VI .
A Physico-mathematical Demonstration of the Impossibility and Insufficiency of Vortices : By M. de Sigorgne .
Translated from the French by T. S. M. D. F. R. S. THAT natural Philosophers of an inferior Class , who consider only the Outside of Things , are obstinate in the Defence of Vortices , is , in my Opinion , not to be wondered at : The Idea of them strikes the Mind very agreeably at first , and even seems to promise the true Mechanism .
But that Persons versed in the most profound Geometry , and in the most sublime Calculations , able Academicians , who incessantly apply themselves to the Study of Nature , should plunge headlong into these Notions , and sustain the Vortices pro aris &amp; focis , is to me Matter of unaccountable Surprise .
It appears to me , that a Vortex is as shocking upon mature Consideration , as its Idea is satisfactory upon the first mentioning it .
And Vortices , in my Opinion , are like smart Sayings ( bons mots ) , which charm the Mind the first , or , perhaps , the second time , but by a Repetition become quite flat and insipid .
What Man , indeed , ( if free from Prejudice , and that the Spirit of Party has not depraved his Judgment ) would not be astonished to see brought on the Scene , not only Vortices , but such as are composed of an infinite Number of smaller Vortices , each of which still contains an innumerable Number of others subordinate to them ?
For Example : What is this Air , this Water , this Oil , &amp;c. which Monsieur de Moliers takes pains to introduce ?
A Sport of the Imagination , or of the Mind , if you please ; but in reality a Paper-building .
It has been long since said , that according as Vortices shall be multiplied , they will degenerate into Littleness and Puerility : And these are the Sentiments even of the good Cartesians of our Days .
But might it not be said , that the great Vortices having the same Origin with the little , the latter show the Meanness of Extraction of the former ?
As Matter is divisible in infinitum ; as to Vorticity , there is no Difference between the Great and the Small : And consequently , we have a Right to reject the large Vortices , since Cartesians proscribe the small .
It is on this Consideration that I am resolved to attack the Vortices : For I must own , to the Shame of our Nation , that the Spirit of Party is so predominant therein , that several Persons , who by a close Study have found the Insufficiency of Vortices for explaining the Phenomenon of the Heavens , yet have not dared to publish their Notions on that Subject .
But as at present the System of small Vortices is freely attacked , I think , as already said , that I have a Right to attack the large ; and to this Purpose I hope to prove , I. That the mechanical Formation of a Vortex is impossible .
II .
That the Vortex , were it formed , cannot be of long Duration .
III .
In fine , that it is not sufficient for explaining the Phenomenon .
FIRSTPAR T. The mechanical Generation of the Vortex is impossible .
DEMONSTRATIO N. In the Hypothesis of a perfect Plenum , GOD at first created Matter indefinite , uniform , homogeneous , and at Rest .
This is allowed by all Cartesians , and follows in their Principles from this alone , that Matter was created at Rest .
Now , from this perfect Homogeneity of Matter it evidently results , in my Opinion , that the Vortex cannot be mechanically formed .
Suppose , say the Cartesians , that while Matter is as yet at Rest , GOD imprints a Motion in a strait Line on one of its Particles : This Particle will every Instant meet with Obstacles to the rectiG gg linear linear Motion in the encompassing Matter ; this Motion must therefore be turned aside , and will by this means become circular .
But why should the encompassing Matter , which is at Rest , be an Obstacle to the rectilinear Motion ?
Because , say they , it happens to be in the Line described by the Particle , on which Motion is supposed to be imprinted .
But this very Reason would also prove , that the Body supposed to be in Motion could not circulate round a Centre at a Distance from it ; because it would constantly meet with Matter at Rest in the Sides of the Polygon which it was to have described .
In a Word , it is a received Principle , that a Body which moves in a homogeneous Medium , never quits the Line of its first Direction : It does not refract , or deviate on one Side or the other of this Direction , except when it passes from an easier into a more difficult Medium , or from a denser into a less dense Medium : and even then its Direction must be oblique on the Surface of this Medium .
Now , the Body in Question would move in a Medium entirely homogeneous ; seeing all the created Matter is supposed to be so , and that all but one Particle of this Matter is at Rest .
