XV .
An Observation of a Fracture of the Os Humeri by the Power of the Muscles only ; by the late Claudius Amyand , Esq ; Serjeant Surgeon to His Majesty .
THE outward Causes of Fractures not being sufficient to break or tear asunder the broken Pieces of a fractured Knee-pan , in Read March 7 .
in the Manner we see them in the Fracture of that Bone , the Cause of it hath justly been ascribed to the Power and Action of the Muscles upon it in a morbid State of that Bone , which disposing it to a Fracture when that Power is strongly applied , and affecting both Knee-pans in a like manner , soon brings about a Fracture also of the opposite Bone , then appearing as thoroughly sound as the fractured Part before was thought to have been .
Many Instances might be given of the Fracture of the Patella in Persons thoroughly sound , where the Part itself had received no Hurt whatever : Which seems to imply , that the Cause of it was to be ascribed to the Muscles only ; and the rather , that many Instances may be given of the Fracture in the Neck of the Os Femoris , in the Middle of the Humerus , Tibia , and Perone , by the Power of the Muscles only , or such Power of them as sufficiently showed they have as great a Share in several Fractures ascribed to outward Causes , as they are frequently known to have in the Fracture of the Tendo Achillis .
However , as the Fractures occasioned by the Action of the Muscles are cured by the same Remedies as are effectually applied to the Cure of others from outward Causes , they deserve no further Notice .
I shall give some Instances of such in which the Bones themselves are morbid .
Upon the 15th Day of July 1738 .
I was sent for to a middle-aged Gentlewoman in my Neighbourhood , of a seemingly strong Constitution , rather fat than lean , who had broke her Right Arm in the Middle , while with her two Hands she was endeavouring to bring together the Ends of a Piece of Tape .
The Standers-by heard the Bone snap , and were the more astonished at the Cause , as the Patient was sitting distant from any thing that could strike her Arm , or contribute to the Breaking of it .
The Grating of the Ends of the Bone against each other , when the Arm was moved , the Loss of its Action , and all the common Attendants of a Fracture , were sufficient convincing Proofs of it .
It was reduced with Ease , and dressed as usual ; but , I own , I doubted of the Cure , till Mr. Shipton , who was consulted thereon , assured me , that he was Witness to several Fractures of this kind , where the Patient had done well .
We agreed , that the Bone must have been distempered , and likely with a Cariosity ; it appearing otherwise hardly credible , that the Bone could have been broke from so slight a Cause as this .
I have known two Patients die after a Fracture of the Os Femoris from the like ; the first snapping in the middle as he was getting into Bed , in whom all the Centre of the Bones was carious ; and the latter getting out of it , wherein only a small Part was so , and above two Thirds of the Circumference in every respect appeared sound .
For two Years last past my Patient , had been attended by Mr. Shipton , on account of several scorbutic Complaints , which I thought proceeded from some Venereal Taint ; but the Patient vowed , and hath all along assured us , she never had known Man .
Two Years before this Accident happened , I had attended this Patient jointly with the late Mr. Fiquel , on account of a Spina ventosa in the Centre of the Os Bregmatis on the right Side ; which being laid bare , the Caries was found to have peneP p trated trated the two Tables thereof , and all that time she had a gummatous Swelling upon the upper Head of the Radius on the right Arm , checking the Motion of this Bone in Pronation and Supination , both which she then mentioned to have appeared , upon the Retreat or Disappearance of broad yellow Spots ( not scarfy , nor in any wise resembling those in the Lues venerea ) her whole Body had been bespecked with for some Years last past ; she having all her Life been addicted to the Scurvy , and never been in the Way of getting a bad Distemper ; neither were the Pains she complained of so vexatious to her during the Night as the Day .
Upon Mr. Fiquel 's Death , for two Years last past , she had , by Mr. Shipton 's Advice , taken the most powerful Antiscorbutics ; notwithstanding which , the forementioned Humour on the upper Head of the Radius was much increased , and a new one of the same kind , for some Months last past , had appeared on the Head of the Shoulder-Bone , and another on the Middle of the Bone where the Fracture now was .
She likewise reported , that she hardly was cured of the Caries I had attended her for on the Os Bregmatis , but another Tumour had appeared on the Skirts of the Os Frontis ; which breaking of itself , the Bone therehad been found carious , whence she had had a Running ever since ; and that of late had appeared two puffy Swellings over the left Brow , of the like Nature with those that had broke before , and therefore feared the Bone there would also prove bad ; and that there was also a hard Swelling , attended with Pain , springing up upon the Head of the Radius on the left Arm .
As all the Remedies hitherto used had proved ineffectual , Mr. Shipton and I concluded , that a Mercurial Salivation was the most likely to conquer a Humour daily laying hold of new Bones ; but we thought it improper to put the Patient into it , whilst we stood in need of a Callus for the Knitting of the broken Bone , The Cure of it has been completed in about six Weeks , and the Patient has ever since had the full Use of it .
