Philos. Transact. No.492 TAB. IIII Fig. 1 .
p. 148 .
Fig. 2 .
XI .
A Letter from Mr. Emanuel da Costa F. R. S. to the President , concerning two beautiful Echinites .
SIR , IHAVE the Honour of laying before you ( in order to communicate to the Royal Society , if you think it worthy ) the Description of two Echinites , or Stones moulded in fossil Echini Shells , hitherto underscribed , as far as I know .
Read May 11 .
1749 .
These Echinites are undoubtedly moulded in Shells , of a Genus of which we at present find some Species now living in the Seas ; mostly in the West Indies .
The Echinometra of Aristotle , Aldrovand , and of Dr. Grew ( a ) , is of this Genus .
Dr. Breynius ( b ) calls the whole Genus Echinanthus ; and Mr. Klein ( c ) Scutum .
Woodward ( d ) in his Distribution of fossil Echini calls them the Pentaphylloides , from the Rays on the upper Part forming a beautiful cinquefoil Figure ; but wrongly fixes their Characteristics in having only one Aperture , and that at the Basis ; in which he nor only contradicts Nature , but also the very Specimens he quotes in his own Collection , which have all two Foramens or Apertures , and are elegantly figured so by Agostino Scilla ( e ) who was the Person that sent them to the Doctor ; and ( a ) Museum Reg. Soc. p. 139 .
( b ) Schediasma de ~ , p. 60 .
( c ) Not .
Disp .
Echinodermatum , p. 20 , TA B. 17 .
A , et TA B. 18 , B. ( d ) Cade of foreign extraneous Fossils , p. 16 .
( e ) La vana Speculazione disingannata dal senso , TA B. 9 , 10 , and our late President Sir Hans Sloane ( f ) has also figured and described two Species of this Genus , whereof one Species is an Inhabitant of our English Seas .
I observed above , that , to my Knowledge , no Author has ever described Echinites or Stones moulded in the fossil Echini of this Genus ; nor even have the fossil Echini or Shells themselves been ever exhibited by any Lithologist , except by the abovequoted A. Scilla , who sent them to Dr. Woodward , and found them in Malta ; to which the Doctor in his Catalogue recounts two other Specimens , which were dug up in Maryland ; so rare are the Instances of the Fossils of this whole Genus !
The two Echinites here described ( as also some few other Specimens of this sort , which I hear are in some Cabinets in this Metropolis ) were all found in the midst of some Rocks , which were blown up at Port Mahon some Years ago , and from whence they were all brought .
The first or largest is in the Possession of the Right Rev. Dr. Lavington , Lord Bishop of Exeter it is composed of a hard or stony arenaceous greyish Substance , and is of an Escutcheon or Heart-like Shape : It measures about 141/ 2 Inch in Circumference , or quite round the Limb or Edge , about two Inches high from the Flat or Basis to the Tip of the Apex , five Inches in Length at the Basis , and 41/ 4 in Breadth .
On the upper Part it rises nearly gradually from the Edge quite to the Apex .
A central Point , with a slight declining Space , tops the said Apex ; from which Space ( f ) Not .
Hist. of Jamaica , Vol. 2 .
TAB. 242 , Fig. 3 .
et seq. Space the Body regularly divides into five Parts figured like Leaves to the Edge .
These Leaves are narrow at the Apex , greatly widen toward theBottom , and narrow a little again at theirEnd .
Each Division or Leaf is bounded on each Side by a Row of parallel Ridges , which are accompanied also on each Side of every said Row , with two other Ranges of Points or Knobs ; all which Rows do not meet or close together at the lower End of the Division , but leave a void unwrought Space : A Row of larger irregular Knobs runs through the midst of each Leaf .
From the Divisions between each Leaf runs a rugged knobb 'd Pillar , which is joined to the Edge : The other Parts between the Leaves and the Edge are Hollows , or void Spaces .
The Edge or Limbus is of a thick cylindric Make , runs quite round the whole Body , and only has some Signs of being disjoined at the one Extreme of the Length , or where the Aperture was ; the Stone answering which is here extended a little cylindrically outward like an Appendage , and was so formed by the stony Matter being too much in Quantity for the Shell , and so was protruded through the said Foramen .
