An Inquiry into the Measure of the Force of Bodies in Motion : With a Proposal of an Experimentum Crucis , to decide the Controversy about it .
By James Jurin , M. D. Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians , London , and of the Royal Society .
M Echanical Forces may be reduced to two Sorts ; one of a Body at Rest , the other of a Body in Motion .
Read May 30 .
1745 .
The Force of a Body at Rest , is that of a Body lying still upon a Table , or hanging by a Rope , or supported upon a Spring , &amp;c. This is called by the Name of Pressure , Tension , Force , or Vis mortua .
The Measure of this Force is the Weight with which the Table is pressed , or the Rope is stretched , or the Spring is bent .
And that Measure being acknowledged by all Writers , there is no Dispute about this Sort of Force , notwithstanding the Diversity of Appellations by which it is called .
The Force of a Body in Motion is on all hands agreed to be a Power residing in that Body , so long as it continues its Motion ; by means of which it is able to remove Obstacles lying in its Way ; to lessen , destroy , or overcome , the Force of any other moving Body , which meets it in an opposite Direction ; or to surmount any dead Pressure or Resistance , as Tension , Gravity , Friction , &amp;c. for some time ; but which will be lessened or destroyed by such Obstacles , or by such Resistance , as lessens or destroys the Motion of the Body .
This is called moving Force , Vis motrix , and by some late Writers , Vis viva , to distinguish it from the Vis mortua spoken of before : And by these Appellations , however different , the same Thing is understood by all Mathematicians ; namely , That Power of displacing Obstacles , withstanding opposite moving Forces , or overcoming any dead Resistance , which resides in a moving Body , and which , in Whole or in Part , continues to accompany it , so long as the Body moves .
But about the Measure of this Sort of Force , Mathematicians are divided into two Parties : And , in order to state the Case fairly between them , it will be necessary to show how far the two Parties agree , and in what Point their Disagreement consists .
Both Sides agree , That the Measure of this Force depends partly upon the Mass , or Weight , of the Body , and partly upon the Velocity with which it moves ; so that , upon any Increase either of the Weight , or of the Velocity , the moving Force will become greater .
They also agree , That if the Velocity continue the same , but the Mass , or Weight of the Body , be increased in any Proportion , the moving Force is increased in the same Proportion : So that , in this Case , the Measure of the moving Force is the same with that of the Weight : Or , when two Bodies move with the same Velocity , if the Weight of the second be double , triple , quadruple , of that of the first , the moving Force of the second will also be double , triple , quadruple , of that of the first .
But , when two Bodies are equal , and the Velocities with which they move are different , the two Parties no longer agree about the Measure of the moving Force .
One Side maintains , That , when the Velocity of the second Body is double , triple , quadruple , of that of the first , the Measure of the moving Force of the second is also double , triple , quadruple , of that of the moving Force , being the same with that of the Velocity .
The other Side pretend , That , in the same Case , the moving Force of the second Body is four times , nine times , sixteen times , as great as that of the first ; the Measure of the moving Force being the same with that of the Square of the Velocity .
In consequence of the Agreement in the first of these two Cases , and the Disagreement in the second , the one Side pretends , That the Measure of the moving Force is , in all Cases , the Product of the Weight into the Velocity ; and the other , That it is the Product of the Weight into the Square of the Velocity .
This Controversy was first started by the famous Mr. Leibnitz , and has been carried on by him and his Followers for near threescore Years ; during which Time a great Number of Pieces have been published on both Sides of the Question , and a great Number of Experiments have been made , or proposed to be made , in order to decide it .
But tho ' both Parties agree in the Event of the Experiments , whether actually made , or only proposed ; yet , as the Writers on each Side have found a Way of deducing from those Experiments a Conclusion suitable to their own Opinion , the Disagreement still continues as wide as ever , to the great Scandal of the Learned World .
Now , if we examine carefully into the Reason of this , and would see by what means it happens , that two opposite Conclusions are so often drawn from the same Experiment , we shall find it not so much owing to false Reasoning on either Side , ( That would be easily detected , and set right ) , as to another Cause ; namely , to their Disagreement in the Principles upon which the Reasoning is founded .
