II .
A Letter from John Byrom M. A. F. R. S. to the President , containing some Remarks on Mr. Jeake 's Plan for ShortHand .
Honoured Sir , AS it has been suggested to me , that I should take some notice of the Plan for a Short-Hand by S. Jeake Esquire , which was lately * read before us at the Royal Society , I take the Liberty of addressing to you the following Remarks upon it ; being obliged to thank you for the public Testimony which you were pleased to give , on that Occasion , in favour of the Method which I had the Pleasure of communicating to you ; and which , in your Judgment , confirmed by the Experience of many other Gentlemen who have learned it , appears sufficiently to be perfected to Demonstration .
Read June 23 .
1748 .
In the Paper read before us it is inferred from the continual Succession of new Short-Hands , that none of them were constructed upon right Principles , which , in the Opinion of the Proposer of this Plan , are briefly these ; 1 .
There are in Nature but 8 simple Characters , viz. 4 rectilinear ones , ( ~ ~ ~ ) and 4 crooked or semicircular ( ~ ~~ ~)~ 2 .
To avoid the Ambiguity and Confusion that must arise from the Use of compound Characters , a perfect Short-Hand should consist of these 8 simple ones only .
3 .
But whereas there are 3 times as many Letters or more ) in the common Alphabet , the Consequence * See Phil. Trans. n. 487 .
p. 345 .
quence is , that one Character must serve for one , two , three , or four Letters ; as their Frequency of Occurrence , or Affinity to each other , shall suggest .
4 .
From these Suppositions , amongst a Variety of Alphabets that would equally answer his Intention , results the following , which ( omitting , as needless , the Letters a , e , i , o , h ) he proposes for the Plan of a perfect Short-Hand ; and computes , with great Exactness , that it may be written in less than one Quarter of the Time that common Long-Hand will require .
The Alphabet .
~ d t. l r. m n. u w. csx z. bf p. cgk q. y This , Sir , with a Specimen of the Lord 's Prayer , as written in it , is the Whole of his Plan ; which , as far as it goes , might have a plausible Appearance to a Gentleman , at the first Turn of his Thought towards Short-Hand ; but a little practical Attention must have shown him how liable it was to the very Objection that he intended to remedy , viz. Ambiguity .
The first Mark , for instance ( L ) , in this short Specimen , stands for these 4 several Words which occur in it , viz. our , will , evil , ever ; and forty more that one might enumerate , must , whenever they occur , be represented by it ; not to mention how often it must occasion Ambiguity in the Beginning , Middle , or End of a longer Word , or Marks , whereof it is a constituent Part only .
Now , though in the Lord 's Prayer it is easy , or in casual Wriring one of his Learning and Saga4 city city might be able , by a long Familiarity with the Characters , to determine the Sense of what was written in them , yet it is evident , that , to common Learners , a Difficulty so perpetually occurring must appear insuperable .
The Postulatum , likewise , which this Plan for Short-Hand is grounded on , is taken up too expeditiously ; for , there being , in Nature , 4 rectilinear Strokes , the horizontal , the perpendicular , and the acute , and grave ( if I may so call them ) ; it is manifest , by Inspection , that from these 4 Directions there will arise , at least , 8 curvilinear Characters , as each of the strait ones admits distinctly of 2 opposite Curves ( ~ ) and there is no absolute Necessity that any of them should be always semicircular ; a Shape that , for the most commodious Combination of simple Characters , is in fact much oftener inconvenient than otherwise .
The Alphabet then of simple Characters may be fairly enlarged by one third ; and Room be also left for the Fancy of an Inventor to extend it farther , if he should find it convenient upon the Whole .
I say , upon the Whole ; for the worst Short-Hand may happen to express a few particular Words better than the best ; and arbitrary Marks for Words or Sentences may be often shorter than regular ones : But this is no Inducement to write , in one Case , by a bad Method , and in the other , by none at all .
Another Oversight , in this Plan , is the Neglect of Beauty and Linearity ; though the Simplicity of its Characters does not , perhaps , admit of such enormous Scrawling as others may .
For , to instance again in the Specimen ; suppose the Mark for the Word Temptation ~ which expresses a vast Variety of different Combinations of Consonants , to be limited , by a previous Knowledge of the Language , to that Word only , yet , after all , it is a very aukward one ; and ought , by a common Short-Hand Rule of leaving out such Conso nants as are not sounded ( as the p is not in Temptation ) to have been formed in another Manner ( ~ ) wherein the Beauty and Linearity , and , of course , the Brevity of the Mark would have been preserved .
