicurs D'Osa .
This Day the Electricity was indifferently strong .
Of all these Persons who were electrized , not one felt any Pains in his Belly , no one had any Evacuation which could be attributed to the electrical Power ; but to say scrupulously all that came to my Knowledge , after several Questions , the Preceptor to young Messieurs D'Ormea declared , there he had parted with more Wind than he had usually done , and he believed also with more Urine .
Thus of seven Persons there was but one who suspected the Operation of Electricity to have had any sensible Effect upon him , and this Suspicion , as we see , was a very slight one .
The Third Experiment .
The 23d of May , the Electricity being more strong than the preceding Days , we chose a Piece of new * Scammony , very strong in its Flavour , and which * M. Bianchi suspected , that the Drugs we had made use of in our first Experiments had lost their most subtle Parts , only capable , as he said , of being introduced with the electric Matter .
which weighed four Ounces : The Marquis D'Ormea , Dr. Allion , a Physician , the two above-mentioned Preceptors , Pere Garo , Count Ferrero , and myself , held , one after the other , this Piece of Scammony , and each was electrized fifteen Minutes , as had been done in the former Experiments .
Two Days passed , and absolutely none of these Persons perceived any thing , that could be attributed to the Electricity .
The Fourth Experiment .
The same Day we endeavoured to repeat an Experiment , which M. Bianchi had wrote me word of some Months before , and which had not succeeded with me at Paris .
This Experiment was the Transmission of Odours along a Chain , or an iron Bar electrized .
One of us prepared and applied a little Piece of Linen , covered with Balsam of Peru , upon the iron Bar , which received the Electricity from the Globe : We fastened to this Rod the End of an iron Chain , which was electrized by Communication ; and we expected , that the Odour of the Balsam would be transmitted to the other End of the Chain , to which was hung a Ball of Metal .
But this was expected in vain ; nobody could perceive the slightest Sign of this Transmission .
M. Bianchi , seeing , as I did , that the Result of all these Experiments did not agree with those , which he had believed to have taken place before , told me , that this Difference might arise from our having employed an Electricity too strong : because that which he had experienced with Success had always appeared more weak .
I submitted to this Reason , having no other to give him more plausible ; and to bring the whole Operation , as near as might be , to its first Circumstances , we met together , to the Number of fourteen , at M. Bianchi 's , where we were expected ; and we were electrized , one after the other , by him , as long a time as he judged proper , sometimes with Scammony , and sometimes with Gamboge , which he himself had chosen .
The Machine used this Day was the same , with which M. Bianchi had always made his own Experiments .
It consisted of an hollow Glass Cylinder , three Inches in Diameter , and something more than half a Foot in Length * , mounted between two Supporters upon a Board , which was fastened to a Table with Screws .
This cylindrical Vessel was turned round , without any other intermediate Apparatus , by an Handle , which was at least four Inches in its Radius ; so that the Hand , by which this Machine was turned , revolved with greater Velocity than the Surface of the Glass Cylinder , which was thereby put in Motion .
This Machine had this Convenience , that one Person only might turn the Handle with one Hand , and rub the Surface of the Glass Vessel with his other : But there is no Difficulty in comprehending , that the Electricity could not but be always very weak with such a Cylinder , and from such Friction ; so that , in the Experiments of this Day , we were scarce able to perceive any Snaps , in touching the iron Chain , by which the Electricity was com* The Author here means the French Foot .
communicated , or from the Person electrized ; but this was precisely what was desired .
These Experiments were made on Thursday , May 29 , between Four and Six o'Clock in the Afternoon , in a very hot and serene Day : on Sunday Evening , all the Persons who had been electrized , being in .
terrogated , answered without Hesitation , and in a manner absolute in all respects , that they had perceived nothing which could be attributed to these Experiments : these Persons were the Marquis de Siria , Count Ferrero , the Marquis D'Ormea , Monsieur de Tignola , an Officer of Artillery , Pere Beccari , Pere Garo , Dr. Allion , Monsieur Verne , Dr. Scherra , the Abbe Porta , the two Preceptors , the young Woman , whom I mentioned before , and myself .
The Night following , that is to say , that between Sunday and Monday , I was troubled with an Indigestion , and felt Pains of the Colic ; but I attributed them much less to the being electrized the preceding Thursday , than to some Roots I had eaten the Day before at Dinner , and to a very large Glass of iced Lemonade , which I had drank some time after , and contrary to my usual Custom .
