A N M CD OF TP D C AB QP A Fig. 2 .
BN HC GE NOVTP Fig. 4 .
M CDS ILZIG WPZV M ~~ CDKKZy y A B O N M CD ~F P ~ ~H L W K y Conjectures upon the Nature of Intermitting and Reciprocating Springs .
By Mr. Joseph Atwell , F. R. S. BEFOREI offer the following Thoughts to the Consideration of the Society , I beg leave to premise something upon the Nature of Philosophical Conjectures in general , and the Sense in which I would be understood to propose these in particular .
A just and satisfactory Account of any one Phenomenon in Nature , cannot be expected without a true and perfect History of the Fact .
This is seldom to be met with : Those who live nearest the Place of any natural Curiosity , and have the best Opportunity of making proper Observations upon it , seldom regard what Time and Use have rendered familiar .
On the other hand , Strangers and Travellers , inclined to make a better Enquiry into Things of this Kind , are too often , if not always , in want of Time , as well as other Conveniences , for acquiring a due Knowledge of the Thing ; and therefore they content themselves with some slight Observations of their own , supplying the rest from the common , but generally fabulous , Reports of the Neighbourhood .
Add to this , that a strong Propensity in Mankind towards the Marvellous , with the Surprise usually attending uncommon Sights , often hinders Men from seeing Things in a true Light ; and even sometimes imposes upon them so far , as to make them report things under Circumstances absolutely false .
Every curious Person can , I believe , furnish himself with Instances of these Truths , from his own Observations compared with the Accounts of others : But notwithstanding so weak a Foundation for raising Philosophical Conjectures , they will still have their use , if they are not imposed upon the World for Accounts of things certain , to be entirely acquiesced in .
Let them be modestly offered as mere Hypotheses submitted to a farther Examination , and then their Consequences will be so many Particulars , which , being carefully examined and compared with the Phenomenon themselves , may serve to refute , correct , or confirm the said Hypotheses , from whence they were deduced .
It is in this Sense only , and with such a View , that I offer the following Conjectures upon the Subject of intermitting and reciprocating Springs .
For though these Thoughts were suggested to me by the Phenomenon of a particular Fountain , seen by my self this last Winter , yet I am sensible that my Observations made on it are very imperfect , in Comparison of what the Society may expect and I my self hope hereafter to give them : And as the Conjectures were framed chiefly for my own use , against another Opportunity of observing this Fountain more carefully ; so they are now communicated only for the use of others , who may perchance find such an Opportunity before me .
These Observations will however discover something of the Nature of this Spring not yet imparted to the Society , nor taken notice of by the Naturalists , so far as I know , in any other Spring whatsoever .
But since they are few , and imperfect , I shall be more particular in my Relation of them , that no greater Stress may be laid on them than they deserve .
The Spring is situated at one End of the Town of Brixam near Torbay in Devonshire , and is known by the Name of Laywell .
It is a long Mile distant from the Sea , upon the North and North-East Side of a Ridge of Hills lying between it and the Sea , and making a Turn or Angle near this Spring .
It is situated in the Side of those Hills , near the Bottom , and seems to have its Course from the South-West towards the North-East .
There is a constantly running Stream which discharges itself near one Corner into a Bason about eight Foot in Length , and four Foot and a half in Breadth ; the Outlet of which is at the farthest End from the Entrance of the Stream , about three Foot wide , and of a sufficient Height .
This I mention , that a better Judgment may be made of the perpendicular Rise of the Water in the Bason , at the time of the Flux or Increase of the Stream .
Upon the outside of the Bason are three other Springs , which always run , but with Streams subject to a like regular Increase and Decrease with the former .
They seem indeed only Branches of the former , or rather Channels discharging some Parts of the constantly running Water , which could not empty itself all into the Bason ; and therefore when by means of the Season , or Weather , Springs are large and high , upon the Flux or Increase of this Fountain several other little Springs are said to break forth , both in the Bottom of the Bason , and without it , which disappear again upon the Ebb or Decrease of the Fountain .
All the constantly running Streams put together , at the time that I saw them , were , I believe , more than sufficient to drive an Over-shut Mill ; and the Stream running into the Bason , might be about one half of the whole .
I had made a Journey purposely to see it , in Company with a Friend .
When we came to the Fountain , we were informed by a Man , working just by the Bason , that the Spring had flowed and ebbed about twenty times that Morning ; but had ceased doing so , about half an Hour before we came .
