V. An Essay on Quantity ; occasioned by reading a Treatise , in which Simple and Compound Ratio 's are applied to Virtue and Merit , by the Rev. Mr. Reid ; communicated in a Letter from the Rev. Henry Miles D.D. &amp; F.R.S. to Martin Folks Esq ; Pr .
R.S. SEC T. I. What Quantity is .
SINCE mathematical Demonstration is thought to carry a peculiar Evidence along with it , which leaves no Room for further Dispute ; it may be of some Use , or Entertainment Read Nov. 3 .
tainment at least , to inquire to what Subjects this kind of Proof may be applied .
Mathematics contain properly the Doctrine of Measure ; and the Object of this Science is commonly said to be Quantity ; therefore Quantity ought to be defined , What may be measured .
Those who have defined Quantity to be whatever is capable of More or Less , have given too wide a Notion of it , which I apprehend has led some Persons to apply mathematical Reasoning to Subjects that do not admit of it .
Pain and Pleasure admit of various Degrees , but who can pretend to measure them ?
Had this been possible , it is not to be doubted but we should have had as distinct Names for their various Degrees , as we have for Measures of Length or Capacity ; and a Patient should have been able to describe the Quantity of his Pain , as well as the Time it began , or the Part it affected .
To talk intelligibly of the Quantity of Pain , we should have some Standard to measure it by ; some known Degree of it so well ascertained , that all Men , when they talked of it , should mean the same thing ; we should also be able to compare other Degrees of Pain with this , so as to perceive distinctly , not only whether they exceed or fall short of it , but how far , or in what proportion ; whether by an half , a fifth , or a tenth .
Whatever has Quantity , or is measurable , must be made up of Parts , which bear Proportion to one another , and to the Whole ; so that it may be increased by Addition of like Parts , and diminished by Subtraction , may be multiplied and divided , and in a Word , may bear any Proportion to another Quantity of the same kind , that one Line or Number can bear to another .
That this is essential to all mathematical Quantity , is evident from the first Elements of Algebra , which treats of Quantity in general , or of those Relations and Properties which are common to all Kinds of Quantity .
Every algebraical Quantity is supposed capable not only of being increased and diminished , but of being exactly doubled , tripled , halfed , or of bearing any assignable Proportion to another Quantity of the same kind .
This then is the Characteristic of Quantity ; whatever has this Property may be adopted into Mathematics ; and its Quantity and Relations may be measured with mathematical Accuracy and Certainty .
SEC T. 2 .
Of Proper and Improper Quantity .
There are some Quantities which may be called Proper , and others Improper .
This Distinction is taken notice of by Aristotle ; but it deserves some Explication .
I call that Proper Quantity which is measured by its own Kind ; or which of its own Nature is capable of being doubled or tripled , without taking in any Quantity of a different Kind as a Measure of it .
Thus a Line is measured by known Lines , as Inches , Feet , or Miles ; and the Length of a Foot being known , there can be no Question about the Length of two Feet , or of any Part or Multiple of a Foot .
And this known Length , by being multiplied or divided , is sufficient to give us a distinct Idea of any Length whatsoever .
Improper Quantity is that which cannot be measured by its own Kind ; but to which we assign a Measure by the means of some proper Quantity that is related to it .
Thus Velocity of Motion , when we consider it by itself , cannot be measured .
We may perceive one Body to move faster , another slower ; but we can have no distinct Idea of a Proportion or Ratio between their Velocities , without taking in some Quantity of another Kind to measure them by .
Having therefore observed , that by a greater Velocity a greater Space is passed over in the same time , by a less Velocity a less Space , and by an equal Velocity an equal Space ; we hence learn to measure Velocity by the Space passed over in a given Time , and to reckon it to be in exact Proportion to that Space : And having once assigned this Measure to it , we can then , and not till then , conceive one Velocity to be exactly double , or half , or in any other Proportion to another ; we may then introduce it into mathematical Reasoning without Danger of Confusion , or Error , and may also use it as a Measure of other Improper Quantities .
All the Kinds of Proper Quantity we know , may , I think , be reduced to these four , Extension , Duration , Number , and Proportion .
Tho ' Proportion be measurable in its own Nature , and therefore hath Proper Quantity , yet as Things cannot have Proportion which have not Quantity of some other Kind , it follows , that whatever has Quantity must have it in one or other of these three Kinds , Extension , Duration , or Number .
These are the Measures of themselves , and of all Things else that are measurable .
Number is applicable to somethings , to which it is not commonly applied by the Vulgar .
Thus , by attentive Consideration , Lots and Chances of various Kinds appear to be made up of a determinate Number of Chances that are allowed to be equal ; and by numbering these , the Values and Proportions of those which are compounded of them may be demonstrated .
