IV .
A Letter from Granvile Wheler , Esq ; to Dr. Mortimer , Secr. R. S. containing some Remarks on the late Stephen Gray , F. R. S. his Electrical Circular Experiment .
* SIR , SOME odd Circumstances led me to make Mr. Gray 's circular Experiment in the following Manner .
While I excited a Cake of Rosin and Beeswax ten Inches Diameter , by clapping with my Hand , I let my ivory Ball continue in a Basin of Water ; then shaking off the Drops , placed it in the Centre , and with my right Hand held a fine Thread , about eight or nine Inches long , having one End rolled up into a little Ball , and the other , for about an Inch , reduced to its greatest Fineness , to only one Fibre , myself and Hand being supported on the Back of a Chair .
The Success was , I had a great many Revolutions , to the Number of Fifty , from West to East ; but at first not so regular as towards the last , at first describing only about one third Part of the Circumference at a time , and after standing still a little , describing another third Part .
I might probably have had a great many more Revolutions , but being tired , I was forced to rest myself , which I did for ten Minutes , then took up the Thread again .
The Thread stood repelled at some Distance , without making any Revolutions , and at last only made half an one the contrary way to what it did before ; but upon wetting it , by drawing it two or three times * See Philosophical Transactions , n. 441 , p. 220 .
and n. 444 , p. 400 .
of the Revolutions of pendulous Bodies by Electricity .
over the Surface of the Water , it made again twenty more Revolutions from West to East , only at a smaller Distance from the Ball , ( for the Water must make it heavier ) but full as regular as before , and rather quicker : The Virtue of the Cake must now have lasted about three quarters of an Hour .
After resting about six Minutes , I tried again with the String fresh wetted , the Ball and Cake continuing as before ; and had , to my great Surprise , one hundred Revolutions in the Space of about twelve Minutes , the Revolutions being still quicker , .
and more regular , and nearer the Ball ; and at the sixth Revolution of this last Hundred , the Thread was attracted to the Surface of the Ball , and , being wet , did not disengage itself , till pulled away ; yet after this , described the remaining Ninety-four Revolutions of the Hundred , and seemed inclined to describe a great many more , but that I was forced to rest my Arm again , which I did for about eight Minutes , then tried again , the Thread being fresh wetted , and had seventy Revolutions at nearly the same Distance from the Ball in less than nine Minutes , all very regular , and without any Attraction of the Thread to the Ball .
I rested again sixteen Minutes , wet the Thread again , and held it as usual ; it was repelled at about half an Inch Distance from the Ball , but seemed to have no Tendency to a circular Motion ; yet after continuing stationary about a Minute , I perceived a Motion about its Axis , about which it took several Turns ; but still had little or no progressive Motion , till about a Minute longer , when it began to move forward , and continued doing so from West to East , for about thirty-three Revolutions , very regular , but slower than in the two last Cases , the String having been held about ten Minutes , nutes , and the Revolutions performed in about seven or eight of them .
I observed each of these three last times , it was rather longer before the progressive Motion began than usual ; and in all the Trials of this Experiment , I frequently perceived a Motion about the Axis , which was generally from West to East , though now-and-then the contrary Way .
The Virtue of the Cake must now have lasted near two Hours ; about three quarters of an Hour after , I tried again , and had sixty Revolutions from West to East , in about ten Minutes , the Distance from the Ball being still less than before , hardly one quarter of an Inch , scarce any Revolution about the Axis appeared , and at the Beginning the Thread was twice attracted to the Ball .
About an Hour and half after , the Virtue of the Ball was not quite gone , the wet Thread being repelled , and making three or four Revolutions from West to East , as well as moving a little about its Axis the same Way .
But as it was reasonable to suppose the Ball itself in the Centre of the Cake was now dry , with a Feather dipped in Water I wet its Surface ; yet found no Increase of Virtue , rather a Diminution of it , the pendulous Body seeming scarce at all repelled ; but it is to be observed , that the Ball , as it was wetting , twice tumbled over , and rolled upon the Surface of the Cake ; by which means the Virtue of the Cake might be much diminished .
It is not improper too to take Notice here , that during the Revolutions of the wet String , I have frequently observed a kind of Oscillatory Motion , as if there was an alternate Intention and Remission of the repulsive Force .
As also that I have often took Notice of little Plucks , and convulsive Motions , in the pendulous Body , and sometimes thought I have felt something like it in my Arm that held it , though at no other time have I ever been sensible of any such thing .
I have several times since repeated this Experiment with the Thread and Ball both wet , and found it succeed much better than when they were both dry ; and once I find by my Notes I had two hundred and twenty Revolutions before I rested my Arm .
I have tried too with the Ball dry , and the String only made wet ; but the Virtue did not continue so long , as when both were wet .
I now flattered myself with Hopes of Success , if the Thread was suspended from an undoubted fixed Point , which therefore I proceeded again to try with the greatest Care and Caution , but in vain ; the Revolutions were uncertain .
This Difference naturally led me to reflect upon the Cause of it .
The Tremor of the Hand would not account for it ; for this being both ways backward as well as forward , must as often hinder as promote a continual Motion one way : And though in two opposite Parts of a Circle , the Motion is really in contrary Directions , and therefore the contrary Impulses of a Tremor may promote a Revolution applied at opposite Places of the Orbit ; yet as these Tremors are irregular , and succeed much quicker than the Revolutions are performed , they seem insufficient to account for the Motions of the pendulous Body , performed with any Degree of Regularity .
