II .
A Letter from Mr. William Watson , Apothecary , F. R. S. to the SOCIET Y , concerning some Persons being poisoned by eating boiled Hemlock .
Gentlemen , NOtwithstanding the Number of Instances , which occur among Writers , concerning the poisonous Quality of our common Hemlock , or Cicuta major of Caspar Bauhin ; such as , that of Cardanus mentioning a Man killed by a Cake , wherein this Plant was an Ingredient ; that of Brassavola , who assures us , that it is mortal not to Men only , but to Geese and Swine ; as well as those of Read May 10 .
of Matthiolus , Scaliger , Kircher , Boccone , and others ; yet the Fatality of its Poison , when growing in this Kingdom , has been doubted by many ; inasmuch as that faithful Collector the late Mr. Ray mentions , in his Synopsis , Edit .
2 .
Page .
326 .
that not only his Friend Mr. Petiver eat half an Ounce of the Root of this Plant , but that Mr. Henly , a Friend of Mr. Petiver 's , in his Presence , eat , without any Inconvenience , three or four Ounces of the same Root .
From hence it has been thought , either that the Root has Effects different from the Stalks and Leaves , or , that Difference of Climate varies the Degree of the Violence of the Poison .
An Observation indeed of the same kind occurs in the German Ephemerides .
Linnaeus , in the Hortus Cliffortianus , makes also some Doubt concerning the Malignity of this Plant ; and , in naming it , has kept to the old Appellation of Theophrastus and Dioscorides , Conium ; and has transferred that of Cicuta , to the Cicuta aquatica of Gesner , and of Wepfer .
Besides , many of the Accidents , said to have proceeded from Cicuta or Hemlock , have been occasioned by different Plants ; some of the Accidents , probably , from the common one , but many more from the Cicuta aquatica before-mention 'd , and from the Oenanthe succo viroso , Cicutae facie , of Lobel .
This Confusion appears manifestly in several Authors , and some of them of the greatest Credit .
Which of these Plants , or whether any of them , was the Athenian Poison , nobody has determined .
Altho ' the Eating of the Roots , as above-mention 'd , was attended with no bad Consequences , a late melancholy Accident has been sufficiently conC 2 vincing vincing of the poisonous Quality of the Leaves of the Cicuta major .
On Sunday , May 6 .
1744 .
two of the Dutch Soldiers lately arrived , who were quartered at Waltham-Abbey in Essex , collected , in the Fields adjoining , a Quantity of Herbs , sufficient for themselves and two others for Dinner , when boiled with Bacon .
These Herbs were accordingly dressed , and the poor Men first eat of the Broth with Bread , and afterwards eat the Herbs with the Bacon .
In a short time after , they were all seized with violent Vertigo 's ; they soon after were comatose ; and two of them grew convulsed , and died in about three Hours .
The People of the Town being exceedingly alarmed at this Accident , a Physician ( Dr. Barrowby junior ) , being there , immediately went , and ordered the other two , at that time almost dead , large Quantities of Oil ; by which means they threw up most of what they had eaten , and afterwards grew better .
In all of them the Effects were the same as those from a large Dose of Opium .
The next Day , being at the Place , I saw one of these Men much recovered , and only complaining of a Heaviness in his Head ; but the other was so well , as to be gone to perform Exercise with the other Soldiers .
There was a fifth Soldier , whom I saw , who told me , He eat some of the Bread out of the Broth , but felt scarce any Inconvenience therefrom .
It so happened , that the twoMen , who gathered the Herbs , were both killed .
As I went down to the Place to satisfy myself in this Matter , a Dutch Officer went with me very courteously to an Inn , where there were two other Soldiers , who had seen and knew the Herbs which had been eaten : He was so kind also as to attend me with these Soldiers into the Fields , to show me the Plants growing .
They first gathered me the Cicutaria vulgaris of John Bauhin , or Cow-weed ; then , the Myrrhis sylvestris seminibus asperis of Caspar Bauhin , or small Hemlock-Chervil .
They then gave me some Cicuta major , and , smelling it , immediately said , That this was the Herb that killed their Comrades ; which I then had no Reason to doubt of , as of the two former Plants : The first grows almost under every Hedge , and is eaten by the Cows , and the other is frequently given to tame Rabbits for Food ; whereas Cattle constantly refuse to eat Hemlock .
Before I was thus satisfied , I imagined this Accident to have proceeded rather from Lobel 's Oenanthe ; thinking , that as that Plant grows near the Sides of Rivers , these Soldiers might have gathered it by the River Lee , which runs by the Town , and eaten it for Smallage , to which it has some Resemblance .
It is now known , that the Cicuta major , the Cicuta aquatica , and the Oenanthe of Lobel , are certain Poisons ; but there are two others of the same Class , growing common in England , and not much unlike these in Smell and other Circumstances , vehemently to be suspected : The one is the Cicutaria tenuifolia of Mr. Ray , which grows frequently in waste Places , and in Gardens among Pot-herbs , of which De la Champ gives some Account of its Malignancy ; the other is the Cicutaria palustris of Lobel and Tabernaemontanus , or Phellandrium of Dodonaeus , which grows in muddy Ditches and Ponds .
I do n't remember any History of the pernicious Effects of the Cicuta major in this Kingdom ; but as the detecting poisonous Plants is of very great Consequence , I presume to lay this Paper before you ; and am , Gentlemen , London , May 9 .
1744 .
Your most obedient , Humble Servant ,

