VIII .
A new Method of improving and perfecting Catadioptrical Telescopes , by forming the Speculums of Glass instead of Metal .
By Caleb Smith .
THE Telescope is deservedly reckoned one of the most excellent of all the Inventions of the Moderns ; such noble and useful Discoveries have been made by means of this admirable Instrument , and are still to be expected from its further Improvement , that many of the most eminent Mathematicians have employed their utmost Skill and Industry to bring it to Perfection .
The Imperfections of Telescopes are attributed to two Causes ; to wit , The Unfitness of the Spherical Figure to which the Glasses are usually ground , and the different Refrangibility of the Rays of Light .
The first of these Defects only , was known to the Writers of Dioptrics , before Sir Isaac Newton ; for which Reason ( as he informs us himself , Opt .
Lect. 1 , 2 .
) they ` ` imagined , that Optical Instruments might be brought to any Degree of Perfection , provided they were able to communicate to the Glasses , in grinding , what Geometrical Figure they pleased ; to which Purpose various Mechanical Contrivances were thought of , whereby Glasses might be ground into Hyperbolical , or even Parabolical , bolical , Figures ; yet nobody succeeded in the exact Description of such Figures ; and had their Success been answerable to their Wishes , yet their Labour would have been lost ( continues this incomparable Mathematician ) ; for the Perfection of Telescopes is limited , not so much for want of Glasses truly figured , according to the Prescriptions of Optic Authors , ( which all Men have hitherto imagined ) as because that Light itself is an heterogeneous Mixture of differently refrangible Rays ; so that were a Glass so exactly figured as to collect any one sort of Rays into one Point , it could not collect those also into the same Point , which having the same Incidence upon the same Medium , are apt to suffer a different Refraction ' ' ( Phil. Trans. No. 80 .
) .
And again , ` ` Diversa diversorum Radiorum Refrangibilitas Impedimento est , quo minus Optica , per Figuras , vel sphaericas , vel alias , perfici possint ; nisi corrigi possint Errores illinc oriundi , Labor omnis in caeteris corrigendis imperite collocabitur ' ' ( Principia , &amp;c. Scholium ad finem Libri Primi ) .
Now , for this principal and last-mentioned Defect , no one , that we know of , has proposed any Remedy ; apprehending , perhaps , the Difficulty of attaining such to be insuperable ; inasmuch as the great Author of this Discovery , himself , had not showed us any Method whereby to correct those Errors which arise from this Inequality of Refraction ; but rather discouraged any such Attempts , by declaring , ` ` that on this Account he laid aside his Glass-works , ' ' ( Phil. Trans. No. 80 .
) ` ` and looked upon the Improvement of Telescopes , of given Lengths , by Refraction , as desperate ' ' ( Optics , 2d Edit .
p. 91 .
) .
However , as it has been proved by incontestable Experiments , that this Dissipation of the Rays of Light , from whatever Cause it proceeds , in passing out of one Medium into another , is not accidental and irregular ; but that every sort of homogeneal Rays , whether more or less refrangible , considered apart , are refracted according to some constant uniform and certain Law ; and as the Removal of so great an Impediment as this of unequal Refraction in the Rays of Light , is of great Importance to the Science of Dioptrics , and absolutely necessary to its further Advancement ; we have thought it worthy of a careful Examination , whether , in some Cases at least , it might not be possible for contrary Refractions so to correct each other 's Inequalities , as to make their Difference regular ; and if this could be conveniently effected , Sir Isaac Newton has acknowledged , ` ` there would be no farther Difficulty ' ' ( Phil. Trans. No. 88 ) .
Now , upon a due Consideration of this Subject , we have found it possible , by proper Methods and Expedients , to rectify those Errors which proceed from the different Degrees of Refrangibility in different Rays , passing from one Medium into another ; admitting only this well-known and established Principle , upon which we ground our Reasoning , viz. That the Sines of Refraction of Rays differently refrangible , are one to another in a given Proportion , when their Sines of Incidence are equal ' ' ( Optics , 2d Edit .
p. 66 .
) .
And our present Design is , to show what Advantage this will yield towards improving and perfecting Catadioptrical Telescopes , by making the Speculums of Glass , instead of Metal , in the following Manner : Fig. 1 .
FA KG QP LHEB R MI DC Let the Figure ABCDEF represent the Section of a concavo-convex Speculum , whose two Surfaces are Segments of unequal Spheres ; call the Radius of the Sphere , to which the concave Side is ground , a ; and the Radius of the convex Surface , which must be quicksilver 'd over , e ; let BR be the Axis of the Speculum , or a Line perpendicular to both the Surfaces ; and therein let P be the principal Focus , or Point where parallel Rays of the most refrangible Kind are collected , by this Speculum ; and Q the Focus , or Point of Concourse , of such Rays as are least refrangible ; to wit , after they have suffered two Refractions , at entering into , and passing out of , the concave Surface DE F , and also one Reflection from the convex Surface AB C : If the Radius of Concavity be greater than the Radius of Convexity , as we will in the first Place suppose , then P will fall nearer the Vertex of the Speculum than the Point Q ; and the Interval QP will be the greatest Aberration , or Error , occasioned by the Separation , or unequal Refraction , of the greatest and least refrangible Rays , after their Emergence from the concave Surface FED .
