XIV .
A Letter from the Rev. Mr. Richard Dunthorne to the Reverend Mr. Richard Mason F. R. S. and Keeper of the Woodwardian Museum at Cambridge , concerning the Acceleration of the Moon .
SIR , AFTER I had compared a good Number of modern Observations made in different Situations of the Moon and of her Orbit in respect of the Sun , with the Newtonian Theory , as in my Letter of Nov. 4 , 1746 ; ~I proceeded to examine the mean Motion of the Moon , of her Apogee , and Nodes , to see whether they were well represented by the Tables for any considerable Number of Years , and whether I should be able to make out that Acceleration of the Moon 's Motion which Dr. Halley suspected .
Vide Phil. Trans. n. 218 .
Cambridge , Feb. 28 , 1748-9 .
Read June 1 .
1749 .
To this End I compared several Eclipses of the Moon observed by Tycho Brahe , as they are set down in his Progymnasmata p. 114 , with the Tables * , and found them agree full as well as could be expected ; considering the Imperfection of his Clocks , and the Difficulty there must commonly have been in determining the Middle of the Eclipse from the Facts observed , as published in his Historia Caelestis .
Indeed the small Distance of Time between Tycho Brahe and ~ See these Transact. No. 482 .
p. 412 .
* My Tables corrected as in my former Letter ; which is always to be understood of the Tables mentioned in this .
and Flamsteea rendered Tycho 's Observations but of little Use in this Enquiry .
The next Observations that occurred to me were those of Bernard Walther and Regiomontanus , which being at double the Distance of Time from Flamsteed that Tycho 's were , seemed to promise some Assistance in this Matter : Upon comparing such of their Eclipses of the Moon whose Circumstances are best related with the Tables , I found the computed Places of the Moon were mostly 5~ too forward , and in some considerably more , which I could hardly persuade myself to throw upon the Errors of Observation ; but concluded , that the Moon 's mean Motion since that time , must have been something swifter than the Tables represent it ; though the Disagreement of the Observations between themselves is too great to inser any thing from them with Certainty in so nice an Affair .
Then I compared the four well-known Eclipses observed by Albategnius with the Tables , and found the computed Places of the Moon in three of them considerably too forward : This , if I could have depended upon the Longitude of Aracta , would very much have confirmed me in the Opinion , that the Moon 's mean Motion must have been swifter in some of the last Centuries than the Tables make it ; though the Differences between these Observations , and the Tables , are not uniform enough to be taken for a certain Proof thereof .
I could meet with no Observations of Eclipses to be at all depended upon between those of Regiomontanus and Albategnius , except two of the Sun and one of the Moon made at Cairo in Egypt , related in the Prolegomena to Tycho Brahe 's Historia Caelestis , p. 34 ; nor any between those of Albategnius and Ptolemy , besides the Eclipse of the Sun observed by Theon at Alexandria ; notwithstanding I carefully searched all the Remains of Antiquity I could find with that View .
These Eclipses of the Sun are the more valuable , because they were observed in Places the Longitudes and Latitudes whereof are determined by Monsieur Chazelles of the Royal Academy of Sciences , who was sent by the French King in the Year 1693 , with proper Instruments for that Purpose .
Du Hamel Hist. Acad. p. 309 , 395 .
The solar Eclipse observed by Theon was in the 112th Year of Nabonassar the Day of Thoth , according to the Egyptians , but the 22d Day of Pauni , according to the Alexandrians : He carefully observed the Beginning of 2 temporal Hours and 50~ Afternoon , and the End at 41/ 2 Hours nearly Afternoon at Alexandria .
Theonis Comment .
in Ptol .
mag .
Construct .
p. 332 .
This Eclipse was June 16 , in the Year of Christ 364 : And the temporal Hour at Alexandria being at that time to the equinoctial Hour as 7 to 6 , makes the Beginning at 3 equinoctial Hours and 18~ Afternoon , and the End at 5 equinoctial Hours 15~ nearly .
