VIII .
Extract of a Letter from Benj .
Heath Esq ; to Peter Davall Esq ; Secr. R. S. enclosing a Proposal for entirely removing the only real Defect in the lateral Operation for the Stone ; by Mr. John Mudge Surgeon at Plymouth .
Dear Sir , ***I TAKE the Freedom of conveying to you a Memoir written by a very ingenious young Surgeon of my Acquaintance proposing an Improvement in the lateral Method of cutting for the Stone .
His View in putting me on giving you this Trouble is , that it may be laid before the Society ; and if it be thought to deserve it , it may be communicated to the Public in their Transactions .
I am , Read Feb. 2 .
1748 .
SIR , Your most humble Servant , Benj .
Heath .
Exeter , Jan. 16 .
1748 .
A Proposal for entirely removing the only real Defect in the lateral Operation for the Stone .
TH O ' the lateral Method of cutting for the Stone is now almost universally allow 'd to have greatly the Advantage of any other hitherto discovered , yet it must be confessed , that the Difficulty and Hazard attending the Extraction of large Stones this Way , has really robbed it of its Title to Perfection ; for tho ' the Incision be made to the Wish , quite through the Prostate , and carried on to the Neck of the Bladder , if this be the Case ( for it frequently happens to the contrary ) as the Bladder itself in general is not , nor in all Probability can be , wounded in this Way of operating , the real Aperture after all for the Exit of a large Stone is so small , that the Parts must suffer most violent Lacerations , and a Train of consequent Evils .
The old Method indeed is greatly more obnoxious to this Misfortune , because the Parts are torn to Pieces by downright Violence , without any previous Incision of any Consequence to prepare them for the Egress of the Stone ; and this Imperfection in the Operation is so notoriously apparent , and so destructive in fact , that this Method is deservedly in Disesteem , and almost universally discarded .
I wish it could be said , that the lateral Method was entirely free from this Imperfection ; but I fear an impartial Inquiry will make it clear , that three Fourth , of the Accidents which have attended this Operation , may in truth be attributed to excessive Distensions and Lacerations of the Bladder , those few Cases , which have miscarried from ( what may have been supposed ) a mere symptomatic Fever , will , I believe on a strict Disquisition , afford a shrewd Suspicion , that this very Fever itself arose from some Violence offered to the Bladder , in the forcible Extraction of the Stone .
I will not enter into a strict Examination of those fatal Symptoms which sometimes succeed the Operation in grown Subjects , in order to prove that they D in in general proceed from the Bladder 's being too roughly dealt with , because I take the Case to be of itself very evident : Unless the Habit is remarkably bad , to what else shall we attribute violent Pain , and the successive Inflammation , Tumour , Suppression of Urine , Mortification , &amp;c. ?
These surely are not the Attendants on a simple Incision only ; for constant Experience evinces , that the Bladder , tho ' an Organ of great Importance , and essentially necessary to the animal Oeconomy , may be wounded with as little Danger of any of the above-mention 'd Evils , as any other membranous Part .
But I believe we shall not be at a Loss for the true Cause of all those Mischiefs , if the State of the Parts in the Extraction of a large Stone be closely considered .
It may be observed , when a Stone is laid hold of by the Forceps , that both together , Stone and Forceps , from the Screw-pin to the former , form a complete Wedge ; insomuch that a Person in a forcible Extraction , can scarcely conceive the Power applied to the Bladder , or the Force with which it is distended .
If the Diameter of the Stone be equal to a third Part of the Length of the Chops of the Forceps , a Force of ten Pounds applied to them will be to the Wound of the Bladder , equal to thirty ; but how shocking must be the Case , when ( either on account of the Magnitude of the Stone , or Narrowness of the Wound ) a Man uses his utmost Force , and many such Instances in adult Bodies I have seen .
The Power is then augmented by the Action of the Lever to two or three hundred ; a Force no doubt sufficient to reduce the Bladder and neighbouring Parts to Rags .
This is scarce to be credited ; but there is too much Reason to believe , that the Want of Success in Subjects arrived at adult Age , where the Stones are almost always large , is owing entirely to this very Circumstance .