Call the common Sine of Incidence , n ; the Sine of Refraction of the least refrangible Rays out of a dense Medium into a rarer , m ; and , of the most refrangible , ~ ; then , according to the known and received Laws of Refraction and Reflection , the Focal Distance of the most refrangible Rays , from the Vertex of the Speculum , ( neglecting its Thickness , as of little or no Moment in the present Case ) will be found =nae/ ( a-e ) 2~+2ne=PB .
And the Quantity of the greatest Aberration , occasioned by the different Refrangibility of the most and least refrangible Rays , PQ , will be to the focal Distance just mentioned , PB , as ( a-e(~(~-m ) to ( a-e ) m+e n ; which Quantity , or Error , thus obtained , ( to abbreviate the Calculation ) call ~ ; and how let it be required to form a Lens , if possible , which , placed at some given Point in the Axis between the Focus of the most refrangible Rays P , and the Vertex of the Speculum ( as H ) , shall refract not only the Rays of the most refrangible Kind tending to the Point P , but also the Rays of the least refrangible Kind tending to Q , in such a Manner , that both Sorts shall concur , after such Refraction , in some other Point of the Axis R ; let HP the given Distance of the Point in the Axis H , from the Focal Point P , be called d ; and then if the Point H has been assumed , so that the said given Quantity , or Distance , d , is greater than ( ~-n)~/ ~-m , but less than m~/ ~-m , I say the refracting Superficies GH I , that shall perform what was required , will be part of a concave Sphere , whose Radius is = ( dd+d~ ) x ( ~-m)/ m~-(~-m ) d ; HR , the Distance of the given Point H , from R , the Point to which all the Rays will tend , after Refraction at the said concave Surface , ( whose Radius being found , as above , we call v ) will be = ~dv/ ( d+v ) n-~d .
Lastly , upon the Point R thus obtained , as a Centre , with an Interval a little less than HR , describe the Circumference KLM , and the Figure GHIMLK will denote the Section of a double concave Lens , which , placed at the given Point in the Axis H , ( taken nevertheless within the Limits above-mentioned ) will collect all Sorts of Rays proceeding from the Speculum , into one and the same Focus , or Point of the Axis , R , as was required ; for the Surface GHI , which first receives those Rays , will refract the most refrangible Sort converging to the Point P , and also the least refrangible converging towards Q , so that both Sorts , after such Refraction , will concur in the Point R ; but the Rays tending to R , it is manifest , will suffer no Refraction at their Emergence from the Superficies KL M , because R is the Centre thereof , by Construction ; which Point , R , where a perfect Image of the Object infinitely distant will be formed , we call the Focus of the Telescope , to distinguish it from the Point , P , which we have before called the Focus of the Speculum .
In this manner a Lens , ( or instead thereof a triangular Prism with two of its Sides ground concave , and the third plain , if that be found as practicable ) may be formed and situated , so as to correct the Errors of the Speculum arising from the different Refrangibility of the Rays of Light .
But , in order to render this kind of Telescopes absolutely perfect in their Construction , the Errors also that result from the spherical Figure , must be rectified ; and with regard to this , we assert , that it is possible to assume a Point in the Axis , between the Focus of the Speculum and its Vertex , ( as we have taken the Point H , in the following Example , see Fig. 2 .
p. 337 .
) at which , if a refracting Superficies , or Lens , be constituted , according to the Method already delivered , it will not only correct the Errors occasioned by the unequal Refraction of the Rays of Light , but also rectify such as proceed from the spherical Figure of this Speculum , to a much greater Degree of Exactness than is requisite for any Physical Purpose ( meaning always the Errors of those Rays which respect the Axis ) .
Now to find or determine this Point , affords a Problem not easy to be solved ; and we recommend it , as worthy of the Consideration of Geometricians .