The Eclipses observed at Grand Cairo were as follows .
Anno Hegirae 367 , die Jovis , qui erat 28 , rabie posterioris ( is est ordine mensis quartus , et incipit ille annus Saracenicus die 19 Augusti , anno Christiano 977 ) observatum fuit Cahirae in AEgypti metropoli initium eclipsis solaris , cum altitudo solis esset esset 15~ 43~ .
quantitas obscurationis 8 digit .
Ea finita , sol elevabatur 331/ 2 gr. Ex Schickardo in M S. ' ' This Eclipse was Decemb. 13 , in the Year of Christ 977 , the Beginning at 8h 25~ , and the End at 10h 45~ apparent Time in the Morning .
Anno eodem die Sabbathi , videlicet 29 mensis Sywal ( numero decimi , qui Paschalis est eorum ) eclipsis Solis occupavit digitos 71/ 2 .
In principio Sol altus fere 56~ .
In fine Sol occiduus elevabatur gradibus 26 .
Ex Schickardo in M S. ' ' This Eclipse was June 8 , in the Year of Christ 978 .
The Beginning at 2h 31~ , and the End at 4h 50~ apparent Time Afternoon .
Anno Hegirae 368 ( qui incaepit die 9 Augusti , anno Christiano 978 ) die Jovis , 14 Sywal , Luna fuit orra cum defectu , qui ad 51/ 2 digitos accrevit ; cum extaret supra horizontem gradibus etiam 26 subaudio finem tunc accidisse ) .
Schickardus.''This Eclipse was May 14 , in the Year of Christ 979 ; but as the Middle cannot be known from what was observed of it , I made no use thereof in this Enquiry .
The Account concludes with the following Paragraph : Hae tres observationes habitae sunt ab Ibn-Junis , qui jussu Regis Abu-Haly Almanzor , sapientis , AEgypto tunc Imperantis , rebus vacabat caelestibus .
Hujus authoris tabulas habet Jac. Golius Professor Lugdun .
( qui mihi inde communicavit ista ) in quibus plures aliae , sui et superioris aevi observationes extant .
Locus observationis propinquus urbi Cahiro .
Schickardus .
' ' That the before-mention 'd solar Eclipses might be applied to the Examination of the Lunar Motions , I contrived the following Method ; which I think renders Eclipses of the Sun as useful at least as those of the Moon are in that Business .
BI ~H~ ~~ ~ G F ~~ ~ AE~C Let ABC in the annexed Figure represent half the Earth 's enlightened Disk , AEC a Portion of the Ecliptic projected thereon FGH the Path of the Moon 's Shadow over the Disk , EI , the universal Meridian , ~ the Situation of the Place at the Beginning of the Eclipse , ~ its Situation at the End thereof , ~ the Centre of the Shade at the Beginning , and ~ its Centre at the End of the Eclipse .
Draw E G , ~ ~ , and ~ ~ , perpendicular to the Path of the Shadow , ~~ parallel thereto ; join ~~ and ~ ~ , and through ~ draw ~~~ perpendicular to A C. Then ( computing the true Places of the Sun and Moon at the observed Times of the Beginning and End of the Eclipse ) we shall have given ~~ the Motion of the Moon from the Sun in her Orbit during the Time of the Eclipse , and ~~=~~ the Semidia~ meter of the Penumbra ; which are to be reduced into such Parts as the Semidiameter of the Disk contains tains 10000 : The Angles BEI and BEG , being found by Methods commonly known , GEI their Sum or Difference will be likewise given .
Also E~ and E~ will be Sines of the Sun 's Altitude at the Beginning and End of the Eclipse respectively ; IE~ and IE~ are the Angles at the Sun between the Vertex of the Place and the Pole of those Times ; which being found , the Angle ~E~ , their Difference will be known , from whence the Line ~~ and the Angle E~~ may be computed .