I observed the Stream running into the Bason , for more than an Hour by my Watch , without perceiving the least Variation in it or the least Alteration in the Height of the Surface of the Water in the Bason ; which we could observe with great Nicety , by means of a broad Stone laid in a shelving Position in the Water .
Thus disappointed , we were obliged to go and take some little Refreshment at our Inn ; after which we intended to come back and spend the rest of our Time by the Fountain , before we returned Home .
They told us in the Town , that many had been disappointed in this manner ; and the common People superstitiously imputed it to I know not what Influence which the Presence of some People had over the Fountain ; for which reason they advised , that in case it did not flow and ebb when we were both present , one of us should absent himself , to try whether it would do so in the Presence of the other .
Upon our Return to it , the Man , who was still at work , told us , that it began to flow and ebb about half an Hour after we went away , and had done so ten or twelve times .
In less than a Minute , we saw the Stream coming into the Bason , and likewise the others on the outside of the Bason , begin to increase and to flow with great Violence ; upon which the Surface of the Water in the Bason rose an Inch and a quarter perpendicularly , in near the Space of two Minutes : Immediately after which , the Stream began to abate again to its ordinary Course ; and in near two Minutes time the Surface was sunk down to its usual Height , where it remained near two Minutes more .
Then it began to flow again as before ; and in the Space of twenty-six Minutes flowed and ebbed five times : So that an Increase , Decrease and Pause , taken together , were made in about five Minutes , or a little more .
I could observe by the Mark upon the Stones , that the Surface of the Water in the Bason had rose before we came at least three Quarters of an Inch perpendicularly higher than when we saw it ; and I thought that I could perceive some very little Abatement each Turn , both in the Height , and in the Time of the rising of the Surface , and consequently in the Time of its sinking ; but the Time of the Pause , or standing of the Surface at its usual Height , or equable running of the Stream , was lengthened ; yet so , as to leave some Abatement in the time of the rising , sinking , and Pause taken together .
This is all which my short Time would allow me to observe ; many more things should have been taken notice of , as will appear from the Hypothesis proposed to explain these Phenomenon .
But before I enter upon explaining that Hypothesis , I must remark what Difference or Agreement is to be found between this Account of the Fountain , and another published in the Philos. Trans. Numb. 204 , p. 909 , 910 , in two Letters from Dr Oliver to Walter Moyle , Esq ; .
The Doctor places it a Mile and half from Brixam : I suppose he means BrixamQuay , which is more than a Mile off from the Town .
He gives , the Dimensions of the Bason a little different from mine , making the Surface of it thirty Foot square , whereas I make it thirty-six Foot .
He says , that it ebbs and flows very often every Hour ; which is certainly false , as appears both by common Report , and by my own Observation .
When it once begins indeed to flow and ebb , it continues to do so several times in an Hour ; but then there is after this again a certain Space of Time , perhaps two Hours or more , when it runs with an equable Stream , without any the least Variation : And this is a particular Circumstance not observed in any Spring whatsoever that I have heard of .
When the Doctor first saw it , viz. in July 1693 , he says that he judged the Flux and Reflux , as he calls them , to be performed in about two Minutes : If he means two Minutes each , it agrees very well with my own Observations ; but as he had neither Glass nor Minute Watch with him , this Observation cannot be depended on .
When he saw it again , viz. in August the same Year , he judged it to flow slower than before ; which he explains by saying , that though it performed its Flux and Reflux in little more than a Minute ( which by the way is quicker than before ) yet it would stand at the Low-Water Mark two or three Minutes ; which I suppose he calls flowing slower than before , because the Space of Time between the End of the Ebb , and the Beginning of the succeding Flux was longer .
I had never read this Account 'till lately ; long since my own Observations were made ; but , if we suppose the Doctor to have made his Observations somewhat nearer the Time when the Fountain was to cease ebbing and flowing , than I made mine , our Observations will perhaps exactly agree : The Time of the Flux and Reflux being shorter , the Time of the Pause longer , but the whole Time of the Flux , Reflux , and Pause taken together being shorter by his Account than by my own .
He says , that he found it by his Watch to flow and ebb sixteen times in an Hour : I do not suppose that he made a whole Hour 's Observations , which must have shown him a Difference in the Times of the Reciprocations that he did not perceive ; but having observed , that one Reciprocation , or a Flux , Reflux , and Pause , took up about the Space of four Minutes , he from thence computed , as I imagine , that there would be sixteen in an Hour , presuming that there was no Alteration in the Times .
