X. An Account , by Mr. John Eames , F. R. S. of a Book entitled , Jacobi Theodori Klein Historiae Piscium Naturalis promovendae Missus primus Gedani , 1740 .
4to .
Or , The first Number of An Essay towards promoting the Natural History of Fishes , by Mr. Klein , Secretary of Dantzick , and F. R. S. ALthough the Natural History of Animals has been vastly improved , since several of the worthy Members of the ROYAL SOCIET Y , both at Home and Abroad , have taken it under their Consideration ; yet there still remain some things to be known , in order to render it full and complete .
As particularly , concerning the Hearing of Fishes , it is remarked , that in no Fishes beside the Cetaceous Kind , have hitherto been found any Auditory Passages , or Ear-holes ; and whether all Fish hear or no , is a Question not yet fully determined , notwithstanding the Experiments alleged to prove the Affirmative .
D2 It is Read Feb. 4 .
Tis with this View , and in order to set this Matter in a clearer Light , the ingenious Author has obliged the World with the Book before us .
It consists of a Dedication addressed to this Honourable SOCIET Y , a Preface , an Essay , and a double Appendix .
The Preface begins with acquainting us , what he means by Fishes , and defines them so , as to exclude several Tribes , that have been commonly taken for such by the Ancients .
Pisces dicimus Animalia ( says he ) apoda pinnis natantia ; and adds in his Annotation upon it , Ab hac definitione seclusa sunt Serpentium Genus , pinnis carens , Cancri , Astaci , Testacea ; Cochleae , Conchaeve ; imo Amphibia , sive Bipeda , ( ut Manati Clusii ) sive Quadrupedia , ut Phocae , &amp;c. Mr. Klein then ( waving the Consideration of the Cetaceous Kind , which are allow 'd by most Authors to have both Auditory Passages , and the Sense of Hearing ) proceeds to the main Question , viz. Whether the Cartilaginous and Spinose kinds of Fishes are endued with the Sense of Hearing ; or have any Organs or Auditory Passages for that Purpose .
He gives us the Sentiments of the Ancients and Moderns , by producing a Variety of Quotations , both pro and con .
out of their Works ; from whence ( says he ) it appears , that though some of them were dubious , yet many of them agree , that Fishes do hear ; nevertheless , none of them were fully satisfied , by what Part , or Ways , they had this Sensation produced .
And though Julius Casserius Placentinus found out some little Bones in the Head of the Pike or Jack , which he looked upon to be the Organs of Hearing , yet he could not discover any manifest external Auditory Passages .
In fine , from a diligent Inquiry into , and Consideration of all , that hath been said from Reason and Experience on both sides the Question , our curious Author determines us in favour of the Affirmative ; and says , That Fishes not only have Organs of Hearing , but also Passages , ( though they are difficult in many Species of them to be demonstrated ) by means of which a tremulous Motion is communicated to these Organs .
Nor does he think the Water in which they live , any Impediment , but rather the Medium , ( or , as he calls it , the Intermedium ) by which Sound is communicated to them : As a Man shut up in one Room , will hear and understand what is said in another , notwithstanding the Interposition of a Party-wall .
Our ingenious Author then proceeds to his Essay , wherein he considers what Parts in the Head of Fish serve for the Organ of Hearing , and by what Passages a tremulous Motion producing this Sensation may arrive at them .
This Part of his Treatise he styles , De Lapillis , eorumque Numero in Craniis Piscium .
These little Bones , sometimes called Ossicula , or little Bones , Mr. Klein looks upon , and accordingly considers , as constituent or essential Parts in the Heads of Fish , and generated with the Brain itself .
They differ ( he says ) in Magnitude , according to the different Size or Bulk of the Fish to which they respectively belong , and are easiest to be discovered in Heads of the Spinose Kind .
There are in all kinds of Fish three Pair of them ; the first are the two largest Bones , and are easily enough found ; but the greatest Difficulty lies in discovering the other two Pair , which are small , and lie enveloped in distinct little Bags , or a fine sort of Membrane .
These he takes to be the Auditory Organs , and answer to the Incus , Malleus , and Stapes , in other Animals : And he thinks by a diligent and careful Inspection , we might determine the Age of Fishes , by the Number and Thickness of the Laminae and Fibres of these Bones , as we can the Age or Growth of a Tree , by the Number of Circles in the woody Part of its Trunk .
