I. Two Letters from the Rev. Mr. Granville Wheler , F. R. S. to the President , concerning a rotatory Motion of Glass Tubes about their Axes , when placed in a certain Manner before the Fire .
I. SIR , London , Mar. 28 .
1745 .
A BOUT four Years ago , Mr. Charles Orme , of Ashby de la Zouch in Leicestershire , acquainted me , That , in drying his glass Tubes for his diagonal Barometers ( which for some Years he has continued to make in much greater Perfection than any other Person that I know of in England* ) , he had observed a rotatory Motion about their Axes , and at the same time a progressive one towards the Fire .
He was so obliging then as to promise at any time to show me the Experiment ; but other Business intervening , I still deferred accepting his Officer ; having the less Curiosity to see it , as I imagined the Motions were occasioned by the Draught of Air up the Chimney , assisted by the Weight of the inclining Tube .
But a little above a Year ago , making some Stay at Ashby , upon repeating his Offer , I went to see the Experiment , which answered fully to his Description : The Tubes , which were about four Feet long , and half an Inch over , moving at six or eight Inches Distance from the Fire , not only progressively , and about their Axes along the SideWall they leaned against , but along the Front .
Wall Xx of Read on March 28 .
and April 4 .
1745 .
One of which Mr. Wheler made a Present of to the Royal Society of the Chimney , which made an obtuse Angle with the other ; so that they seemed to move up hill , and against their Weight .
Surprised at this , I thought the Case deserved a little farther Examination ; and proposed placing two Tubes horizontally , parallel to each other , and at right Angles to the Face of the Fire , to be Supporters to a third , which was to be placed upon them parallel to the Fire .
We did so , and with Pleasure observed the supported Tube turn about its Axis , and move on towards the Fire in such a manner , as made me still less inclined to think either of the Motions owing to the Draught of the Fire , and certainly not to the whole Weight of the moving Tube ; a fine Spirit-Level informing us , that the supporting Tubes leaned from the Fire ; so that the Motion was a little up-hill .
This Success determined me , with Mr. Orme 's Leave , to go on farther ; and , furnishing myself , from him , with Tubes of several Lengths and Thicknesses , I made several Trials ; and found , that with a moderate Fire the Experiment succeeded best , when the supported Tube was about twenty or two-and-twenty Inches long , the Diameter about one Tenth of an Inch , and had in each End a pretty strong Pin , fixed in Cork , for an Axe to roll with upon the supporting Tubes ; which , to lessen the Contact , had nearly the same Diameter with the moving one .
Under these Circumstances the Tube would begin to move at eighteen Inches Distance from the Fire ; and continue to do so , with little Intervals , till it touched the Bars ; and moved much in the same manner , when a little Ball of Cork , an Inch or more in Diameter , meter , was fixed in the Middle of it .
But what surprised me still more , and seemed to take off the Objection of the Draught of the Chimney , was , letting it once stay a little while against the Bars , I found it still continue its Motion about its Axis in the same Direction .
This put me upon making little Rings of Wire , to fix upon and move along the supporting Tubes , so as to stop the moving Tube at any Distance from the Fire I pleased .
Stopped with these , the Motion of the Tube about its Axis still continued .
Desirous to try what would be the Effect in or near an upright Posture , I made the Pin at one End of my Tube rest upon a China Plate , that at the other Turn in a silver Socket ( that carried my Pencil ) fixed in an horizontal Arm of Wood , but so as I could slip it up and down , to adapt it to the Length of of the Tube .
Here I found , that if the Tube leaned to my Right hand , ( which was the Case of Mr. Orme 's Tubes before his Fire ) the Motion was from East to West ; but if they leaned to my Left , the Motion was from West to East ; and the nearer I could get to the perfectly upright Posture , the less the Motion seemed to be either Way .
I now proceeded to place my Tube horizontally upon a glass Plane ( a large Fragment of a Coach-side Window Glass ) .
The Tube , instead of moving towards the Fire , moved from it , and about its Axis , in a contrary Direction to what it had done before , Observing that this glass Plane was broader at one End than the other , and that the Rotation backwards was more sensible when the narrower End was towards the Fire , I placed a triangular Piece of the same Glass with its Vertex towards the Fire nearly horizontal , but rather rising from the Fire ; so that its Base was a little higher than its Vertex ; and upon it a Tube of Glass , about 22 Inches long , and 1/ 8 of an Inch Diameter , near the Vertex and the Fire .
This Tube receded from the Fire , moving about its Axis till it came to the Distance of eight Inches ; which is four Inches more than it receded the Day before upon the same Piece of Coach-Glass , before it was broke into this triangular Form .
I was naturally led now to make use of two supporting Tubes , instead of the triangular glass Plane .
These were about eighteen Inches long each , and 1/ 10 of an Inch in Diameter , and placed parallel to one another at the Distance of about two Inches , so as to support the moving Tube near the Middle of it .
When very nearly horizontal by the Level , the supported Tube moved from the Fire about its Axis to the Distance of thirteen Inches : When the Supporters were a little raised at their remote Ends , so as manifestly by the Level to descend towards the Fire , it receded to the Distance of ten Inches , moving as before about its Axis ; but in this latter Case the Fire had declined a good deal ; otherwise , probably , the Tube would have receded farther , tho ' up-hill .
