V. A Letter from John Byrom M. A. and F. R. S. to the President , containing some Remarks on Mr. Lodwick 's Alphabet .
Honoured Sir , HAVING , by your Permission , borrowed No. 182 .
of the Transactions , wherein is contained An Essay towards an Universal Alphabet , by Mr. Francis Lodwick F.R.S. I shall give a brief Account of it ; and , in Obedience to your Commands at the last Meeting , endeavour to show how it may be reduced into less Compass , and set in a plainer Light .
Read June 30 .
1748 .
Mr. Lodwick premises first the Advantages of such an Alphabet ; which I may as well refer to as repeat ; they all center in acquiring , describing , or perpetuating the true Sounds of any Language , by a Standard Character for all .
He then defines what a single Sound , what a compounded one , a Vowel , Consonant , Diphthong , and Triphthong is ; all which is likewise sufficiently obvious , and needs no Repetition .
To proceed directly , therefore , to his Alphabet , or Collection of all the single Vowels or Consonants which are used in any Language , the Number of Vowels is , according to him , 14 , which are , all but 3 , expressed in English Words in the following Table .
1 .
a tall 8 .
ui muis .
Low Dutch 2 .
a tallow 9 .
y the 3 .
a tale 10 .
o tone 4 .
e tell 11 .
u tun 5 .
ea teal 12 .
u un .
French 6 .
i till 13 .
oo tool 7 .
u dure .
French 14 .
ou told .
These , he says , are the Vowels , each of which is long , and short ; short , as in the Words God , Man , Sin ; long , as in Ball , Demand , Seen , &amp;c. As any Vowel sounded by itself is naturally long , I take it for granted that he intended the 14 in this Table to be all such ; and yet , in the Words Tallow , tell , till , tun , the Vowels , as we now pronounce them at least , are all short ; and in the Words the and told , a Diphthong ( or Composition of 2 Vowels pronounced in the Time of one ) is sounded : So that there are but 5 long Vowels accounted for in our Language by the Words tall , tale , teal , tone , tool .
The foreign Words , as it would be nice and endless to dispute about , so it comes not within the Compass of my present Design ; which is to give a List of Vowels , whereby to discriminate , as conveniently as may be , all the Instances of Vocality that occur , distinctly , in the English Language ; for which I apprehend that half the Number in his Catalogue , or 7 Characters , would be , to all attainable Purposes , sufficient .
As we commonly reckon but 5 Vowels in our Alphabet , a , e , i , o , u ; two of which , viz. i and u , are really Diphthongs , I must denote the single Vowels by 2 apiece , as Custom sometimes does , to show which I mean ; and , beginning from the smallest Aperture of the Organs to the most dilated , they are these .
1 .
oo ooze stool too 2 .
oa oat stole to 3 .
ee eel steel see 4 .
ea eat steal sea 5 .
ai aid stale say 6 .
aa aaron stamen ( sol)fa 7 .
au autumn stall saw Though vocal Sounds , like instrumental , may , in Speculation , admit of numberless Distinctions , yet , as Experience shows that 7 Notes , flattened or sharpened , upon Occasion , suffice for a practical Gamut , or Scale of Music , so I incline to think , that 7 vocal Notes or Vowels , varied in some correspondent manner , or struck , as one may say , in diphthongal or triphthongal Chords with each other , may well enough account for the Sounds of our Language ; or possibly of any other , if it be considered , that different Voices , as well as Instruments , have somewhat so peculiar in them , that nothing but the Ear itself is able to distinguish .
However , as far as these 7 Vowels extend , if they were denoted by any common Characters , as , suppose at present , by the 7 first numeral Figures , the absurd Variety which Custom has introduced of expressing the same vocal Sounds , amongst different Nations , even using the same alphabetical Characters , ters , would , in a great measure , be immediately corrected .
One Instance may serve for many ; the Word we in English , and the Word oui in French , however differently written , have the same Sound , or Composition of Sound , from our Vowels oo , and ee , or their ou and i ; if then the Figure 1 was always to denote the Sound that we express by oo , the French by ou , the Italians by u , &amp;c. and the Figure 3 was to denote our ee , and their i , in like manner , the combined Character , or Diphthong 13 , would be sounded alike by all Readers of any Nation , who should previously be agreed upon such a common Character .
And allowing Mr. Lodwick 's Notion , that there are 3 Vowels in other Languages , which ours has not , there will remain the Figures 8 , 9 , 0 , to express them by or any other Characters may be pitched upon .
What I aim at is to show , that , through an over Pursuit of Accuracy , he has multiplied his Vowels , without any apparent Necessity .
And the Case is the same with respect to his Consonants , which he thus ranges into 11 Files , and 6 Ranks .
1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
1B bond D dark J jest G game = 2P pond T tart Ch chest K came = 3M mind N name gn seign Fr. ng song = 4= dh this j jean Fr. g gaen } Low V Valley 5= th thing sh shall ch dach Dutch F Folly 6 .
7 .
8 .
9 .
10 .
11 .
