XV .
Two remarkable Medical Cases , one of an Extraordinary Haemorrhage , the other an Ascites cured by Tapping ; communicated by Henry Banyer , M. D. Extra-Licentiate of the College of Physicians , London , to C. Mortimer , M. D. Secr. R. S. IN the Month of January 1729 .
Daniel Goddard , a Gardener , about the Age of Twenty-four Years , at Wisbech in the Isle of Ely , Cambridgeshire , happened of a slight Puncture from a rusty Nail in the Sole of his Right Foot .
And , notwithstanding there was not wounded any Tendon , or Blood-vessel , larger than small Branches of Veins , the whole Foot was immediately swelled to a very unusual Degree , without any Fever , or other apparent Cause for it .
It was also attended with great Pain , and an extraordinary Pulsation upon the Part , as in Wounds of Arteries ; and so distended as if the Blood would burst out of its Vessels .
Read Dec. 22 .
1743 .
Accordingly , after Two Days , upon opening a superficial Sinus , to enlarge the Wound , there rushed out immediately such an obstinate Flux of Blood , as would not yield to any styptic Means , longer than the Bandage was holden on by some strong Hand .
And , although , by this Incision , no Vessels were wounded , but Capillary Veins ; yet this Haemorrhage continued to show itself as violent as at first , for Six Days successively , whenever the necessary Means were relaxed .
Upon which , for the sake of Revulsion , the Patient had a Vein opened on the Arm of the opposite Side ; and it had such a sudden and surprising Effect , that the Flux of Blood in the Foot instantly ceased , and the Wound healed very soon without any further Trouble ; but the Flux of Blood , consequent upon Venesection , became equally as difficult to restrain , as that in the Foot , for the Space of Four Days ; all which time it would have continued to flow most violently without the strictest Bandage , as the same Care of the Hand , as before .
Perhaps the Period of this Haemorrhage might have been much longer , if I had not suffered the Ligature on the Arm to be loosened now-and-then , as I judged the Redundancy of Blood required , for the sake of some Evacuation , at each time .
After the Bleeding , he soon recovered his Strength , so as to do his Business in the Gardens ; and continued very well till the Month of March 1730 .
About the Middle of this Month , he complained of Sleepiness , and a particular Heaviness all over his Body ; which was followed , in Three Days time , by a violent Haemorhage from the Nose .
This Flux , in spite of all Means being tried , except Venesection , continued Seven Days , and could never be totally stopped , all this time , for one Hour together .
He recovered again in a very short time , and was able to work in the Summer-season , without any Complaints , till October following .
Then the Haemorrhage returned again at the Nose , as before , with all the same Circumstances , and in Defiance of all Endeavours , continued the Period of Seven Days .
Thus it returned in like manner of Bleeding , by Stools , in the Middle of March 1731 , and continued to discharge this Way great Quantities of Blood , in one Motion , and sometimes two Motions every Day for Seven Days together , in Opposition to the most efficacious Restringents .
Also it made its regular Return by vast Profusions of Blood from the Intestines , in the Beginning of October following , to the End of the first Period of Seven Days , without Gripings , or any such uneasy Sensations .
Thus , again , it kept as orderly Returns about the Vernal and Autumnal Equinoxes of the Years 1732 , 1733 , with vast Profusion of Blood by Stool , for the usual Term of Seven Days , agreeing in all Circumstances with the preceding Years .
Likewise at , or very near these two grand Seasons , in the Years 1734 , 1735 , this habitual Haemorrhage broke away by the Kidneys and urinary Passage ; and still constantly , for these Two Years , kept its old stated Time of Seven Days , without any other Variation .
This young Man was seized in Dec. 1735 , with the Small-pox , of the Distinct Kind , which produced such a Change in his Constitution , that he escaped those periodical Haemorrhages , or any other spontaneous Evacuations equivalent thereto , for the Two Seasons of the Year 1736 ; and remained in very good Health till Christmas following , being above Thirteen Months free from any Symptoms of his old Eruption .
But , upon December the 27th , without any previous Notice of Heaviness and Sleepiness , the Haemorrhage returned by the urinary Passages ; but much more favourably , and continued only Three Days .