On the outer Edge of the Limbus are some few irregular stony Concretions .
The Basis is flat , and is likewise divided into five Parts from the Center , which is one of the Foramens ; the other Foramen ( as has been above described ) being placed at one of the Extremes of the Length .
This Foramen or Center is about the Size of a Shilling .
The five Divisions extend to the utmost Edge of the Body , or quite over the Limbus , contrary to the Divisions on the upper Part , which extend only to it .
Each Division is formed by a stony Line edged on each Side with stony cylindrical Bodies of the Thickness of a Pin , but of different Lengths , so as to appear like the Teeth of a Comb , or the Gills of a Fish ; the Interstices between all which is a rugged stony Work , and Hollows pervading quite through the Body to the upper Part .
I cannot but think these five pectinated Divisions on the Basis owe their Figure to some Parts of the included Fish ; which I am more confirmed in , as I have seen some Specimens of the common pileated and galeated Echinites , which have been hollowed at their Apex , and marked star-wise ; that Concavity , and the stellar Mark proceeding from the Interposition of the Fish between the stony Matter then filling the Shell , and the Top of the Shell itself .
The other Echinite I have the Honour of producing before the Society , belongs to Mr. Edward Jacobs of Feversham .
It is of a different Species , though of the same Genus , of a heart-like Shape , and about one third the Size of the above-described .
This is greatly copped , the Apex lying very high , and the five Divisions running near perpendicularly down to the Edge .
The upper Part of this is elegantly perfect ; the Work is near the same as on the other ; only that , by the Perfection this preserved is in , we observe that the Rows of parallel Ridges , which adorn each Side of each Leaf or Division , rise into a kind of arched Work or Bridge , made up of arched cylindrical Bodies , through which the middle Row runs , joined or connected in a long strait cylindrical Stem , in a most curious and elegant manner .
The Basis or under Part of this Specimen is very imperfect , and only seems to differ in the Center being greatly excavated or concave , answering to the great Copping or Height of the Apex or upper Part .
This Fossil also consists of a hard stony arenaceous Substance like the other .
From the Inspection of the several Hollows of these Echinites , it is evident they were not immediately moulded in the Shells , but were formed in Cavities which those Shells formerly filled in the Rocks they were lodged in .
The Rocks were apparently of a loosened arenaceous Texture , and the Water &amp;c. continually pervading them , rotted and destroyed the enclosed Shells , and bore away their whole Substance .
In the same manner , and by the same means , were the stony Particles replaced into those very Cavities which the Shells formerly filled ; consequently these Bodies were moulded exactly to the said Cavities .
This Remark carries a Conclusion with it , if Observation be made , that the Hollows and solid Parts of these Stones exactly answer to the Hollows and solid Parts of the very Shells themselves ; which , had they been moulded in the very Shells , must have happened directly contrary ; the solid Parts of the Shells forming Hollows in the Stone , and vice versa .
In all sandy or lax earthy Matter fossil Shells are very seldom found , but only the moulded Stones ; the loose Texture of those Substances giving free Access to Water , Vapours , and mineral Exhalations , &amp;c. which entirely corrode and destroy the Shells buried in it .
I have taken the Liberty to produce before the Society a recent Echinus of this Genus from the West Indies , to elucidate my Subject ; as also two Drawings done by Mr. Mind ; viz. of the Basis of the large Echinite , and the upper Part of the small Echinite : All which are engraved in TA B. IV .
I am , with Respect , London , April 27 , 1749 .
SIR , Your very devoted , and obliged humble Servant , Emanuel Mends da Costa .
References to the Figures .
See TA B. IV .
Fig. 1 .
A View of the upper Part of a curious Echinite , in the Possession of Mr. Edward Jacobs , of Feversham in Kent .
Fig. 2 , A View of the under Side of the same Echinite .
Fig. 3 .
A View of the under Side of a curious large Echinite , in the Possession of the Right Rev. Dr. George Lavington , Bishop of Exeter .
N. B. The upper Part of this Echinite having nothing remarkably particular or different , it was not judged necessary to give a Figure of it .