It is moreover evident , that as all the Matter is uniform , every Direction , of what kind soever , of a Body which moves in the midst of this Matter , will be perpendicular to the Surface which corresponds to it ; as is demonstrated in Mechanics .
The supposed Mobile will therefore always move in the Line of its first Direction , until it has communicated all its Force ; or rather it will remain at Rest after the least Shock , if Regard be had to nothing more than what I have hitherto said .
But there still remains a very important Remark to be made on this Subject , to wit , that as it is universally agreed at this Day , that Rest is not a Force , all this Matter created at Rest will be infinitely soft : Its Parts will have no Tenacity , no Connexion , no Viscosity ; they will be but contiguous , and will not have more Adhesion to one another , than Two Globes which would touch out of the Bounds of the World without any reciprocal Attraction ; since Tenacity , Viscosity , &amp;c. are in the Cartesian System but the Effects of Compression every Way .
Wherefore these Parts will be divided at the least Shock , in the same manner as if Quicksilver be thrown against a Wall , it is instantly seen to be divided into a Million of Parts , to be reflected on every Side , and be again divided as soon as it falls on the Floor .
I know my Comparison is not exact , but the Advantage is on my Side ; because Quicksilver is not without Viscosity , or a certain Tenacity between its Parts ; whether it proceeds from Attraction , which is my Opinion , or that it be the Effect of the Pressure of the ambient Fluid .
Therefore the Cartesian Matter will have more Facility to divide than Quicksilver , and will not be susceptible of any regular Motion ; which alone demonstrates , that the mechanical Generation of the Vortex is impossible .
There is however this Difference between the Vortex imagined by Descartes , composed of hard Globules ; and that of the infinitely soft Matter of Father Malebranche , whose System is revived by his Disciple Monsieur de Molieres ; that if the Cartesians admitted Gravity as a Principle ; besides that it would give the true Cause of Hardness , its Combination with the strait or projectile Motion would produce a Motion in a Curve ; as Sir Isaac Newton has demonstrated .
But until they will return to this Idea of primitive Gravity , and further while they will make use of no other Matter than one infinitely soft , and really unintelligible , it will not be possible to conceive a single Vortex formed ; far from having this infinite Number , which , by the-bye , ought to be dissipated as Waves raised in the Water , upon account of their perfect Homogeneity .
The famous Cartesians , always refusing to allow this primitive Gravity , and at the same time plainly seeing , that this first Manner of forming the Vortex was impossible , have had recourse , in order to its Formation , to the Motion of Rotation of a solid Sphere at the Centre of a small Particle of Matter at Rest , &amp;c. and they have pretended , that this Sphere in its Circulation ought to carry along with it the circumambient Matter .
But this Notion is certainly as unsustainable as the First .
For , 1st , They must explain to us the mechanical Formation of this Sphere ; they must account for its Solidity : But all this manifestly supposes the Vortex already formed ; all this supposes a Pressure equal on every Side , uniform and concentric .
2dly , This Sphere would never imprint an equal Velocity on all the Points of the concave Surface which touches and encloses it , seeing itself has not an equal Velocity in every Point of its last Surface ; and therefore the Vortex would not have as much Force to defend itself towards the Poles , as towards the Equator ; as we shall show hereafter .
3dly , This Sphere , in striking against the ambient Matter , would but divide it ad infinitum ; because it is infinitely soft , and that its Parts have no Adherence with each other .
4thly , It is not sufficient , that a Sphere turns round its Centre , to draw into its Circulation the ambient Matter : It is moreover requisite , that to press on this Matter in a Direction from the Centre to the Circumference , ( which a solid Globe either cannot do , or can hardly be conceived possible for it to do ) and further still , it is necessary there should be Unevennesses on this Sphere , and on the concave Surface of the ambient Matter ; because otherwise , though the Sphere should press this Surface by its centrifugal Force , it would only raise it up , or tend to raise it , and it would slide along the Surface without dragging it away with it : On which Head there is this Particularity to be remarked , that , for the uniform Circulation and Conservation of the Vortex , and still more for the preserving of Kepler 's Laws , the Spheres and Surfaces must be strictly Mathematical , as we shall soon see ; and for its Formation they must be rough , and full of Unevennesses : But what can be more whimsical ?