Nevertheless , as some Persons were desirous of saying , that the electrizing had purged me , and that I had not the Candour to speak of it , I thought it my Duty to add here for my Justification , that during my whole Life I have had a weak Stomach ; that I could never take Ice , nor Liquors very cold , without a good deal of Circumspection , and always at the Hazard of being incommoded therefrom ; and that these Roots , which are called Ravanelle in Piedmont , notwithstanding my Attention to eat sparingly of them , had oftentimes disturbed my Digestion , during my Stay there , and at times when I had no Concern in electrical Experiments .
Besides , the not being incommoded for three Days , and more , was sufficient to prevent my attributing what happened to me to the electrical Power .
The extreme Circumspection , with which I was desirous of choosing the Persons for all our Experiments ; the Difficulty of procuring and moving such sick People , who were in a Condition and Disposition to leave nothing to be feared on their Parts from their Prejudice , and their heated Imagination ; that of reconciling my Time with that , which a Physician of great Practice could grant me ; these Obstacles , I say , prevented my attempting with M. Bianchi such Cures , as he believed to have been brought about by means of the electric Virtue , either by its own Action , or by joining thereto Medicines appropriated to the Condition of the Sick , and contained in Glass Vessels electrized by Friction .
But I testified a great Desire of seeing those Persons who had been cured , or considerably relieved , by this Method before this time .
I asked , for this Purpose , the Gentlemen of the Profession , who had been Witnesses of the Experiments , and who were yet in a Condition of seeing every Day some of the Persons , cited in a Manuscript which I had of M. Bianchi 's ; and of whom the exact History is mentioned in the ninth Chapter of a Treatise of M. Pivati * : I went myself to the Shoemaker , in whose * Refflessioni fisiche sopra la Medicina elettrica , p. 149 .
whose Shop the young Man of twenty-one Years of Age worked , mentioned in the 11 0th Page of the above Treatise , and in Page 419 of my Recherches * .
The Obligation of saying the Truth , to which Philosophers ought to sacrifice every human Regard , will not permit me to dissemble that my Enquiries made with all possible Diligence , and without any other Interest than that of knowing the Truth , have made me see sufficiently clear , that these Facts have been greatly exaggerated .
I am willing to believe , that it is the Fault of the Sick , who , being prejudiced perhaps by too great Hope , and possessed by a kind of Enthusiasm , have said themselves , and made others believe , more than really was the Case .
One might have Examples enough to cite of such Illusions ; but be that as it will , I cannot help believing , that a great Part of the electrical Cures of Turin have been no other than temporary Shadows , which have been taken with a little too much Precipitation , or Complaisance , for Realities .
I carried with me to Venice the same Curiosity , and the same Desire of being instructed , upon the Subject of the Transmission of Odours from medicated Tubes , and of the Cures , or of being relieved from Disorders almost suddenly , by the electrical Power .
One of my first Cares was , to find out some Friends or Acquaintance of M. Pivati to acquaint him of my Arrival , and to obtain of him the Favour of being admitted into his Laboratory ; and * They have translated Hatter , instead of Shoemaker , in taking the Italian Word Calcetario for that of Calzolaio , which was sufficiently legible in the Manuscript .
and that he would have the Complaisance to satisfy my great Desire of seeing him cause Odours to pervade the Sides of a well stopped Glass , or by electrifying to diminish sensibly any Substance therein contained .
Mr. Angelo Quirini , a Venetian Gentleman , a great Friend to the Sciences , and one always ready to assist those who apply themselves thereto , did me this Service among many others , for which I am indebted to his Friendship and Politeness .
He accordingly acquainted M. Pivati ; and on the 1st of August , 1749 .
we waited upon him , and found there a large Company , among which were several Persons of Distinction : Among others were Mr. Antony Mossinigo , heretofore Embassor in France , Abbe Horter , &amp;c. At the Sight of this great Assembly I believed ( and I had some Reasons for believing it ) that my Curiosity had been * suspected of Disbelief , and of an Obstinacy to doubt ; this Company therefore was called together to be an Evidence of my Conviction .
I would have been willing to have bought at this Price the Pleasure of seeing a Phenomenon , for the verifying of which I had taken so much fruitless Trouble .
The manner of making it succeed had been without doubt some Novelty to me , as curious itself as the Effect which should have resulted therefrom .
