VII .
A Letter from Mr. Wm. Watson , F.R.S. to the ROYAL SOCIETY ; containing further Remarks concerning Mushrooms : Occasioned by the Reverend Mr. Pickering 's F. R. S. Paper in the preceding Transact. p. 96 .
with Observations upon the poisonous Faculty of some Sorts of Fungi .
Gentlemen , I HOPE I shall have the Reverend Mr. Pickering 's Excuse , if I lay before you a few further Observations upon his Papers concerning Mushrooms .
Read May 31 .
1744 .
With regard to the Seeds of Mushrooms , although they were never shown to the ROYALSOCIETY before , the Fact was known to many Members thereof : for the industrious Micheli did not only raise Mushrooms from their Seeds , but has , in his Tables , shown the daily Progress from their first Point of Vegetation , even to their perfect State .
The Fungus porosus crassus magnus is not the Mushroom usually raised in England for the Table , as this Gentleman did imagine ; that Name being given by John Bauhin , in the third Volume of his History ( p. 833 .
) , to a Species which is to be distinguished from all other Fungus 's , by the inferior Substance not being divided into Lamellae , or ( what we call in England ) Gills ; but has , in lieu thereof , a great many Papillae ; and being of a greenish yellow Colour .
But what is raised in England ( of which this learned Gentleman brought several Samples to the SOCIETY ) is the Fungus campestris albus superne , inferne rubens , of John Bauhin , which differs toto caelo from the former , and which Dr. Dillenius enumerates among the Species of Boletus ; whereas the latter is a Species of Amanita .
I must beg Leave to differ from this Gentleman likewise , in regard to the Use of the Ring , which surrounds the Stalk of this Mushroom .
He imagines it placed there , by the wise Author of Nature , to break the Fall of the Seeds when ripe ; whereby those light Bodies may be preserved from the Fury of the Winds , in order to the abundant Propagation of their Species .
I have Reason to believe , that those Seeds , which fail upon this Ring , fall there by Accident ; and adhere there only from the Viscosity , whereby they are entangled .
But , before I examine this Matter , give me Leave to make a few Observations upon the Oeconomy of this Plant .
The Fungi , then , are of that Class of Vegetables , which are ranged , by that most skilful Botanist Linnaeus , under the Appellation of Cryptogamia , or those which perform their Fructification in secret .
Under this Head we find the Figtree , all the Species of Fern , Mosses , Mushrooms , and a few others , whose Flowering and Seeding are observed with more Difficulty , than in those we usually call the more perfect Plants .
In some of this Class , the Fructification , notwithstanding the great Assistance furnished to the modern Botanists by Microscopes , which the ancient were wholly destitute of , remains yet undiscovered .
This Plant then being of this Class , almost all those whose Stems are thick and fleshy , as well as their Umbels , have a Ring upon their Stem ; from which , when the Plant is young , and until it arrives at a flowering State , there arises a Membrane , which connects the Rim of the Umbel to the Stem , and preserves the under Part of the Plant in this State : But , when this is over , the Umbel , which before was almost of an hemispherical Figure , growing larger , and the Membrane not giving way , is loosened from the Rim of the Umbel , and adheres only to the Stem .
Soon after this State , the Seeds ripen , and the Umbel , losing its former Figure , commences almost a Plane ; and the Plant in this State is sold in our Markets , by the Name of Flaps .
Now , when the Umbel is of this Figure , the Seeds , being perfectly ripe , must fall naturally upon the whole Space the Umbel covers ( which Micheli observed , by placing Leaves of Trees under them ) ; and , upon the Ring , as well as any other Part ; though I have Reason to believe not more .
As for those Species of Fungi whose Stems are thin , and whose Umbels are soft , and more ductile , they need not , nor have they , this Ring or Membrane ; because , in their tender State , the Rims of their Umbels clap themselves quite close to the Stalk , in the Form of a contracted Umbrella ; and expand as the others do , when their Seeds are ripe : nevertheless the Species of this Tribe are as numerous as the former .
I now come to consider how far the Poison of Mushrooms can possibly proceed from Animalcules : But , first , give me Leave to doubt , whether or no any Person was ever injured from eating the common Mushroom , or Amanita ; unless such Accident may have proceeded either from eating too many at once , and thereby overloaded the Stomach ; or from some particular Dislike in the Constitution ; as we sometimes see , even with regard to Honey , Cheese , and some of the most innocent Parts of our Diet ; but which , notwithstanding this , are by no means to be ranked among Poisons .