The Passages by which a tremulous Motion producing the Sense of Hearing , may arrive at these Auditory Organs , are what our Author next inquires after ; and he produces first a Specimen in the Spinose Kind , viz. in a Jack or Pike ; and upon Inspection into the Head of this Fish , he observes several Holes , which , by means of Hogs Bristles , he finds lead directly to these Auditory Bones before described .
In dissecting the Head of a Sturgeon , ( as a Specimen of the Cartilaginous Kind ) he traced the Auditory Duct as far as the Membranous Body in which the three Pair of little Bones are placed .
But as our curious Author has obliged us with an exact Delineation of these Auditory Ducts or Passages , as well as the Figures of a Variety of those Lapilli or Ossicula , from different sorts of Fish , on several Copper Plates , to these I must refer , for a more satisfactory Idea than can possibly be given in Words .
We therefore proceed to the first Appendix , which entertains us with the Anatomy of a Porpess .
This Fish our Author in the Title Page styles Tersio , the usual Name for it in Pliny ; but he calls it Phocaena in the Appendix , the Name used for it by Aristotle .
It is ranked amongst the Cetaceous Kind , and is the smallest Fish in that Tribe , seldom exceeding five Feet in Length ; in which it differs from Dolphins , ( amongst which Species it has by some been improperly reckoned ) for they often exceed ten Feet in Length .
The Snout also of the Dolphin is much larger than in the Porpess , which is another thing sufficient to distinguish them .
It would be needless here to give a Detail of the Anatomy of this Animal , which is so largely done by Dr. Tyson in his Phocaena .
I shall therefore only take Notice of some Remarks made by our Author upon the Dissection of a Porpess , by the accurate Hand of Dr. De la Motte , at Mr. Klein 's Request .
In the first Place , the Meatus Auditorius was found by both to be two Inches distant from the exterior Canthus of the Eye , forming a very small Hole ( lest the Water getting in might prove an Inconvenience to it ) .
He then gives us an Account of the Os Petrosum , and other Auditory Organs , with curious Figures of them ; in order to correct Mr. Ray , who in Philosophical Transactions , n. 76 .
p. 2278 .
says , We observed not in this Fish any Ear-holes or Meatus Auditorii at all , wherein also Aristotle agrees with us .
A second Remark is , that though the Porpess has no Vesicula fellea or Gall-bag , ( and from thence most Authors have been induced to believe no Gall ) yet Dr. De la Motte , upon a more exact Scrutiny , finds a Duct that arises with a great Number of Branches in the Liver , and tending downwards , joins itself to the Pancreatic Duct ; and these two , so united together , form a Canal or common Duct , about four or five Lines long , before they discharge their Contents into the Duodenum .
From whence it appears , ( says Dr. De la Motte ) that the Porpess has always a Discharge of Bile into the Duodenum , though it is but thin and diluted , and such as in other Animals is usually called Hepatic Bile .
In dissecting the Os Petrosum , several Worms were found : Some of these Mr. Klein has presented us with a Figure of , as also of the Parts of Generation proper to the Male Porpess , and lastly the Thoracic Duct in its natural Dimensions .
Our ingenious Author concludes with some Observations made on the Heads of two Raiae of an uncommon Species , and which he says are no-where described .
He gives us the Figures of the Auditory Organs , with the Jaw of one of these Fish very accurately depicted in his with Table .
And having considered the Auditory Organs , with the Seat of them both , in the Cetaceous , Cartilaginous , and Spinose Kinds of Fishes , it appears , says our ingenious Author , that these Lapilli or Ossicula differ from one another both in Structure and Substance ; for in Cetaceous Fishes , whose Skeletons are truly bony , and which , in certain respects , may be compared to truly Lignous Trees , both the Os Petrosum , and Auditory Organs , are in these , as in other Animals , perfectly osseous or bony : Whereas the Cartilaginous Fish , whose Skeletons are Elastic and Cartilaginous , they may be compared to the Keratophyta Species of Sea-Plants ; and these Fish , instead of an Os Petrosum , have something analogous , but cartilaginous ; and the Auditory Bones are of a tartareous kind of friable and easily macerable Substance .

