XIV .
Upon the Sounds and Hearing of Fishes , by Jac. Theod .
Klein R. P. Gedan .
F.R.S. or Some Account of a Treatise , entitled , ` ` An Inquiry into the Reasons why the Author of an Epistle concerning the Hearing of Fishes endeavours to prove they are all mute and deaf ; ' ' by Richard Brocklesby M. D. F. R. S. OUR Author in the first place classes them into two Orders , the first hath Lungs , the other is furnished with Organs analogous to Lungs , which we call Fish-Ears , or Gills : All the Whale-Kind , the Dolphin , Porpoise , and such like , have Lungs .
There are two Families of the second Class , to one of them belongs all that Tribe , Read March 10 .
1747-8 .
* See the Account of Margaret Cutting , who speaks without a Tongue , in these Trans. No , 484 , p. 621 .
Tribe , which have one , two , five , or nine Air-Holes , at the Back , or Sides of the Head , or in their Thorax , in which concealed Gills are found : The other Family comprehends all Kinds of Fishes , whose Gills are usually placed on each Side the Back of the Head .
Our Author 's Antagonist ~ alleges , that all Fishes of both Orders are equally deaf ; but that all Naturalists except Mr. Reaumur are of a contrary Opinion , that Fishes hear distinctly .
Our Author begins with an Air of Ridicule , and shows how far the Letter-writer is ignorant of the various Opinions , modern as well as ancient .
Our learned Countryman Mr. Ray thinks to reconcile these , by allowing that some hear , while others are deaf ; but the greatest Part allow that Fishes actually hear ; and most , except Scheuchzer , seem agreed about the auditory Passages .
But the Letter-writer denies they have any Organs of Voice , merely upon the proverbial Authority , Mute as a Fish ; hence he concludes they are likewise deaf .
But in Answer , it is replied , the spouting Whale hath all its internal Organs , precisely similar to the Organs of Voice in other Creatures , and therefore they may answer the same Purposes , nay actually serve this End : For when the Whales in the Greenland Fishery are struck , they roar frequently so loud ; as to be heard at two French Miles Distance .
But some of the first Family of our second Class , as the Skate , Lamprey , Conger , and others , our Author hath heard utter some kind of Noise ; and gives his Opinion , that most Sorts of cartilaginous Fishes can do the same .
From Analogy he argues , that as no Beast , from the Lion to the meanest Ani4 mal , mal , nor from the Eagle to the humming Bird , but can utter a Voice , so he thinks the same general Law is observed in the Oeconomy of Fishes : But at the same time our Author here seems to lay too much Weight upon what he supposes final Causes , and metaphysical Arguments , which have in all Ages ruined Natural Philosophy .
But the Letter-writer queries , whether Fishes may not be mute in our Air , and yet capable of some Voice in their own Element .
Our Author takes the Noise which Carp and such Fish make in hot Weather , on the Surface of the Water , to be a Voice : And this is most remarkable when the Male impregns the Row which the Female has before deposited ; yet this is often heard , when the Fish is 6 or 7 Inches under Water .
Our Author surther enumerates many foreign Fishes , and particularly our Smelt , which put alive into Vinegar hisses very audibly .
The Letter writer had objected against Fishes , that they have no Occasion for Hearing , because they never copulate , as other Animals~ do : But our Author describes the Manner of Whales , which is performed as that of other Animals ; and observes , that they bring forth their Young alive : These follow the Female , and suck Milk from the Teats , which are placed in them near the Organs of Generation ; and in violent Storms the Dam takes her Off-spring into her Mouth , and protects them from Danger .
This last is common to several of the Skate-kind .
The Letter-writer alleges , That Fish never sleep ; but our Author assures us , all such as have Lungs do in the Night-time , thrusting up their Nostrils into the open Air .
For others he cannot be positive , as their History is little known .
The Letter-writer premises two Questions ; first , Whether Fishes have any Ears ?
or , If the Gills serve the same Purpose ?
and answers positively in the Negative to both : And therefore concludes they cannot hear .
But our Author asserts , that Snakes , Frogs , Chameleons , and others of the Lizard-kind , actually hear , without any of the usual external Apparatus of Hearing .
For though they want the Auricles and Ears , yet have they auditory Passages , by which Sound is conveyed , and even internal Organs , to which the Meatus auditorius reaches .
But our Author farther asserts , that all the Whale-kind , and in general such Fishes as have Lungs , have likewise a Meatus auditorius , and the internal Organs of Hearing ; and appeals to a public Dissection of a Porpoise , and another Fish of the Whale-kind , made by himself ; in which the Os petrosum , with the other Parts of these Organs , had been separately showed ; and calls in the concurrent Testimony of Dr. Tyson , in his Anatomy of a Porpoise .
