A letter from Mr. Abraham De Moivre , F. R. S. to William Jones , Esquire , F. R. S. concerning the easiest method for calculating the value of annuities upon lives , from tables of observations .
SIR , YOU may remember , that some time after the printing of the second edition of my book of annuities on lives , you told me , that it seemed strange to you , that , considering I had demonstrated the chief propositions in the book , I had neglected to demonstrate the theorem , which is found in page 86 .
line 12 .
which , you said , of all the rest , appeared to you the most curious ; I answered , that , as the demonstration depended upon a principle which was not commonly I known Presented June 7 .
known , I was afraid that the publishing of it would have swelled the book too much ; for this reason especially , that many corollaries were annexed to it .
However , I promised to send it you in a short time ; but desired you to let me know , whether you thought it deserved a place in the Philosophical Transactions .
I now discharge my promise ; and expect , with impatience , the favour of your opinion .
I am , with a very particular regard , SIR , Your most humble , and most obedient Servant , A. De Moivre .
A short method of calculating the value of annuities on lives , from tables of observations .
ALTHO ' it has been an established custom , in the payment of annuities on lives , that the last rent is lost to the heirs of the late possessor of an annuity , if the person happens to die before the expiration of the term agreed on for payment , whether yearly , half-yearly , or quarterly : nevertheless , in this treatise I have supposed , that such a part of the rent should be paid to the heirs of the late possessor , as may be exactly proportioned to the time elapsed between that of the last payment , and the very moment of the life 's expiring ; and this by ~ proper , accurate , and geometrical calculation .
I have been induced to take this method , for the following reasons ; first , by this supposition , the value of lives would receive but an inconsiderable increase ; secondly , by this means , the several intervals of life , which , in the tables of observations , are found to have uniform decrements , may be the better connected together .
It is with this view that I have framed the two following problems , with their solutions .
PROBLEM I. To find the value of an annuity , so circumstantiated , that it shall be on a life of a given age ; and that , upon the failing of that life , such a part of the rent shall be paid to the heirs of the late possessor of an annuity , as may be exactly proportioned to the time intercepted between that of the last payment , and the very moment of the life 's failing .
SOLUTIO N. LETn represent the complement of life , that is , the interval of time between the given age , and the extremity of old-age , supposed at 86 .
r the amount of 1l .
for one year .
~ the logarithm of r. P the present value of an annuity of 1 l. for the given time .
Q the value of the life sought .
Then 1/ r-1 P/ ~n = Q. DEMONSTRATIO N. For , let z represent any indeterminate portion of n. Now the probability of the life 's attaining the end of the interval z , and then failing , is to be expressed by z~/ n , ( as shown in page 77 , edit .
1 .
and in page 115 , edit .
2 .
of my book of annuities upon lives ) upon the supposition of a perpetual and uniform decrement of life .
But it is well known , that if an annuity certain , of 1l .
be paid during the time z , its present value will be P= 1-r1/ 2/ r-1 or 1/ r-1 1/ r-1xr2 .
And , by the laws of the doctrine of chances , the expectation of such a life , upon the precise interval z , will be expressed by z/ nxr-1 z/ nr2xr-1 ; which may be taken for the ordinate of a curve , whose area is as the value of the life required .
In order to find the area of this curve , let p=nxr-1 ; and then the ordinate will become z/ p z/ pr2 , a much more commodious expression .
Now it is plain , that the fluent of the first part is z/ p : but as the fluent of the second part is not so readily discovered , it will not be improper , in this place , to show by what artifice I found it ; for I do not know , whether the same method has been made use of by others : all that I can say , is , that I never had occasion for it , but in the particular circumstance of this problem .
Let , therefore , r2=x ; hence z log.r=log.x ; therefore z log.r = ( fluxion of the log.x= ) x/ x , or ~z = x/ x ; consequently z= x/ ~x , and z/ r2 = x/ ~xx : but the fluent of x/ ~xx is ( 1/ ~x = ) 1/ ~r2 ; and therefore the fluent of z/ pr2 will be + 1/ p~r2 .
The sum of the two fluents will be z/ p + 1/ p~r2 ; but , when z= o , the whole fluent should be = o ; let therefore the whole fluent be z/ p + 1/ p~r2 +q= o. Now , when z= o , then z/ p = o , and 1/ ~pr2 becomes 1/ ~p ( for r2=1 , ) consequently 1/ ~p +q= o ; and q= 1/ ~p : therefore the area of a curve , whose ordinate is z/ p z/ pr2 will be ( z/ p 1/ ~p + 1/ ~pr2 = ) z/ p 1 1/ r2 x 1/ ~p .
But P= 1/ r-1 1/ r-1xr2 ; therefore 1 1/ r2 = r-1 x P , and the expression for the area becomes z/ nxr-1 P/ ~n : And putting n instead of z , that area , or the value of the life , will be expressed by 1/ r-1 P/ ~n Q. E. D. Those who are well versed in the nature of logarithms , I mean those that can deduce them from the doctrine of fluxions and infinite series , will easily apprehend , that the quantity here called ~ , is that which some call the hyperbolic logarithm ; others , the natural logarithm : it is what Mr. Cotes calls , the logarithm whose modulus is 1 : lastly , it is by some called Neper 's logarithm .