And further , though these Surfaces were full of Prickles , yet could not the Vortex be formed in the Hypothesis of Father Malebranche 's soft Matter ; because the Parts which would form these Eminences and Unevennesses on the concave Surface of the Matter surrounding the Sphere , not being connected with the other Parts of the same Matter , would be carried off without Difficulty by the Rotation of the Sphere ; and the rest of the Matter would remain at Rest .
And those who would pretend , that these Unevennesses , these Parts which form the Hillocks we are speaking of , could not , in consequence of GO D 's Decree , loose themselves from the other Parts of the Matter , would evidently abandon Mechanism , without reaping any Advantage : Because , supposing it true , that by this Means the ambient Matter would be compelled to circulate , yet could it not form a fluid Vortex , wherein Kepler 's Laws could be observed ; because both the Sphere and these Surfaces being by these Unevennesses wedged into each other by solid hard and inflexible Parts , they would necessarily move all of a Piece , as the Parts of a Sphere do .
5thly , By means of this Sphere one could have but a great Vortex formed ; and not that infinite Multitude of small Vortices , with which the great ones are at this Day supposed to be filled , and in the Centre of all , or most Part of which , People will not allow that there are hard Globules , and so of the rest : For I am persuaded , that the Reader , by a little Meditation on this Subject , will find almost as many Reasons against this System , as there are small Vortices supposed to exist .
It may be objected , that we do not pretend to form a Vortex : We suppose that GOD formed it in the Beginning , and in Consequence hereof we account for its Properties and Conservation .
But , besides that the Impossibility of the mechanical Generation of a Vortex is a strong Prejudice against its Conservation ; I pretend , in the Principles of our Adversaries , GOD could not form a single Vortex .
I desire Attention may be given , that a circular Motion is a redoubled and forced Motion ; and not , as Mr. Perault thought , a natural Motion .
Now the rectilinear Motion cannot be redoubled thus , as against its Nature , in order to become circular , but upon a Supposition that it meets in the ambient Matter invincible Obstacles to its Direction ; or that by a primitive Law it is carried towards a Centre by a Motion of Gravitation , at the same time that it receives a Motion in a strait Line .
Therefore , since on one hand this universal and primordial Gravity is obstinately rejected ; and on the other , as it is solidly proved above , that the ambient Matter is no Obstacle to the rectilinear Motion ; it remains certain , that the Formation of the Vortex is impossible .
Q. E. D. SECOND and THIRDPAR T. The Vortex , though once formed , cannot last , and it is not sufficient for explaining the celestial Phenomenon .
POSTULATU M. The cylindric Vortex cannot long subsist , and is not sufficient for explaining the celestial Phenomenon : This Principle is allowed by all Cartesians in both its Parts .
It cannot subsist ; because not having Force to defend itself towards the Poles , if it happened to hit on that Side against another cylindric Vortex , that presented its Equator , it would soon be broke into , and burst to its very Centre .
If , on the contrary , its same Side touched another cylindric Vortex by the Poles , they would both mix together , and would compose but one Vortex .
It is not sufficient for explaining the celestial Phenomenon ; because it is allowed , that the translative Velocities of its Points cannot be in an inverted Ratio to the Roots of the Distances , and that its centrifugal Force does not diminish in the inverted Ratio of the Squares of these Distances , &amp;c. COROLLAR Y. Therefore the spherical Vortex , in order to be of Use , must have other Properties than the cylindric : That is to say , it must have a relative Force to one and the same Centre ; for it is by this Force alone that it can be different from the cylindric Vortex .
This Force , moreover , must be equal in all the Points of the same spherical Superficies ; because otherwise it might be burst and broke into in its weak Parts , as well as the cylindric , &amp;c. THEOREM I. Even in the spherical Vortex there is no relative Force to one and the same Centre : That is to say , that it has properly but an axifugal Force .
DEMONSTRATIO N. The spherical Vortex is composed , as well as the cylindrical , of several parallel Circles , but with this Difference , that in the spherical Vortex the Radii of the parallel Circles are not all equal , but on the contrary trary diminish according as they recede from the Equator , and approach the Poles .
Now it is manifest , that all the parallel Circles circulating round different Points of the Axis in the spherical Vortex , as well as in the cylindrical , tend to recede only from these different Points of the Axis , round which they circulate ; because a Body cannot tend to recede from any Centre but that of its Circulation .