Thus having satisfied us about such Fish as have Lungs , he goes on to consider the cartilaginous Species , such as the Skate , Ray , and kind of Lamprey , which have Organs of Generation , and copulate like Brutes ; yet exclude the Faetus while yet in the Egg-State : And this from Analogy , that these , and in general all other Fish , as they have Organs which serve them for Lungs , so they may have what answers in others to the Apparatus of Hearing .
In Proof of this he asserts , that all Kinds of Fish but these which have Lungs , are always found to have Stones in their Heads naturally formed , and invariably placed in the same Situation , being joined to the contiguous Parts with Ligaments and Nerves , which take their Rise from the Substance of the Brain , and having examined the Head of a Pike minutely with a Microscope , he discovered the auditory Pores in the Stones , and persuades himself , that three Pair of Stones are to be referred to this Use ; therefore concludes , as there is some Analogy in the Organs , that all Fishes in some measure hear .
The Letter-writer farther objects , that Water is not the Medium of Sounds ; and though Air is actually contained in all Water , yet it cannot be put into Undulations , any more than the circumambient Water ; but that would require a much greater Vibration than the external Air can give .
Thus , says he , if a Person immerge his Head a Foot under Water , he will hear nothing but a boiling Din ; and however great a Noise is made in the open Air , the Event will be still the same ; and if the Water itself be put into the most violent Agitation , the Person will discover no Odds in that Sensation of his Ears from what he perceived in the stillest Water .
Hence he concludes Water incapable of transmitting Sounds .
Our Author replies , That as Fishes are unanimously agreed to be capable of smelling , so , by Analogy , it is probable they have Hearing ; for Odours are conveyed by the Air , as well as Sound .
But he thinks the unnatural Position of a Man 's Head immerg 'd a Foot under Water may be some Cause for that confused Noise , and opposes the experimental Testimony of Abbe Nollet himself , who went different Depths under Water , to satisfy himself how far Sounds could be conveyed in that Medium .
At four Inches under Water he heard the Sound of a Gun discharged , of a Clock striking , and of a Hunter 's Horn : These , repeated at different Depths , were heard first at 4 , then at 8 , afterwards at 18 Inches , and lastly at two Foot .
A Man 's Voice was also heard in the same Manner .
At different Altitudes of Water , none of them exceeding two Feet , he could perfectly distinguish mixed Sounds , when two Bells were struck , or two Pipes sounded together .
He could distinguish under Water , very distinctly , Words uttered aloud : And proved this Assertion , by declaring , when he came above Water , what was said while he was under it .
All Sounds were heard more faintly , and attenuated ; yet the Difference of the Sound , at 4 and 18 Inches Depth , was not answerable to the Difference of the Altitude of Water .
He observed at first , that momentary Sounds were not so well conveyed as continued ; yet he afterwards determined , at the same Depth , one Tap of a Drum-head , as plainly as a continued Round .
This he thinks was the same in a Man 's Voice , and the Sound of a Pipe ; but ingenuously owns , he was not fully satisfied in this Experiment ; and therefore does not lay as great Stress on its Certainty as on the former .
Lastly , he held his Head under the Surface of the Water , so as barely to cover him ; but could not hear the Clock strike , which was audible in the open Air at 45 Feet Distance , especially on a Plain .
The Abbe therefore concludes , if Fishes do not actually hear , it is for want of proper Organs , and not because the Medium cannot convey Sounds .
Our Author mentions the common Notion of Carp , and other Fish , coming out of their Holes at the Sound of a Bell to be fed ; and adds a Story , which Mr. Boyle somewhere relates , that near Geneva a Man had a Fish-pond , whose Banks were so high from the Plain on which it was , that one could not look over them into the Pond ; and therefore it was impossible the Fish could see the Person ; yet they were at any time conven 'd at certain Sounds by the Gardener , in order to be fed , as a creditable Person asserts .
The Letter writer , having made a high Partition in a Pond , watched while an Accomplice behind it made a very great Noise , and discharged a Gun , in order to frighten the Fish ( if possible ) that were playing on the Surface of the Water ; but they did not give any Attention ; yet as soon as ever they came in Sight , the Fish immediately made off .
Our Author thinks this Objection of little Weight , because the Question is not , whether Fishes , when they see nothing , can be frightened by Sounds only .
Upon the Whole , our Author shows himself an experienced and diligent Naturalist , and will ( if I mistake not ) be allow 'd to have fully proved the Falsity of any Assertion , that all Fish are entirely mute and deaf .

