X. The Solution of Kepler 's Problem , by J. Machine , Astr .
Prof. Gresh .
and Secr. R. S. MANY Attempts have been made at different times , but , if I mistake not , never any yet with tolerable Success , towards the Solution of the Problem proposed by Kepler : To divide the Area of a Semicircle into given Parts , by a Line from a given Point of the Diameter , in order to find an universal Rule for the Motion of a Body in an Elliptic Orbit .
For among the several Methods offered , some are only true in Speculation , but are really of no Service .
Others are not different from his own , which he judged improper : And as to the rest , they are all some way or other so limited and confined to particular Conditions and Circumstances , as still to leave the Problem in general untouched .
To be more particular ; it is evident , that all Constructions by Mechanical Curves are seeming Solutions only , but in reality unapplicable ; that the Roots of infinite Series 's are , upon account of their known Limitations in all respects , so far from affording an Appearance of being sufficient Rules , that they cannot well be supposed as offered for any thing more than Exercises in a Method of Calculation .
And then , as to the universal Method , which proceeds by a continued Correction of the Errors of a false Position , it is , when duly considered , no Method of Solution at all in itself ; because , unless there be some antecedent Rule or Hypothesis to begin the Operation , ( as suppose that of an uniform Motion about the upper Focus , for the Orbit of a Planet ; or that of a Motion in a Parabola for the perihelian Part of the Orbit of a Comet ; or some other such ) it would be impossible to proceed one Step in it .
But as no general Rule has ever yet been laid down , to aslist this Method , so as to make it always operate , it is the same in Effect as if there were no Method at all .
And accordingly in Experience it is found , that there is no Rule now subsisting but what is absolutely useless in the Elliptic Orbits of Comets ; for in such Cases there is no other way to proceed but that which was used by Kepler : To compute a Table for some Part of the Orbit , and therein examine if the Time to which the Place is required , will fall out any-where in that Part .
So that , upon the whole , I think , it appears evident , that this Problem ( contrary to the received Opinion ) has never yet been advanced one Step towards its true Solution : A Consideration which will furnish a sufficient Plea for meddling with a Subject so frequently handled ; especially if what is offered shall at the same time appear ( as I trust it will ) to contribute towards supplying the main Defect .
LEMMA I. The Tangent of an Arch being given , to find the Tangent of its Multiple .
Let r be the Radius of the Circle , t the Tangent of a given Arch A , and na given Number .
And let T be the Tangent of the Multiple Arch nxA to be found .
Then if ~ be put for rr , and TT for tt ; The Tangent T will be r+T~n r-T~n/ r+T~n + r-T~n ~ : Which Binomials being raised according to Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule , the fictitious Quantities T and ~ will disappear , and the Tangent T will become equal to ntn/ 1 .
n-1/ 2 .
n-2/ 3 .
t3/ r2 + n/ 1 .
n-1/ 2 .
n-2/ 3 n-3/ 4 .
n-4/ 5 .
t5/ r4 - &amp;c. / 1n/ 1 .
n-1/ 2 .
tt/ rr + n/ 1 .
n-1/ 2 .
n-2/ 3 .
n-3/ 4 .
t4/ r4 - &amp;c. This Theorem ( which I formerly found for the Quadrature of the Circle , at a time when it was not known here to have been invented before ) has now been common for many Years ; for which Reason I shall premise it , at present , without any Proof ; only for the sake of some Uses that have not yet been made of it .
Corollary 1 .
From this Theorem for the Tangent , the Sine ( suppose ) Y , and Cosine Z of the Multiple .
Arch nxA , may be readily found .
For if y be the Sine , and z the Cosine of the given Arch A , then putting w for y y , and substituting ry/ z for t , and rv/ z for T , and rT/ ~rr+TT for Y : The Sine Y will be z+v~n z-v~n/ 2rn~ .
The Cosine Z will be z+v~n + z-v~n/ 2r~-1 .
Each of these may be expressed differently in a Series , either by the Sine and Cosine conjointly , or by either of them separately .
Thus Y the Sine of the multiple Arch nx A , may be in either of these two Forms , viz. = zn-1/ rn-1 y in n-n-1/ 2 .
n-2/ 3 A.y2/ z2 + n-3/ 4 .
n-4/ 5B.y4/ z4 - &amp;c. or = ny nn-1/ 2.3 rr A y3 nn-9/ 4.5 rr B y5 nn-25/ 6.7 rr C y7 &amp;c. Wherein the Letters A , B C , &amp;c. stand , as usual , for the Coefficients of the preceding Terms .