In a Word , in order to make a Vortex spherical , which was cylindrical , they have but proportionally shortened the parallel Circles .
But let the Radius of a Circle be ever so much shortened or lengthened , that will not change the Direction of its dilatative Effort .
I am mistaken !
an imaginary Line is going to change the Direction of the axifugal Force .
This Force , as all agree , has for its Direction the Radius I C , in the Circumference whereof it is the Radius ; but the Direction IC is oblique to CE the Tangent to the Sphere ; therefore it changes , according to the general Law of an oblique Shock , into the Determination IE or OC relative to the Centre O. But if Lines may be imagined , and that nothing more is requisite to realize them , than Points that correspond to them ; we shall have some of all sorts in the Vortex : We shall have oblique Lines on the Radius O A , a perpendicular one , and some more or less oblique , on the Radius I C , and by that means we shall be able to determine nothing .
Let us grant however , that there is a Tangent to the Sphere C E , at the Point C , and let us see if it will be a sufficient Reason for decomposing the centrifugal Force IC into a central Force IE or O C. For that Purpose I ask , What are the Points that compose this TanH hh gent ?
A XC E Z OI gent ?
It is evident , that it can only be the Globules of the upper Stratum that answer thereto .
The Line CE is therefore composed only of a certain Number of Points separate one from the other , and which consequently can move one without the other .
Therefore if the Line IC is perpendicular to the Globule that occupies the Point C , and that it passes through its Centre ; there will be no Decomposure , and the Force IC will not change into a Force that has the Radius OC for its Direction .
Now it is infinitely probable , that the Radius IC passes through the Centre of the Globule C ; and it is easy to demonstrate , that it is actually so even in the Principles of Monsieur Saurin , who first invented this central Decomposition .
For what has been the Cause of the Decomposition of the circular Velocity into the centrifugal Force I C ?
It seems plain to me , that no other Cause can be assigned than the Point or Globule C ; seeing there is but that one at the Point where it happened .
The Line IC passes then through the Centre of the Globule C ; since the Decomposition is always made in a perpendicular Line to the Point that caused it .
And indeed , either the Radius IC passes through the Centre of the Globule C , or the Centre of this Globule is on one Side or the other of this Radius , but so as that this Radius cuts the Point C ; or else , it is a Space intercepted between Two Globules , which directly answers to the Point C. In the First Case , there is no Decomposition : In the Second , and in the Hypothesis , that the Centre of the Globule C happens to be between the Radius IC and the Equator , there will be a Decomposition ; but it is manifest , that it will not be a central one : It will , on the contrary , be relative either to the very Pole , or to one of the polar Circles .
In the Third Case , wherein it is supposed , that it is a Space intercepted between Two Globules , which answers to the Point C ; there may be a Decomposition , but it will be double , the one relative to the Centre O , and the other relative to the Pole Z. Now the Cartesians can never draw from this Decomposition the Advantage they propose ; because there will not be more Reason for heavy Bodies precipitating to the Centre of the Sphere by means of the central Force , than to the very Pole by the Assistance of the polifugal Force ; or rather , the Complication of these Two Forces will compel the Mobile to precipitate to the Centre I of the Parallel it happens to be in .
Wherefore , in order to defend the spherical Vortex , they must say , that the Centre of the Globule C is comprehended between the Poles and the Radius I C. But on what Foundation will they assure it ?
What are the Proofs they will give for it ?
One must certainly be a very bold Gamester , to hazard this Point ; because besides the Appearance of Truth , the Adversaires of Vortexes may wager Three to One , that it does not so happen .
But in case it be allowed , will they ever find in the soft Matter of Father Malebranche and Monsieur de Moliere , a sufficient Cause of the Decomposition ?
There must be a Resistance to produce a Decomposition ?
and an infinitely soft Matter does not resist .
And further , in the Hypothesis of the Decomposition of IC or O C , the Vortex would not be in Safety ; because there would be a Remainder of the centrifugal Force I C , that would be parallel to the Tangent C E , and would evidently spread Confusion in the Vortex , by driving all the parallel Circles towards the Equator .
This seems to me sufficient to discredit , in the Minds of rational People free from Prejudice , this central Force , which is attempted by all means to be introduced .
