Philos. Trans. No. 490 .
TAB. IV .
Fig 1 p. 599 .
Fig. 2 .
1 9 .
Fig. 5 .
IMP CALL CTVSPFAVG ARE ORIE NSAVG ML III .
A Letter from Mr. David Erskin Baker to Martin Folks Esq ; Pr .
R. S. containing Considerations on two extraordinary Belemnitae .
SIR , VARIOUS have been the Opinions of Authors concerning the Origin of the Belemnitae , and as various the Systems and Hypotheses advanced by them in Support of their Opinions ; some having imagined them vegetable Productions ; others have taken them for the different Parts of Animals , as Teeth , Horns , Bones , &amp;c. in which even these again have differed , as to the referring them to land or marine Animals ; and they have been by others supposed of mineral Origin , or Lapides sui generis .
What they really are , will , I doubt , be still very difficult to determine ; but , as one principal Objection to their being originally marine Bodies ( which Supposition seems to carry the greatest Colour of Probability ) has been , that no marine Bodies have been found adhering to them , that Objection will be obviated by no less than two Specimens , from the same Place , of Belemnitae , whereto undoubted marine Substances are found firmly affixed ; by which Instances , as some further Light may be thrown on this Subject , that Consideration will , I hope , stand as an Excuse for my troubling you with this Paper .
Read Nov. 24 .
1748 .
These curious Fossils , which , together with the Drawings of them , I humbly submit to your Examination , mination , were found in a Chalk-Pit in Norfolk , from whence they were sent not long since to my Father Mr. Henry Baker F. R. S. See TAB. IV .
Fig. 1 .
Is a Belemnites , whose Apex is perfect ; the conic Cavity , and the longitudinal Seam , evidently distinguishable ; which , as well as the Contexture of the Substance whereof it is composed , show it to be a true Belemnites ; but on its Surface are placed , in their natural Condition , by which I mean not at all seemingly petrify 'd , or otherwise altered , two of those Vermiculi that are so frequently found sticking to Oysters , Scallops , and many other kinds of Shells , when taken out of the Sea .
Fig. 2 .
A Frustum of another Belemnites , the Apex whereof is broken , but the conic Cavity is still remaining , and shown at a. To this Belemnites adheres a Shell of the Oyster-kind , which is fastened thereto so strongly , that they are not to be separated without breaking : Which Shell , as well as the before-mention 'd Vermiculi , seems not altered in its Substance , but appears like a recent one , of which many are to be met with in the Cabinets of the Curious .
Fig. 3 .
Shows the other Side of the said Shell , wherein the Cardo or Hinge at b is plainly discernible ; at c appears the broken End of the Belemnites , where the radiated Contexture ( well known to belong to their Bodies ) is represented , as also the longitudinal Seam at d. As As these Specimens are undeniable Proofs of marine Bodies adhering to Belemnitae , several of the Curious who have seen them , are of Opinion , that they tend likewise to prove the Belemnitae to be marino Productions .
It may probably be objected , that these Shells might have been brought and deposited near the Belemnitae whereto they are affixed , by whatever mighty Change it came to pass that Productions of the Sea are discovered in most Countries at great Depths in the Earth , and in the Bowels of Mountains at great Distances from the Sea ( even supposing the Belemnitae to be Lapides sui generis , and produced in the Earth ) and that these Shells might be cemented to them afterwards by some mineral , slony , or other Matter .
But the following Observations will render this improbable ; for , 1 .
The Vermiculi of Fig. 1 .
are not any Species of the Tubuli marini , found sometimes recent , and sometimes fossil , detached entirely from every other Body ; but are of that sort , which is perhaps never seen separate , or in any other Manner , when recent , than attached and fastened to other Shells or Stones ; and they are placed on this Belemnites exactly in the same Manner as they are commonly found on other marine Bodies ; viz. lying on their broadest Side , with their Ridge upwards , and glued as it were thereto by a shelly Substance .
2 .
In Fig. 3 .
at e , is plainly to be distinguished , that the Shell has been fashioned thus by the convex Surface of the Belemnites , in the same manner as these Shells commonly receive a Form from whatever Substance they adhere to ; which plainly implies , that this Shell was fastened to the Belemnites when itself was very small , and in a growing State ; and that the Shell in its Growth was formed according to the Figure of the Body on which it was affixed : But such Growth could not possibly have proceeded any-where but in the Sea ; and therefore these two Bodies must necessarily have been in the Sea at one and the same time .
There is now but one Way more , whereby these Shells ( supposing the Belemnitae to be Stones sui generis ) could possibly become affixed to them ; which is , that the Belemnitae might have been by some Accident thrown on the Sea-shore ; and that there the Shells might fasten themselves to them , as well as to any other Stone .
But as this must imply some former Convulsion in Nature , whereby they were cast out of their natural Beds upon the Seashore ; and again a second Convulsion to carry them to the Chalk-pit where they were found ; so farsetch 'd an Objection will , I believe , carry but little Weight .
To conclude , I submit to your Opinion , whether the Sides of the conic Cavity , whereto the Oystershell is affixed , has most the Appearance of a Stone or of a Shell ; and remain , with the utmost Respect , SIR , Strand , Dec. 15 .
1748 .
Your most obedient and obliged humble Servant , D. E. Baker .