When all this Violence is insufficient , there is at present no other established Method , than either to attempt the making a second Incision on the Stone , as it is held in the Forceps , or to withdraw the latter , and to make it on the Bladder , in the flaccid State it then lies , without any Guide at all .
As to the first Method , it is evident the Forceps , Stone , and Bladder in Men are so much in the dark , that the Incision must be made with the utmost Difficulty ; indeed it is hardly possible to cut at all with any Certainty .
The other Way of cutting on the Bladder when the Forceps is withdrawn is much worse ; for if it be remembered , that the Bladder lies upon , and is contiguous with the Rectum , and that they are both in the same flabby State , it will appear impossible to cut the one , without ( at least a very great Risque of ) wounding the other .
This manifest Defect in the Operation would be intircly removed , if there always was a Director for the Knife left in the Bladder ; and this is so easily and completely to be done , that its great Simplicity seems to be the Reason it has not been attended to .
If one Limb of the Forceps , from the Joint to its Extremity , be converted into a Staff , by making a deep Groove through its whole Length , it will better answer the End desired , than if it were possible to suffer the Staff itself to remain in the Bladder during the Operation ; for , when a large Stone is laid hold of , and the Forceps of course much divaricated , insomuch that the Extraction of the Stone is found to be impracticable with Safety , without a second Incision on the Parts upon the Stretch ; you then slide the Point of a narrow Knife on the Groove of the Forceps quite on into the Bladder , and it will divide the very Part which needs it most ; whilst the Rectum , on account of its flaccid State , will most certainly escape wounding .
If the Wound is desired to be but little larger , the Forceps must be but gently drawn forward when the Incision is made ; but if , on the other hand , the Stone prove extremely large , the Forceps should be then drawn forwards with a Force sufficient to put the Bladder upon the Stretch ; and by this Management the Dilatation may be made as great or little as is required .
As the common Knife is not so proper for this Purpose on account of its Breadth , I have got one made of a more convenient Form , with a GorgetHandle and Button-Point , as in the Bubonocele Knife .
This Method , as it removes all Occasion for Violence to the Bladder , will reduce the Effects of the Operation nearly to those of a mere Incision only , which might , as now , sometimes prove fistulous , but I believe scarcely ever mortal .
I would not be understood to mean that it should be used in common Cases , and moderate sized Stones ; no ; Mr. Cheselden has sufficiently demonstrated to the World , by Experiment , the Inconvenience of cutting beyond the Prostate , when it can be avoided .
I only say this , that where a large Stone offers , and the Circumstances are such , that the Operator is under a Necessity of tearing the Parts to Pieces , unless divided by an Incision , the latter is more safe and eligible .
The principal Advantages of this Contrivance are , 1 .
That the Degree of Dilatation is in the Operator 's Power , to the greatest Exactness : 2 .
That it will infallibly divide those Parts only which are upon the Stretch ; and for this Reason , 3 .
The Rectum , if it is empty , and consequently flaccid , must certainly escape wounding .
Its great Simplicity is another Circumstance much in its Favour ; for it seems allow 'd on all Hands , the less an Operation is encumbered with Instruments the better .
In common Cases , where the Assistance of this Method is not wanted , the Forceps is not the least incommoded as to its general Use ; but if the Stone prove large ( which can never be certainly known till it is laid hold of ) , the Remedy is at hand .
Plimouth , Jan. 6 .
1748-9 .
John Mudge .
P. S. These Forceps and Knife are represented in TAB. I. Fig. 3 , 4 , 5 .
Fig. 3 .
The Forceps , with the Knife , a b , applied to one of the Cheeks of it .
c , the Button .
bfg , the Handle .
Fig. 4 .
The Cheek of the Forceps with the Groove in it d e. Fig. 5 .
The Knife .
The Blade ab ; the Button c , made to fit , and slide along the Groove d e ; bfg the Handle ; cab the sharp Edge ; chf the Back of the Knife , which must have the same Curve as the Back of the Cheek of the Forceps or Groove to which it is to be applied , as in Fig. 3 .
C. M. a p. 29 .
h b Fig. 4 .
p. 29 .
Fig. 5 .
p. 29 .
f d g