But let us not be tired of examining this Point thoroughly : It is of Consequence , and the Cartesians well deserve the Trouble of an abundant Refutation .
Wherefore let us suppose , that GOD forms a Vortex cylindrical and fluid ; it is a received and evident Principle , that its Points will have but an axifugal Force .
And if a Sphere be conceived to be inscribed in this Cylinder , the Points that compose it , will not in like manner have any central centrifugal Force , according to the Axiom : Nostrum intelligere nihil ponit in re .
Now let us realize this spherical Vortex , which before we had but conceived ; that is , let us suppose , that GOD has destroyed the translative Velocity of the Points that form the angular Spaces intercepted between the last Surface of the inscribed Sphere and that of the Cylinder ; it is manifest , that no Change will happen in the Velocity and axifugal Force of the rest of the Points , which are not included in these ; for this Reason , that the Points which fill the Two kinds of Basons that mark the Excess of the Cylinder above the inscribed Sphere , remain in the same Order , Disposition , and Direction , with regard to the inferior Points , which they were in at the time of their Motion .
And there is no other Difference to be perceived herein , except that at present it is the same Point that constantly corresponds to the same Place ; and that before this Place was successively occupied by Points entirely resembling each other , and that which remains or is supposed constantly to remain therein .
Now whether this Place be constantly occupied by one and the same Point , or successively by Points entirely alike and in the same Order , is what ought not to produce any Variation in the Effect which we are examining : And this appears to me at least as clear as Noon-day .
Wherefore , since these inferior Points had then but an axifugal Force , it follows that even now they have no other Tendency than to recede from the Centres of their Circulations , without having any Force relative to the Centre of the Vortex .
This is all that pure Reason dictates to me on this Point of the Nature of the Vortex , whether spherical or cylindrical : And I dare flatter myself , that whosoever will attentively examine my Reasonings , will find them as demonstrative as can be desired in Natural Philosophy .
In Effect , Experience agrees here with Reason .
If a glass Globe filled with Water be rapidly turned on its Axis , one sees little Foulnesses ; the small Atoms which it never fails to contain , gather together along the Axis , and form a little Cylinder round it .
Which very plainly shows , that in this spherical Vortex of Water there is but an axifugal Force .
Q. E. D. COROLLAR Y. Therefore Gravity is inexplicable in the Vortex , and it has not Strength to defend itself towards the Poles .
THEOREM II .
Supposing there was in the spherical Vortex a central Force according to the Radius O C , it could not by Reaction be changed into a centripetal Force according to the Radius C O. This Proposition is well known to all who are somewhat conversant in Mechanics .
It is therein demonstrated , that if the Radius I C , for Example , forms with the Tangent CE an Angle of 45 Degrees , the Line of Reflexion will be parallel to the Axis ; and that from the Point C to the Pole Z , the Lines of Reflexion will be divergent to the Axis ; and , in fine , that from the Point C to the Equator , these same Lines of Reflexion will be indeed convergent to the Axis , but will never terminate at the Centre O : In a word , that because the Angle of Reflexion is always equal to the Angle of Incidence , it is only at the Equator that the centrifugal Force can be changed into a centripetal Force .
Q. E. D. COROLLARY I. Therefore the modern Cartesians are strangely mistaken , when they pretend to account for Gravity by the Reverse of the central centrifugal Force .
COROLLARY II .
And they can never , a fortiori , in their Principles , explain the Figure of the Earth and of Jupiter , which are flatted Spheroids made by the Conversion of an Ellipsis upon its small Axis .
LEMMA I. If the centrifugal Force represented by IC ( see p. 420 .
) be decomposed on the spherical Tangent into a Force , that for its Direction has the Centre of the Sphere ; the central Force , which results from this Decomposition , will be to the centrifugal Force , as the Radius IC to the Radius O C. For the centrifugal Force I C , being decomposed into C on the Tangent of the Sphere , will strike this Tangent with a Force that will be represented by I E. But on account of the simular Triangles IE C , IO C ; I E. I C : : I C. O C. LEMMA II .
A Body which describes a Curve , strikes this Curve every time it passes from one Side to the other , with an infinitely small Force of the first kind with regard to its Velocity .
