III .
A Discourse concerning the Difficulty of curing Fluxes , writ occasionally on reading Dr. de Jussieu 's Memoir in the History , &amp;c. of the Royal Academy of Sciences in Paris , for the Year 1729 .
By William Cockburn , M. D. F. R. S. and of the College of Physicians , London .
IN reading Dr. de Jussieu 's Memoir , about the present Disgrace of Ipecacuanha in France , and the Method he proposes for redressing its Defects by Simarouba , a Root brought from Cayen in America , I was surprised to find a Remedy almost adored for half a Century , to have fallen into the utmost Contempt ; a Specific , a very short and satisfactory Word , totally neglected by its most zealous Votaries .
The learned Professor alleges , that this great Revolution , in the Fame of Ipecacuanha , proceeds from its having been unskilfully administred : Physicians commonly considering the general Appearance of a Looseness only , without penetrating into the particular Causes which support it , and that require , on that Account , different Methods of curing it .
Mons. de Jussieu , avoiding all Extremes , is an Enemy to the banishing Ipecacuanha altogether out of the Practice of Physic , as many of its disappointed Adorers now do ; because it is not the infallible Specific they vainly imagined it to be .
This common Misapplication of Medicines , or our Ignorance of the particular Circumstances of a Disease , when it requires a different Method of Cure , is the very Reason why great Numbers of excellent Medicines , cines , among ancient Physicians , have been lost , because they were not understood .
Take a broken Shin only , which has the Skin only rubbed off , observe the Difficulty the best and honestest Surgeons have to cure it .
Go to Aetius , and others , where you may find a safe , easy and speedy Cure ; which , as the same Author on another Occasion observes , the People make Slight of , because they do not know the Danger or Trouble that often attend it .
A Looseness is more liable to be mistaken than the greatest Number of other Diseases ; because it is produced by two immediate Causes that are very different , when the rest have one Cause only , however great the Diversity of particular Cases may appear to be .
A Fever , viz. has but one Cause , tho ' the Variety of Fevers , or the various Appearances of a Fever are infinite , and never can be classed by Observation , I shall therefore consider the different Circumstances of a Looseness observed by Dr. de Jussieu , and that occasion the Misapplication of Ipecacuanha ; but I shall afterwards endeavour to make his Account more perfect ; for thereby Physicians will be able to have more perfect Intentions and Views of Curing than hitherto they have had .
When great Crudities , says the Doctor , and indigested Stuff in the first Passages , or an Obstruction in the Bowels of the lower Belly are the Cause of a Looseness , we may always expect the common good Effects of the Ipecacuanha for a Cure .
On the contrary , when Ipecacuanha is given against an Hepatick Dysentery , or against a great Discharge of Blood upwards or downwards , often occasioned by a purging Medicine that was given for a Cure of the Looseness , no Success can reasonably be expected from the Specific , far less have we any Hopes , when Ipecacuanha is given for the Cure of a Looseness that subsifts on an Inflammation of the lower Belly ; or when sharp and fixed Pains give us a Suspicion that the Dysentery has a cancerous Ulcer for its Cause .
As there is no Difficulty that is peculiar to a Dysentery , and is not common with the Dangers of a Diarrhea , the Terror of Blood not excepted , it must be acknowledged that any Vomit as well as Ipecucuanha , is a proper Cure against Indigestions and Crudities in the Stomach , as Hippocrates anciently observed , and has been believed by all Physicians since his Time : So that there is nothing in the French Specific that is not in Salt of Vitriol ; which we find held its Reputation , in curing Dysenteries , longer than Ipecacuanha is like to do .
It is more wonderful that this Way of Curing a Looseness by Ipecacuanha was not sooner determined .
Nothing besides the lazy Talk of a Specific , that excludes all Reasoning and Reflection , could have made Men easy under so gross Ignorance .