But how great were my Surprise , and my Regret , when M. Pivati declared *I had been acquainted , that my Arrival at Venice had been notified by Letters from Turin , which had described me as a Man so prejudiced against Facts , that the strongest could not make me believe .
In this they did me great Injustice ; unless they took for Incredulity on my Part the Precaution I took , against Illusion , and false declared frankly to me , in the Presence of this whole Company , that he would not attempt to show me the Transmission of Odours ; that that Phenomenon had not succeeded but once or twice , as he had said in his first Letter printed at Lucca , although since that he had made many Attempts to repeat that Experiment , with the same as well as with other Glasses ; that this Cylinder had been since broke ; and that he had not so much as kept the Fragments of it !
But at least , I told him , I might see him use one of his medicated Tubes , and weigh it before and after electrifying , to see , with him , the included Matter diminish sensibly .
This Fact , he told me , had succeeded with him a great many times ; but that now there was too much Company ; that it was too hot , and , in consequence , that the Electricity would be too weak for it .
He might perhaps be in the Right : But why did he call together so numerous a Company ?
I then asked him concerning the Cures related in his Works , and especially concerning that of the Bishop of Sebenico * .
He avowed to me ( and in Part I knew it already ) , that the Prelate was not cured ; and that , since the Electrification , he had been as he was before .
I took my Leave of M. Pivati , and acquainted him , that I proposed to continue about a Week in Venice ; and I very earnestly begged of him to collect together his best Vessels , to renew the Substances therein , and to let me know , that , if they succeded , I might wait upon him , that I might be able to publish * See Page 374 .
supra .
lish them as an Eye-witness ; and I spoke to him with a good deal of Sincerity .
M. Pivati promised me he would ; but , as I heard nothing from him afterwards , I presume that he had nothing to show me .
Dr. Sommis , of the Faculty of Physic at Turin , being at Venice a little while after me , had also the Curiosity of visiting M. Pivati in August last , and to see , under his Management , the Effects attributed to the medicated Tubes .
The following is the Letter * he wrote me upon this Subject , Nov. 15 .
1749 .
Here is , kind Sir , in a few Words , the Account of what I observed in Venice , at Signor Pivati 's , during the Month of August last .
The 25th Day , after Dinner , he electrified me , makeing use of a Tube of the Length of about five Inches , and a little more than two in Diameter , causing me to hold in my Hand an Ounce of Scammony .
There were present at this Experiment his Excellency the Abbate Barbarigo , the Fathers Bertinelli and Magrini , Jesuits , Dr. Grampini , and several other Persons .
I found not any Change in myself either that Evening or the following Day .
The 29th of the same Month I returned again to Signor Pivati , where I found a Gentleman of the House of Soranzo , two Spanish Officers , two other Venetian Gentlemen , a Physician , and some others ; and he caused a Tube to be lined [ or plaistered within ] for the Experiment , which was represented by him in a dangerous Light ; but which was not such however as to hinder my telling him , that I desired that the Experiment might * This Letter is translated from the Italian .
might be made npon myself .
He began then to electrize me at 35 Minutes after Five in the Afternoon , and made an end , because the Line of the Wheel tangled , at 57 Minutes after Five .
Having then new-fitted the Line , he began again at five Minutes after Six , and continued till 14 Minutes after , making again this time the Sparks to issue continually from my Forehead .
This Tube was nearly of the same Length and Size as the former .
The Experiment being over , I then prayed him to tell with what Materials the Tube had been lined ; and so much the rather , as he had let fall in Discourse with the Spanish Gentleman , that they might have seen me sleep ; and he answered me , that the Tube was lined with two Ounces and six Drams of Flowers of Benjamin , and two Drams of Opium .
Having heard him mention the Opium , I prayed him to take the Trouble of making another Experiment , his Excellency Signior Abbate Pietro Barbarigo , and my self also , having with us an Ounce and Half of Opium ; and he complied with my Desire .
He therefore electrified his Excellency , making him hold the Opium , that is to say , the Quantity of half an Ounce of it , in his Hand , and the Sparks issuing from his Hand for half an Hour together , beginning at 18 Minutes , and finishing at 48 Minutes , after Six .
In this second Experiment he made use of the same Tube which he had used the Monday before , the 25th of the same Month : But neither his Excellency nor I slept more than ordinary .
These are the Experiments which I made at Venice with Signor Pivati .
