Remarks on the Operation of Cutting for the Stone ; by Claud .
Nic .
Le Cat , M. D. F.R.S. Surgeon to the Hotel Dieu at Rouen , and Royal Demonstrator in Anatomy and Surgery .
Translated from the French by T. S. M. D. F. R. S. ARTICLE I. ALL the Methods of Cutting for the Stone may be commodiously divided into the high Apparatus [ or Operation ] wherein the Incision is made above the Os Pubis ; and into the low Apparatus , wherein the Incision is below the Os Pubis and Scrotum .
In the first , the Stone is extracted through the upper OpenD dd2 ing Read at several Meetings ; finished May 16 .
1745 .
ing of the Pelvis : In the second , the Stone is taken out thro ' the lower Opening of the same Pelvis .
The low Apparatus [ or Way ] may be likewise divided into direct and lateral .
The direct is the greater Apparatus [ or Cutting on the Staff ] : The lateral is of four Sorts .
The lateral Apparatus of the first Sort is that which is done without the Staff [ or Catheter ] , and wherein the Operator has no other Guide but the Stone itself , which is pushed forward , as much as possible , towards the Perinaeum .
This is called the lesser Apparatus [ or Cutting on the Gripe ] , which Celsus has described .
It is the oldest of all the Ways of Cutting , and may be looked on as the Source of all the other Sorts of the lateral Operation .
The second Sort of lateral Apparatus is that wherein the Operator makes use of a grooved Staff , on which he cuts the [ inner ] End of the Urethra lengthways , and makes laterally on the Inside of the Prostate , and on the Neck of the Bladder , an Incision about two Lines deep , or a Sort of laying open , which only makes way for the Dilatation or Laceration .
This is the Method of Cutting which I use , after having had it from Mr. Morand , who learned it of Mr. Cheselden .
And it is to this I have endeavoured to give the Improvements which are already known in the World , and which I intend speedily to publish .
In my Opinion , one may rank in the same Class the Method whereby Monsieur de la Peyronie lays open laterally the Neck of the Bladder , with Instruments differing but little from those of the greater Apparatus .
[ For ] this Method , as it has been communicated to me by that great Surgeon , scarcely differs from ours but in the Instruments .
The The third Sort of lateral Operation is that , wherein , under the Direction of the same grooved Staff , he cuts quite thro ' the Neck of the Bladder , the Prostate .
and the [ inner ] End of the Urethra .
This is , properly speaking , Friar Jaques 's Method rectified ; that which Mr. Cheselden practised last , that of Mr. Sharp his Disciple , and , probably , that of Mr. Rau ; if , after all , it is not of the second Sort .
In fine , the fourth Sort of lateral Operation is that , in which , without touching the Urethra , or Neck of the Bladder , the Incision is made into its Body , on one Side of the Neck .
This is ascribed to Mr. Rau ; but I am of Opinion , that the first Persons who tried it on the living Body were Mr. Bamber and Mr. Cheselden , who soon after abandoned it ; after them , Mr. Foubert , who endeavoured to improve it ; and , in fine , myself , who am in hopes , that I have given it those Degrees of Perfection , which were essentially wanting in the Methods of those who went before me .
This fourth Sort of lateral Operation , and those Improvements which I think I have added to it , are to be the Subject of our first Remarks .
ARTICLE II .
Remarks on the fourth Sort of lateral Operation , commonly ascribed to Mr. Rau .
FRIAR Jaques 's Manner of Cutting , quite imperfect as it was , is the Source , or , at least , the occasional Cause , of all the new Methods of the lateral ral Operation .
Immediately after Friar Jaques , Mr. Rau , who was qualified to correct the Defects in the Method of the former , invented a particular one , of which he never showed more than the outward Part , which he could not conceal , and made a Mystery of the essential Part of the Operation .
The only Particulars that have been known with Certainty , are ; 1 .
That he made use of a grooved Catheter passed into the Bladder without being injected ; and that he himself held this Catheter in his left Hand during the Operation .
2 .
That he made the outward Incision between the left Erector [ Penis ] and the Accelerator [ Urinae ] , and carried it down to near the Buttock on one Side of the Anus ; which he did by several Strokes of the Knife .
3 .
That he made the inward Incision with the same Instrument , which was like the common IncisionKnife .
But , in Mr. Rau 's Operation , we know not what Parts he cut in his inward Incision : However , from the foregoing Circumstances , I believe I can demonstrate , that this Surgeon never performed the fourth Sort of lateral Operation , of which he is said to be the Author ; and that his Manner was , at most , to cut thro ' the Urethra , the Prostate , and the Neck of the Bladder , as is done in the second and third Sorts of this Operation .
[ For ] First , Mr. Rau made use of a grooved Staff .