Velocity , the Quantity of Motion , Density , Elasticity , the Vis infita , and impressa , the various Kinds of centripetal Forces , and different Orders of Fluxions , are all Improper Quantities ; which therefore ought not to be admitted into Mathematics , without having a Measure of them assigned .
The Measure of an improper Quantity ought always to be included in the Definition of it ; for it is the giving it a Measure that makes it a proper Subject of mathematical Reasoning .
If all Mathematicians had considered , this as carefully as Sir Isaac Newton appears to have done , some Labour had been saved both to themselves and to their Readers .
That Great Man , whose clear and comprehensive Understanding appears , even in his Definitions , having frequent Occasion to treat of such improper Quantities , never fails to define them , so as to give a Measure of them , either in proper Quantities , or in such as had a known Measure .
This may be seen in the Definitions prefixed to his Princip .
Phil. Not .
Math. It is not easy to say how many Kinds of improper Quantity , may in time , be introduced into Mathematics , or to what new Subjects Measures may be applied : But this I think we may conclude , that there is no Foundation in Nature for , nor can any valuable End be served by applying Measure to any , thing but what has these two Properties .
First it must admit of Degrees of greater and less .
Secondly , it must be associated with , or related to something that has proper Quantity , so as that when one is increased the other is increased , when one is diminished , the other is diminished also ; and every Degree of the one must have a determinate Magnitude or Quantity of the other corresponding to it .
It sometimes happens , that we have Occasion to apply different Measures to the same thing .
Centripetal Force , as defined by Newton , may be measured various Ways , he himself gives different Measures of it , and distinguishes them by different Names , as may be seen in the above-mentioned Definitions .
In reality , I conceive that the applying of Measures to things that properly have not Quantity , is only a Fiction or Artifice of the Mind , for enabling us to conceive more easily , and more distinctly to express and demonstrate , the Properties and Relations of those things that have real Quantity .
The Propositions contained in the two first Books of Newton 's Principia might perhaps be expressed and demonstrated , without those various Measures of Motion , and of centripetal and impressed Forces which he uses : But this would occasion such intricate and perplexed Circumlocutions , and such a tedious Length of Demonstrations as would fright any sober Person from attempting to read them .
4 SEC T. 3 .
Coroll. first .
From the Nature of Quantity we may see what it is that gives Mathematics such Advantage over other Sciences , in Clearness and Certainty ; namely , that Quantity admits of a much greater Variety of Relations than any other Subject of human Reasoning ; and at the same time every Relation or Proportion of Quantities may by the Help of Lines and Numbers be so distinctly defined , as to be easily distinguished from all others , without any Danger of Mistake .
Hence it is that we are able to trace its Relations through a long Process of Reasoning , and with a Perspicuity and Accuracy which we in vain expect in Subjects not capable of Mensuration .
Extended Quantities , such as Lines , Surfaces and Solids , besides what they have in common with all other Quantities , have this peculiar , That their Parts have a particular Place and Disposition among themselves : A Line may not only bear any assignable Proportion to another , in Length or Magnitude , but Lines of the same Length may vary in the Disposition of their Parts ; one may be straight , another may be Part of a Curve of any Kind or Dimension , of which there is an endless Variety .
The like may be said of Surfaces and Solids .
So that extended Quantities admit of no less Variety with regard to their Form than with regard to their Magnitude : And as their various Forms may be exactly defined and measured , no less than their Magnitudes , hence it is that Geometry , which treats of extended Quantity , leads us into a much greater Compass and Variety of Reasoning than any other Branch of Mathematics .
Long Deductions in Algebra for the most part are made , not so much by a Train of Reasoning in the Mind , as by an artificial kind of Operation , which is built on a few very simple Principles : But in Geometry we may build one Proposition upon another , a third upon that , and so on , without ever coming to a Limit which we cannot exceed .
The Properties of the more simple Figures can hardly be exhausted , much less those of the more complex ones .
SEC T. 4 .
Coroll. 2 .
It may I think be deduced from what hath been above said , That mathematical Evidence is an Evidence sui generis , not competent to any Proposition which does not express a Relation of Things measurable by Lines or Numbers .
All proper Quantity may be measured by these , and improper Quantities must be measured by those that are proper .
There are many Things capable of More and Less , which perhaps are not capable of Mensuration .
Tastes , Smells , the Sensations of Heat and Cold , Beauty , Pleasure , all the Affections and Appetites of the Mind , Wisdom , Folly , and most Kinds of Probability , with many other Things too tedious to enumerate , admit of Degrees , but have not yet been reduced to Measure , nor , as I apprehend , ever can be .
I say , most Kinds of Probability , because one Kind of it , viz. the Probability of Chances is properly measurable by Number , as is above observed .