Seeing therefore it is possible , and we believe also practicable , to remedy the Imperfections of this kind of Speculums , ( from whatsoever Cause they arise ) by the Method we have here proposed ; it seems to follow , that Catadioptrical Telescopes may be carried , by this means , to as great a Degree of Perfection , as they are capable of receiving ; provided spherical Figures can be truly communicated , with an exquisite Polish , to Glasses of a large Aperture , and a Foil of Quicksilver made also to retain that Figure accurately , and without any Inequality ; for the Object-glass or Speculum being rendered perfect , so as that all sorts of Rays , proceeding from one lucid Point in its Axis , shall be collected by means of the Lens exactly in another Point , its Aperture may then be extended to its furthest Limits ; and that is , till the whole Pupil of the Eye ( or the whole Portion of the Eyeglass to be used , when that becomes necessarily less than the Pupil ) be filled with Rays proceeding from the Speculum , and flowing from one Point of the Object , but no farther ; because this is a Limitation made by Nature in the Structure of the Eye itself : And in Telescopes whose Construction is such as we have now described , the largest Aperture of the Speculum that can ever be of Use , will be to the Diameter of the Pupil of the Eye , very nearly , in a Ratio compounded of the Ratio 's of the Focal Length of the Speculum to the Distance of that Focus from the Lens , and of the Distance of the Lens from the Focus of the Telescope , to Unity : That is , of BP ~ PH , and of RH to 1 ; which Proportion holds , whatever be the Charge or the Power of Magnifying .
But if Inquiry be made as to the Charge most proper and convenient , that will be determined best by Experience , in these , as well as in all other sorts of Telescopes : However , on Supposition that one of a given Length has its Aperture and Charge rightly ordered and proportioned , the Rule for preserving the same Degree of Brightness and Distinctness , in all others of a like Construction , will be , to make the Apertures , and magnifying Powers , directly as the Focal Lengths of the Speculums ; which shows the vast Advantage and Perfection of these Telescopes , above the common reflecting ones ; where , according to Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule , the Apertures , and Powers of Magnifying , must be as the Biquadrate Roots of the Cubes of their Lengths ( See his Optics , 2d Edition , p. 97 .
) .
It is likewise a considerable Advantage in this Construction , that the Reflection from the concave Side of the Speculum will do no sensible Prejudice ; because the Image of any Object made thereby , is removed to so vast a Distance from the principal Image , formed by the convex Surface , as to create no manmer of Confusion or Disturbance in the Vision ; which necessarily happens , in some Degree , from the Vicinity of those Images , when the Glass is ground concave on one Side , and as much convex on the other ; according to the Method propounded by Sir Isaac Newton , in his most excellent Book of Optics .
It may be imagined , perhaps , at first View , that ( if our Reasoning is just ) the Errors of refracting Telescopes , occasioned by the different Refrangibility of Light , may be corrected by a like Artifice : But the Aberration of the Rays from the principal Focus is there so great , and bears so considerable a Proportion to the Focal Length of the Telescope , that the Error cannot be rectified by the Interposition of any Lens , until the Rays are , by a contrary Refraction , collected again at an infinite Distance , which renders this Expedient quite useless ; however , there is no need to despair of accomplishing even this , by other Methods : And , by the way , we may observe , if it were worth while to seek a Remedy for the Errors occasioned by the spherical Figure of the Object-glass only , in Dioptrical Telescopes ; that might be obtained by the proper Application of a suitable Lens , between the Focus and the Vertex of the Object glass ; which is much more easy and practicable , than the grinding of Glasses to Hyperbolical or Elliptical Figures .
For a further Illustration of what is gone before , it may be proper to exhibit the several Parts and Proportions of a Telescope in Numbers computed according to the Theorems already delivered ; and in Practice we judge it will be most convenient , that the Radii of the Spheres to which the concave and convex Sides of the Speculum are ground , be nearly in the Ratio of 6 to 5 ; as in the following Example ; where ( see Fig. 2 .
p. 33 7 .
) ABCDEF , represents the great Speculum of Glass , ground concave on one Side , and convex on the other ; quicksilver 'd over the convex Side , and of an equal Thickness all round its Circumference .
The Radius of Concavity =a= 48 Inches .
The Radius of Convexity =e= 40 Inches .
Then putting n , the Sine of Incidence = 100 ; m , the Sign of Refraction of the least refrangible Rays , out of Glass into Air , = 154 ; and ~ , the Sine of Refraction of the most refrangible Rays , =15 6 ; as Sir Isaac Newton found them by Experiments ; we shall have , P B , the Focal Length of the Speculum with regard to the most refrangible Rays = 18.2926 + , which will be somewhat increased by the Thickness of the Glass , when that is considerable .
P Q , the greatest Aberration of the Rays , occasioned by their different Degrees of Refrangibility , =.0 5594 + , which Quantity , in Practice , should be a very little augmented , rather than otherwise ; wherefore we put it here =.056 = ~ .
The Radius of the concave Surface of the Lens , turned towards the Speculum , viz. of GHI , =~ = 2.8 Inches .
The Radius of the concave Surface of the Lens , turned from the Speculum , viz. of KLM , = 6.7 Inches .
The Thickness of the Lens at the Vertex LH = 1/ 10 of an Inch .
The Aperture of the Lens must be about 1/ 6 of the Aperture of the Speculum .