For , whereas whatever is laid down on either Side as a Principle , ought to be something all the World agrees in , at least what is admitted by the other Party ; without which , all Reasoning upon it is to no Purpose ; this Conduct has been so little observed in the present Dispute , that what has been offered on the one Side as an undoubted Principle or Axiom , has has commonly been something that the opposite Party does not admit , nay , even absolutely denies .
Of this it were easy to produce a Number of Examples ; but I shall content myself with two only , one taken from each Side .
Those who maintain , That the moving Force is as the Weight into the Velocity , lay down for a Principle , or Axiom , That When two Bodies meet one another in contrary Directions , if their moving Forces be equal , neither Body will prevail over the other : And if their moving Forces be unequal , the stronger will always prevail over the weaker .
This the Leibnitian Party deny .
They maintain , That one of these Bodies may prevail over the other , though their moving Forces be equal : Nay , that , in many Cases , the weaker will prevail over the stronger .
It is therefore to no Purpose to allege , That the Principle above laid down is founded on common Sense ; or that it was always universally received , till this Dispute began : For , since the opposite Party now reject it , all Reasoning upon it can have no Weight with them ; you must have recourse to something else .
On the other hand , those who adhere to Mr. Leibnitz 's Sentiment , lay down for a Principle , That Equal Effects always arise from equal Causes ; provided the Causes be entirely consumed in producing those Effects .
This their Opponents do not admit , unless in the Case where those equal Effects are produced in equal Times : And therefore , till both Sides shall agree in admitting this Principle , no Argument can be drawn from it by one Party , that will be of any Service to convince the other .
But as this Principle is chiefly made use of in reasoning upon Experiments made with Springs , many of which have been produced by both Parties , in Support of their Opinions , it may be worth while more particularly to consider , What Right there is on the one Side to impose this Principle , and what Reasons may be given on the other for rejecting it .
When one End of a Spring , wholly unbent , leans against an immovable Support , and the opposite End is struck upon by a Body in Motion , which , bending the Spring to some certain Degree , does thereby lose its whole moving Force ; the moving Force of the Body may be considered as the Cause of bending the Spring ; and the Bending of the Spring may be looked upon as the Effect of that Cause , which is wholly spent and consumed in producing it .
Now if two unequal Bodies , moving with uneequal Velocities , strike in this manner upon two equal Springs , and each of them bend the Spring it strikes upon , exactly to the same Degree ; and by so doing , the moving Force of each Body be entirely consumed ; Here , say the Leibnitian Writers , are two equal Effects produced ; for the Springs are equal , and are now equally bent ; and the moving Forces , which are the Causes of those Effects , are wholly consumed in producing them ; and therefore , by virtue of the Principle above laid down , those Causes must be equal ; that is , the moving Forces of the two Bodies must be equal .
But their Antagonists will reply , That this Principle is not admitted by them , except the Times of producing those Effects are equal ; and that they are not so in the Case before us : For the greater Body will take up a longer Time in producing its Effect , or in bending its Spring .
If therefore the Leibnitian Party pretend , That equal Effects , when produced in unequal Times , do always arise from equal Causes , they must not impose this upon their Opponents by way of Principle or Axiom , but must demonstrate it .
Till this be done , there will be Room to doubt , at least , whether the two Bodies have equal moving Forces , though they bend equal Springs to the same Degree .
For the larger and slower of these two Bodies will bend the one Spring more slowly ; and , consequently , will be resisted for a longer Time , than the smaller and swifter Body will be resisted in bending the other Spring to the same Degree .
May not therefore the total Resistance of a Spring be greater , if that Resistance continues for a longer Time ?
And , if the total Resistance be greater , must not the moving Force , which is destroyed and consumed by that Resistance , be also greater ?
Is there not Reason then to doubt , whether the moving Forces of these two Bodies be equal , though they bend equal Springs to the same Degree ?
In like manner , when a Spring , already bent to some certain Degree , does , by unbending , drive before it a Body which gives way to its Pressure , is there not Room to doubt , whether the Pressure of the Spring may not produce a greater Effect , when that Pressure continues for a longer Time ?
That Pressure may be said to produce three Effects , all of which may , if we please , be considered as different from one another .
1 .
The Pressure carries the Body thro ' a certain Space ; by which Space the Length of the bent Spring is increased , in returning to its natural Situation .
2 .
The Pressure gives to the Body a certain Quantity of Motion .
3 .
It gives the Body a certain moving Force .
