V. Part of a Letter from of Cambridge , to a Friend of the ROYALSOCIET Y , occasioned by what has lately been reported concerning the Insect mentioned in PAge 218 of this Transaction .
Nov. 20 .
1742 .
THE last News from Paris gives something very surprising in the Account of Monsieur Reaumur 's late Memoir , read in the Royal Academy of Sciences there , concerning an Animal called a Polypus , in which Life is said to be preserved , after it has been cut into several Pieces , so that One Animal seems by Section to be immediately divided into Two or Three more complete Animals , each separately enjoying Life , and continuing to perform the proper Offices of its Species .
Read Nov. 25 .
1742 .
Such an Account would have been less regarded , had we not been informed before , that Two * Letters had been communicated to the ROYALSOCIET Y , some Months since , from good Hands , both which mentioned the same thing , and related it as a Fact averred , and carefully examined , by one of the greatest Judges , and most indefatigable Promoters , of Natural History , and especially of that Part of it , which leads to the Knowledge of what is most particular and remarkable in the Insect and Reptile Part of the Creation .
Some of our Friends , who are firmly attached to the general Metaphysical Notions we have formerly learned , reason strongly against the very Possibility of such a Fact : but as I have myself for* See above p. 219 and 220 .
merly owned to you , on other Occasions , my Distrust of the Truth , or Certainty at least , of some of those Principles , which I never yet had a sufficient Understanding of , to give a full and clear Assent to ; I shall now make no Scruple of acknowledging , that I have already seen so many strange things in Nature , that I am become very diffident of all general Assertions , and very cautious in affirming , what may , or may not possibly be .
The most common Operations both of the Animal and Vegetable World are all in themselves astonishing ; and nothing but daily Experience , and constant Observation , makes us see , without Amazement , an Animal bring forth another of the same Kind ; or a Tree blossom , and bear Leaves and Fruit .
The same Observation , and daily Experience , make it also familiar to us , that besides the first Way of propagating Vegetables from their respective Fruit and Seed , they are also propagated from Cuttings ; and every one knows , that a Twig of a Willow particularly , cut off and only stuck into the Ground , does presently take Root and grow , and becomes as much a real and perfect Tree , as the original one from which it was first taken .
Here is then , in the Vegetable Kingdom , the very thing quite common , that Monsieur Reaumur 's Memoir is said to give a rare Example of in the Animal .
The best Philosophers have long observed very strong Analogies between these two Classes of Beings : and the Moderns , as they have penetrated further into Nature , have every Day found Reason to extend that Analogy : some have even with great Probability bility talked of a Scale of Nature , in which she , by an insensible Transition , passed from the most perfect of Animals , not only to the most imperfect , and thence to the most imperfect of Vegetables , but even through Coralline Bodies , and Minerals , to the very Earths and Stones , which seem the most inanimate Parts of our Globe .
Now in such a Scale , who is the Man that will be bold to say , Just here Animal Life entirely ends , and here Vegetable Life begins ?
Or , Just thus far , and no further , one sort of Operations goes , and just here another sort quite different takes its Place ?
Or , again , Who will venture to say , Life in every Animal is a Thing absolutely different from that which we dignify by the same Name in every Vegetable ?
And might not a Man even be excused , if he should modestly doubt , whether Plants and Vegetables may not themselves be considered as a very low and imperfect Tribe of Animals ; as Animals might , in like manner , be considered as a more perfect and exalted kind of Vegetables ?
We see the Two Sexes of Male and Female run through all the higher Parts of the Animal Creation ; yet would he have gone a great deal too far , who should have thence asserted , there were no Exceptions to this general Oeconomy ; or that this was one of the general and distinguishing Affections of all the Animal Kind : For modern Discoveries have informed us , that there is somewhat very analogous to this in the Vegetable Creation also : And even in the Animal it has been found , that Snails , Earth-worms , and some others , are really Hermaphrodites , having in themselves the Organs of both Sexes ; whilst the working ing Bee is truly of no Sex at all , nor any-ways employed in the Production of that Species , it labours so hard daily to provide with Food .
But , whereas , in Animals , the Division of the Sexes is almost general ; and the Union of them in one Subject appears but in a few Instances ; contrariwise , in Vegetables , almost all have the whole Apparatus of Generation in each Individual , whilst only a few Sorts seem to emulate Animals in what is analogous to the Division of them .
I seem , perhaps , to wander too much from the Point first-mentioned ; but as I am only offering loose Hints , and such wild Conjectures as come in my Way , hope to be excused , though I yet hazard another Observation , which is , That what appears chiefly to be new , in the Subject of this Memoir , is , that the Animal or Animals live and do well after their Separation , and that they are capable of re-producing such Parts as the Head and the Tail , which seemed essentially wanting .
I say , that the Animal 's living and doing well again , is what is chiefly new ; for that an Animal , after Separation of some of the principal Parts , seems for some time to retain Life in each Part , must have been observed by every body * ; and though People generally * The Ancients have taken Notice of this , and some even seem to have had no doubt , that Life continued some time in the Parts of a divided Insect .
Aristotle observes in the Fourth Book of his History of Animals , that almost all Insects live some time when pulled asunder , Wasps particularly ; and that those live longest , when so separated , which have a long Body , and many Feet ; so that the Scolopendra being cut asunder , one Part moves on forwards , and the other backwards .
But a rally say , from their Prejudice in favour of some of the Principles above hinted at , that to be sure only one of the Parts , though they know not always which , feels and has the Sensation of Pain ; yet have all I have ever talked with on the Subject , as freely acknowledged , that the Phenomenon appeared on the other Side .