Now , in order to cut into the Body of the Bladder , the grooved Staff is quite useless ; and even the common Staff is generally of little or no Use , because the End of the Staff , that answers to the Body of the Bladder , is plunged very deep towards the Pelvis , and also very apt to slip ; for which Reason Lithotomists , such as the celebrated Mr. Cheselden , who resolved to try this Manner of Cutting , have been obliged to inject [ the Cavity of ] the Bladder , that its Body might be the less subject to slip [ from the Knife ] ; but made no Use of the Groove of the Staff , as deeming it useless .
Incisionem in sulco catheteris fieri non posse , sive necesse non esse , ut sectio in sulco fiat .
Douglas in Heister on the lateral Operation .
But Mr. Rau made use of the Groove ; therefore he did not make his Opening into the Bladder thro ' its Body .
Secondly , This Lithotomist did not inject the Bladder ; and yet his Operation was quick and safe : Wherefore , it cannot be that he cut into the Body of the Bladder .
For , even with the new Staff of my Invention , which I shall by-and-by describe , and which makes a considerable Elbow forward , the Incision into the Body of the Bladder is tedious and difficult .
And I can assure you , from Experience , that this same Incision with the common Staff is so difficult , that it comes near to an Impossibility ; and that it is absolutely impossible to be always sure of making this Incision in one certain Place , and without fatal Mistakes , in this Method , even supposing the Bladder injected .
Therefore Mr. Rau , who did not inject it , would have , a fortiori , performed an impossible Operation , and with Success too : Therefore this Surgeon did not cut into the Body of the Bladder .
Thirdly , Mr. Rau held the Staff with his left Hand , and did the Operation with his right .
Those who do the lateral Operation of the first three Sorts do not certainly find both their Hands too much for cutting into the Urethra and the Prostate , without injuring the neighbouring Parts : And yet it is pretended , that Mr. Rau could open the Body of the Bladder very exactly ( an Operation which I have proved above to be impossible in his Manner ) ; it is pretended , I say , that he did this Operation with one Hand , a Thing which is more than possible ; since , in order to do it with the new Staff , which projects forward , besides the two Hands of the Operator , which are absolutely necessary , we are obliged to make an Assistant put his Finger , or an Instrument instead of it , into the Rectum , to keep the Gut clear of the Place of the Incision .
Fourthly , Mr. Cheselden , in the first Trials he made of this pretended Method of Mr. Rau , opened the Body of the Bladder , and found himself under a Necessity of relinquishing this Method , because putrid Ulcers were formed , in the Course of the Cure , in the cellular Membrane that surrounds the Bladder and Rectum .
Now Dr. Heister , a Disciple of Mr. Rau , says , This Accident never happened to Mr. Rau ; therefore he did not open the Bladder in its Body ; For there is no Reason why he should avoid this Accident rather than Mr. Cheselden .
Fifthly , Mr. Rau made all his Incisions , the inward as well as the outward , with the same Instrument , whose Make was much like the common Cutting Knife , according to Dr. Heister .
This last Circumstance makes me think , not only that Mr. Rau did not cut into the Body of the Bladder ; because , with so broad an Instrument , and the little Precaution he used , as we have already seen , he would never have succeeded ; but likewise this broad Instrument gives me a violent Suspicion , that this Lithotomist did not so much as cut into the Neck of the Bladder ; and that he only laid it open , as is the Practice in that masterly Operation with the greater Apparatus executed in Mr. de la Peyronie 's Manner : For it is well known what Precaution must be used in the several lateral Operations , to remove the Rectum from the Prostate and the End of the Urethra , in order to cut these Parts without touching the Gut .
Wherefore , in all the several Ways of the lateral Operation , not only the Fore-finger of the left Hand of the Operator is necessary , but also , as I have just now said , it is requisite that the Finger of an Assistant , or an Instrument introduced into the Anus , should contribute to keep off this same Gut .
Whether Mr. Rau opened the Body of the Bladder or not , his Disciples believed he did : And as they were Witnesses to the great Success of their Master , they have not failed to conceive and give the Public an high Opinion of a Method of Cutting which opened the Body of the Bladder with all the Safety that could be expected from a true Method .
The Trials made in England having failed of Success , it was pretty natural in France to think , that the Persons , who made these first Trials , had not light on the true Manner of making this Opening , so greatly cried up , and so much desired .
Monsieur Foubert , Surgeon of Paris , flattered with these Hopes , added to the common Instruments for Cutting , the grooved Trochart of the Paracenthesis , which he proposed to thrust in between the Tuberosity of the Os Ischium and the Anus , directly into the Body of the Bladder ; and on which he was afterwards to introduce a sharp Instrument of his Invention , to make a proper Wound for extracting the Stone .
He made Trial of these Instruments on a dead Body ; and , in fine , he cut a certain Number of Patients for several Years successively in that manner .
People are divided on the Success which attended these Trials : Much has been written against it ; and I have heard a great deal said in its Favour by good Judges .
One Advantage , which flattered me in this Method , was that of its not being liable to occasion Incontinencies of Urine , nor even Fistula 's , as I was assured ; Inconveniences from which the lateral Operation is not exempt in the Case of large Stones , because this Operation attacks the Bladder in its Neck .