Now , the first of these Effects is greater , when the Pressure acts for a longer Time .
For , if the Pressure of a bent Spring , by acting for one Second upon the Body 1 , carry that Body 1 thro ' the Space 1 ; the Pressure of the same , or of an equal Spring equally bent , by acting for two Seconds upon the Body 4 , will carry that Body 4 thro ' the same Space 1 .
Likewise the second Effect is greater , when the Pressure continues for a longer Time .
For , in the Case just now mentioned , the Body 4 will have twice the Quantity of Motion that the Body 1 has ; though these two Quantities of Motion arise from the Pressure of the same , or , which is all one , of equal Springs equally bent .
Why therefore are we take it for granted , or to have it imposed upon us by way of Principle or Axiom , That the third Effect is not greater , when the Time , in which it is produced by the Pressure of the same , or equal Springs , is longer , nay , infinitely longer ?
But we are told , that all the Force , which resided in the Spring , while bent , is now , upon the Unbending of the Spring , communicated to the Body moved .
I ask therefore , What was that Force , or what kind of Force was that , which resided in the Spring , while bent , and without Motion ?
Was it a bare Pressure , or a moving Force ?
A Vis mortua , or a Vis viva ?
You must acknowledge , it was a Vis mortua , a bare Pressure , and nothing more .
But the Force communicated to the Body , and which now resides in the Body in Motion , is a Vis viva , a moving Force .
This therefore is not the same Force , nor a Force of the same kind , as that which resided in the bent Spring .
It will be said , however , That the Force of the bent Spring is entirely exhausted in giving the Body its moving Force .
I ask therefore again , What is it I am to understand by these Words , The Force of the Spring is entirely exhausted ?
If the Meaning be , that the Spring could not possibly give that same Body any greater moving Force , than what it has already given , I allow it : But this does not prove , that the same Spring , bent afresh to the same Degree , or an equal Spring equally bent , cannot give a greater Force to a greater Body .
But if the Meaning of these Words be , That the Spring cannot give a greater moving Force to any Body whatsoever , I must answer , That this is taking for granted the very Point which is in Dispute .
For the opposite Party pretend , That a Body of four Times the Bulk , will receive twice the moving Force in twice the Time , from the Pressure of the same Spring in unbending itself , or , if you please , in exhausting all its Force .
It is plain , therefore , that the Followers of Mr. Leibnitz have no Right to say , A Body has such or such a Force , because such or such a Spring has put it in Motion by unbending itself , or can be bent by it .
This is not a Position to be taken for granted , but stands in need of a Demonstration , which nobody has as yet attempted to give , at least from any uncontroverted Principle ; and , till this be done , the laying down any such Position can have no other Effect , than to perplex the Controversy more and more , without Hopes of ever coming to an End of it .
For which Reason I propose to take a quite different Method in what follows , and to lay down nothing , by way of Principle or Axiom , but what is allowed of by all the World , or , at least , has never yet been contradicted a priori .
Axiom I. When a bent Spring does , by unbending itself , push a Body before it , the greater the Body is , the more slowly will the Spring unbend itself .
Axiom II .
The more any Spring is bent , the greater is its Pressure .
Axiom III .
A greater Pressure produces a greater moving Force , if the Time be given .
Proposition I. Moving Forces are not proportional to the Masses of the Bodies , and the Squares of their Velocities .
Demonstration .
Let there be two Springs , equal , and equally bent , A and B , which , by unbending themselves , push before them two unequal Bodies ; the Spring A pushing before it the greater Body .
Now , by Axiom I. the Spring A will unbend more slowly than the other : from which it follows , that , at every Instant of the Time which the Spring B takes up in unbending itself , the Spring A will have unbent itself less than B , or will be more bent than B. Therefore , by Axiom II .
the Pressure of the Spring A will , at any Instant of that Time , be greater than the Pressure of the Spring B at that same Instant .
Hence , by Axiom III .
the nascent , or infinitely small moving Force , which is produced by the Pressure of the Spring A in every infinitely small Part of that Time , will be greater than that produced by the Pressure of the Spring B in the same infinitely small Part of the Time .
