XVI .
An Answer to that Part of Mr. W. Kersseboom 's Essay , which treats of the Number of the Inhabitants of London ; by Wm. Maitland , F. R. S. SOME time ago an Abstract of a Political Essay , written by Mr. W. Kersseboom , a Dutch Gentleman , ( entitled , Verhandeling tot even Proeve om te weeten de probable Menigte des Volks in de Proventie van Hollandt en Westvrieslandt ) was read before this Honourable SOCIET Y ; wherein the Author , to the great Disparagement of the City of London , has asserted a , that the City of Paris , in the Year 1684 , and at the Close of the last Century , contained more Inhabitants than the City of London .
And to prove that Paris contains a greater Number of Inhabitants than London , he has had recourse to the Accounts of Christenings annually published in both Cities , without giving himself the Trouble to inquire into the Nature of those his Authorities ; which if he had , he would soon have discovered , that the former , is a perfect Account , while the latter , is perhaps the most defective of any extant ; for the Christenings therein mentioned , are only those whereat the Parish Clerks are present : which , I am of Opinion , cannot amount to near two Thirds of the whole , as I shall endeavour to make appear .
The Burials in the annexed Table , by some Typographical Errors in the Political Account of my History of Ggg London a Kersseboom 's Verhandel .
p. 14 .
ib. 17 .
London a , from which it is taken , being increased 491 above the real Number , in Graunt 's Account b , the Sum Total whereof , amounting to 90350 , must be reduced to 89859 ; and as in the annexed Term of Years , there appears to have died of the Plague 1741 c , three and a half of which , I compute , would have died of common Distempers , out of each Hundred , which amounting to about 61 , the same being deducted from 89859 , the real Number of the Burials , the Sum will be reduced to 89798 , which taken from 90883 , the Number total of the Christenings , the remaining Sum will be , 1085 , which being divided by Ten , the Medium thereof will be 108 1/ 2 yearly in Favour of the Christenings .
A Decenary Account of the Christenings and Burials of London , in the following Years .
Buried .
Buried Totals Years .
Christn 'd Com. Dist .
Plague .
Buried .
1626 6701 7400 134 7534 1627 8408 7713 4 7717 1628 8564 7740 3 7743 1629 9901 8771 0 8771 1630 9315 9228 1317 10545 1631 8524 8288 274 8562 1632 9584 9527 8 9535 1633 9997 8392 0 8392 1634 9855 10899 1 10900 1635 10034 10651 0 10651 Tot .
Gen. 90883 88609 1741 90350 This Difference in Favour of the Christenings , is owing to the Citizens of that Time being almost of the same Religion ; but the Civil War breaking out soon after , the People deviated into a Variety of Sects , subverted the Church of England , and assuming the Civil Power , established a new Hierarchy , or ChurchGovernment .
But the Members of the abolished Church continuing to baptize among themselves , ( witha Maitland 's Hist. Lond. p. 535 .
b Graunt 's Not .
and Polit .
Observe .
3d Edit .
Lond. c Maitland 's Hist. Lond. p. 535 .
( without reporting their Christenings to the new-appointed Members of the Company of Parish-Clerks ) occasioned a very great Defect in the Account of Christenings annually published by the said ParishClerks .
From this Epoch , is to be dated the Majority of the Burials in the Bill of Mortality over the Christenings of London : And though the Church of England was soon after re-establish 'd , yet the numerous Dissenters of all Denominations , persevering in their Separation , continued to baptize within themselves , without sending in Accounts of their Christenings to the restored Members of the Company of ParishClerks ; and the Schism still continuing , the Accounts of the Christenings and Burials of this City remain upon the ancient Foot of Division and Imperfection .
Add to this , that not only all the foreign Churches in London christen within themselves , but likewise many Churches and Chapels of the Church of England , that send not in their Accounts to the Company of Parish-Clerks , which , together with those of the Dissenters and Foreigners of all Denominations , amount to no less a Number than one hundred and eighty-one Congregations , whose Accounts of Christenings are not published : By which it is evident , that the vast Disparity between the Christenings and Burials of this City , is not owing , as Mr. Kersseboom vainly imagines a , to the Residence of the Court , Convention of Parliament , and great Resort of People from all Parts , but in Fact to the great Defect abovemention 'd .
Ggg2 How~ Kersseboom 's Verhandel .
p. 25 .