But one Defect of Mr. Foubert 's Method , which his very Partisans cannot help taking for an essential Inconvenience , is , that the Operator thrusts the Trochart in toward the Bladder without any thing to guide him , and , as it were , by Guess .
It is needless to enlarge on the fatal Consequences of this Defect ; they appear at first Sight ; and are sufficient to make one refuse giving even the Name of a Method to so uncertain a Way of Cutting .
Nevertheless , if this Way of Cutting had otherwise great Advantages , and that one could clear it of that Blemish which overcasts it , by giving it this Guide which it wanted , and rendering its Process steady and certain , it must be allowed , that it would prove an excellent Method , a lateral Operation of the fourth Sort , worthy of being put upon a Par with , or perhaps of having the Preference of , the other three .
Such are the Reflections which I was led to make on Mr. Foubert 's Operation , by the good Things I have heard of it , and the ill Consequences which I knew attended it .
I endeavoured to find an Instrument that could fix the Incision into the Body of the Bladder to the Place intended : And here is [ the Description of ] that which I invented for this Purpose : This Instrument is a Staff represented in TAB. IV .
Fig. 1 .
such as it is when I pass it into the Bladder .
A , Is its crooked End , which is split lengthways into two Pieces , the concave Piece of which , A , is fixed , and of the same Piece with the rest of the Staff ; and the convex Piece , C , is moveable , having its fixed Point joined by a Hinge to the End a of the Piece A , and its moveable Part jointed at b , with a Piece which makes the End of a strong Stilet [ or Wire ] that runs thro ' the Centre of the Piece B , where it is riveted at e. This Piece B , the Wire , and the Piece C , are held in the Situation which the Operator puts them in , by the Screw E , the End of which bears against the Piece B. This is made of two solid Plates of Silver solder 'd together ; in the Middle of which a Groove has been made to lodge the Wire .
The Handle , D , of the Staff , is square , especially on the Inside , in order to serve as a Sheath for the Piece B , and give it a Firmness , which it communicates to the Wire , and to the moveable Piece C. The Body , G , of the Catheter is almost entirely solid , leaving in its Centre but just Room enough for the Passage of the Wire .
Without this Solidity and this Narrowness of the Passage of the Wire , the Catheter would not be firm ; and the Wire itself , liable to waver , would not run true , but would impart its Weakness , or Want of Justness , to the moveable Piece C , which is the Guide of this Operation .
This Body , G , is solder 'd to the Piece D at H , making it enter square into the said Piece D , till it meets the Slider B , which I suppose entirely within the Piece D. The Rings are very large and strong , for the Convenience of using it .
This Catheter is made of Silver , from the Rings inclusive to F : All the rest , together with the Wire , ought to be of the hardest Gold ; because it is on this End of the Catheter that the greatest Stress is laid ; and Silver has not Firmness enough to resist the Efforts that these Pieces must sustain .
And particular Care must be taken , that all the Angles and Prominences be rendered very smooth .
I enter into these Details of the Make of the Instrument , because I have learned , to my Cost , that the Workmen do not think of them .
Fig. 2 .
shows the whole Mechanism of this Catheter , by representing it open , and such as it is in the Bladder while the Incision is making .
The Piece B , of Fig. 1 .
is here sunk in its Sheath D ; whereby the small Style or Wire is thrust towards the crooked End of the Catheter , and , at the same time , pushes the End b of the small moveable Piece C towards this same Part .
The Catheter being thus open in the Bladder , when the Operator draws the Instrument towards him , it is stopped by the Neck of this Organ , at the Place marked d d ; and then the Angle b projects about a Finger 's Breadth from the Orifice of the Bladder .
Yet there are some Subjects , in whom this Orifice , being very wide or relaxed , gives greater Way to the Effort made by the Widening , d d , of the anterior Angle of the Catheter ; whereby it happens , that , instead of stopping this Angle at d d , it lets it pass thro ' to f f , which brings the Incision so much nearer the Neck of the Bladder : Nay , I have seen in some dead Bodies , in which the Relaxation is still greater , that the Prostate was somewhat concerned in the Incision ; which is no great Misfortune .
But even this may be easily avoided , by taking care , in the first Incisions , to disengage the Part that answers to the projecting Angle from every thing that may hide from us the Prostate and Bladder ; and then the foregoing Case becoming visible , it is easy to guard against it , by causing the projecting Angle of the Catheter to be pushed , or by pushing it one 's Self farther into the Bladder .
This projecting Part of the Catheter is not seen ; but it is very perceivable to the Touch , thro ' the Integuments ; and still more so , after they are cut through .
I must not omit observing here , that , notwithstanding all the Care I have taken to instruct the Instrument-maker in the Construction of this Catheter , and especially of the moveable Piece b C , in order to make it solid : Yet it has often proved too weak to bear the Effort of thrusting the Part forward , which we are obliged to do on one Side ; so that it bent , and remained in the Middle , while the rest of the Catheter was to the left Side .