To the best of my Remembrance , this Proposition is demonstrated in Dr. Clarke 's Notes on Rohault 's Physica , and in Monsieur de Moliere 's Lectures : And it is evident from this alone , that it can only be by a Force represented by the Sine of the Angle of Contact that this moveable Body strikes the Tangent of its Curve .
THEOREM III .
Let us put Complaisance on the Stretch , and grant that Vortexes have a central and centripetal Force relative to one Centre O : I say , that the spherical Vortex will not have as much of this central Force , to defend itself towards the Poles , as towards the Equator .
CONSTRUCTIO N. Let us take , in the same Superficies X ( see the Fig. p. 420 .
) Two Points at Pleasure , the Point A in the Circumference of the Equator , and the Point C in the Circumference of a subduple parallel Circle ; we will give in the Demonstration an equal Velocity to the Globules which circulate in these Two Circumferences ; which is the most favourable Concession imaginable for the Patrons of Vortexes .
DEMONSTRATIO N. It is manifest , that if the Point A is in an equal Space of Time struck an equal Number of Times as the Point C , and that each Stroke against the Point A be double each Stroke against the Point C ; it is manifest , I say , that there is more Force at the Equator than at the parallel Circle .
Now the Supposition is very certain in both its Parts : For , 1 .
Since the Circumference of the Equator is the double of that of the parallel Circle , and that being at an equal Distance from the Centre O , ( see Fig. p. 420 .
) the Globules they contain are equal to each other ; if there be a Thousand Globules in the Circumference of the Parallel , there will be Two thousand in the Circumference of the Equator .
And as these Globules are supposed to have in both an equal Velocity , they will make ( but ) One Revolution in the Equator , while those of the subduple Circumference will make Two .
Therefore , in both , there will be Two thousand Strokes employed in the same Space of Time , against the Points A and C. 2 .
Each central Stroke is double at the Equator : Because , as there is in both an equal Velocity , and that ( LEM .
II .
) each centrifugal Stroke in every Circumference is a Fluxion of the first kind , with regard to the Velocity of the Globule which is in Motion ; it follows that the centrifugal Strokes both in the Equator , and in the parallel Circle , are equal to each other .
But the central Effort ( which is the only one by which a Vortex can defend itself towards the Poles ) is at the Point C ( LEM .
I. ) but half the centrifugal Effort , since it is represented by IE subduple of I C ; whereas at the Equator the central Effort is the same with the centrifugal Effort , because the Radius OA is perpendicular on the spirical Tangent , which corresponds to it .
Therefore , &amp;c. Q. E. D. COROLLARY I. Therefore if a Vortex be in AEquilibrium with another Vortex , and that the Equator of one happens to answer to the Poles or Tropics of the other ; the latter will be burst and penetrated to the Centre : And I do not think , that the Cartesians can find their Account in this Consequence .
COROLLARY II .
Therefore if the Vortex was the mechanical Cause of Gravity , Gravity ought to be greater at the Equator than at the Poles ; and the Earth would be an oblong Spheroid ; which is contrary to Observations .
REMAR K. I have said , that it was making a large Concession to the Cartesians , to suppose that the Globules of both the Circumferences have an equal Velocity .
For if a Sphere full of Water be made to turn on its Centre , Experience teaches , that the Velocity is greater at the Equator than in the parallel Circles ; since it is observed , that the Times of their periodical Revolutions are equal .
Whence it follows , that I have , in my Demonstration , made the most favourable Supposition for the Cartesians that was possible .
THEOREM IV .
In order to determine the Tendency of a Layer towards the Upper Part of the Vortex , regard must be had not only to that which results from its own Circulation , but also to that which it receives from the other lower Layers , unless it be the Layer next the Centre .
DEMONSTRATIO N. While a Layer is in Circulation , it visibly makes a continual Effort towards dilating itself , by reason of the centrifugal Force , with which all its Parts endeavour to recede from the Centre of Circulation : But its actual Dilatation being impeded by the Layer next above it , this last will be naturally pressed by it .
And thus it is that the first or lowest Layer , being put into Circulation , presses the Second ; and the Second , assisted by the First , presses the Third ; this , assisted by the Two preceding , presses the Fourth ; and so on from Layer to Layer , through the whole Extent of the Vortex .
Whence it follows , that in order to estimate the Quantity of Force with which a Layer tends towards the Surface of the Vortex , one must take the centrifugal Force proper to this Layer and that , which all the Matter of the Fluid contained under it acquires by Circulation .