The first of these Theorems terminates when n is any integer Number , the other ( which is Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule , and is derived from the former by substituting ~ rr-yy for Z ) terminates when n is any odd Number .
The Cosine Z may , in like manner , be in either of these two Forms , viz. = zn/ rn-1 in 1-n .
1 n-1/ 2.y2/ z2 + n/ 1 .
n-1/ 2 .
n-2/ 3 .
n-3/ 4 .
y4/ z4 - &amp;c. or =r nn/ 2rr A y3 nn-4/ 3.4 rr B y4 nn-16/ 5.6 rr C y6 - &amp;c. The latter of which terminates when the Number n is even , and the other as before , when it is any Integer .
Corollary 2 .
Hence the Sine , Cosine , and Tangent of any Submultiple Part of an Arch ( suppose ) 1/ n A , may be determined thus : The Tangent of 1/ nA will be r+T~ 1/ n r-T~ 1/ n/ r+T~ 1/ n + r-T~ 1/ n~ The Sine of 1/ n A will be z+v~ 1/ n z-v~ 1/ n/ 2r1/ n~ For these Equations will arise from the Transposition and Reduction of the former for the Tangent and Sine of the Multiple Arch , upon the Substitution of t , y , z and A ; for T , Y , Z and nx A. Corollary 3 Hence regular Polygons of any given Number of Sides may be inscribed within , or circumscribed without , a given Arch of a Circle .
For if the Number n express the double of the Number of Sides to be inscribed within , or circumseribed about , the given Arch A ; then one of the Sides inscribed will be the double of the Sine , and one of the Sides circumscribed the double of the Tangent of the Submultiple part of the Arch , viz. 1/ n A. LEMMA II .
To find the Length of the Arch of a Circle within certain Limits , by means of the Tangent and Sine of the Arch. Let t be the Tangent , y the Sine and z the Cosine of the Arch A , whose Length is to be determined , and let ~ , T , ~ be expounded as before ; then , if any Number n be taken , the Arch of the Circle will be always less than r+T~ 1/ n r-T~ 1/ n/ r+T~ 1/ n + r-T~ 1/ n xn~ , and bigger than z+v~ 1/ n z-v~ 1/ n/ 2r 1/ n xn~ .
For if , by the preceding Corollaries , a regular rectilinear Polygon be inscribed within , and another without , the Arch A , each having half so many Sides as is expressed by the Number n ; then will the former of these Quantities be the Length of the Bow of the circumscribed Polygon , ( or the Sum of all its Sides ) which is always bigger , and the latter will be the Length of the Bow of the inscribed Polygon , which is always less , than the Arch of the Circle ; how great soever the Number n be taken .
Corollary 1 .
Hence the Series 's for the Rectification of the Arch of a Circle may be derived .
For by converting the Binomials into the Form of a Series , that the fictitious Quantities , ~ , T , ~ may be destroyed ; it will appear , that no Number n can be taken so large as to make the inscribed Polygon so big , or the circumscribed so little as the Series .
ry/ z-ry3/ 3z3+ry5/ 5z5-ry7/ 7z7+ &amp;c. in one Case , or its Equal t-t3/ 3r2+t5/ 5r4-t7/ 7r6+ &amp;c. in the other Case .
Wherefore since the Quantity denoted by the Sum of the Terms in either of these Series 's is always bigger than any inscribed Polygon , and always less than any circumscribed , it must therefore be equal to the Arch of the Circle .
Corollary 2 .
If , in the first of the above Series 's , the Root ~ rr-yy , be extracted and substituted for Z , there will arise the other Series of Sir Isaac Newton , for giving the Arch from the Sine ; namely , y+y3/ 6r2+3y5/ 40r+5y7/ 112r6+ &amp;c. or otherwise , =y+1/ 1.2.3xy3/ r2+3.3/ 1.2.3.4.5.xy5/ r4+3.3.5.5/ 1.2.3.4.5.6.7.xy7/ r6+ &amp;c. SCHOLIU M. In like manner , as the Arches of the Polygons serve to determine the Arch of the Circle , so by comparing the Areas of the circumscribed and inscribed Polygons , 1/ 2 nr T and 1/ 2 nY Z , the Area of the Sector of a Circle may be found .
For if T , Y and Z are the Tangent , Sine and Cosine of the Arch A ; then by the second Lemma the Area of the circumscribed Polygon will be found to be 1/ 2 nr~x r+T~ 1/ n r-T~ 1/ n/ r+T~ 1/ n + r-T~ 1 n=1/ 2 nr T. and the Area of the inscribed will appear to be 1/ 2 n~x z+v~ 2/ n z-v~ 2/ n/ 4r 2/ n-1=1/ 2 nY Z. But upon the Expansion of these Binomials it will appear , that no Number n can be taken so large as to make the one so big , or the other so little , as the Area denoted by the Series .