A Chicken , or a Pigeon , whose Head is suddenly struck off , shows in both Parts , if no preconceived Opinion led us to think otherwise , strong Signs of Pain and Suffering , and the very same Signs , that the respective Parts of the Animal show of that Sensation , whilst it is surely living and entire : And I have been told by some , who have seen the Heads of Malefactors suddenly severed from their Bodies , that the same Observation holds also in our own Species .
But we have all seen it hold much stronger in the more imPassage of St. Austin is so remarkable on this Head , that I cannot help transcribing it : Me revocat quod his hausi oculis ... ... Cum enim nuper in agro essemus Liguriae , nostri illi Adolescentes , qui tunc mecum erant studiorum suorum gratia , animadverterunt humi jacentes in opaco loco reptantem bestiolam multipedem , longum dico quemdam vermiculum : vulgo notus est ; hoc iamen quod dicam nunquam in eo expertus eram ; ver so namque stylo , quem forte habebat , unus illorum animal medium percussit : tum ambae parts corporis ab illo vulnere in contraria discesserunt , tanta pedum celeritate , ac nihilo imbecilliore nisu , quam si duo hujuscemodi animantia forent .
Quo miraculo exterriti , caussaeque curiosi , ad nos , ubi simul ego ~ Alypius considebamus , alacriter viventia illa frusta detulerunt .
Neque nos parum commoti , ea currere in tabula quaquaversum poterant , cernebamus ; atque unum ipsorum , stylo tactum , contorquebat se ad doloris locum , nihil sentiente alio , ac suos alibi motus peragente .
Quid plura ?
Tentavimus quatenus id valeret ; atque vermiculum , imo jam vermiculos , in multas parts concidimus : ita omnes movebantur , ut nisi a nobis illud factum esset , ~ comparerent vulnera recentia , totidem illos separatim natos , ac sibi quenquam vixisse crederemus .
Aug. Lib. de Quantitate Animae .
perfect Animals , as they are commonly called , such as Worms , where , on the Separation of the Body into two Parts , Life has continued seemingly in both , and with strong Signs of it , longer than we have had the Patience to attend and examine .
We have been , indeed , quite uncertain , in which of the Parts this seeming Life has been most conspicuous : and as both Parts have seemed to endeavour to get away , and have frequently soon after been found missing , Boys and ordinary People are generally possessed of an Opinion , that they unite and grow together again after their Separation .
Now , if it could once be allowed , that Animal Life and Sensation might subsist but an Instant , in both Parts of the Creature , after its Section ; the whole remaining Difficulty would be only as to the Cure of the Wounds , and the Reproduction of the necessary Organs that are wanting .
And , for the first of these , we know very well , that the more imperfect Animals are killed with much greater Difficulty than the more perfect , their Vitals being more diffused , and their general Organization being , I suppose , far more simple than that of the higher Tribes : And as to the other , I think no one will see any Impossibility in the Reproduction of certain Parts , after what we have seen and read of , in the Lobster and Cray-fish Kinds , who when they chance by any Misfortune to lose a Claw , reproduce it in a short time , with all its Joints , and the proper Muscles for moving them ; all which appears as difficult as the regaining of a Mouth and a Tail to some of the Worm-kind ; whose general Organization being simple , and consisting chiefly of only one strait Gut , or Passage , from the Mouth to the Vent , they seem to want little more to reproduce either , than a Contraction of the Wound , with the Assistance of the Muscles that move the several Rings of which the Body is composed ; and every one of which , in its first and natural State , performs almost the same Motions as are necessary for Suction or Ejection : the latter of which we have even sometimes seen very wonderfully supplied in our own Species , in those Cases , where grievous Wounds of the Intestines have put Nature upon trying to perform her Operations in a new Way .
Upon the Whole , we are all very desirous to see Monsieur Reaumur 's Memoir on this curious Subject ; we hope it will soon be published , when , as his curious and exact Experiments will afford infinite Entertainment , so his judicious Remarks upon them will doubtless be no less instructive ; but will , in all Probability , give a Light into these Matters we do not yet think of .
In the mean time I could not help just mentioning to you , what came into my own Head on the Occasion , hoping that however you may look on my Thoughts as the Dreams , perhaps , of a Man bewildered in his Inquiries into Nature , you will still believe me to be a firm and constant Lover of Truth , and ready at all times to receive and embrace whatever is really such , however odd and surprising it may at the first chance to appear .
I shall therefore only add one or two Facts I should indeed have mentioned before , when I was speaking of the Difficulty of killing some of the Tribes of Insects and Reptiles ; which are , that I have myself seen the Heart of a Viper continue its regular Beats more than Six Hours after it had been taken out of the Body : That I have seen that Body move and seem alive to all Purposes for a great Part of the same time , after having lost the Heart ; and that I have seen Wasps , whose Heads had been taken off , creeping in the Window the next Day ; and Butterflies that have lived , and attempted even to fly , several Days after undergoing the same severe Operation .
Insects seem at first to suffer but little from the Loss of their hinder Parts , although these contain most of their Viscera ; nor does the Loss of Limbs seem to affect them in any Proportion to the more perfect Animals .
But even in our own Kind , in Infancy , before the Parts have lost all their Softness , much greater Wounds may be received without Loss of Life , than afterwards .
If we go yet further back to our Embryo State , it is very probable , that yet vastly greater Hurts are recoverable : And it is upon that Principle chiefly , that the best and most likely Account has been given by modern Writers in Anatomy , of some very remarkable Monsters that have appeared in the World , where even some of the most essential Parts of Two Faetus 's have been seen wonderfully united in One and the same Body .
I shall now detain you no longer , than to assure you , that I am , with Truth and Respect , SIR , Your most obedient , Humble Servant , &amp;c.