If there were many Instances of their being pernicious , such must frequently occur to the Practitioners in Physic , on account of the vast Quantity annually consumed in London ; but I do n't remember to have even heard of any such Accident ; but many Instances occur of the noxious Quality of many of the other Species of this Tribe : Nor is it at all wonderful , that the different Subjects of this Class of Vegetables should differ in their Effects more than those of the more perfect Kind .
The Roots of Carrot , Parsnep , and many others of the umbelliferous Class , are daily used as Food ; but the Water-Hemlock , and Lobel 's Oenanthe , though of the same Class , are most certain Poisons .
Here I must observe what Pains have been taken by Naturalists , to distinguish the useful from the pernicious Kinds .
Among the Romans , the Boletus mentioned by Juvenal , on account of the Death of the Emperor Claudius , is sufficiently described by Pliny ; but , among the later Writers , Carolus Clusius was of the first of those , who , about the Middle of the sixteenth Century , being tired with the Critics and Commentators of the Time he lived in , presumed to believe , that the Whole of Knowledge was not confined to the Writings of the Greek , Roman ; and Arabian Physicians ; because , from the Revival of Letters in the Western World to his Time , nothing was regarded , as of any Importance , but what was dignified with the Authority of Antiquity : And hence it came to pass , that when the Clouds of Ignorance began to disperse , the Epoch of Commentators took Place ; but many of the Descriptions of the Plants of Theophrastus , Dioscorides , and Pliny , were so very deficient , that little Light could be acquired therefrom ; especially from this last Author , who is to be considered as the only Roman Naturalist that we have handed down to us ; and it is no Wonder , if , among the vast Variety of Subjects that this most admirable Historian treats of , he is , in many Instances , rather to be considered as an Enumerator , than as a Describer : I shall only mention the imperfect Sketches he he has left us of Silaus , Geum , Molon , among the many others .
There arose , I say , such Heats and Disputations among the Critics upon those Authors , very often about Trifles , that they rather increased than diminished the Ignorance of those Times .
This excellent Clusius , finding that a thorough Knowledge of Nature was necessary , not only to understand rightly the Ancients , but to lay the Foundation of future Knowledge , was desirous to join careful Observations of his own to those which were to be acquired from Books .
How much he travelled , and what Progress he made in this Undertaking , his many valuable Works are the best Testimony .
Among them , his History of Fungus 's bears not the least Character ; he therein enumerates a great Variety , not only of the esculent , but noxious Kinds ; but , as the different Appellations of every Species was not , at that time , much considered , he gives no other Synonyms to either Class , than that of , viz. Esculentorum primum Genus , Noxiorum decimum Genus , and such-like .
But this Want of specific Names has been sufficiently supplied by John and Caspar Bauhin , Ray , Morison , Tournefort , Vaillant ; but , above all , by Dillenius , in his Catalogus Gissensis , and by Micheli , in his Nova Plantarum Genera .
In most of these Authors we find Instances of mischievous Effects from the pernicious Kinds ; which Property some of them have equal to Opium , Aconite , or Henbane ; but how far this Property proceeds from Animalcules , the following Instance will sufficiently demonstrate .
We have a Sort growing in Eugland , called , by Caspar Bauhin , Fungus albus acris ; which Monsieur Tournefort has rightly observed stimulates the Tongue , and is almost as sharp as tho ' it were steeped in Spirit of Nitre ; and , being rubbed upon Paper dyed blue with turnsole , turns it as red as any violent acid Spirit will .
This caustic Quality remains even after the Fungus is dry .
We need make no further Inquiry for the Cause of the Poison in this Plant ; the above-mentioned is a sufficient Criterion .
John Bauhin likewise tells you , that after having handled this Fungus , he rubbed his Eyes by Accident , and brought on a violent Irritation upon his Eye-lids .
Caspar Bauhin mentions a Sort which kills the very Flies .
Micheli describes a Species , which , upon eating them , almost killed the Painter he usually employed , and an old Woman , the Painter 's Mother .
This Man , being sent by the Author to delineate some of these Fungus 's , and being taken with their Appearance , ordered some of them to be fried , and he and his Mother eat thereof ; but were , in about Two Hours , seized with violent Pains in their Bowels , from which they were with great Difficulty relieved .
I might produce many other Instances of this Sort ; but the above , I believe , are sufficient .
I presume I have set these Matters in a clear Light ; but , fearing I have already taken up too much of your Time , I conclude myself , Gentlemen , Your most devoted , London , May 12 .
1744 .
humble Servant , W. Watson .

