Fig. 2 .
~ 123456654321 FGcH XY e PV W l fg u DKE p N d Fig. 1 .
M b Df Ae B g C a Fig.3 .
ap WMP An Account of an Experiment explaining a mechanical Paradox , viz. that two Bodies of equal Weight suspended on a certain sort of Balance [ as in Tab. Fig. 2 .
] do not lose their AEquilibrium , by being removed one farther from , the other nearer to the Center .
By the Rev. T. J. Desaguliers , L. L. D. &amp; F. R. S. Proposition .
IF the two Weights P , W , in Fig. 3 .
hang at the Ends of the Balance A B , whose Center of Motion is C ; those Weights will act against each other ( because their Directions are contrary ) with Forces made up of the Quantity of Matter in each multiplied by its Velocity ; that is , by the Velocity which the Motion of the Balance turning about C will give to the Body suspended .
Now the Velocity of an heavy Body is its perpendicular Ascent or Descent , as will appear by moving the Balance into the Position a b ; which shows the Velocity of P to be the perpendicular Line e a , and the Velocity of B will be the perpendicular Line b g : For if the Weights P and W are equal , and also the Lines ea and b g , their Momenta made up of ea multiplied into W , and bg multiplied into P , will be equal , as will appear by their destroying one another in making an AEquilibrium .
But if the Body W was removed to M , and suspended at the Point D , then its Velocity being only f d , it would be over-balanc 'd by the Body P ; because fd multiplied into M , would produce a less Momentum than P multiplied into b g. As the Arcs A a , B b , and Dd described by the Ends of the Balance orPoints of Suspension are proportionable to their Sines e a , g b , and d f , as also the Radii or Distances C A , C B , and C D ; in the Case of this common sort of Balance , the Arcs described by the Weights , or their Points of Suspension , or the Distances from the Center may be taken for the Velocities of the Weights hanging at A , B , or D ; and therefore the acting Force of the Weights will be reciprocally as their Distances from the Center .
SCHOLIU M. The Distances from the Center are taken here for the Velocities of the Bodies , only because they are proportional to the Lines e a , b g , and f d , which are the true Velocities .
For there are a great many Cases wherein the Velocities are neither proportionable to the Distances from the Center of Motion of a Machine , nor to the Aris described by the Weights or their Points of Suspension .
Therefore it is not a general Rule , that Weights act in Proportion to their Distances from the Center of Motion ; but a Corollary of the general Rule , that Weights act in Proportion to their true Velocities , which is only true in some Cases .
Therefore we must not take this Case as a Principle , which most Workmen do , and all those People which make Attempts to find the perpetual Motion , as I have more amply shown in the Philosophical Transaction , No 369 .
But to make this evident even in the Balance , we need only take Notice of the following Experiment , Fig. 2 .
ACBEKD is a Balance in the Form of a Parallelogram passing thro ' a Slit in the upright Piece NO standing on the Pedestal M , so as to be movable upon the Center Pins C and K. To the upright Pieces AD and BE of this Balance are fixed at right Angles , the horizontal Pieces FG and H I. That the equal Weights P , W , must keep each other in AEquilibrio , is evident ; but it does not at first appear so plainly , that if W be removed to V , being suspended at 6 , yet it shall still keep P in AEquilibrio ; tho ' the Experiment shows it .
Nay , if W be successively moved to any of the Points 1 , 2 , 3 , E , 4 , 5 , or 6 , the AEquilibrium will be continued ; or if , W hanging at any of those Points , P be successively moved to D or any of the Points of Suspension on the cross Piece F G , P will at any of those Places make an AEqulibrium with W. Now when the Weights are at P and V , if the least Weight that is capable to overcome the Friction at the Points of Suspension , C and K be adR 2 ded ded to V , as u , the Weight V will overpower , and that as much at V as if it was at W. From what we have said above , the Reason of this Experiment will be very plain .
As the Lines AC and K D , CB and KE always continue of the same Length in any Position of the Machine , the Pieces AD and BE will always continue parallel to one another , and perpendicular to the Horizon : However , the whole Machine turns upon the Points C and K ; as appears by bringing the Balance to any other Position , as abe d : And therefore as the Weights applied to any Part of the Pieces FG and HI can only bring down the Pieces AD and BE perpendicularly , in the same Manner as if they were applied to the Hooks D and E , or to X and Y , the Centers of Gravity of AD and B E ; the Force of the Weights ( if their Quantity of Matter is equal ) will be equal ; because their Velocities will be their perpendicular Ascent or Descent , which will always be as the equal Lines 4l and 4 L , whatever Part of the Pieces FG and HI the Weights are applied to .
But if to the Weight at V be added the little Weight u , those two Weights will overpower , because in this Case the Momentum is made up of the Sum of V and u multiplied by the common Velocity 4 L. Hence follows , that it is not the Distance c6 multiplied into the Weight V , which makes its Momentum ; but its perpendicular Velocity L4 multiplied into its Mass Q. E. D. This is still further evident , by taking out the Pin at K ; ~ for then the Weight P will over-balance the other Weight at V , because then their perpendicular Ascent or Descent will not be equal .