Q. E. D. COROLLARY I. Therefore the dilatative Effort of the Layers increases with the Layers in a greater Proportion than these Layers .
COROLLARY II .
Therefore it is impossible to explain in the Vortex , how Gravity decreases in an inverted Ratio of the Squares of the Distances ; and consequently there will be nothing found in the Vortex to answer to Attraction , whose Existence Sir Isaac Newton has so demonstratively established .
COROLLARY III .
Thus we have re-established in its full Light the Difficulty , which Monsieur de Fontenelle proposed to Monsieur Villemot in the Memoirs of the Academy for the Year 1705* .
This learned Academician pretends , that as in the Vortex the lower Points ought to move faster than the upper , in order to preserve Kepler 's Astronomical Law ; they ought also to have a greater centrifugal Force , and consequently compel them to descend , particularly in proportion to their Fluidity .
The Objection made a great Noise , and the only Method found of getting rid of it , was by saying , that although each lower Point had more centrifugal Force than each upper ; yet as the Vortex was in AEquilibrium , and the Sums of the Force of each of the Two Layers were equal , there was no Reason why the lower Stratum should get the better of the upper ; because this was as prevalent by the Number of its Points , as that was by the Force of each of its own .
But it is manifest , after what has been demonstrated above , that the second Layer , being assisted by the first , must have a greater Force than the third , and consequently compel it to descend , pursuant to the Principle then granted to Monsieur Fontenelle .
But if it be asked , How could the upper Layer descend , seeing Matter is impenetrable ?
* He afterwards published a Book , entitled , Nouveau Systeme , ou nouvelle Explication Au Mouvement des Planetes , par M. Philippe Villemot , Pretre , Docteur en Tbeologie , &amp;c. Lyon , 1707 .
in 12~ .
I shall ask in my turn , How , in an entire Plenum , do heavy Bodies fall to the Centre ?
And I reason on the Principle granted to Monsieur Fontenelle .
But yet , because what is allowed by one Cartesian is not always allowed by all ; let us suppose , that the upper Layer cannot descend ; this , at least , will follow from my Demonstration , that , according to the Principles of all these Gentlemen , an upper Layer being pressed by all the under ones , it must hasten its Circulation , as long as it is slower than that of these under Layers ; by reason that the Excess of their Velocities will act upon it , as if it had been at Rest .
COROLLARY IV .
Therefore the Layers of a Vortex will move all of a Piece , as do those of a solid Sphere ; and Kepler 's Law cannot possibly be preserved .
We shall now give other Proofs upon other Principles .
THEOREM V. The Motion of the Points of the Equator is absolutely independent of the Motion of the parallel Circles ; and consequently , in order to determine the AEquilibrium of the Points of the Equator , we must attend to nothing but its Motion .
DEMONSTRATIO N. The Plane of the Equator is parallel to the Planes of the other parallel Circles , that turn round the same Axe with it : Its centrifugal Force is perpendicular to the Tangent to the Sphere , which answers to it : It has not then any lateral Tendency towards these parallel Circles , and by a necessary Consequence its Motion is absolutely independent of theirs .
And indeed , if it be supposed , that the Motion of the other parallel Circles stops , there is still some Motion conceived in the Equator , just as in the Case of the cylindrical Vortex : It is likewise conceivable , that the Velocity may be greater at the Equator than in the parallel Circles , as the Experiment already cited shows us : And if no Regard be had to the lateral Frictions , as the Cartesians would have it , who suppose them none or insensible , and as indeed they are obliged to say , that the Vortex , by the lateral Friction of the Equator , may not become cylindrical ; this Equator will always continue to circulate uniformly , without communicating any of its Velocity to the Points that laterally surround it .
Therefore , &amp;c. Q. E. D. COROLLARY I. Therefore for the AEquilibrium of the Points of the Equator , it is necessary , at least , that an upper Circumference should have as much Tendency towards the Superficies of the Vortex , as another under concentric Circumference ; because , if it had less , there would be no AEquilibrium , even in the Principles of the Cartesians ; and the under Circumference , pressing the upper , would either make it descend , or communicate to it a Force equal to its own .