However , that Gentleman , from the aforesaid very defective Account of the Christenings of this City , has calculated the Number of its Inhabitants by a Medium of the Christenings in the Years 1684 a and 1685 ; whereby he makes the Number at that Time amount to five hundred thousand three hundred and forty-four : But as this Number , is only taken from a Medium of two Years , he imagines it too great ; therefore to reduce the same to the Number of b four hundred and sixty-nine thousand seven hundred , by a Medium of twenty Years , he has unwarrantably precluded the Sum of fourteen thousand seven hundred and two , the Number of Christenings in the Year 1684 , to make room for the Sum of eleven thousand eight hundred and fifty-one , the Number of Christenings in the Year 1674 ; whereby the Number of the Inhabitants of London , is very much lessened .
And as a farther Instance of Mr. Kersseboom 's Partiality in Favour of the City of Paris , he has calculated the Number of its Inhabitants ( without mentioning the Uncertainty of a Calculation founded on a short Space of Time , as he has done in the Case of London ) at a Medium of the Christenings for the Years c 1670 , 1671 and 1672 , whereby he makes them at that time , amount to , six hundred and ten thousand three hundred ; adding , the Number must have been greater at the End of the last Century ; as by his extravagant manner of Calculation it should be at present .
But as it appears by the above-specified ten Years Account , that the Christenings of London greatly exceed the Burials of that Time , I think it will not be ~ Kersseboom 's Verhandel .
p. 14 .
b id. ibid. c ib. p. 16 .
be denied , that they exceed the same at present ; espe cially if we consider , that the Number of Christenings in Paris , at a Medium of nine Years ( preceding that of 1737 ) exceeded that of the Burials ninety-eight yearly ; notwithstanding that City , not only abounds with a vast Number of Religious of both Sexes , who are sworn to Celibacy , but likewise many Thousands of Students belonging to the University , who lead a single Life ; whereas in London , there are no such Persons , to prevent the Increase of its Inhabitants .
And as in my Political Account of London , it appears a , that at a Medium of nine Years , there are annually buried in London 29542 , and in Paris only 17804 , which is 11738 in Favour of the former ; so must the Births in London at present ( according to the above-specified ten Years Account , the Reasons aforesaid , and the Paris Account of Christenings ) yearly exceed those of Paris 12320 ; whereby is shown , that the Inhabitants of London exceed those of Paris above three fifths in Number .
By what has been said , I doubt not but Mr. Kersseboom 's Astonishment will not only cease , in respect to the great Difference between the Christenings and Burials of London ; but he will be likewise induced to do Justice to this injured City , by acknowledging that the Inhabitants thereof vastly exceed those of Paris in point of Number .
What Mr. Kersseboom 's Partiality in Favour of the City of Paris is owing to , I know not ; unless it be out of Pique to Sir William Petty , ( with whom he seems not well pleased ) for saying , that the City of London contained as many Inhabitants as the Province of a Maitland 's Hist. Lond. p. 540 and 548 .
of Holland and West-Fireland : Which , I think , will be no difficult matter to make appear , by allowing that Gentleman his supposed Number of 28000 a Children to be annually born in the said Province ; whereas , according to the above-specified ten Years Account , and the Paris Proportion of Births , there must be annually born in London thirty-one thousand and eight Children : Therefore , as this Number , according to my Calculation b , is the Produce of 725903 , the present Number of the Inhabitants of London ; so must 28000 c , the Number of Children supposed to be born yearly in the Province of Holland and WestFriesland , be the Produce of 655485 , the present Number of the Inhabitants of the said Province .
Notwithstanding Mr. Kersseboom , by his excessive and unprecedented reckoning of the Births at a thirtyfifth part of the People , has calculated them at 980000 ; whereas by the ingenious and learned Dr. Halley 's Method of Calculation ( which is so highly approved of by Mr. Kersseboom , that he seemingly would be thought to make it the Standard of his Calculations ) the Inhabitants of the Province of Holland and West-Friesland do not amount to twenty-nine times the Number of the Births ; which gives room to suspect , that Mr. Kersseboom has introduced this unheard-of Excess , to increase the Number of People in the said Province of Holland and West-Friesland .
~ Kersseboom 's Verhandel .
p. 3 .
b Maitland 's Hist. Lond. p. 541 .
c Kersseboom 's Verhandel .
p. 3 .
Printed for T. WOODWAR D , at the Half-Moon , between the Two Temple-Gates in Fleetstreet ; and C. DAVI S , the Corner of Pater-noster-row , next Warwick-lane ; PRINTERS to the ROYAL SOCIET Y. M.DCC .
XL .

