XI .
An Account of Margaret Cutting , a young Woman , now living at Wickham Market in Suffolk , who speaks readily and intelligibly , though she has lost her Tongue .
A Brief Account of this young Woman 's Case , in a Letter from Mr. Benjamin Boddington , of Ipswich , Turkey-Merchant , to Mr. Henry Baker , F. R. S. was communicated to the ROYALSOCIETY in the Month of February last , and appeared so extraordinary , that Mr. Baker was desired to make all possible Inquiries into the Reality of the Fact , and lay before the SOCIETY what Information he should receive in relation thereto .
Read July 1 .
1742 .
In pursuance of this , he wrote to Mr. Boddington , and begged the Favour of him to make the strictest and most critical Inquiry he was able into this Affair , not only by viewing the young Woman 's Mouth , and examining her himself , but also by calling to his Assistance some skilful Gentleman in the Physical Way , and any other learned and judicious Person whom he might judge most likely to contribute towards discovering the real Truth , and detecting any Error , Fallacy , or Imposition .
He likewise desired they would heedfully observe her Manner of speaking and articulating the Sounds of those Letters and Syllables , in the Formation whereof the Apex of the Tongue seems more particularly needful : And , in order to render their Examination more easy , as well as more satisfactory , he sent a List of Letters and Sounds , together with several such Sentences as he imagined would be most difficult to be pronounced without the Help of the Tongue .
Mr. Boddington , as soon after this as their Affairs would give them Leave , prevailed upon Mr. Notcutt , a Minister , a learned and curious Gentleman , and Mr. Hammond , who perfectly understands Anatomy , to accompany him to Wickham Market , about Twelve Miles from Ipswich , where the young Woman lives ; whose Case ( after they had inspected her Mouth , and examined her in the strictest Manner ) is set forth in the following Certificate signed by them all .
Ipswich , April 9 .
1742 .
WE have this Day been at Wickham Market , to satisfy our Curiosity concerning Margaret Cutting , a young Woman , who , we were informed , could talk and discourse without a Tongue .
She informed us , that she was now more than Twenty Years of Age , born at Turnstal , a Village within Four Miles of Wickham Market in Suffolk , where she lost her Tongue by a Cancer [ being then about Four Years old ] .
It first appeared like a small black Speck on the upper Superficies of the Tongue , and soon eat its Way quite to the Root of it .
She was under the Care of Mr. Scotchmore , a Surgeon of Saxmundham , who soon pronounced the Case incurable : However , he continued using the best Means he could for her Relief .
One Day when he was Syringing of it , the Tongue dropped out , and they received it into a Plate , the Girl , to their Amazement , saying to her Mother , ` ` Do n't be frighted , Mamma ; 'twill grow again .
' ' It was near a Quarter of a Year after , before it was quite cured .
We proceeded to examine her Mouth with the greatest Exactness we could , but found not the least Appearance of any remaining Part of a Tongue , nor was there any Uvula .
We observed a fleshy Excrescence on the under Left Jaw , extending itself almost to the Place where the Uvula should be , about a Finger broad : This Excrescence , she said , did not begin to grow till some Years after the Cure : It is by no means moveable , but quite fixed to the Parts adjacent .
The Passage down the Throat , at the Place where the Uvula should be , or a little to the Right of it , is a circular open Hole , large enough to admit a small Nutmeg .
Notwithstanding the want of so necessary an Organ as the Tongue was generally supposed to be , to form a great Part of our Speech , and likewise to be assisting in Deglutition , to our great Admiration , she performed the Office of Deglutition , both in swallowing Solids and Fluids , as well as we could , and in the same manner : And as to Speech , she discoursed as fluently and well as other Persons do ; though we observed a small Sound , like what is usually called speaking through the Nose ; but , she said , she had then a great Cold , and she believed that occasioned it .
She pronounced Letters and Syllables very articulately ; the Vowels she pronounced perfectly , as also those Consonants , Syllables , and Words , that seemed necessary to require the Help of the Tongue , as * d , l , t , n , r , at , al , ath , ash , cha , la , ta , ja .
The little Dog did not eat Bread.-Touch the Tooth .
-Try to light the Candle .
Thrice Thirtythree .