At this time we had an aedematous Phlegmon over the left Brow , with a Fluid undulating there in two Places ; and , by way of Addition to the former Complaints , a Node also was springing up with Pain on the Head of the Radius upon the left Arm , attended with an aedematous Swelling .
In this Condition she was put into a Salivation by Unction .
This Salivation , copious as it was , was kept up a whole Month : In the first Fortnight of it , the Matter , gathered in the aedematous Phlegmons over the Brow , entirely disappeared , and then the Oedema and Tumour in the Bone upon the Fore-Arms where the Nodes were ; and these being nearly dissolved in the last Fortnight , we were in Hopes the Cure had been brought about without opening the Tumours over the Brow , where Matter had been felt , and the Bone was thought carious : But our Joy was not lasting , many of the Complaints re-appearing in a short time after , notwithstanding we took the utmost Care to confirm the Cure by Salivation , by a subsequent Course of Antiscorbutics , the Decoction of the Woods , &amp; c. For as , upon the Retreat or Disappearance of the yellow Spots in the Skin , firstmentioned , the Distemper in the Skull had begun , and the Nutriment of the Bones in general had thereupon been vitiated , as appeared by the gummatous Tumours , and Nodus 's on the Bones , the Spinae ventosae in the Skull , and the Extravasations of Matter , denoted by the aedematous Phlegmons upon the Brow and Radius ; so it appeared no less evident , that the Retreat of these , and the Reflux of the Matter into the Blood , had contaminated it again , being the forementioned Symptoms , and worst , re-appeared within less than three Months after : They had disappeared very fast , as the Vessels were emptied during the Salivation , but they re-appear 'd again faster upon the Filling .
During the Salivation , or soon after , the Cariosities in the Skull , that had been laid bare , having been exfoliated , were cured ; the Nodus 's upon the Shoulder-Bone , and Radius on the Arm that had been broke , had vanished away ; and , what was thought no less remarkable , the Matter extravasated upon the right Side of the Os Frontis over the Brow , where the aedematous Phlegmon had appeared and disappeared at times , were entirely dispersed ; and these , saving the Tumour on the Radius of the left Arm , never appeared again .
The Renewal of the Distemper showed itself upon the Bones that had been laid bare , by a new Cariosity spreading very fast in the Neighbourhood .
At this time an inflammatory Oedema , that had appeared upon the Os Frontis over the right Brow ( very distant from that Collection that had been made on the left before the Salivation , which had been dispersed , and now continued well ) suppurating , was opened , and the Matter found to spring from the frontal Sinus 's on this Side thro ' the Bone that was carious .
And as the Tumour that had lately appeared upon the Radius of the left Arm , and stood out the Salivation , was now increasing with Pain , with an aedematous Phlegmou upon the Arm where the Tumour was ; it was agreed to put her forthwith into a second Salivation no less copious than the first , but of a longer Continuance ; to denude , first , all the frontal and parietal Bones on the right Side , that were carious , but to leave untouched those on the left Side ; which , before the first Salivation , had been suspected of being a Spina ventosa , but now appeared sound .
The Patient entered into this Salivation about the latter End of May 1739 , after she had been duly prepared to it .
This was continued ten Weeks , because of the frequent Interruption we had met with by the Returns of a Diarrhea , as oft as she was anointed , and the profuse Sweats during the DogDays .
In this , as in the former Salivation , all the Accidents gave Way during the Course .
The Progress of the Cariosity in the Bones of the Skull was stopped , and the Exfoliation being made , the Wound was cured afterwards .
She was put into a Milk Course , and sent into the Country for the Recovery of her Flesh ; and after that into a subsequent one of a Decoction of the Woods , &amp; c. but the Advantage she had reaped by these did not continue long .
In the Autumn , she was frequently traversed by irregular Shiverings and Rigors , upon the Re-appearance of the phlegmonous Oedema about the Node still subsisting on the left Arm ; which now again grew larger with Pain in it , still increasing in proportion as the Vessels emptied in the Salivation were replenished .
The aedematous Swelling about the Tumour was also more phlegmonous , and Matter was forming there on the Bone , which , it was apprehended , was a Spina ventosa : I therefore insisted upon the Laying of that open : But , whilst she was preparing for her Removal to Town , this Tumour entirely disappeared upon the Appearance of a Diarrhea , that sunk her too fast to admit either of her Removal , or any Operation .
This followed her to her Death .
During the two last Days of her Life , she was in a constant Delirium , and universal Convulsions .
The Patient dying thus in the Country the 25th of September last , I was not acquainted with these latter Accidents till after her Burial ; and therefore missed the Opportunity of dissecting the Body , which perhaps might have given some additional Light to this Case : But , from so much as has been reported of it , I think it may be inferred , 1 .