A Stream of Air in my Room might impel along the Tangent the pendulous Body , kept at a Distance from the Ball by its repulsive Force ; and then Gravity , taking place , might with the first Motion compound a Curve ; but still the Resistance of the Air would soon destroy the original Impulse , could a few Revolutions be performed ; and besides , one Revolution could not be performed , because the same Stream of Air that began the Motion , must be contrary to it in its Return .
A Finger held on the right Hand near the pendulous Body , when suspended from a fixed Point , will make it revolve from West to East ; but then it must be applied and removed alternately : The repulsive Force therefore which the Arm may acquire , by being held in the Sphere of the Effluvia , is insufficient ; for , as it is in one Place , it must impel only one way , and constantly the same way ; and therefore , like a Stream of Air in the Room , though it might create the Beginning , it must hinder the Completion of a Revolution .
Sometimes I have doubted , whether the Pulse of the Arm might not be assisting in giving a projectile Motion .
When one Leg is laid over the Knee of the other , a Motion and Heaving of the Leg that lies over , answering to every Stroke of the Pulse , is very apparent at a Distance : The Arm therefore in some Postures , in which its great Artery meets with a proportionable Pressure or Resistance , may have a constant Motion , though less perceivable .
What seemed the most probable Solution , was this : When the Arm is extended , the Posture being uneasy , there must be a Reaction of the Muscles , or a continual pulling of the Arm towards the Body .
When therefore the right Arm is made use of , the pulling will be from Right to Left ; and consequently the Motion produced in the Body held by it in the same Direction , or from West to East .
When the left Arm is made use of , the Reaction of the Muscles will be from Left to Right , and therefore the Motion of the pendulous Body from East to West .
And , agreeably to this , I have observed , ( as I formerly took Notice , though this Reason did not then occur to me ) when I used my left Hand , all other Circumstances continuing the same , the Motion of the pendulous Body was from Left to Right , or from East to West , contrary to what was observed when held by the right Hand .
Yet still neither of these Solutions would account for the Variety of Oddnesses I have met with under various Circumstances .
I proceeded therefore to try with Rests for my Arm of different Heights , having an Arm of Wood , about two Feet long , fixed to a Rest for my Telescopes , which I could raise to any Height I wanted ; and I found the Experiment succeed only well , when the Rest was lower than the electric Area , and the Arm was supported upon its Elbow , which was the Posture constantly made use of , when rested upon a Chair , the Chair being lower than the electric Area , that it might less affect the Effluvia , as was then thought .
I began now to think with myself , whether it was not possible , that an Inclination to a Motion one way in the Person that holds the Body , might not have such an Influence upon the Arm , and consequently the String and pendulous Body , as to determine them the same way by some Pressure or Bias put upon it , though no Motion sensible even to himQ 2 self , self , was produced in the Hand .
If so , I might , by a contrary Inclination , produce a Motion the contrary way .
Having therefore a fine Day , and my circular Cake being well excited , I tried if I could not produce a regular Motion from East to West , about the Ball in the Centre , having my Hand supported , as usual , upon the Back of a Chair .
I found I could produce a very regular one from East to West for many Revolutions , and change from one Motion to another , without being sensible I moved my Hand at all .
I then wet the Ball and String , as in the Experiment before-mentioned , and found I could tire myself with a Motion either from East to West , or from West to East , as I pleased , without giving any Motion , that I could perceive , to my Hand or Fingers .
Hence many odd Experiments that please , may , when repeated , succeed .
Since therefore the Motion of the pendulous Body from a Point undoubtedly fixed , is irregular , as I have found by many different Experiments , repeated with the greatest Care and Caution ; and since I am convinced from these last-mentioned Trials , the Motion from West to East , and from East to West , must generally have been determined by myself ; I am Inclined to think , that a Desire of producing a Motion from West to East , was the secret Cause that determined the pendulous Body to that Direction , by some Impression from Mr. Gray 's Hand , as well as my own , though I am persuaded at the same time , he was not sensible of giving any Motion to his Hand himself : And I the rather think this was the Case , from the Instance Mr. Gray gives , by way of Explanation , nation , of a Man resting his Elbows upon his Knees , this implying that he rested his Arm upon his Elbow , as I did myself .
But though upon the Whole it does at last appear , that this Motion from West to East in a pendulous Body , applied to another in the Centre of an electric Area , is to be ascribed to the Hand that holds it , and not solely to the Nature of the electric Effluvia , or the Figure of the central Body ; yet still , perhaps , it may not be improper for Astronomers to consider , whether or no a Medium with this Property , that all Bodies immersed in it , are repulsive of one another , ought not to be joined with Gravity to explain the heavenly Phenomenon ; especially since the Phenomenon of Fire , and our electric Effluvia , have a great Affinity to each other ; and since many of the heavenly Phenomenon are to be accounted for , upon this Supposition , with great Simplicity ; and some of them , that have not yet perhaps been fully accounted for , seem necessarily to follow .
I am , Sir , with a very great Regard , Otterden-Place , Your much obliged , Feb. 20 .
1737-8 .
humble Servant , Granv .
Wheler .
P S. This was intended to have been sent eleven Days ago .
Mar. 3 .
1737-8 .