Let the large Cat scratch the little Dog .
The Church .
doth .
Lilly .
All these she pronounced perfectly .
She read to us in a Book very distinctly and plain ; only we observed , that sometimes she pronounced words ending in ath as et end as embad as eib - ; but it required a nice and strict Attention to observe even this Difference of Sound .
She sings very prettily , and pronounced her Words in Singing as is common .
What is still very wonderful , notwithstanding the Loss of this useful Organ the Tongue , which is generally allowed by Anatomists , and Natural Philosophers , to be the chief , if not the sole Organ of Taste , she distinguishes all Tastes very nicely , and can tell the least perceivable Difference in either Smell or Taste .
We the Underwritten do attest the above to be a true Account .
Benjamin Boddington .
William Notcutt , Minister .
William Hammond , Apothecary .
Mr. Baker received along with the foregoing Certificate , by Letter from Mr. Boddington , some farther Particulars , which he supposed less material .
He says , in her Person she is a little thin Body , genteel * These were the Letters , Sounds and Sentences mentioned by Mr. Baker .
enough , a pretty good Face , fair Complexion , with light-brown Hair , of a weakly Constitution , lame on one Side , through Weakness after a Fever and the Small-pox , which she had last Summer .
She seems a well-behaved Girl , and has nothing of a Country Mien .
She discourses agreeably , very fluently and pertinently , has every thing clean and neat about her , gets her Livelihood by making Mantuas , and has an Aunt in London , named Mary Cutting , who is Housekeeper to the Dowager Lady Rochford in Bondstreet .
He says , if she were among Twenty People in a Room , he thinks it would be impossible for a Stranger by any means to guess her being the Person without a Tongue , for she has no odd Motion of her Mouth or Lips in Speaking : She sings with an easy Air , and modulates her Voice prettily .
He asked her , if she did not miss her Tongue , or find any Inconvenience from the Want of it ?
She answered , No : Not in the least ; nor could she imagine what Advantage he had in the Use of his .
He inquired , how she did to guide her Food in her Mouth to eat : She replied , very easily , she could eat before , on one Side or the other as she pleased , but could not explain the Manner how .
He was very observing to see her eat , but could discern no Difference from others in the moving of her Jaws , or other Motions of her Face , nor in her swallowing Food , or in drinking ; she did both very neatly , and had exactly the same Motion in her Throat as we have in its passing down .
He was apprehensive the Excrescence mentioned in the Certificate , might , in some measure , supply the Use of a Tongue ; but she assured him , it never .
moved in the least , and that she spoke as well before it began to grow ( which was several Years after the Cure ) ; and Mr. Hammond convinced him , by trying with their Fingers and a Spoon , that it was quite fixed and immovable .-He observes further , that she is no ways assisted by a good Set of Teeth ; for she has but few , those bad , and scarce so high as her Gums.--He asked her , in what Part of her Mouth her most sensible Taste lay ?
She said , it was all over alike ; and , smiling , added , She was afraid she was too nice in that ; for , if her Butter was not curious , she eat dry Bread .
Mr. Boddington , in another Letter to Mr. James Theobald , F. R. S. dated the 14th of April 1742 .
after giving an Account of this young Woman in the Manner as before , adds , He can recollect nothing more , except her telling him , that though she was able to speak from the very first losing of her Tongue , she was not so happy as to her Deglutition ; for she was unable to swallow any thing solid for many Months after , without its being minced very fine , and then thrust into her Throat by a Finger : But by degrees , she knows not how , she became able to manage without that Help , and could eat any thing in the same manner as other Persons can.-He adds , That , in his own Mind , he thinks the fleshy Excrescence is of great Service to her , though she cannot make out in what manner : That for his own part , he had formerly supposed it as impossible to speak without a Tongue , as to see without Eyes ; and therefore expects many , who shall hear this Account , will continue Unbelievers , and think he and his Friends are all mistaken , that they do not know what they see , and that their Ignorance is the only Ground of their Admiration .
