I. An Account by John Eames , F. R. S. of a Dissertation , containing Remarks upon the Observations made in France , in order to ascertain the Figure of the Earth , by Mr. Celsius , entitled , De observationibus pro Figura Telluris determinanda , in Gallia habitis , Disquisitio .
Auctore Andrea Celsio , in Acad. Upsal .
Astronom .
Prof. Regio , &amp;c. Upsaliae , 1738 .
4to .
THAT the Figure of the Earth is Spheroidical is agreed upon by all : But whether it be an oblong or oblate Spheroid , i. e. whether the Axis be longer or shorter than a Diameter at the Equator , has been for some time a matter of Doubt .
Three several Methods have been proposed to determine this Controversy by Experiments ; as by the different Lengths of Pendulums vibrating Seconds , in different Latitudes ; the Figure of the Earth 's Shadow in Lunar Eclipses ; and by the actual Measurement of the Lengths of a Degree on the Meridian in different Latitudes .
It is certain , if the Lengths of the Degrees of Latitude decrease as we go from the Equator toward the Poles , then the Axis is greater , and the Figure an oblong Spheroid ; but , on the contrary , if these Lengths increase as you remove towards the Poles , the Axis is less than a Diameter at the Equator , and consequently an oblate Spheroid .
Mr. Cassini and others , judge the Earth to be of an oblong Spheroidical Figure ; and the Observations made in France , if entirely to be depended upon , prove this Hypothesis to be a Matter of Fact .
Our late illustrious President , Sir ISAACNEWTO N , Mr. Huygens , and others , make the Earth to be an oblate Spheroid , higher at the Equator than at the Poles ; and this Figure of the Earth is undoubtedly the true one , if the Observations lately made near the Arctic Circle be admitted as~ certain and exact .
So that since both Sets of Observations have been taken by Persons of known Skill , Dexterity , and Integrity , it is now become absolutely necessary to inquire into this Matter , in order to find out the Occasion of so great a Difference in their Conclusions .
Mr. Celsius , in the Treatise before us , proposes to consider this Matter more closely , and begins with a Defence of the Observations made at Tornea , near the North Polar Circle ; and then takes Notice of some things , proper to be considered , relating to the Instruments , Astronomical Observations , and Trigonometrical Operations , performed in France ; which , in his Judgment , render the Observations uncertain ; at least so far as not to be accurate enough to be depended upon in determining the Matter in Question .
To begin with the Defence of the Observations made at Tornea : Perhaps it may not be improper to premise a short Account of them .
They were undertaken at the Charge of the King of France , by Five skilful Gentlemen ; Three of them Members of the Royal Academy at Paris , who were joined by Mr. Celsius , and the Abbe Authier .
The Trigonometrical Part of the Work was performed near the River of Tornea , whose Direction is the same with the Meridian of Tornea ; the Coasts of the Gulf of Bothnia being found very inconvenient for that Purpose .
By the favourable Situation of Five Mountains they formed Eight Triangles , which took in Space enough for their Design .
All the Five Gentlemen observed , one after another , each Angle of these Triangles , setting them down in writing separately .
They afterwards determined the Distance between Tornea and Mount Kittis , under the same Meridian , by a Basis , measured on the River when frozen over , whose Length was 7406 Toises 5 Feet , by the first Measurement ; and when measured again , was barely Four Inches over .
This Distance between them they found to be 55,234 Toises .
The first Part of their Work being thus finished , the next was to find the Difference of Latitude of these two Places : This they did by the Help of a Telescope , fixed to a Sector of Nine Foot , made at London , by the Gare and Direction of Mr. George Graham , to whom the Lovers of Astronomy are indebted for the curious and well-contrived Instruments he has supplied them withal .
The Star they observed at Tornea was ~ Draconis : They repeared their Observations three times , and the greatest Difference between them was but Two Seconds : Removing to Mount Kittis , they took the same Number of Observations , of the same Star , without finding more than One Second Difference .
The Result was , that the Amplitude of the Arch , in the Heavens , between Tornea and Mount Kittis , ( allowing for the Precession of the Equinox , and the Time elapsed between the Two Observations , according to Mr. Bradley 's Theory ) was 57~ Minutes 26 Seconds .