Again , on May the 13th following , 1737 , he then felt the previous Warnings , and bled again by Urine to the 20th of the same Month ; with this Difference , that for Three Days the Urine was only Coffee-coloured , but afterwards , for Four Days longer , every Discharge resembled an Effusion of Blood from a Vein just opened .
He presently recovered his Strength , even although the Air was exceeding warm at this Time ; and I saw him Five Months after , very robust and healthy , and , as he told me himself , was free from all kinds of Tendency towards his old Complaint .
But he had always the Appearance of too much Fulness , though I am of Opinion , that his Constitution did not suffer so much as might reasonably be imagined , from such prodigious Haemorhages .
Of my own Knowledge , he had no Return of his Bleeding , or any thing like it , the ensuing Autumn ; but remained perfectly well all the following Winter Season .
Afterwards I had no Opportunity of making further personal Inquiries , but was informed by an intelligent Man , that in March 1738 this unfortunate Person got a slight Wound again , somewhere upon one of his Legs , which proved equally as difficult , with respect to the Flux of Blood , as the first Puncture in his Foot .
And , whether from too strict a Restraint of the Haemorrhage , or for want of Venesection , he fell into very violent Convulsions for Four or Five Days , and died in a manner like Suffocation , from too much Redundancy of Blood .
As this Haemorrhage never once depended upon any other Distemper , or observed any regular Concurrence with the Revolutions of the Moon , it appears to be a very extraordinary simple Plethora .
During the Four Years that this Flux of Blood came from the Nose and Intestines , the Urine was never of a higher Colour than Amber ; nor was there any Symptom of a Fever by the Pulse , or otherways , for the whole Term of the Disorder .
Nnnn2 ON January the 6th , 1743 .
ON March the 26th , 1739 , the Wife of Mr. Matth. Wilkinson , of Long-Sutton , in Lincolnshire , was tapped for an Ascites , proceeding from frequent Haemorrhages , and a too liberal Use of small Liquors .
She was between 30 and 40 Years old , of a very low Stature , and always of a weak Constitution .
The Water was all taken at one Time , and measured Five Gallons .
She was very faint immediately after the Operation , and remained so for near Three Weeks after .
But , by great Abstinence from Liquids , excepting Lower 's bitter Infusion , and sometimes a Spoonful or Two of Cordial Julap , she perfectly recovered her Health again ; and to a much better Degree of it , than she had enjoyed for many Years before ; without any Appearance at all of a Return of the abdominal Tumour to this Day .
The Water was clear , and readily turned to a strong Jelly upon heating it ; and I am very certain , there was unavoidably left in the abdomen a Quantity sufficient to prove the Existence of absorbent Vessels .
Perhaps those Patients , in this Distemper , whose Water turns to a Jelly , have a better Chance to be cured by Paracentesis , than others , whose Discharge is more like Urine , and will never curdle by Heat .
But Time , and repeated Observation , must confirm this Opinion .
Postscript against Empiricism .
NOtwithstanding the great Usefulness and Tendency of successful Observations in Physic and Surgery , to encourage Practitioners in a Perseverance in their Duty , even where the regular Prognostics stand against them ; yet I cannot forbear taking this Opportunity to assert the Impossibility of any Person 's obtaining a competent Knowledge of the Art of Healing , by Practice only ; without a previous Knowlege of Anatomy , and the Animal Oeconomy .
Hence have I met with an old Practioner , of very extensive Business , who had never been educated in this fundamental Qualification , and who , for want of it , was treating his Patient with Cataplasms and Fomentations , to cure that Numbness in the Thigh which is a certain Diagnostic of a Nephritic Case .
And I have more than once seen a Dysuria under the Treatment of a gravelly Case , when it has plainly arisen from the Venae Haemorrhoidales having been too much swelled towards the urinary Passages .
Thus , where Men are not qualified to distinguish at all upon the Symptoms of a Distemper , from some true Knowlege of the Parts concerned , they must necessarily be often mistaking the Symptoms for Distempers , and so vice versa , after this Manner ; insomuch that their longest Practice will be little better than a Multiplication of Blunders , without much Chance to be wiser by Time and Experience .
Huic Ratiocinationi adstipulatur Experientia , qua sine vana omnis Theoria , bella sit utcunque .