But Emendations of this Nature would , I doubt , in many Cases , which continued writing upon this Hypothesis must exhibit , be utterly impracticable .
In short , this Gentleman set out upon right Principles , which many hap-hazard Undertakers have but little considered ; but he had not Leisure enough , perhaps , to examine them to the Bottom ; as was the Case with Dr. Green of Cambridge ( he that wrote the Greenian Philosophy , as he calls it ) , who formed a Short-Hand for his own private Use , upon much the same Plan and Principles .
He gave me one of his Sermons in it ; and , upon Suggestion of the Advantages that he might have taken , he said , that for want of Time to consider of his Scheme more thoroughly , when he first adopted it , he had overlooked them .
A perfect Short-Hand , I suppose , would be a Solution of some such Problem as this : ` ` A Language being given , to assign the most compendious Method of expressing it readily , and legibly , by an Alphabet , and Rules , the best adapted to that Purpose .
' ' How easy soever the general Principles of such a Method may appear to be , there is a deal of Nicety required to put them in Execution : An exact Attention to continual Trials and Amendments is necessary to ascertain the Preference amongst an infinite Variety of Dispositions , which Inventors may select , and throw their Characters into .
So that it is no Wonder , that so many Publishers of new ShortHands content themselves merely with Newness , or at most with some still imperfect Meliorations of foregoing Attempts .
This Gentleman proceeds no farther than to make an Alphabet for his Plan * ; but must be sensible , that , were it never so complete a one , many compendious Applications of it might be obtained by a proper Enquiry into the Nature of our Language ( the most happily susceptible of this Art of any ) and the Abbreviations which it admits of , very intelligibly , in Writing .
And , in his Alphabet , he entirely omits the Letter h ( which is often wanted ) , and the Vowels a , e , i , o , and yet retains the Vowel u , which is certainly as needless as any of the rest : But as a single Point , in five distinct Situations , would have provided for them all alike , he might as well have added that to his Plan , in order to express any particular Vowel , upon Occasion ; because it would not * Mr. Jeake only offers his Plan as the mere Elements of a Short-hand , leaving it to every Practitioner to build upon his Foundation , as they shall judge necessary from Practice : He retains the ~ , because if often stands for v or ve or w. C. M. not have hurt his Alphabet ; and because the Reading of his Short-Hand without any Vowels at all , is so extremely difficult .
For , as one of his strait Strokes ( ~ ) must stand for the Words am , an , in , on , no , me , him , home , &amp;c. and one of his crooked ones ( c ) for as , is , us , so , has , his , ease , ice , use , ax , ox , &amp;c. and so of the rest ; he would himself , in all Probability , be often at a Loss to distinguish what he had written , upon his own Plan * .
The Consonants j and v he has taken no notice of ; as if the common Way of repeating 24 Letters did really give a just Idea of an Alphabet ; which it does not ; nor can a prefect Short-Hand for our Language ( or any other respectively ) well be planned , without considering the real Alphabet , or Table of every particular Sound , or Modification of Sound ; that is to say , Vowel or Consonant which occurs in it ; and then adjusting the proper Characters to them , and taking all the Advantages that either Nature or Custom may afford .
I do not recollect , that any Author has ever entered into such a Disquisition with a View to ShortHand ; but , with a View to other Advantages , many different Accounts have been given of a real or universal Alphabet ; several of them by eminent Members of the Royal Society : That proposed by Mr. Lodwick , in particular , is published in the Trans. No. 182 .
but might , I think , be reduced into less Compass , * Vowels may be known to be antecedent or consequent , by the Mark being wrote above or below the Line of Level : e.g. C as , C sa ; ~ am , ~ ma : The Ambiguities in many of these Words are not important , viz. as , has , is , his , use , us .
S. J. Compass , and set in a plainer Light ; and if it be agreeable , I shall , on this Occasion attempt to do it .
In the mean time , Sir , it will not , I hope , be thought impertinent in me to offer these Remarks upon the Plan that has been laid before us , of an Art which I have taken so much Pains to cultivate , and bring to that Perfection which my first and last Intention of introducing one common Standard , for the general Practice of it , required .
If I have succeeded , Gentlemen will , I persuade myself , concur to facilitate the Design ; which tho ' the Accidents of Life , at a Distance from this Place , have hitherto retarded , I am intent upon accomplishing to the utmost of my Power .
I thank you , Sir , for the many Marks of Friendship which you have shown me , and am Your obliged humble Servant ,