HP , the Distance of the Focal Point P from the Point H , where the abovesaid Lens is to be placed , so as to correct the Errors arising from the different Refrangibility of the Rays , and also the Errors of the spherical Figure , = 2.24/ 73 Inches .
HR , the Distance of H the Vertex of the Lens from R the Focus of the Telescope , = 6.8 Inches .
And if we suppose the Diameter of the Pupil of the Eye to be ~ of an Inch , ( though it has not one certain Measure ) then the Diameter of the greatest Aperture of the Speculum , that can ever be of Use , will be 6 2/ 3 Inches , nearly .
The small plano-convex Eye-glass O must always have one common Focus with the Telescope , to wit , the Point R translated to r , by Reflection from the Base of the Prism N ; for which Reason it must retain , at all times , an equal and invariable Distance from the Lens GHIKLM ; which Distance will be the Focal Length of the said Eye-Glass more HR ( = HN+N r ) the Distance of the Lens from the Focus of the Telescope R. Fig. 2 .
FA KG QP NLHEB RMI r DC O The Form and Position of the Prism N , and the Contrivance of the other Parts necessary , will be much the same as in the Newtonian Telescope .
If the Focal Length of the Eye-glass be 1/ 4 of an Inch , the Telescope will magnify about 200 times .
This Telescope may be contrived in the Gregorian way , by using , instead of a Lens and Prism , a small Speculum spherically concave on one Side , and convex on the other ; but we think it not worth while to attempt this Construction , as an Investigation of the Proportion between the two Surfaces necessary , in this small Speculum , to unite the Rays proceeding from the great one , into one Point , would be intricate , and the Practice also very difficult ; by reason that a little Inaccuracy will , in this Case , occasion Errors much more considerable than a like Imperfection in the refracting Lens .
We have hitherto supposed the Radius of the Concavity greater than that of the Convexity ; as being most convenient and useful , on several Accounts , in forming this kind of Telescopes ; however , it may be proper to remark , that the same Method may be used for correcting the Errors of the Speculum , when the Radius of its Concavity is less than that of the Convexity ; only the refracting Superficies of the Lens , placed between its Vertex and Focus , will be convex , and not concave , as in the former CaseAnd there is another thing worthy of Remark , that the Focus , or Point ( P ) , where the most refrangible Rays are collected , will fall farther from the Vertex of this Speculum , than the Focus of the least refrangible ( Q ) ; a Circumstance which never happens by Refraction alone , in Glasses of any Figure whatsoever , or howsoever they be disposed .
Fig. 3 .
FA KG PQR LHEB MI DC Now all things being put as before , and making ( Fig. 3 .
) HQ= d , I say the convex Superficies GHI of a Lens placed at H , that shall correct the Errors arising from the different Refrangibility of Rays , in this kind of Speculum , will be part of a Sphere , whose Radius is = ( ~ m ) ~ ( d d+d ~)/ ( ~ m ) d+n~= u. And H R , the Distance of the Point R , where the Rays of all sorts will unite , after this Refraction , from H the given Point in the Axis , will be =~du / ( ~ n ) d+n u ; which Point R being taken as a Centre , describe thereon the Arch KL M , and the Figure GHIMLK will represent the Section of a Meniscus-glass , or Lens , which , placed at the Point H , assumed between the Vertex and Focus of the Speculum , will collect all sorts of Rays proceeding therefrom into one and the same Point , or Focus , R. We might also show , how this Error may be rectified by one or more Glasses , placed in the Axis , at a Distance farther from the Vertex than the Focal Point P ; but the former Speculum is so much preferable to this , for the constructing of Telescopes , that we think it not worth while to prosecute this Matter farther .
To conclude this Essay ; Whoever shall think fit to put the Method here proposed in Execution , we dare venture ( from a Trial that has been made ) to assure him of Success ; provided the same Diligence , Care , and Accuracy , be applied , in choosing , figuring , polishing and foiling , the Glass , that has of late been employed for the forming Speculums of Metal ; and let none be discouraged , though the first and second Attempt should fail ; for that must be expected , if the ordinary way of grinding and polishing be used : Greater Exactness is here required , than is usually thought sufficient for the Object-glasses of refracting Telescopes : Let it be also considered how many Essays , for a long Term of Years , were made by Mr. Gregory , Sir Isaac Newton , and others , to reduce their Constructions of the reflecting Telescope into Practice , without answering , in any tolerable Degree , what their Theories promised : The Workmen they employed were chiefly Optical Instrument-makers , and had it been left to such Persons only to perform by themselves , we have reason to think , that it would have been pronounced impracticable to this Day , to make a reflecting Telescope that should equal or excel refracting ones of Ten times its Length ; though we now see , that most of these Artificers are capable of making them to such a Degree of Perfection as was formerly despaired of .