While Mr. Baker was making his Inquiries , he was informed , that Mr. John Dennis , Tobacconist , in Aldersgate-street , could give him a full and satisFactory Account of this Affair : He therefore applied to Mr. Dennis , who assured him in a very civil , candid and intelligent Manner , that he was well acquainted with Margaret Cutting , having many Years ago been carried by a Gentleman to see her as a prodigy for being able to speak without a Tongue : That he had seen her several times since , commonly calling on her when he travels that Way , and carrying some Friend or other with him ; and at all these times he had inspected her Mouth , and was sure she had no Tongue : And that last Summer , in particular , he and another went to see her : That he would declare this under his Hand , and should always be ready to attest the Truth of it to any Body , or in any Manner .
He likewise gave an Account how she lost her Tongue , as he had it from her Mother , who died some Years ago , and it was exactly as above related ; and said he had been told the same by an Apothecary also , who had her in Hand along with Dr. Scotchmore .
The Testimony of Mr. Dennis , and the Person who saw her with him last Summer , is as follows : March 20 .
1741 .
WE the under-written saw Margaret Cutting , at Wickham Market in Suffolk , in or about June last ; and , examining her Mouth , found she had no Tongue , and yet she speaks very intelligibly .
John Dennis .
Gabriel Daniells .
MYself saw her in about Two or Three Years after her Tongue was lost , had a full Account of it from her Mother , heard her then speak , and have seen and heard her divers times since , and heard her talk better and better .
She was under the Care of Dr. Scotchmore at Saxmundham , Suffolk .
John Dennis .
Mr. Dennis ( upon Mr. Baker 's Inquiry ) wrote to the young Woman herself , acquainting her , that many People would not believe it possible for her to speak without a Tongue , and desiring she would not be ashamed to give an Account of herself under her own Hand ; in Answer to which he received the following Letter : To Mr. John Dennis , in Aldersgate-street .
Sir , THIS being the first Opportunity that I had to answer your Letter , I assure you , that I have no more Tongue in my Mouth than I had when you saw me last , which is none ; but , Thanks be to my GO D , I have had the Happiness to speak ever since it came out , which was when I was about Four Years old .
As for my Age now , I cannot rightly tell , but I think I am about Twenty-four Years old .
I would have none suspect the Truth of it ; for I have no Tongue , and can speak very well , and this is from my own Hand .
I was not ashamed to write about myself , but of my bad Writing .
So no more , but I am Your humble Servant , Margaret Cutting .
The Case of this young Woman is indeed extraordinary * ; but there are several Examples of like Nature to be met with in medical Writers , and those of the greatest Authority ; one of which , as it has the Attestation of a whole University , cannot be improper to mention here .
Monsieur Drelincourt , a very noted Physician , tells us , in his Treatise on the Small-pox , of a Child Eight Years of Age , who had lost his Tongue by that Distemper , and was yet able to speak , to the Astonishment of the University of Saumur in France ; and that the University ( who doubtless had first carefully examined into the Truth ) had attested it , by drawing up a particular Account of the Fact , that Posterity might have no room to doubt concerning the Validity of it .
The Account is to be met with at large , in the Third Volume of the Ephemerides Germanicae , under the Title of Aglossostomographia .
Tulpius too makes mention of a Man who had the Misfortune to have his Tongue cut out by the Turks , and yet , after Three Years , could speak very distinctly .
He says , he went himself to Wesop , a Town in Holland , to be satisfied of the Truth of it , and found it to be as it was reported .
Nay , he does not so much as mention any Defect in his Speech , but assures us , that he could pronounce those Letters which depend upon the Apex of the Tongue , even the Consonants , very articulately .
And this Case is still the more worthy Attention , because the Patient could not swallow even the least Quantity of Food , unless he thrust it into the Oesophagus by means of his Finger .
* N. B. All the original Papers are in the Repository of the Royal Society .
If we go back to earlier Times , the Emperor Justin , in Cod .
Tit .
de Off .
Praef .
Praet .
Af .
says , he had seen venerable Men , qui abscissis radicitus Linguis , paenas miserabiliter loquebantur , whose Tongues having been cut out by the Roots , they miserably SPOKE , or complained , of the Punishments they had suffered .
And again , Nonnullos alios , quibus Honorichius Vandalorum Rex Linguas radicitus praeciderat , loquelam tamen habuisse integram , that some others , whose Tongues Honorichius , King of the Vandals , had cut out by the Roots , yet perfectly retained their Speech .