In my Return home , passing thro ' Placentia , I here spoke with Dr. Cornelius , who assured me , in Presence of Dr. Riviera , that he also had tried a great many times to purge others by electrifying them ; but that it had never succeeded with him but once , which was upon a Maid-Servant , to whom he had given some Rhubarb to hold in her hand .
Notwithstanding which , finding it never to have produced the same Effect in any other Person , it rather seemed to him , that some other Cause might have occasioned what happened to his Maid .
Please to let me know , if in any thing else I can obey your Commands , and you shall ever find me ready , to the best of my Ability , ' ' &amp;c. We see then from this Letter , and from the Account I have before given of my Visit to M. Pivati , that I have not been able to verify at Venice any of those Facts , in which my Curiosity was interested .
I might add also ( and I ought , without Doubt , since I have engaged to mention exactly every thing I have been able to find out from my Enquiries upon this Subject ) , that of all the Persons of the Country , who have been with M. Pivati , to be certified of the Truth of his Experiment from ocular Demonstration , and whom I was able to interrogate , I found but one who attested them , as having seen them : This was a Physician , a Friend of M. Pivati , whom I found at his House , and who had , as he said , almost always assisted him in his Experiments .
From Venice I went to Bologna , where I became acquainted with Dr. Verati , a Member of the Academy De l ' Institut .
From the frequent Conversations I had with him , I was convinced that he was a learned , wise , and candid Man , as I had heard before .
I laid before him , without Scruple , the Doubts I had , touching the Transmission of Odours , the Effects of lined Tubes , purging by electrizing , as well as the almost sudden Cures .
Dr. Verati answered me , first , ` ` That he had made many Experiments , from the Result of which it seemed to him , that the Odour of Balsam of Peru pervaded from within to the Outside of a Glass Cylinder which he showed me .
' ' This Tube however , at this time , would not convince us of its having been done , although we rubbed it with our Hands very strongly .
But upon my representing to him , that as the Glass was closed only with wooden .
Stoppers , which could be taken off at Pleasure , to put in or take out the odoriferous Substances , it might happen , that the Odours , agitated by the Heat , might have passed through the Pores of the Wood ; he answered me , ` ` That this was possible ; and although Appearances had inclined him to believe the Transmission of these Odours through the Pores of the Glass , he had nevertheless suspended his Judgment upon this Effect , as well as upon that from lined Tubes , until new Proofs , made with more Precaution , should have entirely dissipated his Doubts .
Secondly , with regard to the Purging by Electricity , he had in his House a Man and Maid-Servant , who had been purged in this manner : That at least these two Persons had felt the same Effects as though they had taken Physic ; after having been electrized in M. Bianchi 's manner : That this Effect having no other apparent Cause than the preceding Electrization , the great Number of Facts of this kind , which had maniD dd ` ` fested fested themselves at Turin , had determined him to believe , that what happened to his two Servants was the natural Consequence of this Electrization : That , with regard to the rest , he proposed to try the Experiment again upon a sufficient Number of Persons of another Sort ; and if this Method of Purging was not constant , according to the Idea he had had thereof , he would correct , with great Freedom , what he had published thereupon in his Works , printed in 1748 .
' ' Thirdly , Mr. Verati assured me , ` ` That the ten Cures , related in his Work just mentioned , were exactly made in the manner they are described : ' ' And they are related with a good deal of Prudence , and with a Simplicity which characterizes the Truth .
The fifth of them was told and certified to me by the Person himself , one Day when I visited Father Trombelli , Abbot of the House in which he lives .
These Cures are not such as give me Difficulty to believe them : We see , at least , that they are made with Speed : We see that the Disorder , if I may be allowed the Expression , defends itself against the Remedy , and does not give place but by little and little ; and that Nature makes no sudden Transition from one State to the other absolutely different , by the means of an Electricity scarce sensible .
These Cures , I say , give me no Trouble to believe them ; because it appears to me natural enough , and I have said it a great while ago * , that a Fluid , active as the electric Matter , and which passes into our Bodies with so much * In a Discourse read to the Royal Academy of Sciences just after much Ease , may produce therein , in time , Alterations either * salutary or pernicious .
I learned nothing in the other Cities of Italy , which did not strengthen my Doubts in relation to those electrical Phenomenon , which I had a Desire to verify in the Course of my Travels .
