II .
A Letter to Martin Folks Esq. LL. D. Pr .
R. S. containing some Observations upon certain Shell-Fish ( lodged in a large Stone brought from Mahon Harbour by Mr. Samuel More , Purser of the Sterling-Castle Man of War ) from James Parsons M. D. F. R. S. THE Favour Mr. More and Mr. Graham have done the Royal Society , by their Present of the Stone containing the shell 'd Fish , and called the Dottle-Stone , has given Occasion to the following Hints , to show of what sort these Fish are , and that they are rare and curious to us .
Read Jan. 21 .
1747 .
Upon our first hearing of them by Mr. More 's Letter to Richard Graham Esq ; because it was said the Fish were lodged in a Stone , it was thought they were the same we know by the Name of Pholades , and of which there are Plenty upon our own Coasts ; but I believe none of us had seen these before , nor had a Notion of any others being lodged in Stone but our Pholades above mentioned ; whereas these seem to be peculiar to the Mediterranean Sea , since Rondeletius , and after him Aldrovandus , have given their Account and Figures of them , among others that are Inhabitants of the same Regions .
These two Authors call them simply Pholades , which Term is derived of the Greek Verb ~ , and signifies , to have a hiding Place ; every Animal therefore that absconds in Earth or Stones might be called so too : Hence I think , that ~ is too vague and insignificant a Name for any particular Animal , and that some other , which has a nearer Relation to its generical Character ought to be given to it .
If Aldrovandus had seen those , which we as erroneously call Pholades , enclosed in their Cells , he would , no doubt , have called them by the same Name , and for the same Reason ; but I am inclined to think he never saw the entire Fish , but only the Shell ; because he gives a very imperfect Description of it , among several others which he has Figures of also , and which he calls Conchae longae Authoris aliae , which follow an Account and Figure of the Concha longa of Pliny .
Dr. Lister and Rumphius also have Figures of this Mediterranean Fish , and , after that Author , call it Pholas : But since this Term barely denotes the Place of its Residence , let us endeavour to give it a proper Name , which may be done by considering its Similarity with some Genus already known .
The above-mention 'd Gentleman says , the Stones are from half a hundred to four or five hundred weight each , lying at all Depths to twenty Feet under Water ; full of Cells , each containing a single Fish , called by the Inhabitants the Dottle Fish ; which Name he judiciously supposes to be a Corruption of the Word Dactylus from their Form .
He also says , the Fish is of the same Nature with the common Muscle , but much more delicious , and that eating them is never attended , with those poisonous Symptoms , that have been often thought to be caus 'd by eating Muscles .
The Shells are indeed , in all Respects but one , like the Mytulus vulgaris , or common Muscle ; these being small at the Hinge-End , and having a broad thin Edge at the Opposite ; whereas the former are nearly equal at both Ends , as well as strait and somewhat depressed , and as to the Structure of the Fish of both , they are alike , tho ' with this small Difference , that the Lingula of the common Muscle is detached towards the Point , and that of the other is confined all along .
I therefore submit it , whether either of the following Names would not properly express it , Mytulus cylindroides , the cylindroid Muscle , or Mytulus Dactyliformis , the Date Muscle .
Its external Form conducing much to encourage the latter , which Mr. More has hinted at , in calling the Stone the Dottle , Dotting , or Dating-Stone ; for as to the Place of its Residence , that belongs rather to its general natural History than its distinguishing Name .
Doctor Lister , and after him Monsieur D'Argensville have drawn our Pholas with five Shells ; but we have some Reason to suspect they are only Bivalves ; for , upon examining those enclosed in the Specimen before you , in Company with Mr. Hill , none of them appeared to have any more than two Shells .
And in a Specimen ( given to Mr. Peter Collinson by Sir Charles Wager ) of one of these Fish , which lodged itself in the Bottom of a Ship , there were but two Shells found ; which Shell together with the Piece of Wood , wherein it was lodged , I myself saw along with several other Friends in the above mentioned Gentleman 's Collection .
Now these ought , in like manner , after its generical Character , to be ranged among the Chamae ; and as they have a Proboscis which none of the Mytuli have , I would also offer the following Name for this Fish ; Chama longa rugis asperis , alba .
The long rough white Chama .
Mr. Baker has shown me another Species of Pholas , which he lately took out of a Stone from the Coast of Cornwal , and which has more of the Pectuncle than any other kind , in its Form , Cardo , and shutting close ; which the Shells just mentioned cannot do : Now these three distinct Kinds of ShellFish can never be said to be rightly called by the single Name of Pholas .
The common Objection to these Fish boring their Way into the Stones in which they are found , viz. that the Stones are first in a soft State , and so harden about them , may be obviated by the following Considerations : First , that in Mr. More 's great Stone , when it was broken , there appeared thro ' its Substance several petrify 'd fossil Shells ; which clearly show that its Formation was of an ancienter Date than the Age of these Muscles can admit of .
Secondly , That the Holes on the Surface are narrower , in general , than the Cavity in which the Fish lies ; and which demonstrates , that they enter young , and are capable of enlarging their Room as they grow bigger , by abrading the Sides of their Cells : And this is further apparent , by the sandy Matter found in the Bottoms of those Cells , which the Fish cannot well get rid of , when it happens , that the Orifice is higher than the Bottom ; Abundance of which Mr. Hill and myself observed in some of the Holes ; and which is easily thrown quite out , when the Ori fice is depending ; for in these we observed none : And this is further confirmed by what Dr. Woodward relates in the first Volume of his Catalogue * , that certain Pillars of white Carrara Marble taken out of the Sea , on the Coast of Leghorn , after lying there a Number of Years , were destroyed by the boring of these Pholades .
As to the Manner of their penetrating the Stones , I cannot give the least Account of it ; who am , SIR , Your most obedient Servant , James Parsons .
* Page 25 .