Therefore , the Sum of the infinitely small moving Forces ; that is to say , the whole moving Force , which is produced by the Spring A , during that Time , will be greater than the moving Force produced by the Spring B in that same Time : Or the moving Force of the greater Body will be greater than that of the lesser , at the Instant that the Spring B , being now wholly unbent , ceases to act any longer upon the Body it has pushed before it : And as , after that Instant , the Spring A , not being yet wholly unbent , continues to act upon the greater Body , the moving Force of the greater Body will still continue to increase , and consequently will more and more exceed the moving Force of the smaller Body .
But every one knows , that the Products of the Masses and Squares of the Velocities are equal in the two Bodies .
Therefore the moving Forces , which we have proved to be unequal , are not proportional to the Products of the Masses and Squares of the Velocities .
Which was to be demonstrated .
To consider this in a particular Example , let us suppose the Masses of the two Bodies exposed to the Pressure of the Springs A and B , to be 4 and 1 respectively ; and let the Spring B unbend itself , and thereby give the Body 1 its whole moving Force in one Second of Time .
Then , at the End of that Second , the moving Force of the Body 4 will already exceed that of the Body 1 , and will still grow greater during another Second of Time .
For the Times are as the square Roots of the Masses .
Also , if the Masses be 100 and 1 , the moving Force of the Body 100 , will , at the End of the first Second of Time , be greater than that of the Body 1 , and will continue to increase during the Space of nine other Seconds .
Corollary .
When a bent Spring does , by unbending itself , drive a Body before it , the larger that Body is , the greater will be the moving Force which it receives from the Spring .
Having now clearly proved , that the moving Forces are not proportional to the Squares of the Velocities , I proceed next to demonstrate , that they are proportional to the Velocities themselves : And , in order thereto , I shall , as I have hitherto done , make use of no other Principles or Axioms , than such as are admitted on both Sides , or , at least , have never yet been controverted a priori by either Party .
Axiom IV .
Springs of unequal Lengths , when bent alike , have equal Pressures .
We speak here of Springs equal in all Respects , except the Length only ; and , by being bent alike , we mean , that they are so compressed , as that the Lengths they are now reduced to , are exactly proportional to their natural Lengths , or to the Lengths they are of when no way compressed .
In this Condition , if one be directly opposed to the other , they will mutually sustain each other 's Pressure , so as to maintain a perfect AEquilibrium : Or , if each be placed separately in a vertical Situation , they will sustain equal Weights .
And in one or the other of these Cases , it is evident , that they must exercise equal Pressures .
Axiom V. Equal Pressures in equal Times produce equal moving Forces .
Proposition II .
Moving Forces are proportional to the Masses and Velocities jointly .
Demonstration .
Let there be two Springs , of the Lengths 1 and 2 , but equal in all other Respects , and bent alike : And , in unbending themselves , let the Spring 1 drive before it a Body whose Mass is 2 ; and the Spring 2 another Body of the Mass 1 .
Now , by Coroll. 11 .
of my general Theorem concerning the Action of Springs , these two Springs will unbend themselves exactly in the same Time ; and , consequently , the Spring 2 will unbend itself with a Velocity double of that of the Spring 1 : And .
by Coroll. 12 .
of the same Theorem , it will give to the Body 1a Velocity double of that , which the Body 2 will receive from the Spring 1 .
Also , as the two Springs were supposed to be bent alike at first , and the Spring 2 unbends itself with a Velocity double to that of the Spring 1 , it is manifest , that , during the whole Time of their Expansion , they will be always bent alike , one to the other .
Therefore , by Axiom IV .
their Pressures will be constantly equal one to the other : And hence , by Axiom V. the infinitely small moving Forces produced by each of these Springs , in every infinitely small Part of Time , will be equal one to the other .
Consequently , the Sums of those infinitely small moving Forces , that is , the whole moving Forces , produced by the two Springs , will be equal one to the other .
And the Masses of the two Bodies being 2 and 1 , and their Velocities being 1 and 2 respectively , it is plain , that the moving Forces are proportional to the Masses and Velocities jointly .
Which was to be demonstrated .
For the greater Facility of examining this Demonstration , we have suited it to a single Case only , and that the most simple that can be supposed : But every body will see , how easy it is to form a general one upon the same Principles .
As we do not think , that any Flaw can be found in either of the Demonstrations above laid down ; and the Axioms , upon which they are founded , have never yet been disputed , as far as we know ; we presume , that the Leibnitian Opinion about the Measure of moving Forces , is incontestably overthrown by the first Proposition , and the opposite Sentiment is as evidently established by the second .