The next Day , the same Tube , when the same supporting Tubes were 8 1/ 2 Inches distant from each other , receded nearly as before : When 121/ 2 Inches from each other , it stood still ; and when removed to the Distance of 161/ 2 Inches , the supported Tube very manifestly changed its Motion , and went towards the Fire ; as it did afterwards , when the Inclination of the supporting Tubes was altered , so as to ascend towards the Fire .
I made several other Experiments , with regard to the Situation of the Tubes to the Fire , with regard to the Quantity of Fire suffered to come at the Tubes , and with regard to Attraction and Repulsion , which I will not trouble you with at present : Only observe , that , when the Tube had four others under it , all supporting , one near each Extremity , and one on each Side of its Centre , no Motion at all was perceived ; and when two of them on the same Side of the Centre were taken away , the supported Tube moved into an oblique Situation with regard to the Fire , the unsupported Half receding from the Fire .
Upon the Whole , it appears sufficiently plain , that the Stream of Air up the Chimney is not the Cause of the Rotation : Another may be assigned , simple and easy ; but as I have already said too much , it will be better to make it the Subject of another Paper .
I am , SIR , Your most Obedient Humble Servant , Granville Wheler .
II .
SIR , IN the last Paper I had the Honour of communicating to you , I endeavoured to make it appear , that the rotatory Motion of glass Tubes about their Axes , before a Fire , was not owing to the Draught of the Chimney .
In this , I beg Leave first to mention an Experiment or two , to show that the Motion is not owing to any Attraction or Repulsion in the Tubes ; and then give the Solution I proposed in my last , but deferred laying before you , because my Paper was already carried to too great a Length .
I suspended two Fragments of small Tubes , 8 Inches long , and about 1/ 10 of an Inch in Diameter , near the Fire , from two Pins , by blue Silk Lines , which had each a Loop at one End , were tied at the other to the Top of the Tubes , and hindered from slipping off by a little Sealing wax .
The Tubes came together at the upper End , and receded manifestly from each other at the lower , appearing to be in a State of Attraction above , and a State of Repulsion below : But , suspecting this to be owing to the Sealing wax , which soon began to melt , I scraped it off both , leaving only as little as was possible , to hinder the Silks from slipping .
The Consequence then was , they came together at the lower Ends , and very near so at the upper ; and , when suspended from one Pin , so that the Loops of the Silks touched each other , the Tubes seemed equally close all the Way down , without any Appearance either of Attraction or Repulsion .
But , imagining still ~that a repulsive Power in the heated supporting Tubes , when placed near together , might possibly be the Occasion of the receding of the upper Tube at Contract with them .
To put the Matter out of all Doubt , I wet the three Tubes all over ; yet the regressive and rotatory Motion was still manifest , with very little , if any Difference ; not more than might be well accounted for , from the Increase of Resistance by Wetting .
These two Experiments fully convinced me , that neither Attraction nor Repulsion would be of any Assistance in solving our Rotation .
Upon considering therefore the Matter farther , I found nothing was wanting , but that the moving Tube should swell towards the Fire ; and indeed I thought I could perceive such a Swelling in Mr. Orme 's long Tube of four Feet and an half , which I saw first placed near a good Fire in the Manner described in my last .
For , allowing such a Swelling , Gravity must pull the Tube down , when supported near its Extremities horizontally ; and a fresh Part being exposed to the Fire , and swelling out again , must fall down again , and so on successively ; which is , in other Words , a rotatory Motion towards the Fire .
When the supporting Tubes are brought near to each other , as well as near to the Centre of the supported Tube , then the Parts hanging over on each Side , being larger than~ the Part which lies between the Supporters , will , by their Weight , pull downwards , and consequently force the middle Part , resting upon its two Fulcra , upwards ; and being less advanced towards the Fire , as being less heated , will , by their oblique Situation , pull the middle Part backward also from the Fire : Which Effects , being successive , cessive , will exhibit a rotatory regressive Motion , quite contrary to what the Tube had when supported near its Extremities : And when a single Tube lies inclining opposite to the Fire , either to the Righthand or the Left , out of a Plane perpendicular to the Surface of the Fire , Gravity will not permit the curved Part to rest , but pull it down till it co incides with a Plane perpendicular to the Horizon ; and , consequently , as new Curves are generated , new Motions will be so too ; that is , the Tube will be made to move about its Axis ; but with this Difference , when the Tube inclines to the Right hand , the Motion about the Axis will be from East to West ; when to the Left-hand , from West to East .
The Justness of this Reasoning is made manifest with a very little Trouble ; only bending a Wire , and supporting it first near its Extremities , then near its Centre on each Side , afterwards inclining it to the Right , and then to the Left ; the Bending in every Case representing the curved Part of the Tube next the Fire .
And that this Solution is the true one , seems farther probable from hence , that when four Supporters were made use of , one at each Extremity , and two near the Middle , there was no Motion at all either backward and forward : Nor is it of any Service to object here , that the Increase of Contact hinders the Motion ; because , upon the Plane of Glass , mentioned in my former Paper , so large as to have a much greater Contact with the Tube , both a rotatory and regressive Motion was manifest .
I am , worthy Sir , with a high Regard , Your most obedient humble Servant , London , April 4 .
1745 .
Granv .
Wheler .