In case of this Accident , it came into my Thought to turn the Catheter upside-down ; so that the Angle of the moveable Piece might answer to the upper Part of the Neck of the Bladder , and stop there , while the concave and immovable Part of the Catheter answered to the Incision , and that the very End of the Catheter projected at the Place where I was to open the Body of the Bladder .
And , upon several Trials , I found that this Place was the very same which had before been pointed out by the Angle of the moveable Piece ; therefore , when I have one of these Catheters , on which I cannot depend , I make use of it in this last Manner ; and it entirely answers my Expectation ; because the fixed Piece of these Catheters is always very solid , and that the Angle of the moveable Piece does its Duty as well on the upper as on the under Side of the Neck of the Bladder .
It has even seemed to me , that the End of the Instrument makes the greater Protrusion forward .
In fine , this Catheter , being almost strait , easily assumes in the Bladder every Situation which one finds necessary to give it .
Fig. 3 .
represents the Incision-Knife , which I use .
It is the same that I call Urethotome in my common lateral Operation ; excepting that here I give a greater Length to the Back .
A is the Handle ; BC the Blade ; of which B is the great Edge , C the Back , FE is the little Edge .
In the middle of this Blade is a Chanel , that ends with the Point of the Instrument at E. The little Edge FE must not go beyond the Point F , if the Operator would spare the Neck of the Bladder , when he plunges the Instrument into this Organ ; for , if it be made longer , it must carry the Incision as far as into the Prostate .
The Manner of performing the Operation .
HAVING placed the Patient as usual , I pass an hollow Catheter into the Bladder , thro ' which I half-inject the Bladder ; because I have found , that , as a moderate Injection renders the Operation more speedy and safe , so a complete Injection forces back toward the Rectum the Place appointed for the Incision , and makes the Operation laborious and dangerous .
When I have made the Injection , I draw out the hollow Catheter , and pass in my new Staff by half a Turn ; which I make very short , upon account of its little Convexity .
I push it to the Bottom of the Bladder ; and when I am quite sure it is there , I give to the moveable Piece b C , the Situation requisite to make the Protrusion answer the Places where I intend to open the Body of the Bladder .
The Places which I have chosen in the Trials I have made of this Method are two ; the first is between the two Vesiculae seminales , close to the left , under the Orifice of the left Ureter ; the second is above the Orifice of the Ureter , and over the left Vesicula seminalis .
For doing the Operation pursuant to the first Intention , when my Staff is in the Bladder , I keep its Rings exactly in a horizontal Position , so that the moveable Piece bC may bear directly on the Line , which may be imagined to pass between the Orifices of the Ureters .
In this Situation , I loosen the Screw which stopped the sliding Piece B of Fig. 1 .
I thrust in this Piece , which opens the Staff , and makes the Elbow or Angle b , Fig. 2 .
I then fasten the Screw to fix the Staff thus open : I afterwards draw the Rings towards me , as if to draw back the Staff , always in a horizontal Position , till the Angle bda stops me .
Then , being sure that the Elbow b of my Staff has passed directly between the Orifices of the Ureters , and that it is a good Finger 's Breadth from the Neck of the Bladder , I raise up the Handle of my Staff a little , carrying it softly toward the right Thigh , and I give to the Rings an oblique Direction approaching to a diagonal , in order to push the Elbow b toward the Space between the Anus and left Os Ischium .
An Assistant holds the Staff in this Attitude ; another passes the Fore-finger of his right Hand , or an Instrument made for this Purpose , Fig. 4 .
* into the Anus , and pushes down the Rectum on the right Side .
With my left Thumb I secure the Integuments , resting it on the Middle of the Perinaeum ; and with the right Hand I make , with the Incision-Knife , Fig. 3 .
a long and deep Incision between the Os Ischium and the Anus , beginning on one Side of the Place , where ends the Incision with the greater Apparatus .
This first Incision generally * Tho ' this Instrument serves me here for removing the Rectum from the Parts destined for the Incision , it was not for this Use that I invented it , but to make a Speculum Any &amp; Matricis , being joined to another entirely like it , with its Angle and Groove placed on the Angle and Groove , A B , of this .
We shall have Occasion , in another Place , to give a more ample Description of this Instrument , and its Advantages over the other Sorts of Speculum .
rally lays open no more than the common Integuments : Then , with the Fore-finger of my left Hand , I feel for the Elbow of my Staff ; and on this Elbow I cut upward and downward ; first , the Septum , formed by the Elevatores Any ; secondly , the ligamentous Lamina that supports these muscular Expansions , and which , without an accurate Knowledge of those Parts , may be easily mistaken for the Bladder .
These Obstacles being well removed , the Elbow of my Staff becomes more and more disengaged , and the End of the Prostate and Beginning of the Bladder are laid bare .
Then , being certain of the Place I am at , I feel again for the Elbow of my Staff : I set it right , if the Assistant has let it slip from its due Position , and on it I plunge the Knife into the Bladder , so as that its Point runs on the Outside , and the whole Length of this Elbow , and the great Edge B , Fig. 3 .
faces the posterior Part of this Organ .