But , if any Reader shall be of a different Opinion , we must beg Leave to propose to his Consideration the following Experiment , which we hope may justly deserve the Name of an Experimentum Crucis ; and , as such , may put a final Period to this Controversy .
It is not new indeed , having been proposed before by myself and others ; but , as the Manner , in which it was formerly offered , has given Occasion to some Objections , which , tho ' not affecting the Substance of the Argument drawn from it , may yet have amused and embarassed the less attentive Readers , I shall now propose it in such a Manner , as may obviate all those Difficulties , and , I think , will render it absolutely decisive .
To me , I am sure , it will be so , since I shall immediately embrace the Leibnitian Doctrine , if my Argument drawn from it can receive a clear and satisfactory Answer .
Experiment .
Upon an horizontal Plane , at Rest , but moveable with the least Force , suppose upon a Boat in a stagnant Water , let there be placed , between two equal Bodies , a bent Spring , by the unbending of which the two Bodies may be pushed contrary Ways .
In this Case it is evident , that the Velocities , which the two Bodies receive from the Spring , will be exactly equal , and their moving Forces will also be exactly equal ; and that the Plane they move upon , and also the Boat upon which it lies , will have no Motion given them either Way .
Let us call the Velocity of each Body 1 , and the moving Force also 1 .
Now , let us suppose the Spring to be bent afresh to the same Degree as before , and to be again placed between the two Bodies lying at Rest ; then let the Plane , upon which the Spring and the Bodies lie , be carried uniformly forwards , in the Direction of the Length of the Spring , with this same Velocity I. In this Case it is evident , that each of the Bodies will have the Velocity 1 , and the moving Force 1 , both in the Direction of the Axis of the Spring .
During this Motion , let the Spring again unbend , and push the two Bodies contrary Ways , as before , the one forwards , the other backwards : Then the Spring will give to each of these Bodies the Velocity 1 , as before , when the Plane was at Rest .
By this means the hindmost Body , or that which is pushed backwards , will have its Velocity 1 , which it had before by the Motion of the Plane , now entirely destroyed , and will be absolutely at Rest .
But the Body , which is pushed forwards , will now have the Velocity 2 , namely 1 from the Motion of the Plane , and 1 from the Action of the Spring .
Thus far every body agrees in what will be the Event of this Experiment .
But the Question is , What will be the moving Force of the foremost Body , or of that which is pushed forwards , and which has the Velocity 2 ; viz. 1 from the Motion of the Plane , and 1 from the Action of the Spring .
By the Leibnitian Doctrine , its moving Force must be 4 : And , if so , it must have received the moving Force 3 from the Action of the Spring ; for it had only the moving Force 1 from the Motion of the Plane .
Let us examine , whether this be possible , or reconcileable to their own Doctrine .
Their Doctrine is , That equal Springs , equally bent , will , by unbending themselves , give equal moving Forces to the Bodies they act upon , whatever those Bodies are .
We agree to this , not generally indeed ; but in the Case before us , where the Bodies are of equal Masses or Weights , we agree to it .
Let us therefore imagine the bent Spring , which is placed between the two Bodies , to be divided transversly into two equal Parts .
In this Case it is plain , that the two Halves of the Spring , may be considered as two entire Springs , equal , and equally bent , each of which rests at one End in AEquilibrio against the other Spring , and at the opposite End , presses against the Body it is to move .
Consequently , by the Leibnitian Doctrine , to which , in this particular Case , where the Bodies are equal , we also agree , the two Springs will give equal moving Forces to the two Bodies .
But the moving Force received by the hindmost Body from the hinder Spring , was undoubtedly the moving Force I : For by that Force given it in the Direction backwards , the moving Force I , which it had before from the Motion of the Plane in the Direction forwards , is exactly balanced and destroyed , the Body remaining , as was observed before , in absolute Rest .
Therefore the moving Force received by the foremost Body from the foremost Spring , was also the moving Force I. And this , added to the other moving Force I , which it had before from the Motion of the Plane , makes the moving Force 2 , and not the moving Force 4 , as the Leibnitian Philosophers pretend .
Consequently , that Body , which had before the Velocity I , and the moving Force I , and now has the Velocity 2 , has also the moving Force 2 : That is , the moving Forces are proportional to the Velocities .