Pere La Tor , Professor of Philosophy at Naples ; M. De la Guard , Director of the Coinage at Florence , one who has been much engaged in these Inquiries ; M. Guadagni , Professor of experimental Philosophy at Pisa ; the Marquis Maffei , at Verona ; Dr. Cornelio , at Placentia ; Pere Garo , at Turin ; all these , I say , with very excellent and well-contrived Machines , and with a great Desire of succeeding , have attempted many times to transmit the Odours , as well as the Powers of Drugs closed ( carefully ) in Tubes or Spheres of Glass , by electrizing them : All these have attempted to purge a Number of Persons ; and , according to the Accounts they gave me , have never gained their Point ; or the little Success they had , appeared too equivocal to draw therefrom Consequences conformable to those M. Pivati had believed to have seen in his Experiments .
I am now then , as it were , certain of what I began to believe last Year , when I printed my Treatise , entitled , Recherches sir les Causes particulieres des Phaenomenes Electriques : I am , I say , as it were certain , that M. Pivati has been deceived by some Circumstance to which he had not given sufficient Attention ; and what makes me believe it more than ever is , that he assured me himself , that this Transfusion of Odours , and of Drugs , through Ddd2 electrized * See these Trans. No. 476 .
p. 479 .
C. M. electrized Glass Vessels , had never manifested itself to him but once or twice directly ; I mean by a sensible Diminution of Bulk , and by such Emanations as the Smell was capable of perceiving .
Since I have understood Italian , I have been surprised not only to find this Confestion in a Letter printed at Lucca* , but also to see , that it had not had all the Effect it ought to have had upon the Minds of those , who have been in a Situation to be instructed : For my own Part , had I known it earlier , I might have saved myself a great Part of the Trouble I have taken in verifying the Fact ; and I am astonished , that they should be desirous of building upon such very slender Foundations .
It is however upon this pretended Transmission , and with a glass Tube , which was cracked from one End to the other , as M. Pivati tells you himself ~ ; it is , I say , upon this Fact , than which , in my Opinion , nothing can be less certain , that they have established the Use and Effects of lined Tubes , of which they are willing to abate nothing .
But how can we reconcile these two things , the almost never failing Operation of lined Tubes , upon so many Distempers which are said to have been cured , or considerably relieved , on one Part , and on the other the Transmission so very seldom to be perceived of the Odours of the Drugs enclosed in those Glasses , with * Page 28~ Un tale dileguamento succedutomi in un cylindro , non mi e poi veramente succeduto in altri , di quali mi son servito per vary ~ .
~ Si consumo la materia interna a segno , che siridusse non ostante l'essere quasi ermeticamente serato alla sottiliezza di un delicato foglio di carta , e come un capo morto , che no tenea piu odore ni sapore , e fino il vetro medesimo quasi consunto si apri da se stesso in piu sissure per longo .
with which you electrize ?
If it is truly the Peruvian Balsam , the Benjamin , Camphire , &amp;c. which , being animated by the electric Matter , have brought about so many Cures , as M. Pivati has given us in his Writings , why do not these strongly-scented Substances send forth their Effluvia copiously , and always , in those Places where the Experiments are made ?
And why do they not communicate themselves by their Odour to all Persons , who are penetrated thereby by means of Electrification ?
Will they say , that the Electricity , specifically operating upon their medical Virtue , separates it from their odoriferous Quality ?
Miserable Subterfuge !
Which does not merit to be opposed seriously ; and the more so , as it is by the Transfusion of their Odours , that they pretend to be assured of the Efficacy of their lined Tubes .
I am disposed to believe , that the Electricity may have cured or relieved distempered Persons ; but I do not find the Proofs of M. Pivati sufficiently strong , or sufficiently certain , to make me conceive , that the lined Glasses have contributed to these good Effects .
I think , and M. Verati himself appeared to me pretty much of the same Opinion , that if any one has been so happy as to cure Distempers by electrifying with Glasses containing Drugs , all that can be said in Favour of these Substances is , that they have not hindered the Operation of Electricity .
M. Pivati appears by his Conversation an honest and difinte.ested Person , and one capable of inducing me to be of his Opinion : But among the Facts which he collects in his Writings to fortify his Proofs , I find some that do not do much Honour to his Delicacy in choosing ; and which may make him suspected of too great Credulity .
Would one believe with him for Example , that the electric Virtue was capable of setting a Watch a going , which was stopped ; and , by its means , of regulating its Motion , when so disordered as to be impracticable to be done by the Hands of the Workmen * ?