By this Incision I cut into the Bladder an Inch long or more , if I think proper , a Finger 's Breadth from its Orifice , under and close to the left Vesicula seminalis , and the Orifice of the left Ureter .
I had caused a Groove to be made on the projecting Piece C , Fig. 2 .
to direct my Knife , but I found it of no Use .
On the Groove of my Knife , now in the Bladder , I slide the Gorget ; and then the Assistant , who held the Staff , loosens the Screw , draws the Ring of the Piece B , whereby the Staff is brought back to its former Shape , as in Fig. 1 .
and then he draws it out of the Bladder .
The rest of the Operation is performed in the usual Manner .
In order to open the Bladder above the left Vesicula seminalis with the same Staff , as soon as it is in the Bladder , one must turn the moveable Piece bC Fig. 2 .
towards the left Side of the Bladder , by giving to the Rings of the Staff such an oblique Direction , that they make an Angle of about Forty five Degrees with the horizontal Line .
In this State I open the moveable Piece , and oblige it to make an Elbow exactly in the Place desired .
Then I do my Operation , as above described .
The above described Operation is the Result of a great Number of Experiments made on dead Bodies ; in some of which I had injected the hypogastric Artery .
These numerous Trials have constantly convinced me , that my Staff is an Instrument with which one is as sure as possible , always to open the Body of the Bladder in the Place resolved on by the Operator .
For if it happens , that a Bladder either too large or too small , or some other Motive , obliges the Surgeon to make his Incision farther from , or nearer to , the Neck of this Organ , he will fulfil that Intention , by more or less pushing the Piece with the Slider B , and thereby causing the moveable Piece bC to make a greater or lesser Angle .
From Trials on dead Bodies I passed to Operations on living Subjects ; and , having had some Reasons to think , that the Incision into the Body of the Bladder between and beyond the Ureters , was preferable to that which is practised above the left Vesicula [ seminalis ] .
In Autumn 1741 , I cut three Patients in this Way ; viz. John Peter Desmarest , whose Stone could not be extracted whole .
He lost much Blood during the Operation , and after it ; and died the 17th Day .
Peter le Grand ; who died in three Months after cutting , of a sinuous Fistula in the Pelvis .
Giles Laurence ; who had likewise an Haemorrhage .
Of three or four soft Stones which he had , the greatest Part remained , and he died the fourth Day .
As I was accustomed to good Success in our lateral Operation , I was concerned for the Accidents that happened in these first Trials more sensibly than another would probably have been .
I publicly opened the three above-mentioned Subjects .
The Incisions of the Bladder were found to be most exactly done in the Place above specified , without hurting any of the neighbouring Parts : And it plainly appeared , that the Death of these Subjects was occasioned by the following Inconveniences attending this Method .
1 .
The Haemorrhage , which is almost inevitable from the Depth of the Incision .
2 .
The Stripping of the Gut of the cellular Membrane that surrounds it ; which , together with the Depth of this Denudation occasions putrid Ulcers by the Irruption of the Urine into the rest of the cellular Membrane , behind the Septum Levator Any , and thence into the whole Circumference of the Bladder .
Mr. Cheselden complained of this Accident , when he tried this Method .
3 .
The Stones more difficult to be found , either with the Fingers , or the Instruments ; especially when they are lodged in the right Side , and anterior Part , of the Bladder .
4 .
Even when the Operator has laid hold of the Stone , he finds more Difficulty in extracting it than in any other sort of the lateral Operation .
I was formerly of the contrary Opinion ; but Experience has since convinced me , and I have plainly seen the Grounds of this fourth Inconvenience ; which are these : It is not the exterior Integuments that ever hinder the Passage of the Stone ; for they yield too easily [ to give any Obstacle ] .
The Septum Levator Any is not more difficult to dilate from the Moment it has begun to be divided : Wherefore the real Obstacles to the Extraction of the Stone are , either the Bones of the Pelvis , the Bladder , or the Prostate .
The Bones of the Pelvis give an equal Obstacle to all the Sorts of lateral Operation : And even , generally speaking , in all the Methods of the low Apparatus , it is the same Road , the same Outlet , the same Obstacle .
The Bladder presents as great an Obstacle in the fourth Sort of the lateral Operation as in the second , or in ours .
In the first , the Wound of the Bladder is made an Inch long ; in the second , the Bladder is laid bare for some Lines , and then dilated the rest of the Way .
In both these the Opening is the same , when the Forceps is introduced .
In extracting the Stone , you must in both still dilate or tear as much as the Size of the Stone requires ; and , consequently , in this respect , the Difficulty is the same .
The Prostate and Neck of the Bladder are the remaining Obstacles to the Extraction of the Stone .
These Parts are divided in our Method , and they are left whole in the lateral Operation of the fourth Sort .