Wherefore , calling F the proper centrifugal Force of a Point of the upper Circumference , and f that of a Point of the under one ; if S , s mark the different Sums of the Points contained in these Two Circumferences , we shall have FS=f s. COROLLARY II .
Therefore the centrifugal Force does not diminish in the Plane of the Equator in the inverted Ratio of the Squares of the Distances from the Centre ; for since FS=f s ; F.f : : s. S. But the Points being supposed equal on both Sides , their Sums are as the Circumferences , and one has s. S. : : d. D , which gives F.f : : d. D. instead of : : d d. D D. COROLLARY III .
Therefore Kepler 's Rules cannot be observed in the Vortex , or at least in the Plane of its Equator ; for since F.f : : d.D ; by putting in the Place of F , f , their Values , we shall have V V/ D.u u/ d : : d. D , and therefore V=u and D2 , d2 : : TT.tt .
whereas we ought to have V. u : : 2~d .
2~ D and D3 .
d3 : : T T. t t. REMAR K. There is here a Finesse of the Cartesians to be observed .
These Gentlemen consideronly the AEquilibrium of the spherical Layers of the Vortex , and from the Equality of their central Forces they deduce Kepler 's Laws , as well as they can .
But it is manifest , that whatever becomes of the Equality of Force in different spherical Superficies of the Vortex , there must be an AEquilibrium in the Plane of the Equator ; because it is in this Plane that the Planets move ; and if there had not actually been an AEquilibrium between its Points , they would soon place themselves there , by reason that Fluids always tend to the Side where they are less pressed ; and it is by an actual AEquilibrium alone that they are kept in their Places ; which entirely overturns the Theory of these Gentlemen .
Let us however grant to the Cartesians , that the Sums of the Forces of the Two spherical Surfaces are equal ; I cannot see , that they can thence infer , as they do , that the central Force diminishes in a reciprocal Ratio of the Square of the Distance from the Centre .
Let us examine their Argument : FS=f s , say they ; therefore F.f::s.S ; but s , S mark the Sums of the Points contained in the Two Surfaces , therefore they are as these Surfaces , which , being as the Squares of their Distances , give , F. f : : ddD D. But it must be remarked , that the Surfaces of the Vortex are not Mathematical , they are Surfaces which have some Thickness : They cannot then be proportional to the Squares of their Distances from the Centre , except in the Case when their Thickness is equal .
Now , according to the Cartesians , the Points or Globules , which compose the Vortex , increase in Bulk according as they recede from the Centre ; and , besides , they are homogeneous , or of an equal specific Density , at least in their common System .
And consequently it is certain , that the different natural or real Strata of the Vortex are not of an equal Thickness , and that the Matter contained therein is not proportionate to the Squares of the Radii of these Surfaces , but only to the Squares of these Radii multiplied by the Thickness of the Strata .
Therefore , &amp;c. Q. E. D. COROLLARY IV .
Therefore , even allowing the Cartesians , what one has a Right ( COROL .
I. THEOR .
IV .
) to refuse them , they will never be able to explain Kepler 's Rules in the Vortex ; for it is only by the Proportion , which I have just now annulled , that they pretend to do it .
See M. de Molieres 's Lecons de Physique .
And if it be objected , that I have not , in the preceding Corollaries , had any regard to the Thickness of the Circumferences ; I answer , that it was by way of pure Concession that I have not done it ; and if any Person will be at the Pains of doing it , he will easily find , that Kepler 's Rules will only be the more disturbed thereby .
CONCLUSIO N. Therefore the Vortex is every way impossible , and insufficient in Natural Philosophy .
Its mechanical Generation is impossible ( PART I. ) ; it has only an axifugal Force , and not a centrifugal and centripetal Force , as it should have ( THEOR .
I. and II .
) ; and even if it had , it cannot ( THEOR .
III .
) defend itself equally on all Sides .
It is not sufficient for explaining Gravity , and its Properties ; it destroys Kepler 's Astronomical Laws ( COROL .
III .
THEOR .
IV .
and V. ) .
What more can be desired , in order to conclude with Sir Isaac Newton ?
` ` Itaque hypothesis Vorticum ( est impossibile &amp; ) cum phaenomenis astronomicis omnino pugnat , &amp; non tam ad explicandos quam ad perturbandos motus coelefts conducit .
' ' Q.E.D.