The very Instance given us by the late excellent Dr. Tournefort , in the Case of his Tutor Petrus Sylvanus , is a sufficient Proof that Ipecacuanha is no Charm of a Specific , but that it cures by its Evacuating : For , when the Weakness of Sylvanus made them cautious in administring the Specific , the Disease held its Ground against the Charm , and its Adorers , 'till Despair drove the Physician upon larger Doses , the last Resort of the Vanquished , and they produced Evacuations by Vomit and Stool , and thereby his Health in one Night It would be superfluous to observe upon what is said about the Simarouba , and how far it may remedy the Defects of Ipecacuanha , the Trials of it being few , not sufficient to determine the Universality of its Use .
Far less shall I enquire , whether the West-India Plant has any relation to the Macir from the East-Indies , mentioned by Pliny * ; though I wish Dr. de Jussieu had prepared the Simarouba with Honey , since the great Cures , recorded by Pliny , by the Macir might be assisted by its being prepared in that Way .
I shall then proceed , and make the foregoing Account more perfect , and more obvious , better fitted to fix the Views of Physicians , in the Point they are to pursue .
For this Purpose , I shall give a plain Account of the several Species of a Looseness , and in each of them apply the different Kind of Remedies employed for the Cure of them .
Thus we shall perceive the proper Administration for every Looseness , and how far any of them is left without a Cure .
The Anatomy of the Guts alone , informs us , that the immediate Cause of every Looseness , whether it by Symptomatic or Essential , must either be a quicker Conveyance of the common Quantity of concocted Food , and of the Liquors that are commonly mixed with it in the Guts .
Or the Cause of a Looseness is a greater Secretion than ordinary , of a watery Substance from the Blood into the Guts , and brought into them by the Pancreas , and various other Glands .
In both which Cases there must needs be a larger Discharge of liquid Excrements , by Stool , than usual , or there must be a Looseness .
A Looseness produced by the first of these Causes , admits of great Variety ; both on the Account of the different * Hist. Natur .
lib. xii .
different Stimuli , and even from the different Degrees of the Stimulus in each of them .
The Stimulus , viz. of indigested Food , Fruits , and the like , differs very much from the Stimulus of Gall .
The first Sort is confined to the Stomach and Intestines : In which Case , the Disease is often a Cure to it self ; whereas the Stimulus of Gall is greater , and the Cause is more permanent and seldom carries off it self .
The Degree of the Stimulus may be determined by some other concomitant Symptoms of Slime , Glaire , &amp;c. But when the Stimulus is occasioned by the Piles , an Ulcer , or a Stricture in the Guts , it is vastly more Violent , and much departs from the common Cure of a Looseness , whereby Physicians are often subjected to fatal Errors , and gross Misapplications of their Medicines .
The Watery Looseness produced by the other immediate Cause , is indeed deplorable ; because a Method of Curing it is not commonly known .
It is not only as a Principal , but it is a Second , in the Beginning , at the Ending , and in the intermediate Times of all other Diseases , and even in old Age , when Nature is submitting to the Power of Death ; when Physicians call it a Colliquative Looseness , because it seems to melt away the Flesh of the Sick .
* Petrus Salius Diversus , a most approved Physician , affirms it to be vain for a Physician to attempt the Cure of it .
Carolus Piso , who endeavours to explain it , and the most sagacious Laz .
Riverius , after trying all the common Methods , give us no better Hopes of a Cure .
It is now manifest why a Looseness , that in all outward Appearance is one and the same thing , and promises to submit to the same Remedy , is vastly different Fff in * Page .
188 , 189 .
lib. de Peste .
in the manner of Curing it .
Our Experience has contradicted our Belief , and the Remedy that has proved Effectual and Sufficient in one Case , has proved Ineffectual and Useless on other Occasions ; on which Account Remedies are very liable to be misapplied .
To prevent this Misfortune in a great Measure for the Future , I shall consider the Medicines commonly made use of by Physicians for the Cure of a Looseness ; and next , how they may most properly be adapted to that End : For thus we must perceive the particular Cases wherein they are like to be useful , and when they are not like to be of any use at all .