Now it is plain , and I have experienced it in the three Operations I did , that the Neck of the Bladder and the Prostate advance , while the Stone is extracting , under the Pubis , and against the interosseous Ligament of the Os Pubis , and there form a considerable siderable Obstacle ; and indeed so considerable , that , in the Case of John Peter Desmarest it could not be forced by the greatest Efforts : A Circumstance which has never happened to me in the lateral Operation these ten Years past that I have used it .
5 .
Tho ' I have had the good Fortune , in the foregoing Operations , not to hurt the Vesiculae seminales , nor the Ureter , much less the Rectum ; and that , with the Precautions which I have laid down in the Account of my Manner of doing the Operation , one always avoids these Accidents ; yet it must be allowed , that the above-mentioned Organs are extremely near the Incision ; and that in so terrible and bloody an Operation as that of Cutting for the Stone , one is not always in a Condition to make so strict an Examination as is requisite for shunning these Dangers .
For which reason I reckon them as one of the Inconveniences of this Method , especially of that which opens between the two Vesiculae [ seminales ] : And I have found it so on some dead Bodies , which I cut by an affected Negligence , without making use of that scrupulous Exactitude of which I have just now made mention .
In my Opinion , the second Method I have spoken of , to wit , that wherein the Bladder is opened above the left Vesicula seminalis , is less exposed to the Hazards above mentioned , especially with our Staff .
But it is subject to the other Inconveniences , and also to this additional one of Opening the Bladder in a Place thick set with [ Blood ] Vessels , and in particular with a very considerable Plexus ; as is well known to those who have dissected these Parts .
In fine , I do not pretend in this Place to examine the Advantages and Inconveniences of all the different Methods : This Detail I have reserved for a more complete Work than this Paper : At present , I only seek to lessen the Inconveniences of the general Way of Cutting by opening the Body of the Bladder ; or , rather , I endeavour to improve it ; and I am humbly of Opinion , that the Instrument which I have the Honour to lay before the Society , may contribute to this End .
REMARKS on the Operation of Cutting for the Stone .
ARTICLE III .
On the Method of Cutting by the high Operation .
WHATEVER Improvements have been made in the different Methods of Cutting for the Stone by the low Apparatus , there still remains in them several Inconveniences , to which the high Operation is not subject .
These Advantages of the high Operation above all the other Ways , have been learnedly treated of by celebrated Authors French and English , and have not been contradicted by any one ; so that it would seem as if this Operation had been abandoned , in order to run after the lateral Operation , pretty much as People quit an old Fashion for a new one .
This being a shameful Circumstance in an Art of such Importance as Surgery is , and with respect to so serious an Operation as that of Cutting , it was at length said , in Justification of this Change , That the high Operation is not so general a Method as the low ; That it is not practicable on Subjects of too full a Habit of Body , on indurated Bladders , which are said to be very common in Persons afflicted with the Stone .
One might say , in Answer to these Objections against the high Operation , that Persons troubled with the Stone are very seldom plethoric ; for I do not remember to have met with one Instance of it in above fifteen Years that I am conversant with this Distemper : That most Part of the indurated Bladders become so , by the Stones being lodged many Years therein , and that such Stones are of extraordinary Size and Weight ; and that , in this Case , the Bulk of the Stone alone pushes the Bladder forward enough to be able to cut by the high Operation ; and the rather , because these Subjects are so much emaciated , that , generally speaking , one may feel the Stone above the Pubis , thro ' the very Integuments .
This I have experienced on one Anthony Germain , of forty-four Years of Age , a Native of Calais , but residing at Diepe ; who coming to our Hospital in order to be cut , and being dead of an accidental Fever , even before the [ usual ] Preparation , I cut him , by the high Operation , on the very Stone , and without injecting the Bladder .
This Stone however was not excessively large : It is represented of half its natural Dimensions , together with the Bladder , in TAB. IV .
Fig. 5 .
and 6 .
and it weighed but eight Ounces .
But , granting that the high Operation is not a general Method , is there any one Method universally proper in all Cases ?
And even the lateral Operation , which I look upon as the most perfect of all the Sorts of the low Apparatus , does it lay Claim to this Universality ?
It must be allow 'd , that it does not , whatever Attachment one has to it .
True it is , that very large Stones are extracted by this Method ; but it is equally true , that the Lacerations attending the Extraction of these large Stones are generally mortal , and always followed by Fistulas .
It is a decided Point in Practice , That large Openings , whether made by Incision or Laceration , in the lower Part of the Body of the Bladder , are almost all mortal : Wherefore our Posterity may spare the Public from such murdering Experiments .
Thus the Case of large Stones is one of those , wherein the lateral Operation becomes too fatal to venture putting it in Practice ; and besides , we are not destitute of Examples to prove , that some Stones are too large to be extracted by this Method , even with all these Risques it is exposed to .
On the other hand , Experience has long since determined , that the largest Stones , even those on which the low Apparatus has failed , are extracted by the high Operation with Ease , and constant Success .
This then is one Case , wherein the high Operation , if it be not an universal Method , is at least the only one .