That if a scorbutic Humour occasioned the Complaints in this Case , as there is Reason to believe it did , from the Veracity and Character of the Patient ; and those Symptoms being wanted that usually appear in the Lues Venerea ; yet it must be confessed the Affection in the Bones yielding to a Mercurial Salivation , as these did , and the Return of Complaints upon the Reflux of the Matter extravasated , contaminating and tainting the Blood with a new Ferment , or the same as before the Flux , may ground a strong Suspicion , that those in our Patient proceeded from some Venereal Taint .
2 .
That a Siccity or Brittleness in the Bones , inclining them to a Fracture , may happen , independent from a Caries in the Bone : For , had the Os Humeri of our Patient been carious , at the time the Fracture happened from so slight a Cause as attended the Endeavour of bringing and joining together the opposite Ends of a String held in the two Hands , it was morally impossible the complete Cure of such a Fracture could be brought about within six Weeks .
Whence it appears , that the occasional Siccity of a Bone may be no Bar to the Flowing of that Quantity of Sap or callous Matter necessary to operate the Cure after a Fracture .
3 .
That the Muscles must have a great Share , as well in the Fracture of all Bones , as in the Dislocations of them ; as in this Case the Os Humeri was broke by the Power and Action of the Muscles only ; and therefore that the keeping of them quiet , by placing the broken Limb in the most natural and easy Posture , must be highly instrumental to the Cure .
4 .
That the Absortion , or Reflux into the Blood of a purulent Sanies , inflating the Part where it is lodged under the Appearance of an aedematous Phlegmon , or phlegmonous Oedema , is as dangerous as the Absorption by the Blood-vessels of a purulent Matter extravasated .
So that the Reflux in either Case will again taint the Blood with the Corruption that had critically been flung out of the Course of the Circulation ; and that , when this happens , there will be Cause to fear a Renewal of the Complaints , and , possibly , worse Symptoms ; as has happened in the present Case .
5.That yet there appears a wide Difference betwixt a Phlegmon aedematous and an aedematous Phlegmon ; inasmuch as , in the first , the Oedema goes off as the Phlegmon comes to a Crisis ; whereas , in the latter , that seldom comes to a Crisis , but changes , and appears and disappears continually .
When the Matter of a Phlegmon prevails , the Tumour may be resolved , without any Inconveniency to the Patient , if it is not critically determined upon the Crisis of a Fever ; and when it is , the Depuration being complete , he fares the better for it : Whereas , in the aedematous Phlegmon , wherein the Serum prevails , the Tumour beginning with an Oedema , neither the Tumour , nor the Inflammation of it , are permanent ; but appearing and disappearing , as the sanious Matter is thrown out of the Blood , or refluxes back into it .
The sanious Matter of it is apt to contaminate the whole Mass , as oft as the Tumour disappears ; and therefore it is evident , that , in this latter Case , that is in the Oedema phlegmonous , we are to give a Vent to the Matter lodged in the Parts as soon as may be , and even before the Matter is concocted , or fully collected , as in critical Abscesses ; viz. so soon as some irregular Shiverings , and such other Symptoms , have denoted the Extravasation of the Matter in the Membrana cellularis , wherein the Humour first makes its Appearance .
For that when in an Oedema phlegmonous , or aedematous Phlegmon , the Matter changes , at times , with more , and at others with less Inflammation ; the Tumour increasing and diminishing alternately , as the Matter becomes more or less sanious and purulent , and refluxes into the Blood at times : We may then fear some Lodgement of it will be made upon some some of the Viscera , if that again is not critically thrown out : And if it remains in the Mass , that , in the Course of the Circulation , it will occasion such Symptoms as here have happened to our Patient , during the Course of the Distemper , even to her last , as oft as that has happened ; and that in so plain a manner , as to make it evident , that the Renewal of the Symptoms was consequential upon the Reflux of a purulent Sanies back again into the Blood from the Part wherein it had been lodged : And thus it appeared , that as this Reflux of Matter was principally made during the Salivation , when the Vessels emptied could best attract it ; so it was expedient the Discharge of it had been made before that was entered upon .
5 .
The Return of the Complaints from this Cause was very obvious at last , but not so at first : And should not this make us tender and circumspect , when we pass a Judgment upon the Conduct of others ?
That the Matter should so shift its Lodgments after every Salivation , is no less remarkable than that it should rather fix on new Parts , than those which had been affected before ; and that the Cause of it , virulent as it was from the first , and attacking the Juices flowing in the Bones in so particular a Manner , should have been no Check to the complete Cure of the fore-mentioned Fracture in the usual Time .
It were to be wished Men of Experience were more ready in showing the Errors , Failings , and Slips in their Practice than their Successes : That might be of great Service to the Public , and those Warnings prove of singular Benefit to those who have not had the like Opportunities ; it being more eligible to be informed by the Failings and Misfortunes of other