=L lane H hand Y yarn R rand W wand = = Z zeal lh Welsh S seal By this Distribution one is led to think , at first , that he would hint that there were in Language 11 times 6 , or 66 Consonants ; though Experience had taught him to complete the 6 Ranks of his second File only .
But , as the Mark ( = ) by which he signifies that there are indeed analogous Consonants that might be expressed in those Places , but with a Difference that would be too nice for common Discernment ; and such as he had never heard expressed in any Language ; as this Mark , I say , occurs but 8 times , I will suppose him to take the real Number of Consonants in Nature to be 37 , whereof 29 may answer the Purposes of an universal Alphabet .
To reduce both Files and Ranks into less Compass , and plainer Order , I would take the real Consonants of his first and fifth Files into one File or Rank ; and place them in this manner P. B. M. F. V. dismissing the 5 unexpress 'd ( and , for any thing that appears , inexpressible ones ) as imaginary .
And to this Order of Consonants all such as are used in our Language may be adjusted ; for , beginning thus with the labial and labio-dental Consonants , and so proceeding to the Gutturals , they will stand , in Rank and File , after this manner .
P. B. M. F. V. S. Z. R. Sh .
Zh .
T. D. L. Th. Dh .
K. G. N. Ch. J. wherein their mutual Analogy and Correspondence seems to appear in the plainest Light that one can possibly put them in ; as a little Attention will better discover , than a Prolixity of Particulars explain .
If not , I shall be glad to be set right , if I am mistaken in supposing , 1 .
That here is no Consonant omitted , which is really used in our common Pronunciation ; or , 2 .
That here are none superfluous , or compounded ; or , 3 .
That , in this View of them , their Relation to each other is the most discernible .
I except the Letter H , which may have its Place amongst the guttural consonantal Aspirates , which some foreign Nations are accustomed to , but ours , in general , is not : And these , as I conceive , will not be found to be distinctly more than what the Addition of a fifth Rank to the foregoing may exhaust .
The Power or Force of this peculiar Letter h is so capable of Intermixture with that of others in this Table , and that of the Naso-guttural N , of sliding , without its full Expression , into a following Consonant ( as it does particularly in French Pronunciation ) , that they have led the Writers on this Subject to imagine Consonants in Nature , which they endeavour to express by N French , gn , ng , and by divers Changes of the Letters h , n , g , that give an attentive Examiner no clear Idea of any distinct Consonant , but rather perplex the Matter by unintelligible Niceties , and hinder the Prospect of an universal Alphabet , by seeming Impossibilities of arriving at it .
Y and W , which constitute Mr. Lodwick 's 9th and 11th File of Consonants , are equal to the Vowels ee and oo : His two Dutch Consonants may have their Place in the 5th Rank above mentioned .
So that omitting such of his 29 as ought , if these Observations are just , to be omitted , there will remain the 20 that are here digested into 5 Files and 4 Ranks , for the real Alphabet of Consonants in the English Language ; together with the H , which whether it may be reckoned one or not , I shall leave to the Grammarians .
The 5 Files , for an Assistance to the Memory , may by the Help of intermediate Vowels , be comprised in 5 technical Words of an hexameter Verse , such as , PaSTiKa , BoZDaGo , MeRLiN , FiSh ThoChe , VeZhaDhJo .
And the 4 Ranks , as they begin with the Letters P , S , T , K , may , for the same Reason , be called Prima , Secunda , Tertia , Quarta , ( =Kuarta ) Classis .
These 20 Consonants may appear to be too few ; but I much question whether the real Alphabet of any Language has either more in Number , or better fitted for the Purposes of Speech than this of ours : The Difference lies chiefly in the Gutturals , which the Orientals , Welsh , Germans , &amp;c. pronounce differently from us .
Our Neighbours the French ( which is very remarkable ) few as these 20 are , have but 16 of them ; and yet they are able to express themselves with greater Fluency and Precision than we can well be Masters of , till we shall imitate their Care to polish and to propagate their Language , by some Attention to the Improvement of our own .
They have none of our th , dh , ch , or j ; and if a Man 's Name , suppose , were Thatch th ' edge , they would not be able , without previous Practice , to pronounce any one of these 4 Consonants , which help to compose it , and which Custom obliges us to denote , so absurdly , by 9 Letters that have not the alphabetical Force of any one of these 4 amongst them .
The most important Reflection upon the Subject is this , that whereas we have in our Language but 7 distinct Sounds or Vowels , and thrice the Number of Stops or Modifications of them ; if we had accordingly 28 Letters or Types appropriated to them , and always wrote or printed what we spoke , the Theory of Reading might be acquired in as few Hours , as it costs at present Months or Years to acquire it in .
But I forbear the Pursuit of this Topic any farther ; understanding , from Gentlemen who were desirous that I should examine Mr. Lodwick 's Scheme immediately , that the Society would break up for the Summer , at the next Meeting : Attendance upon my Short-hand Scholars has obliged me to urge what occurred upon the Perusal of it as briefly as I could , and so I submit it to Consideration , and am , &amp;c.