Would one believe with him upon the Faith of a Letter void of Authority , and without having tried it , ` ` that an Ounce of Mercury had been entirely evaporated through the Pores of a Glass Vessel , with which a Man was electrized , which had made his Skin of a leaden Colour , and which had been followed by a copious ~ Salivation ?
' ' This Fact , which was said to have been done at Naples , interesting as it is , had there made so little Noise , that I was not able to find any Traces of it during my Stay in that City , after the printing and publishing of the Book , in which it is cited .
If any one should think fit to say , that it is from Humour , or from some personal Interest , that I am so obstinate in disbelieving the Facts published in Italy , which are the Subject of this Memoir , I flatter myself , that so unjust an Imputation will make no Impression upon reasonable People , by whom I have the Honour of being known , either personally , or by my Writings .
Have not I received and published in France all the Wonders in Electricity , which * Reflessioni fisiche sopra la medicina ellettrica , p. 103 .
La subita efficacia ( della ellettricita ) in dar giusto movimento alle mostre , di orologio , o ferme , o restie , o ritardanti sanza rimedio .
which have manifested themselves in England , in Germany , and in Holland , as soon as I have been able to be assured thereof by a Repetition of them ?
Have not I spoke and written concerning the Cure of the Paralytic of Geneva , as a Man truly persuaded of the Truth of the Fact , since it had been so justly authenticated * ?
By what Caprice then am I made more difficult of believing what passed in Italy than in other Countries , if the Phenomenon , which are pretended to have been seen there , could have been repeated ; or if the Testimonies , which they offered me , were not considerably weakened , or entirely abolished , when , being in the Places themselves , I was in a Condition of knowing their just Value ?
Had I only consulted my personal Interest , to whom would it have been more convenient than to me , to have adopted these Novelties ?
If they were real , they would have been so many evident Proofs of a Principle ~ , by which I have endeavoured to account for the electrical Phenomenon : A Principle , which as yet has sufficiently well served me , and which , having offered itself to Mr. Watson as well to myself , has enabled him likewise to give some Inferences exceedingly probable concerning them : Would not Odours , would not medical Substances , carried through the Pores of Glass , prove , without Doubt , that the effluent electric Matter served them for a Vehicle ?
If purging Substances were forced to pass * See my Essay sir l'electricite des corps , printed at Paris , 1746 , and my Recherches sir les Causes particulieres des Phaenomenes electriques , 1749 .
~ Essai sir l'Electricite des Corps , p. 148 .
et suiv .
pass into the Hand , and into the Body , of an electrized Person , could one doubt of their being introduced there by the effluent Matter , which came to the electrized Body ?
If the Electricity restores Health to a sick Person , in delivering him from some vicious Humour , might not I say with great Probability , that this Effect is brought about by the Effluence of the electric Matter ?
Especially as I have demonstrated by Experiments , made with great Care , that this same Matter , in going from the Body electrized , accelerates , and considerably augments , the insensible Transpiration of Animals , and , in general , all organized Bodies , replete with Fluids .
I have then set apart my own Interest to follow the Truth ; and if Prejudice has tended to lead me astray , it would be in inclining me to receive rather than call in doubt the Facts , which are the Subject of this Paper .
It is only because I cannot consider them as true , that I refuse to believe them ; and this even with Regret , as they favour my System : This indeed is of no great Importance ; but what makes me more desire their Reality , is , the great Good which would result to Society .
Could any good Subject , possessed of the Art of healing by Electricity , as M. Pivati pretends to be , spend his whole Time better than in devoting it to the Relief of a great Number of human Creatures , afflicted with great Variety of Maladies ?
I am induced to believe , that the Greatness of this Idea has imposed upon those , who have published , without Doubt , with a little too much Precipitation , this new Medicine : The great Desire of being useful has made them hope ; and the Goodness of their Hearts making them dispense pens too easily with the Severity of a necessary Examination , it may be imagined , that they have considered as real Success , what was in Truth only a Phantom .
It remains to say , that in these Researches I have coveted Truth , only for her own sake ; and have no Interest in convincing those who may think proper still obstinately to believe , what has been published concerning lined Tubes , electrical Purgations , instantaneous Cures , &amp;c. I do not pretend to make any of my Opinion , but those , who , having read without Prejudice what I have here related , may find themselves touched by my Reasons : But if after this there can be any one , upon whom the Love of the Marvellous can make a victorious Impression , I shall not think ill of them , if they embrace Opinions opposite to mine ; Qui vult decipi , decipiatur .