The Angle GE~ is the Sum or Difference of the known Angles GEI and IE~ : In the Figure before us , the Complement of this to a Semicircle is E~~ ; which being subtracted from E~~ leaves the Angle ~~~ , from whence and the Line ~~ , ~~ , and ~~ = ~~ may be found .
Let a=~~-~~ , b=~~=~~ , c=~~ , and x=~~=~~ .
Then ~bb-xx=~~ , and ~bb-cc-2cx-xx=~~ , by Eucl .
1.47 .
Consequently a-~bb-xx=~bb-cc-2cx=xx which being reduced , gives us the quadratic Equation xx cx = 4a2b2-a4-2a2c2/ 4aa+4cc .
This Equation solved , gives us the Value of x , from which ~~ and ~~ will be likewise had .
In the Triangle ~~~ we have ~~ and the Angle ~~~=GEB given , whence ~~ and ~~ may be found : Consequently ~~ will be known ; and from the observed Time of the Beginning of the Eclipse , and hourly Motion of the Moon from the Sun , the Time when the Centre of the Shade is at ~ will be had .
Lastly , in the Triangle E1~ , we have given the Side E~ , and the Angle E~1= BE~ ( the Sum or Difference of the Angles BEI and IE~ ) ; therefore the Sides E~ and ~~ may be found .
But E~ is the Distance of the Moon from the Sun in the Ecliptic , and ~~~~~ the Moon 's Latitude at the Time when the Centre of the Shade is at ~ ; which may be compared with the Computation from the Tables for that Time .
By this Means I compared the aforesaid Solar Eclipses with the Tables , and found the Difference in Longitude and Latitude , as follows .
Apparent Time Diff. ~a~ Lat. ~~a~ Lat. ~ Diff. from Obser. Diff. in Lat. A. D. at Greenwich .
from E ~ .
from ~~ .
by Tab. by Tab. nLong in Lat. from Digits observed .
~ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 364 June 16 .
24 20 39 41 in conseq .
34 37 Nor 35 25 37 26 Nor .
-4 16 +2 49 ' ' ' 977 Dec. 12 .
19 12 30 43 39 in antec .
30 23 Nor .
36 3 31 50 Nor .
+7 36 +1 27 -2 36 ~ June 8 .
1 16 10 29 3 in conseq .
8 24 Sou .
37 48 3 21 Sou .
+8 45 -5 3+3 38 The Agreement there is between the two last of these Differences in Longitude , shows that the Tables represent the mean Motion of the Moon 's Apogee very well for above 700 Years , the Moon being very near her Perigee at the Time of one of those Eclipses , and near her Apogee at the Time of the other .
By the same Method I also compared the Sun 's Eclipse , July 29 , 1478 .
( which appears , from what is related of it , to have been carefully observed by Bernard Walther at Nuremberg ) , with the Tables , and found the Difference in Longitude to be + 10 ' 29 ' ' , and in Latitude + 9 ' 12 ' ' .
This wide Difference in Latitude , from the Tables , that agree so well with the former ancient Observations , confirmed me in the Opinion , that the Nuremberg Observations are too inaccurate to determine any thing from them in this Affair .
The Eclipses recorded by Ptolemy in his Almagest , are most of them so loosely described , that , if they show us the Moon 's mean Motion has been accelerated in the long Interval of Time since they happened , they are wholly incapable of showing us , how much that Acceleration has been .
There are indeed two or three of them attended with such lucky Circumstances as not only plainly prove , that there has been such an Acceleration , but also help us to guess at its Quantity .
One of these is the Eclipse , said by Hipparchus to have been observed at Babylon , in the 366th Year of Nabonassar , the Night between the 26th and 27th Days of Thoth , when a small Part of the Moon 's Disk was eclipsed from the North East , half an Hour before the End of the Night , and the Moon set eclipsed .
This was in the Year before Christ 313 , Decemb. 22 .