Astringents , or binding Medicines , were the first employed for the Cure of a Looseness , as well as of every other Evacuation : But Hippocrates observing that a Looseness was often the easiest cured when it was attended with Vomiting , Vomiting Medicines were introduced on that Account .
On a like Consideration , Purging Medicines were admitted by Celsus , because he found the Purging the Cure of itself ; or that the Looseness went off by going to Stool for a few Days : But he advises Physicians to take care that the Looseness does not run longer than seven Days , and that it is not attended with a Fever ; for in that case the Looseness is not Critical and Salutary , but Symptomatical , and hastens on the Ruin of the Sick .
All these Observations have not been found universally true in many other Countries ; for Caelius Aurelianus , a most accurate Observer of Diseases , Rhaza and Avicenna blame this free Use of Purging and Vomiting , and may be justified by what will be shown in the Progress of this Discourse .
But , now that we may apply this Artillery of Physicians against the two general Causes of all Loosenesses , we shall begin with the most ancient of the mentioned Methods , which was practised by Prodicus Selymbrianus , whose School was adorned by the divine Hippocrates .
Binding Medicines , as I lately observed , were employed for the Cure of every Evacuation , and are still the Refuge of Physicians when all other Methods have been baffled , under their own Conduct and Direction ; they tacitly have the Preference given them to all other Medicines ; for Instance , Ipecacuanha is preferred to any other Vomit , and Rhubarb to any other Purge , because they are more astringent than any other of the Tribe .
So far do Physicians extol the Power of Astringents , that many of them affirm , that by them any Looseness may be repressed , if they did not think it unseasonable or improper .
However , it may stand with these Boasters , it is very certain , that these Medicines only affect a Looseness occasioned by a Stimulus , and if this is small , the Looseness may be cured by it ; but if the Degree of the Stimulus is greater , the astringent Medicine is either not able to put a Stop to it , or it will tear the Sick with Gripes if it does .
It is on the same Account of the Stimulus , that a Vomit or a Purge is properly premised to other Medicines , if it consists with the Strength of the Sick ; but after all , the Store-house of Physicians seems to be exhausted in curing a Looseness that proceeds from Indigestion , or Gall ; but if the Stimulus is from the Piles , an Ulcer , or a Stricture in the Guts , Physicians are lost without any Remedy , and too frequentF ff2 lie lie have recourse to the Omnipotent Astringent , without any Success .
Here is a real Want , an Inability and Unskilfulness in our Work , and leaves too much room for misapplying Medicines .
But if we turn these Engines of Vomiting , Purging andBinding , upon the other general Cause of aLooseneis they either fall very short , or like a little Water thrown upon a great Fire , they rather inflame than extinguish it .
Hippocrates * indeed does not mention the Watery Looseness , but he says many things that peculiarly concern it ; which Foesius not understanding , blamed him for Obscurity in this Place .
Piso ~ gives a very plain Description of this Looseness , and his Observation is admitted by every succeeding Physician .
The desperate State of the Watery Looseness was formerly mentioned from the Confession of Authors of the greatest Knowledge and Veracity ; and Physicians shall for ever find that Looseness to become more violent the more you press it with Astringents , Vomits , or purging Medicines .
The boasted Omnipotency of putting a Stop to a Looseness at Pleasure , must serve another use with the Sick , though it may not be able to put the desired Stop to his Purging .
There is even a Singularity in the Cure of this Looseness which I think has not hitherto been observed .
In every other Kind of Looseness the Stools acquire a Consistence , when they begin to be cured ; but in the Watery Looseness , the Stools commonly lessen in Quantity though not in their Looseness .
I should say something of Opium , a Medicine often made use of for the Cure of every Kind of Looseness , * Coac .
Praenot , 134 .
Praedict .
81 .
~ Sect. IV .
cap. 1 .
Obs , 54 .
ness but as it neither acts as an Astringent , nor in a Way observed by Physicians , it must still remain among other Desiderata .