In this Sense I would understand him , when he adds , that he was informed it sometimes flowed twenty Times in an Hour .
For , according to his Observations , it flowed at the rate of sixteen Times in a Hour ; according to my own Observations , at the rate of twelve Times in an Hour ; perhaps before my Observations at a less Rate , and after his at a greater : So that in the whole Hour , according to the several Rates taken together , it may flow and ebb about nine or ten Times , according to another Account which I have received ; but of this I can assert nothing certain , or upon my own Observations .
The Doctor adds , that when the Water in the Bason began to rise , he observed a Bubbling in the Bottom of the Bason , which ceased when the Water began to sink .
This I did not see , because the Springs were small and low , by means of a dry Season ; but it was confirmed to me by the Report of Eye-Witnesses , as is before observed .
Having thus compared the two Accounts given of this Fountain , I come now to my Hypothesis , for explaining the Phenomenon observed by me ; and I imagine them to be occasioned by two Streams or Springs , one of which passing through two Caverns or natural Reservoirs with Syphons , meets with the other Stream in a third Reservoir without a Syphon ; where being joined , they come out of the Earth together .
This complicated Piece of Machinery will be best understood by beginning with an Explanation of the more simple Parts first ; in doing of which , we shall have an Opportunity of considering some other Sorts of Fountains , which have already been observed , or may hereafter be found to be in Nature .
The Petitio Principii , or Supposition of Reservoirs and Syphons in the Bowels of the Earth , has been made by others : Pere Regnault , in his Phil. Conversations , Vol. 2 .
Conv .
6 .
p. 125 , &amp;c. Eng. Edit .
has mentioned it in general , and Dr. Desaguliers , in Phil. Trans. Numb. 384 , has attempted to apply it to two Cases in particular ; as Dechales , Tract .
xvii .
de Fontibus Naturalibus , &amp;c. Prop. xv .
had done in two other Cases before him .
Nor is it unnatural or hard to be granted .
Whosoever has seen the Peak of Derbyshire , the Hilly Parts of Wales , or other Countries , must be satisfied that they abound with Caverns of many sorts .
Some of them are dry , others serve only for Passages , or Channels to Streams , which run through them ; and a third Sort collect and hold Water , 'till they are full .
They must likewise have observed , that there are sometimes narrow Passages running between the Rocks which compose the Sides , and going from one Cavern to another .
Such a Passage , of whatsoever Shape or Dimensions , how crooked and winding soever in its Course , if it be but tight , and runs from the lower Part of the Cavern , first upwards to a less Height than that of the Cavern , and then downwards below the Mouth of the said Passage , will be a natural Syphon .
A natural Reservoir then , Tab. II .
Fig. 1 .
ABC D , with such a natural Syphon , MNP may be supposed .
Let a Stream , which I shall call the Feeding-Stream , enter it , near the Top at O. The said Cavern must contain all the Water which comes in at O , 'till it is filled to the Top of the Syphon at N. Then the Syphon beginning to play , and being supposed always to discharge more Water than comes in by the Feeding-Stream at O , will empty the Cavern , 'till the Water is sunk in it below the Mouth of the Syphon at M ; when it must must stop , 'till the Cavern is filled , and the Syphon runs again as before .
If the Water discharged by such a Syphon , MP be brought out of the Earth by a Channel P Q , the Water will flow out of the Earth , and stop alternately , making an intermitting Fountain at Q. By this plain and easy Contrivance , several of the flowing and ebbing Springs observed by the Naturalists , may probably be explained ; and even a much greater Variety of them than is hitherS s2 to to known .
For if the Feeding-Stream at O should arise only from the Rains in Winter , or from the melting of the Snow in Summer , the intermitting Fountain would become a temporary Spring , as Dr. Plot calls such Springs which are confined to a Season .
Or if the Feeding-Stream at O should be constant , but yet liable with other Springs to an Increase and Decrease arising from the Seasons , Weather , or other Causes , the Construction of the Syphon would make a great Alteration .
For when the Syphon is so made , that its Discharge ( which is continually decreasing , as the Surface of the Water subsides in the Cavern ) shall at any Time be equal to the Feeding-Stream entering at O , in such a Case , the Syphon must continually run , and yet not empty the Cavern , 'till the Feeding-Stream at O is sufficiently diminished .