Hence the Magnitude of a Degree , on the Earth , intersecting the Polar Circle , was found to be greater than a mean Degree of France 377 Toises ; and to differ 900 Toises from what it should have been , according to Mr. Cassini 's Hypothesis : And if the Correction , according to Mr. Bradley 's Theory , were omitted , the Difference would have amounted to above a Thousand Toises : The Consequence of which , say the curious Observers , is , That the Earth is not only flatted towards the Poles , but that it is much more so than Sir Isaac Newton or Monsieur Huygens thought it .
This unexpected Difference being so very great , made them resolve upon a careful as well as new kind of Verification of the Whole .
In the first Place , they repeated their Astronomical Observations Three several times , at Tornea and Kittis , with the same Instrument , but on another Star , viz. ~ Draconis : The Difference of Latitude between the Two Places was found to be the same , within Three Seconds and an half , with the First .
They then not only examined the Truth of their Meridian Line , the Exactness of the Sector , in the different Divisions upon the Limb , chiefly in the Two Degrees employed in observing ~ &amp; ~ Draconis , but supposed that , in their Trigonometrical Operations , they had erred in each Triangle , by Twenty Seconds in each of the Two Angles , and Forty Seconds in the Third ; and that all these Errors tended to diminish the Length of the Arch ; the Calculation , upon this Supposition , gives but 44 1/ 20 Toises for the greatest Error that could be committed .
When a particular Relation of all these Observations was read before the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , and inquired into ; the main Exception taken to them was , That the Observers , omitting to make a Proof of the Line of Collination , by means of double Observations , with the Face of their Instrument turned contrary Ways , have thereby not duly ascertained the Truth of their Observations .
But this Objection was fully answered by Monsieur Maupertuis , as Mr. Celsius hopes and believes , to the entire Satisfaction of Monsieur Cassini , who made it .
He allows M. Cassini had very good Reason to mention this , as a thing proper to be done in Instruments of common Use , for this Purpose , which generally stand in need of such a Method of Verification : But it was not at all necessary in the Instrument used at Tornea and Mount Kittis : The very Make of it was such , that no Alteration could easily be made in it , so as to create any perceptible Error in the Observations .
The whole Apparatus of the Telescope and Sector is all framed together ; the Object-glass and Cross-wires , as well as the Limb , so firmly fixed to the Tube , as not to be dislocated without great Violence .
Notwithstanding all this , the utmost Care was taken in transporting it from one Place to another ; being placed in a Chest , that the Laplanders , to use his own Words , in illa cista idolum quoddam servari facile sibi persuaderent .
He adds , the same Objection may be made to Monsieur Picard 's Observations , who does not seem to have used this Precaution , as Monsieur Cassini himself acknowledges , who nevertheless approves and extols his Observations for their Accuracy : So that those at the Arctic Circle may be very good , notwithstanding the want of this , supposed necessary , Operation .
And indeed , that they were so , sufficiently appears from this Fact .
The Difference of Latitude between Tornea and Mount Kittis , found in September , was observed again in March following , by the Help of the same Star ~ Draconis , and did not differ from the former above 3 1/ 2 Seconds , though the Instrument had been twice carried from one Place to the other .
This is a Degree of Exactness not easy to be met with ; no not in Monsieur Cassini 's Observations , made on different Stars , which differ sometimes 40 Seconds , in determining the Amplitude of an Arc in the Heavens , though their Instrument was carefully examined in the way above-mentioned .
The Author then proceeds , in his Turn , to inquire into the Accuracy and Certainty of the two Sets of Observations made in the North and South Parts of France , in respect of the Royal Observatory at Paris .
As to the Measures of the Degrees in the Northern Parts of France , between Paris and Dunkirk , he owns they cannot be much out of the way ; being in some measure confirmed by Monsieur De la Hire , in the Year 1683 .
and Monsieur Cassini himself .
Yet Mr. Celsius observes , that the Basis on the sandy plain Shore , near Dunkirk , when measured again , differed Three Feet from the former Measurement ; which is a much greater Difference than that Mr. Celsius and the other Gentlemen found , in measuring a much longer Line twice over , which was but Four Inches .