I think this Circumstance might have deserved more of the Attention of Lithotomists ; and that , while they cultivate new Ways of Cutting by the low Apparatus ( which are indeed useful in a great Number of Cases ) , they should not absolutely neglect the high Apparatus , which [ in its Turn ] is necessary in several Cases , wherein the former are either insufficient , or very dangerous .
For , even supposing the Number of these Cases to be but small , the high Operation is not the less a necessary Supplement plement to the other Methods for all Cases that offer .
Thus much I have learned by Experience , that is , by the ill Success of the different Methods of Cutting by the low Apparatus in the Case of large Stones : And therefore I am resolved to follow the high Operation in the said Case .
In adopting this Way of Cutting , as practised by Mr. Douglas , Cheselden , and Morand , I thought I might , under the Patronage of these great Men , be able to make some Improvements on it .
An Inconvenience , which always happened in doing this Operation , is , that as soon as the Knife has opened the Bladder , the Urine or Liquor injected , which kept up its Side close to the Integuments , comes off ; the Bladder sinks , and often slips from the Instrument before the Incision is made large enough ; and then it is very difficult to find the Bladder , and finish the Operation , which by this means becomes tedious and painful .
This Accident has happened several times .
In order to guard against it , I have thought of two Things : First , Instead of cutting the Bladder downward , which contributes to the sinking-in of its Coats , I plunge the Knife into the Bladder behind the Os Pubis , and I cut it upward toward the Belly ; by which means the Edge raises and supports the Coats of the Bottom of the Bladder .
When I see that my Incision is large enough , I turn my Instrument quick , so that the Back may be where the Edge was : And this Back has a very smooth Shoulder , as appears in TAB. IV .
Fig. 7 .
This Shoulder continues to keep the upper Side of the Bladder close up to the Integuments .
Then along the Blade of the Knife I introduce into the Bladder the Part a of the Instrument represented in Fig. 8 .
and placing this very easy smooth Crotchet in the room of the Back of the Knife , I give it to an Assistant to hold and keep up the Bladder close to the Integuments .
This done , I put the Fingers of my left Hand very securely into the Bladder , and examine , if it be sufficiently opened .
I lengthen the Incision , if requisite ; and , if the Stone presents itself to my Fingers , I draw it out , if it can be done without Difficulty ; if not , I use the Instruments represented in Fig. 9 .
10 .
and 11 .
in this manner : By means of the first Suspensor , placed at the upper Angle of the Wound , I slide into the Bladder the End B of one of the Instruments of Fig. 9 .
and 10 .
I apply this second Instrument , which I call DilatatoSuspensor , under one of the Lips of the Wound : I raise it up , carry it close to the Integuments , and give it to an Assistant to hold .
I do the same Thing to the other Lip of the Wound with the other Instrument exactly like the foregoing .
Thus the Wound of the Bladder is kept close to that of the Integuments in all its Parts ; whereby the Urine cannot ouze out towards the cellular Membranes ( a very common Accident in the old Way ; ) and it must all come thro ' the exterior Opening .
In the Case of little Bladders , and small Stones , the two last Instruments are sufficient for this Purpose ; and then I draw out the first .
The Bladder being in this Condition , in order to extract the Stone I introduce either my Fingers , or the Forceps , or the Scoop , Fig. 11 .
which I have found , by Experience , to be much more commodious and sure than the Forceps .
To be able to use this Instrument with the utmost Advantage , one must practise with it a little on dead Bodies : And I am bold to say , it will be found much superior to the Forceps ; and that with it one will extract Stones with Ease and Safety , which the Forceps would either miss , or not draw without great Pain .
The essential Reason of this Superiorty is , that the Scoop takes up less Room , and that it pushes the Stone from behind , so that it can never slip back .
This Instrument , as well as the Forceps , is passed into the Bladder between the two Instruments that support and line the Lips of the Wound .
The Passage for the Forceps is , as it were , marked out on the Back B of these Instruments , Fig. 9 .
and 10 .
which I have designedly made lightly concave , in order to direct the Forceps or Scoop , and prevent their going wrong .
They are in the same manner drawn out , with the Stone , between these two Concavities ; and it is easy to conceive what Advantages must attend this Contrivance .
The whole Stress of the Operation falls on these Concavities : All the Contusions , all the Rubbing , which these Efforts might have caused to the Lips of the Wound , and to the Bladder , bear upon these Instruments : The Shrinking of the Lips of the Bladder behind the Integuments , which is another common Consequence of these Efforts ; the Tearing of the cellular Membranes , which follows this Shrinking , and makes Way for lodging the Urine , and forming purulent and mortal Sinus 's : All these Accidents , I say , which are common in the usual high Operation , and which have contributed toward disgusting some Operators , are avoided by this aforesaid Contrivance .
The Instruments that extract the Stone touch the Bladder no otherwise than to lay hold of the extraneous Body : And , as soon as they have laid hold of it , they have nothing to do but with the Dilatato-Suspensors , which are so broad , smooth , and well polished , that they preserve the Bladder from any Hurt , dilate the Lips of the Wound as gently as the Operator thinks proper , and prepare a slippery Issue for the Stone , which must render the Operation equally expeditious and safe .