But , when the Diameter of the Syphon at N , according to the Height of the Cavern , is so great , and the Feeding-Stream at O so small , that the Syphon can carry off ( in the Manner of a WastePipe ) all the Water which comes in , and yet not run with a full Stream ; the Syphon must then continue , to run without emptying the Cavern , 'till the FeedingStream at O is sufficiently enlarged .
So that by these different Constructions of the Syphon , there may be some Fountains which shall flow constantly in the Winter , or a wet Season , and intermit in the Summer , or a dry Season ; and on the contrary , others which shall flow continually in the Summer , or a dry Season , and intermit in the Winter , or a wet Season .
There is a third Variety , which may arise from the Make of the Syphon , and will occasion such Irregularities as admit of no certain Explanation .
This happens when the Discharge of the Syphon at the very last is just equal to the Feeding-Stream , and the Cavity of the Syphon at N is large ; for in this Case , the Air-Bubbles , made by the Fall of the Feeding-Stream from O to the Bottom of the Cavern , will sometimes accidentally get into the Mouth of the Syphon at M , and lodging at N , will so choke it as to render its running and stopping , as well as the Quantity of its Discharge , entirely uncertain ; so that these sort of Fountains will admit of no farther Consideration .
But before I leave the Consideration of Fountains explicable by one Reservoir and Syphon , it may not be amiss to observe , that those which intermit regularly will have their Flux always longer , and their Pause or Intermission shorter in Winter and in wet Weather , than in Summer or in a dry Season ; which is a Consequence of this Hypothesis , by which it may be examined , whether it be applicable to any particular intermitting Fountain , or not .
If the single Reservoir and Syphon has another Outlet at R , Fig. 2 .
situated between the Bottom CD of the Cavern , and the Top of the Syphon N , we shall have another kind of Fountains .
For if the Feeding-Stream at O , is capable of being discharged by the Out-let at R , a Fountain derived from R will continually run , whilst the Feeding-Stream can be discharged that Way , and will increase and decrease with any little Alteration happening to the Feeding-Stream at O , provided that the said Stream does not grow too large for the Out-let at R. But in that Case the Cavern must be filled up to N , and the Syphon may begin to play ; which , together with the Out-let at R , may discharge so much as to make the Surface of the Water in the Cavern sink below R , and consequently the Fountain proceeding from R must stop .
If the Discharge of the Syphon is so great as to empty the Cavern , then the Fountain derived from R will , after some time , begin to run again , and increase 'till the Water rises in the Cavern to N ; after which it will decrease , and at length stop .
But if the Discharge of the Syphon only keeps the Surface of the Water below R , without emptying the Cavern , then the Fountain derived from R shall be dried up , so long as the Stream at O continues increased ; and shall run again when the said FeedingStream is lessened .
Thus we may have a Spring which shall run all Summer , and be dry all Winter : Such a Spring will increase just before it begins to fail , i. e. whilst the Water in the Cavern is rising to N , will be dried up sooner in a wet Summer , and break out later in a wet Winter , contrary to the Nature of other Springs .
Which Particulars are worthy of Observation in such sort of Springs ( of which it is said we have some in England ) and will serve to discover , whether they are occasioned by this kind of Machinery , or not .
If the Syphon Fig. 3 .
MN P , of the Reservoir ABC D , having no Out-let at R , should discharge itself into a second Reservoir EFGH of a smaller Capacity , but furnished with a Syphon ST V , which discharges the Water more plentifully than it comes in ; a Fountain derived from this second Syphon STV would flow and intermit , whilst the first Syphon MNP continued running ; i. e. 'till the great Reservoir ABCD should be emptied .
After which it would entirely stop , 'till the said Reservoir ABCD was filled again by the Feeding-Stream at O , and then it would flow and intermit as before .
Such a Sort of compound Fountain would be liable to all the Variations of the former Fountains derived from a single Reservoir , if we take the Fits of flowing ing and intermitting of this for the Flux of the former , and the long Stop in this , whilst the great Reservoir is filling , for the Pause or Intermission of the former .
Besides which , we must remark , that as the Flux in the former Fountains may be changed , and be made longer or shorter ; so in this , the Number of Intermissions during one Fit of flowing and intermitting may not always be the same , because of the different Capacities of the two Reservoirs , and a Difference or Change occasioned in the Feeding-Stream at O. For if , whilst the great Reservoir ABCD is emptying , the little Reservoir EFGH should empty itself nine times , for Instance , and be half full again , the Fountain derived from its Syphon STV must have nine Intermissions in one Fit , and ten in another , alternately , whilst the Feeding-Stream at O remains the same .