Altho ' Attempts have been made to apply mathematical Reasoning to some of these Things , and the Quantity of Virtue and Merit in Actions has been measured measured by simple and compound Ratio 's ; yet I do not think that any real Knowlege has been struck out this Way : It may perhaps , if diseretely used , be a Help to Discourse on these Subjects , by pleasing the Imagination , and illustrating what is already known ; but until our Affections and Appetites shall themselves be reduced to Quantity , and exact Measures of their various Degrees be assigned , in vain shall we essay to measure Virtue and Merit by them .
This is only to ring Changes upon Words , and to make a Show of mathematical Reasoning , without advancing one Step in real Knowlege .
SEC T. 5 .
Coroll. 3 .
I apprehend the Account that hath been given of the Nature of proper and improper Quantity may also throw some Light upon the Controverfy about the Force of moving Bodies , which long exercised the Pens of many Mathematicians , and for what I know is rather dropped than ended ; to the no small Scandal of Mathematics , which hath always boasted of a Degree of Evidence , inconsistent with Debates that can be brought to no Issue .
Tho ' Philosophers on both Sides agree with one another , and with the Vulgar in this , That the Force of a moving Body is the same , while its Velocity is the same , is increased when its Velocity is increased , and diminished when that is diminished .
But this ~ Notion of Force , in which both Sides agree , tho ' perhaps sufficient for common Discourse , yet is not sufficient to make it a Subject of mathematical Reasoning : In order to that , it must be more accurately defined , and so defined as to give us a Measure of it , that we may understand what is meant by a double or a triple Force .
The Ratio of one Force to another cannot be perceived but by a Measure ; and that Measure must be settled not by mathematical Reasoning , but by a Definition .
Let any one consider Force without relation to any other Quantity , and see whether he can conceive one Force exactly double to another ; I am sure I cannot , nor shall , till I shall be endowed with some new Faculty ; for I know nothing of Force but by its Effects , and therefore can measure it only by its Effects .
Till Force then is defined , and by that Definition a Measure of it assigned , we fight in the dark about a vague Idea , which is not sufficiently determined to be admitted into any mathematical Proposition .
And when such a Definition is given , the Controversy will presently be ended .
SEC T. 6 .
Of the Newtonian Measure of Force .
You say , the Force of a Body in Motion is as its Velocity : Either you mean to lay this down as a Definition as Newton himself has done ; or you mean to affirm it as a Proposition capable of Proof .
If you mean to lay it down as a Definition , it is no more than if you should say , I call that a double Force which gives a double Velocity to the same Body , a triple Force which gives a triple Velocity , and so on in Proportion .
This I entirely agree to ; no mathematical Definition of Force can be given that is more clear and simple , none that is more agreeable to the common Use of the Word in Language .
For since all Men agree , that the Force of the Body being the same , the Velocity must also be the same ; the Force being increased or diminished , the Velocity must be so also , what can be more natural or proper than to take the Velocity for the Measure of the Force ?
Several other things might be advanced to show that this Definition agrees best with the common popular Notion of the Word Force .
If two Bodies meet directly with a Shock , which mutually destroys their Motion without producing any other sensible Effect , the Vulgar would pronounce , without Hesitation , that they met with equal Force ; and so they do , according to the Measure of Force above laid down : For we find by Experience , that in this Case their Velocities are reciprocally as their Quantities of Matter .
In Mechanics , where by a Machine two Powers or Weights are kept in equilibrio , the Vulgar would reckon that these Powers act with equal Force , and so by this Definition they do .
The Power of Gravity being constant and uniform , any one would expect that it should give equal Degrees of Force to a Body in equal Times , and so by this Definition it does .
So that this Definition is not only clear and simple , but it agrees best with the Use of the Word Force in common Language , and this I think is all that can be desired in a Definition .
But if you are not satisfied with laying it down as a Definition , that the Force of a Body is as its Velocity , but will needs prove it by Demonstration or Experiment ; I must beg of you , before you take one Step in the Proof , to let me know what you mean by Force , and what by a double or a triple Force .
This you must do by a Definition which contains a Measure of Force .
Some primary Measure of Force must be taken for granted , or laid down by way of Definition ; otherwise we can never reason about its Quantity .
And why then may you not take the Velocity for the primary Measure as well as any other ?
You will find none that is more simple , more distinct , or more agreeable to the common Use of the Word Force : And he that rejects one Definition that has these Properties , has equal Right to reject any other .
I say then , that it is impossible , by mathematical Reasoning or Experiment , to prove that the Force of a Body is as its Velocity , without taking for granted the thing you would prove , or something else that is no more evident than the thing to be proved .
SEC T. 7 .
Of the Leibnitzian Measure of Force .
Let us next hear the Leibnitzian , who says , that the Force of a Body is as the Square of its Velocity .