As to the Astronomical Observations taken by the Six Foot Sector , whose Limb of 12 Degrees was divided only at every 20 Seconds ; it is true , Monsieur Cassini examined the Instrument several ways , at Paris , after his Return thither : but that a Correction , owing to the Change of Centre , might be safely applied to the Observations at Dunkirk , the Examen of the Centre should also have been taken at Dunkirk ; it being uncertain , whether this Alteration or Aberration of the Centre was caused by the Journey to or from Dunkirk .
The Difference of 41 Seconds between the Observations taken to settle the true Measure of the Arc of the Heavens , seems to be enormous .
Perhaps the Stars were not lucid enough to be well observed by the Three Foot Tube ; but might they not , for a due Degree of Accuracy , have been viewed through the Nine or Ten Foot Telescope ?
Our Author prefers the Observations of 1719 , made after the Return to Paris , to those made before ; because made at the same time of the Year with those of Dunkirk , and so not standing in need of Mr. Bradley 's Correction : Though this Caution , perhaps , may be thought not necessary here , where the Errors of the Observations are greater than the Correction itself .
Mr. Celsius remarks farther , if the Difference of Latitude between Dunkirk and Paris be supposed to be Two Degrees 12 Minutes 12 Seconds and an half , which is a Mean between Four others he mentions , the Length of a Degree will amount to but 56,395 Toises .
And if the Observations at Malvoisine and Amiens , be counted according to Mr. Bradley 's Theory , for the Interval of a Month between the Observations , the Length of a Degree will come out to be 56,926 Toises ; which is 135 Toises less than the Length of a Degree , found by measuring the whole Length of France ; and 134 less than that of Mr. Picard , so highly approved of by Mr. Cassini , as confirming his own .
The Reflections Mr. Celsius makes upon the Observations , &amp;c. taken in the South Parts of France , shall be referred to another Meeting .
The Continuation of the Remarks made by Mr. Celsius on the Observations taken in France , in order to ascertain the true Figure of the Earth .
MR. Celsius having finished his Remarks upon the Observations made in the North Part of France , extending from Paris to Dunkirk , proceeds to examine those taken in the South , from Paris to Collioure , near the Borders of Spain , and the Pyrenean Mountains .
By the former , a mean Degree was found to consist of 56,960 Toises , by the latter 57,097 ; and consequently the Earth is an oblong Spheroid .
Mr. Celsius , in examining these Observations , which were taken under the Conduct and Direction of the late M. Cassini in 1700 , first considers the Structure and Goodness of the Instruments used ; then the Accuracy of the Astronomical Observations for finding the Difference of Latitude ; and , in the last place , the Trigonometrical Operations for determining the Distances of Places ; especially the two Extremes under the same Meridian .
The principal Instrument M. Cassini carried with him , was , a Limb of 12 Degrees , whose Radius was indeed 10 Foot , but divided only into Degrees and Minutes ; the other Parts were added to it at Perpignan .
Here Mr. Celsius observes , that the finding the true Centre of this Limb was and still is a very difficult and troublesome Problem to a good Artist ; that no mention is made , whether the Position or Place of this Centre , and the Divisions of the Limb , were ever examined at Paris or Collioure , though the Carriage of the Instrument through so long and rough a Way , could not but make some Alteration in the Place of the Centre .
It is true , the Zenith Distance of Capella , taken by it at Paris , was confirmed to be right by another Instrument ; but it cannot be concluded , that the Zenith Distance of the same Star , taken at Collioure by this Instrument , and not confirmed there by another Instrument , must be true also .
For the Point of Division , answering to this Distance in the Limb , was not examined ; and a Centre wrong placed may by Accident give the true Zenith Distance , viz. when the true and erroneous Centre happen to lie in the same Perpendicular to the Horizon .
The Exceptions taken to the Astronomical Observations for finding the Difference of Latitude between Paris and Collioure , are , in the first place , That though Five Stars were observed at Collioure and Paris , yet One only was made use of , viz. Capella : That the Difference of Latitude by Capella is 6~ 18~ 57~ : If Lucida Lyra had been used , the Difference would have been but 6~ 17~ 7~ ; but by the Right Shoulder of Auriga , 6~ 19~ 25~ : Hence arises the Uncertainty or Difference of 2~ 18~ between the greatest and least of their Observations : That the late Mr. Cassini makes the Difference 57~ less than Mr. Cassini , who accounts for this Difference from the Observations being taken by an ordinary Instrument ; but the Instrument is the same which was used to take the Altitude of the Pole of Amiens , which was very near that found by Mr. Picard .