But the Feeding-Stream at O being lessened or enlarged , without making the Syphon MNP run continually , the Number of Intermissions in each Fit will be diminished or augmented accordingly .
But it is peculiar to this last Sort of Fountains , that in each Fit of flowing and intermitting , the first Flux will be larger and longer than the second , and the second than the third ; but the first Intermission will be shorter than the second , and the second than the third : because the Syphon MNP running faster at first than at last , the Reservoir EFGH must be a shorter Time in being filled , and a longer Time in being emptied the first Time than the second ; the second than the third , and so on .
As to the whole Time of the first Flux and Intermission , in Comparison of the whole Time of the second Flux and Intermission , it is a Particular , requiring so many Things to be taken into Consideration , for determining it in each Case , that I shall wave it here , and content myself with showing that it may be longer , by an Experiment that will presently be made .
Another Variety in this Sort of Fountains might be made by a second Feeding-Stream Z , coming into the second Reservoir EFG H ; but the bare mentioning of that will at present be sufficient .
If in the Contrivance of a single Reservoir and Syphon , the Stream derived from the Syphon should fall into another Reservoir Fig. 4 .
IKK L , having no Syphon , but only a common Out-let X , and should in this Reservoir meet and join with another Stream constantly running , a Fountain derived from the said Outlet X would be a Reciprocating-Spring ; by which Name I call those Springs which flow constantly , but with a Stream subject to increase and decrease , to distinguish them from Intermitting-Springs , which flow and stop alternately .
And if the Out-let X be too small to carry off all the Water brought into the Reservoir IKK L , by the Syphon , over and above what is brought in by the constantly running Stream W ; then the Surface of the Water in the said Reservoir IKKL must continually rise , 'till the Velocity of the Stream going out at X , is sufficiently increased , to carry off the Water coming in : Upon which , the Discharge of the Syphon being continually lessened , the said Surface will again subside , and the Velocity of the Stream at X will diminish ; so that both the Increase and Decrease in this Reciprocating-Fountain will be gradual .
Besides , if the Reservoir IKK L , or the Channel derived from it , should have any Leaks , Crevices , or other Outlets , the Water will issue through them upon the Rising of the Surface in the said Reservoir , and occasion Springs , which will cease again when the Surface Let us now suppose such a Reservoir Fig. 5 .
IKKL , with a constantly running Stream W , and an Out-let X , to receive the Water of a Syphon STV , coming through two Reservoirs ABCD and EFGH , as before described .
A Fountain derived from X in this Case , would be an intermitting Reciprocating-Spring , whose Stream would reciprocate , but whose Reciprocations would sometimes stop , and have Fits of Intermission .
Such , in all probability , is the Fountain called Laywell , before described , whose Phenomenon gave occasion to these Thoughts , and seem capable of being accounted for by such a Contrivance .
And for the better Discovery of the Nature of this Fountain , whether it is owing to such a Piece of Natural Machinery , or otherwise , it would be proper to observe the length of Time of each Increase , Decrease , and Pause in every Reciprocation , together with the Number of Reciprocations in every Reciprocating-Fit , and likewise the length of the Intermissions of the said Fits .
These Observations should be continued for some Time , both in a settled Season , when the Feeding-Stream at O cannot change , and in Variety of Seasons , when the said Stream may be altered .
Having now brought these Thoughts to the End proposed , viz. an Explanation of such a Fountain as Laywell , I shall carry them no farther ; but conclude , by presenting to the View of the Society , an artificial Fountain of this kind , Fig. 5 which being very easily made , may be buried in the Bottom or Slope of a Terrace , where a constant Stream of Water can be brought , and will furnish us with a new sort of Water-Works in Gardens .
The two Reservoirs ABCD , EFGH , with their Syphons MNP , STV , and the third Reservoir IKKL , with its Out-let X , are included in a Box YYYY .
Into this Box at ~ enters a Funnel T~T divided within the Box into two Pipes , viz. ~ O , which serves for a Feeding-Stream to the great Reservoir , and ~ W , which serves for a constant Stream to the third Reservoir .
A Stream of Water being let into the Funnel T~T , will discharge itself like such an intermitting Reciprocating Fountain at X , where there is a Bason YZZZ without the Box to receive it ; with an Out-let ~ , and a Daigonal Gage ZY , to mark the Rise and Fall of the Water in the