And , to save the reader some trouble in the practice of this last theorem , the most necessary natural logarithms , to be made use of in the present disquisition about lives , are the following : If r= 1 .
04 , then will ~= 0.0392207 .
r= 1 .
05 , ~= 0.0487901 .
r= 1 .
06 , ~= 0.0582589 .
It is to be observed , that the theorem here found , makes the values of lives a little bigger , than what the theorem found in the first problem of my book of annuities on lives , does ; for , in the present case , there is one payment more to be made , than in the other ; however , the difference is very inconsiderable .
But , altho ' it be indifferent which of them is used , on the supposition of an equal decrement of life to the extremity of old-age ; yet , if it ever happens , that we should have tables of observations , concerning the mortality of mankind , entirely to be depended upon , then it would be convenient to divide the whole interval of life into such smaller intervals , as , during which , the decrements of life have been observed to be uniform , notwithstanding the decrements in some of those intervals should be quicker , or slower , than others ; for then the theorem here found would be preferable to the other ; as will be shown hereafter .
That there are such intervals , Dr. Halley 's tables of observations sufficiently show ; for instance ; out of 302 persons of 54 years of age , there remain , after 16 years ( that is , of the age of 70 ) but 142 ; the decrements from year to year having been constantly 10 ; and the same thing happens in other intervals ; and it is to be presumed , that the like would happen in any other good tables of observations .
But , in order to show , in some measure , the use of the preceding theorem , it is necessary to add another problem ; which , tho ' its solution is to be met with in the first edition of my book of annuities on lives , yet it is convenient to have it inserted here , on account of the connexion that the application of the preceding problem has with it .
In the mean time , it will be proper to know , What part of the yearly rent should be paid to the heirs of the late possessor of an annuity , as may be exactly proportioned to the time elapsed between that of the last payment , and the very moment of the life 's expiring .
To determine this , put A for the yearly rent ; 1/ m for the part of the year intercepted between the time of the last payment , and the instant of the life 's failing ; r the amount of 1 l. at the year 's end : then will r1/ m-1/ r-1 A , be the sum to be paid .
PROBLEM II .
To find the value of an annuity for a limited interval of life , during which the decrements of life may be considered as equal .
SOLUTIO N. LETa and b represent the number of people living in the beginning and end of the given interval of years .
s represent that interval .
P the value of an annuity certain for that interval .
Q the value of an annuity for a life supposed to be necessarily extinct in the time s ; or ( which is the same thing ) the value of an annuity for a life , of which the complement is s. Then Q+b/ a x P-q will express the value required .
DEMONSTRATIO N. For , let the whole interval between a and b be filled up with arithmetical mean proportionals ; therefore the number of people living in the beginning and end of each year of the given interval s will be represented by the following series ; viz. a.sa-a+b/ s. sa-2a+2b/ s. sa-3a+3b/ s. sa-4a+4b/ s. &amp;c. to b. Consequently , the probabilities of the life 's continuing during 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , &amp;c. years will be expressed by the series , sa-a+b/ sa .
sa-2a+2b/ sa .
sa-3a+3b/ sa .
sa-4a+4b/ sa .
&amp;c. to b/ a. Wherefore , the value of an annuity of 1 l. granted for the time s , will be expressed by the series sa-a+b/ sar + sa-2a+2b/ sar2 + sa-3a+3b/ sar3 + sa-4a+4b/ sar4 , &amp;c. to + 5/ ar5 ; this series is divisible into two other series 's , viz. 1st .
s-1/ sr + s-2/ sr2 + s-3/ sr3 + s-4/ sr4 , &amp;c. to + s-s/ sr5./ 2d .
b/ a x 1/ sr + 2/ sr2 + 3/ sr3 + 4/ sr4 , &amp;c. to s/ sr5 .
Now , since the first of these series 's begins with a term whose numerator is s-1 , and the subsequent numerators each decrease by unity ; it follows , that the last term will be = o ; and , consequently , that series expresses the value of a life necessarily to be extinct in the time s. The sum of this series may be esteemed as a given quantity ; and is what I have expressed by the symbol Q in problem 1 .
The second series is the difference between the two following series 's , b/ a x 1/ r + 1/ r2 + 1/ r3 + 1/ r4 + &amp;c. to 1/ r5./ b/ a x s-1/ sr + s-2/ sr2 + s-3/ sr3 + s-4/ sr4 &amp;c. to + s-s/ sr5 .
Where , neglecting the common multiplier b/ a~ the first series is the value of an annuity certain to continue s years ; which every mathematician knows how to calculate , or is had from tables already composed for that purpose : this value is what I have called P ; and the second series is Q. Therefore Q+b/ a x P-q will be the value of an annuity on a life for the limited time .
Q. E. D. It is obvious , that the series denoted by Q , must of necessity have one term less than is the number of equal intervals contained in s ; and therefore , if the whole extent of life , beginning from an age given , be divided into several intervals , each having its own particular uniform decrements , there will be , in each of these intervals , the defect of one payment ; which to remedy , the series Q must be calculated by problem 1 .