If he lays this down as a Definition , I shall rather agree to it , than quarrel about Words , and for the future shall understand him , by a quadruple Force to mean that which gives a double Velocity , by 9 times the Force that which gives three times the Velocity , and so on in duplicate Proportion .
While he keeps by his Definition , it will not necessarily lead him into any Error in Mathematics or Mechanics .
For , however paradoxical his Conclusions may appear , however different in Words from theirs who measure Force by the simple Ratio of the Velocity ; they will in their Meaning be the same : Just as he who would call a Foot twenty-four Inches , without changing other Measures of Length , when he says a Yard contains a Foot and a half , means the very same as you do , when you say a Yard contains three Feet .
But tho ' I allow this Measure of Force to be distinct , and cannot charge it with Falsehood , for no Definition can be false , yet I say in the first place , it is less simple than the other ; for why should a duplicate Ratio , be used where the simple Ratio will do as well ?
In the next place , this Measure of Force is less agreeable to the common Use of the Word Force , as hath been shown above ; and this indeed is all that the many laboured Arguments and Experiments , brought to overturn it , do prove .
This also is evident , from the Paradoxes into which it has led its Defenders .
We are next to consider the Pretences of the Leibnitzian , who will undertake to prove by Demonstration , or Experiment , that Force is as the Square of the Velocity .
I ask him first , what he lays down for the first Measure of Force ?
The only Measure I remember to have been given by the Philosophers of that Side , and which seems first of all to have led Leibnitz into his Notion of Force , is this : The Height to which a Body is impelled by any impressed Force , is , says he , the whole Effect of that Force , and therefore must be proportional to the Cause : But this Height is found to be as the Square of the Velocity which the Body had at the Beginning of its Motion .
In this Argument I apprehend that great Man has been extremely unfortunate .
For , 1st , Whereas all Proof should be taken from Principles that are common to both Sides , in order to prove a thing we deny , he assumes a Principle which we think farther from the Truth ; namely , that the Height to which the Body rises is the whole Effect of the Impulse , and ought to be the whole Measure of it .
2dly , His Reasoning serves as well against him as for him : For may I not plead with as good Reason at least thus ?
The Velocity given by an impressed Force is the whole Effect of that impressed Force ; and therefore the Force must be as the Velocity .
3dly , Supposing the Height to which the Body is raised to be the Measure of the Force , this Principle overturns the Conclusion he would establish by it , as well as that which he opposes .
For , supposing the first Velocity of the Body to be still the same ; the Height to which it rises will be increased , if the Power of Gravity is diminished ; and diminished , if the Power of Gravity is increased .
Bodies descend slower at the Equator , and faster towards the Poles , as is found by Experiments made on Pendulums .
If then a Body is driven upwards at the Equator with a given Velocity , and the same Body is afterwards driven upwards at Leipsick with the same Velocity , the Height to which it rises in the former Case will be greater than in the latter ; and therefore , according to his Reasoning , its Force was greater in the former Case ; but the Velocity in both was the same ; consequently the Force is not as the Square of the Velocity any more than as the Velocity .
SEC T. 8 .
Reflections on this Controversy .
Upon the whole , I cannot but think the Controvertists on both Sides have had a very hard Task ; the one to prove , by mathematical Reasoning and Experiment , what ought to be taken for granted , the other by the same means to prove what might be granted , making some Allowance for Impropriety of Expression , but can never be proved .
If some Mathematician should take it in his Head to affirm , that the Velocity of a Body is not as the Space it passes over in a given Time , but as the Square of that Space ; you might bring mathematical Arguments and Experiments to confute him ; but you would never by these force him to yield , if he was ingenuous in his Way ; because you have no common Principles left you to argue from , and you differ from one another , not in a mathematical Proposition , but in a mathematical Definition .
Suppose a Philosopher has considered only that Measure of centripetal Force which is proportional to the Velocity generated by it in a given Time , and from this Measure deduces several Propositions .
Another Philosopher in a distant Country , who has the same general Notion of centripetal Force , takes the Velocity generated by it , and the Quantity of Matter together , as the Measure of it .
From this he deduces several Conclusions , that seem directly contrary to those of the other .
Thereupon a serious Controversy is begun , whether centripetal Force be as the Velocity , or as the Velocity and Quantity of Matter taken together .
Much mathematical and experimental Dust is raised ; and yet neither Party can ever be brought to yield ; for they are both in the right , only they have been unlucky in giving the same Name to different mathematical Conceptions .
Had they distinguished these Measures of centripetal Force as Newton has done , calling the one Vis centripetae Quantitatis acceleratix , the other Quantitas motrix ; all Appearance of Contradiction had ceased , and their Propositions , which seem so contrary , had exactly tallied .

