VIII .
A short Account of Dr. Jurin 's Ninth and last Dissertation De Vi Motrice , by Mr. John Eames , F. R. S. THE last Dissertation is * new , and treats of the Motive Forces of Bodies , whether they are to be estimated by the Velocities , or the Squares of the Velocities , when the Masses are equal .
The Original of this Dispute among the Mathematicians , the Author ascribes to a Slip committed by the celebrated Mr. Leibnitz , in the Year 1686 .
and the Continuance , to the Neglect of the Times , wherein equal Effects are produced .
The one Side asserts all Causes to be equal , whose Effects are so , whether the Times , during which the Causes act , are shorter or longer .
The other , on the contrary , maintains , that equal Effects may arise from unequal Causes , if the Times of Action are unequal ; that consequently the Times , as well as the Effects , ought to be taken into the Account .
He wishes the Gentlemen on the other Side of the Question would produce some Experiment in their Favour , where the Equality of the Times is preserved ; since all the Experiments they have hitherto made , and argued from , may justly be set aside , as incompetent , on the Account of the Inequality of the Times of Action .
* The Eight preceding Dissertations had been before printed separately ; but were now all collected together , with the Addition ~ this Ninth , and published in one Volume in Octavo , London , 1732 .
The Author then proceeds to prove the Truth of the common Opinion of the Forces in equal Bodies being proportional to their Velocities .
This he does by Three Mediums , the First taken from the Action of a single Spring upon the same Body : The Second from some Experiments of Mr. Mariotte ; the Third from the joint Action of several Springs upon Two unequal Bodies .
I. A single Spring , fixed to a moveable horizontal Table , is made to communicate to the same Body , Degrees of Force unquestionably equal , while the Degrees of Velocity communicated at the same time are also undoubtedly equal ; therefore the Forces are proportional to the Velocities .
II .
In Mr. Mariotte 's Experiments , the Impressions made upon equal Surfaces in the same Point of Time , are found to be in the Duplicate Ratio of the Velocities ; but the Masses or Numbers of impinging Particles are in the simple Ratio of the Velocities ; consequently , the Masses and Velocities conjunctly being in the Duplicate Ratio , i. e. as the Impressions , must also be as the Forces which made them : Which is the old Opinion .
III .
A complicated or bent Spring interposed between Two unequal Bodies , acting upon each with an equal Pressure , and during an equal Time , must communicate equal moving Forces to each ; but their Velocities are by Experiment reciprocally proportional to their Masses ; therefore their Masses , drawn into their respective Velocities , are also equal , as were their moving Forces ; and by consequence their moving Forces are as the Masses and Velocities conjunctly : Which is the generally received Opinion .
In the Appendix , the Author answers some of the principal Arguments brought in favour of the contrary Side .
I. The first is drawn from the compound Motion of a Body along the Diagonal of a Rectangle , whose Sides represent the simple Motions .
Here it is said , that the simple Forces are no-ways contrary to each other ; that being united or added together in the compound Force , that compound Force will not be to both or either of the simple Forces , as the Diagonal is to both or either of the Sides ; but as the Square of the Diagonal to the Sum of the Squares of the Sides , or to the Square of either Side respectively .
He answers , The simple Forces , while they act in their proper Directions , are not contrary to each other , either Wholly or in Part ; but when considered as contributing to the Motion of the Body in the Direction of the Diagonal , Part of the one acts contrary to Part of the other , and destroys it ; as is evident , if you resolve each simple Force into two others , one acting along the Diagonal , the other in a Direction perpendicular to it .
And then it is to be observed , that the Sum of the two former is equal to the Diagonal ( while the two latter destroy each other ) : Which is perfectly agreeable to the old Opinion , but not at all to the new ; for the demonstrating of which this Argument is brought .
II .
The second Proof is taken from the equal Compression of Four equal Springs , before the Force was consumed , by the same Body moving with double the Velocity ; and labours at the Bottom under the same Parallogism .
III .
The last Argument is founded upon the learned and ingenious Mr. Poleni 's Experiment , wherein equal Cavities are formed in soft Substances , by equal Bodies falling from Heights reciprocally proportional to their Masses .
This the Author sets aside , as insufficient , since the Times of forming these equal Cavities are unequal , and unequal Causes may produce equal Effects in unequal Times .
The learned Mr. Poleni does , indeed , reply , and say , that the Formation of these Cavities seems to be instantaneous : But the ingenious Author shows the contrary , and that from a Position allowed of by Poleni himself , in his