EXAMPL E. To find the value of an annuity for an age of 54 , to continue 16 years , and no longer .
IT is found , in Dr. Halley 's tables of observations , that a is 302 , and b 172 : now n=s=16 ; and , by the tables of the values of annuities certain , P=10.8377 ; also ( by problem 1 .
) Q=(1/ r-1-P/ ~n= ) 6.1168 .
Hence it follows ( by this problem ) , that the value of an annuity for an age of 54 , to continue during the limited time of 16 years , supposeing interest at 5 per cent. per annum , will be worth ( Q+b/ a x P-q= ) 8.3365 years purchase .
From Dr. Halley 's tables of observations , we find , that from the age of 49 to 54 inclusive , the number of persons , existing at those several ages , are , 357 , 346 , 335 , 324 , 313 , 302 , which comprehends a space of five years ; and , following the precepts before laid down , we shall find , that an annuity for a life of 49 , to continue for the limited time of 5 years , interest being at 5 per cent. per annum , is worth 4.0374 years purchase .
And , in the same manner , we shall find , that the value of an annuity on life , for the limited time comprehended between the ages of 42 and 49 , is worth 5.3492 years purchase .
Now , if it were required to determine the value of an annuity on life , to continue from the age of 42 to 70 , we must proceed thus : It has been proved , that an annuity on life , reaching from the age of 54 to 70 , is worth 8.3365 years purchase ; but this value , being estimated from the age of 49 , ought to be diminished on two accounts : First , because of the probability of the life 's reaching from 49 to 54 , which probability is to be deduced from the table of observations , and is proportional to the number of people living at the end and beginning of that interval , which , in this case , will be found 302 and 357 : The second diminution proceeds from a discount that ought to be made , because the annuity , which reaches from 54 to 70 , is estimated 5 years sooner , viz. from the age of 49 , and therefore that diminution ought to be expressed by 1/ r5 ; so that the total diminution of the annuity of 16 years will be expressed by the fraction 302/ 357r5 , which will reduce it from 8.3365 years purchase to 5.5259 ; this being added to the value of the annuity to continue from 49 to 54 , viz. 4.0374 , will give 9.5633 , the value of an annuity to continue from the age of 49 to 70 .
For the same reason , the value 9.5633 , estimated from the age of 42 , ought to be reduced , both upon account of the probability of living from 42 to 49 , and of the discount of money for 7 years , at 5 per cent. per annum , amounting together to 3.8554 , which will bring it down to 5.7079 ; to this adding the value of an annuity on a life to continue from the age of 42 to 49 , found before to be 5.3492 , the sum will be 11.0571 years purchase , the value of an annuity to continue from the age of 42 to 70 .
In the same manner , for the last 16 years of life , reaching from 70 to 86 , when properly discounted , and also diminished upon the account of the probability of living from 42 to 70 , the value of those last 16 years will be reduced to 0.8 ; this being added to 11.0571 ( the value of an annuity to continue from the age of 42 to 70 , found before ) , the sum will be 11.8571 years purchase , the value of an annuity to continue from the age of 42 to 86 ; that is , the value of an annuity on a life of 42 ; which , in my tables , is but 11.57 , upon the supposition of an uniform decrement of life , from an age given to the extremity of old age , supposed at 86 .
It is to be observed , that the two diminutions , above mentioned , are conformable to what I have said in the corollary to the second problem of the first edition , printed in the year 1724 .
Those who have sufficient leisure and skill to calculate the value of joint lives , whether taken two and two , or three and three , in the same manner as I have done the first problem of this tract , will be greatly assisted by means of the two following theorems : If the ordinate of a curve be z/ rz ; its area will be 1/ a2 1/ a2r2 z/ arz .
If the ordinate of a curve be z2/ rz ; its area will be 2/ a~ 2/ a~rz 2z/ a2rz z2/ arz .
I beg leave , in this place , to take notice , that in the theorem in line 12 .
page 63 .
of the second edition of my book of annuities on lives , instead of P , it ought to be p/ n P ; where n and p represent the complements of the age , in the beginning and end of a given interval of time .
And I desire the reader of that edition to adapt the fourth article of the rule put in words at length , in page 64 , to the theorem so corrected : then the solution there given , and that in page 21 .
of the first edition , will perfectly agree ; provided that the decrements of life be supposed , in both cases , uniform , from an age given , to the extremity of oldage .
I must also take notice of an accidental error , that has crept into the 25th proposition of the second edition ; which I chuse to correct as follows ; 1 .
Let the first line of the proposition , and part of the second line , as far as A exclusive , be erased .
2 .
Let the solution proceed thus : since the life of A is supposed to be worth 14 years purchase , when interest is at 4 per cent. per annum , it follows , from our tables , that A must be 35 years of age ; therefore find , by the twenty-third proposition , the value of an annuity of a life for 35 to continue for a limited time of 31 years : let that value be subducted from the value of an annuity certain , to continue 31 years ; and the remainder will be the value of the reversion .