All that I have here said , has been practised upon one John Goubert , a Lad of seventeen Years old , of the Parish of Plane in Normandy .
In searching this Lad , I judged the Stone was consid erable ; and , from all the Reasons above-recited , I concluded , that he ought to be cut by the high Operation ; which I performed on the 23d of May 1742 .
Instead of the Table that commonly serves to cut on , I had prepared one of those little Beds which are made by Turners .
I placed my Patient so as to have his Head turned towards the Window , and his Feet at the opposite Part ; the Hips raised , the Breast low , the Head raised on a Pillow .
Two Assistants , standing at his Shoulders , took hold of his Hands , and , unknown to him , threw a Ligature on each Wrist , which they fastened to the Bedstead : Two others did the same to his Knees ; for his Legs left hanging beyond the Bed , and held by Assistants .
Having placed myself on the Right-hand of the Patient , I did the Operation in the Manner above described , having begun by injecting the Bladder .
The The Subject was not such as one would chuse ; he had a strong Fever , and was blooded twice the Day of the Operation .
The second Day he complained of great Pain about the Hips ; which , as he would not lie on his Belly , I attributed to the Urine got into the cellular Membranes , and beginning to hurt the Parts adjacent to the Bladder .
As the Fever , and the other Accidents which the Patient complained of , were attended with a Cold over all his Body , and a Paleness of his Face , I bled him no more ; but put him into a warm Bath at Eleven in the Morning .
He had a Clyster given him at Four in the Afternoon , and at Night he was bathed again .
He was put in on his Back with the Wound bare , that the Water of the Bath might enter in ; and , when he was put to Bed , he was desired to lie on his Belly .
The third Day in the Morning , as the Symptoms were not ceased , he took a Clyster , and was bathed at Eleven o ' Clock , and again at Night .
The fourth Day he was bathed once more .
He slept therein half an Hour , and the Symptoms abated .
This Method of bathing might seem strange to Practioners ; but I have used it for many Years with Success in Cases like this .
The first Year that I tried it , I gave an Account of this Practice to the Royal Academy of Sciences .
The fifth Day my Patient was upon the mending Hand ; and he lay regularly on his Belly .
The seventh Day the Accidents quite disappeared .
The fifteenth Day he was purged .
The Wound was almost closed ; he made Water pretty easily thro ' the Urethra : But , what was singular , in order to make Water thro ' the Yard , he was obliged to put himself on his Belly ; and when he lay on his Back , the Urine came out thro ' the Wound .
To prevent which , I put a common Catheter into the Urethra , which he could not bear : I changed it for one made like an S ; but that also he could not bear .
A Fever seized him , which made a greater Quantity of Urine pass thro ' the Wound ; so that I was compelled to let him lie on his Belly , to suppress this Efflux , which , one would be apt to think , ought to be facilitated by this Situation .
The Reason of this uncommon Appearance seems to be , that the Opening of the Bladder , and that of the Integuments , no longer answering to one another , the Posture on the Belly applied the Wound of the Bladder , now shrunk , and become lower , against the Pubis ; and thereby stopped up the Passage of the Urine [ that Way ] .
I allow 'd him to put himself in whatever Posture agreed best with him ; And , notwithstanding several Indigestions , which his Greediness of Eating was the Occasion of , he was perfectly cured .
Explanation of Fig. 5 .
and 6 .
in TA B. IV .
Fig. 5 .
The Bladder of Antony Germain opened throughout , and its Neck slit by two Incisions .
A A , The Fundus of the Bladder .
B B , The Neck of the Bladder .
c c , The Orifices of the Ureters dilated to the Breadth of an Inch .
d d , A transverse Fold , which imprinted on the Stone the circular Furrow which appears thereon .
Fig. 6 .
The Stone of Antony Germain , of half its natural Size , viewed by its posterior Surface , which lay on that of the Bladder represented by Fig. 5 .
E , The posterior End of the Stone .
F , The anterior End answering to the Neck of the Bladder .
g g , The circular Furrow remarked above .
N. B. The Catheter , TA B. IV .
Fig. 1 .
and 2 .
is figured , and a short Account given of it , in the Med. Essays , Vol. V. p. 466 .
C. M. A Philos. Trans. No.476 .
A ~ Fig. 1 .
eB p.399 .
Fig. 9 .
B p. 414 .
E E Fig. 4 .
E p. 404 .
DD F Fig. 2 .
p. 400 .
H B C Fig.3 .
p.402 .
B A A G A Fig. 5 .
p. 411.418 F Fd d c c b dd B ffAB A ~C TAB. IV .
~ A Fig. 10 .
Fig.11 .
p. 414 .
p.414 .
Fig. 7 .
p. 413 .
Fig. 8 .
p.414 .
B b ~ .
418 E Fig. 6 .
p. ~ .
418 .
g g