The Middle of this Eclipse at Babylon ( supposing with ~ the Meridian of that Place to be 50 ' in Time East of the Meridian of Alexandria ) , by my Tables was Dec. 22 .
4h 4~ apparent Time ; the Duration was 1h 37~ , Ptolemy makes it 1h 30~ nearly ; whence the Beginning should have been about 5h 15~ after Midnight : According to Ptolemy , the Night at Babylon was at that Time 14h 24~ long , and therefore Sun rise at 7h 12~ after Midnight : and as the Moon had then South Latitude , and was not quite come to the Sun 's Opposition , her apparent Setting must have been something sooner , i. e. more than an Hour before tha Beginning of the Eclipse , according to the Tables ; whereas the Moon was seen eclipsed some Time before her Setting ; which , I think , demonstrates , that the Moon 's Place must have been forwarder , and consequently her Motion since that Time less than the Tables make it by about 40 ' or 50 ' .
But the computed Place of the Moon in each of the before-mentioned Solar Eclipses observed at Grand Cairo , being about 8 ' before her Place , from Observation shows us , that the mean Motion of this Luminary has been something greater in the last 700 Years than the Tables suppose it , and therefore must have been accelerated .
This Acceleration is further confirmed by the Eclipse , which Hipparchus says was observed at Alexandria , in the 54th Year of the second Calippic Period , the 16th Day of Messori , when ( he says ) the Moon began to be eclipsed half an Hour before her Rising , and was wholly clear again in the Middle of the third Hour of the Night .
This was in the Year before Christ 201 .
Sept. 22 .
The Middle of this Eclipse at Alexandria by the Tables was Sept. 22 .
7h 44~ apparent Time ; and the Duration 3~ 4~ , which makes the Beginning at 6~ 12~ apparent Time , that is , about 10 ' after the rising of the Moon at Alexandria , or 40 ' later than the Beginning from Observation .
This Difference in Time makes a Difference of near 20 ' in the Moon 's Place .
The most ancient Eclipse of which we have any Account remaining , namely that related by Ptolemy , to have been observed at Babylon the first Year of Mardokempad , in the Night between the 29th and 30th Days of Thoth , in which the Moon began to be eclipsed when one Hour after her Rising was fully past ; if , by reason of the Latitude of the Expression , pression , it be not a direct Proof of the Acceleration , it may nevertheless help to limit its Quantity .
This Eclipse was in the Year before Christ 721 .
March 19 .
The Middle whereof at Babylon , by the Tables , was March 19 .
10h 26~ apparent Time ; and the Beginning at 8h 32~ , the apparent Rising of the Moon at that Place was about 5h 46~ Afternoon ; so that the observed Beginning of the Eclipse was at least 6h 46~ Aftetnoon , i. e. not above ~ before the Beginning , by the Tables : Wherefore the Moon 's true Place could precede her Place by Computation but little more than 50~ at that Time .
If we take this Acceleration to be uniform , as the Observations whereupon it is grounded are not sufficient to prove the Contrary , the Aggregate of it will be as the Square of the Time : And if we suppose it to be 10~ in 100 Years , and that the Tables truly represent the Moon 's Place about A. D. 700 .
it will best agree with the before-mentioned Observations ; and the Difference between the Moon 's Place by the Tables and her Place in the Heavens , will be as follows .
Years Error of Years Error of Years Error of before Tab. of Tab. of Tab. Christ .
Christ .
Christ .
~~~~~~ 70 56 6 200 12 30 1100 +40 600 49 50 300 9 20 1200 +4 10 500 44 0 400 6 30 1300 +40 400 38 30 500 40 1400 +3 30 300 33 20 600 1 50 1500 +2 40 200 28 30 700 00 1600 +1 30 100 24 0 800 +1 30 1700 00 A. D.~ 19 50 900 +2 40 100 16 0 1000 +3 30 I am , SIR , Your humble Servant ,