As to the Trigonometrical Operations for finding the Distance of Places , Mr. Celsius thinks they labour under considerable Uncertainties ; not only on the Account of the many Difficulties they met withal , viz. mountainous Countries , want of proper Signals , &amp;c. so that convenient Triangles could not be formed ; but add to all these , several of the Triangles had but Two Angles observed , and some of these Angles too acute ; whence , as Mr. Cassini himself very justly observes , in his Examination of Snellius and Riccioli 's Observations , great Errors may arise .
Mr. Picard thinks all Angles less than 20 Degrees ought to be avoided ; as also that the Triangles should be contrived so as to have Sides of a due Length , neither too great nor too small : Then follow 16 Triangles , wherein one or more of these Inconveniences are to be found .
It may be said , the Whole of these Observations and Measures of Monsieur Cassini seem to be sufficiently confirmed , if not ascertained ; since the principal Base in Roussillon was found , when computed , to differ but Three Toises from the same as it was actually measured ; and that , after some due Corrections , it was made to agree with the greatest Exactness .
Mr. Celsius replies , Why are we not told what those Corrections were , that we may see whether they were really necessary or no ?
Why were they not taken notice of in the Calculations of each Triangle ?
Besides , the real Length of the Base , or the fundamental Line , in Roussillon , is not fully ascertained , it not being measured more than once ; whereas that at Dunkirk and that of Mr. Picard were measured twice ; and there was more Reason for doing so here than at Dunkirk , on account of the uneven and almost ever changing Shore in Roussillon , from the restless overflowing Sea .
The great Number of the Triangles , joined with the numerous small Errors of the Angles , is another Ground of Uncertainty ; for the Errors in the Angles , though small , may make the Distance of the Parallels of the Two extreme Places greater than it ought to be ; and yet the principal Sides , that is , those that are made Bases to the following Triangles , continue the same .
This made it necessary to verify the Sides , at least at every second Degree , by measuring the principal Base twice over with due Care ; which might have been done , and therefore should have been done , in a Matter of so much Nicety as an Attempt to find the Difference between Two Degrees so near one another , under the same Meridian .
To show what bad Consequences may arise from small Errors committed in observing the Angles of several Triangles , Mr. Olavus Hiorter , a curious and ingenious Friend of Mr. Celsius , has taken the Pains to form the Triangles of Mr. Cassini between Bourges and Collioure ; so that the Distance between their Parallels shall be considerably lessened ; and yet the Base in Roussillon , found by Computation , shall not , after due Correction , differ sensibly , if at all , from the same actually measured .
In consequence of this , Mr. Celsius concludes with observing , that the Distance between the Royal Observatory and the Perpendicular to the Meridian of Collioure , deduced from the Triangles of Cassini , corrected after Mr. Hiorter 's Method , &amp;c. will amount to but 358,980 Toises .
This , divided by the mean Difference of their Latitudes , 6~ 19~ 11~ , will give 56,803 Toises , for the Length of a Degree , one with another , between Paris and Collioure , which is less than the Length of a mean Degree found by Mr. Picard , and pretty near the Truth : So that the Degrees decrease as you go towards the Equator ; and consequently the Earth is higher at the Equator than at the Poles , as Sir Isaac Newton and Mr. Huygens believed .
The Distance of the Parallels of Paris and Collioure by this Method is indeed less than that computed by Mr. Cassini ; but this cannot reasonably be complained of , since these computed Measures of Mr. Cassini seem very capable of being lessened ; and it is no more than what Mr. Cassini himself hath done to the Measures published by his Father , which he has shortened by 325 1/ 2 Toises .
But however that Matter be , whether this particular Correction of Mr. Cassini 's Distance , and , consequently , Length of a mean Degree , be admitted or no , Mr. Celsius is fully persuaded , upon the Whole , that he hath made it plain to every unprejudiced Reader , that these Two Sets of Observations in France are not taken with such a Degree of Exactness as to be depended upon , in determining so nice a Matter , in Dispute for 50 Years , as the true Figure of the Earth ; which was the thing proposed to be done by them .