1/ 2r in tt3/ 3rr+t5/ 5r4-t7/ 7r6+ &amp;c. So that this Area being larger than any inscribed , and smaller than any circumscribed Polygon , must be equal to the Area of the Sector .
It may further be observed , that as the Arch or Area is found from the Sine , Cosine or Tangent of the Arch , by means of the limiting Polygons , so may the Sine , Cosine or Tangent be found from the Length of the Arch by the same Method .
Thus , if A be the Arch whose Tangent T , Sine Y , and Cosine Z , are to be determined , then will the Tangent T be =A 1/ 1.2.3 .
x A3/ r2 + 1/ 1.2.3.4.5 x A~/ r4 &amp;c. / 1 1/ 1.2 x A2/ rr + 1/ 1.2.3.4 x A4/ r4 &amp;c. Sine Y=A 1/ 1.2.3 x A3/ r2 + 1/ 1.2.3.4.5 x A~/ r4 &amp;c. Cosine Z=r 1/ 1.2 x A2/ r + 1/ 1.2.3.4 x A4/ r3 &amp;c. For it may be made to appear , from the first Lemma , and its Corollaries , that if in any of these Theorems , as suppose in the First , the Quantity A stand for the Bow of the circumscribed Polygon , then will the Quantity T exhibited by the Theorem , be always bigger ; but if for the Bow of the inscribed , always less than the Tangent of the Arch , how great soever the Number n be taken ; and consequently , if A stand for the Length of the Arch itself , the Quantity T must be equal to the Tangent ; and the like may be shown for the Sine , and , mutatis mutandis , for the Cosine .
These Principles , from whence I have here derived the Quadrature of the Circle , which is wanted in the Solution of the Problem in hand , happen to be upon another Account absolutely requisite for the Reduction of it to a manageable Equation .
But I have enlarged , more than was necessary to the Problem itself , on the Uses of this sort of Quadrature by the limiting Polygons , because it is one of that kind which requires no other Knowledge but what depends on the common Properties of Number and Magnitude ; and so may serve as an Instance to show that no other is requisite for the Establishment of Principles for Arithmetic and Geometry .
A Truth , which though certain in itself , may perhaps seem doubtful from the Nature and Tendency of the present Inquiries in Mathematicks .
For among the Moderns some have thought it necessary , for the Investigation of the Relations of Quantities , to have recourse to very hard Hypotheses ; such as that of Number infinite and indeterminate ; and that of Magnitudes in Statu fieri , existing in a potential Manner , which are actually of no Bigness .
And others , whose Names are truly to be reverenced on account of their great and singular Inventions , have thought it requisite to have recourse even to Principles foreign to Mathematicks , and have introduced the Consideration of efficient Causes and Physical Powers for the Production of Mathematical Quantities ; and have spoken of them , and used them , as if they were a Species of Quantities by themselves .
N. B. In the following Proposition I have , for the sake of Brevity , made use of a peculiar Notation for composite Numbers ( or such Quantities as are analogous to them ) whose Factors are in Arithmetical Progression .
The Quantity expressed by this Notation has a double Index : that at the Head of the Root at the Right-hand , but separated by a Hook to distinguish it from the common Index , denotes the Number of Factors , and that above , within the Hook on the Left-hand , denotes the common Difference of the Factors proceeding in a decreasing or increasing Arithmetical Progression .
Thus the Quantity a~/ n +a ( m denotes by its Index m on the Righthand , that it is a composite Quantity , consisting of so many Factors as there are Units in the Number m ; and the Index ~ above , on the Left , denotes the common Difference of the Factors , decreasing in an Arithmetical Progression , if it be Positive ; or increasing , if it be Negative ; and so signifies , in the common Notation , the composite Number or Quantity , ~n+a .
~n+a-~ .
~n+a-2 ~ .
~n+a-3 ~ .
and so on .
For Example : 2~/ n+5 ( 6 is = ~n+5 .
~n+3 .
~n+1 .
~n-1 .
~n-3 .
~n-5 , consisting of six Factors whose common Difference is 2 .
After the same manner 2~/ n+4 ( 5 is =~n+4 .
~n+2 .
~n .
n-2 .
~n-4 , consisting of five Factors .
According to which Method it will easily appear , that if a be any Integer , then 2~/ n+2a+1 ( 2 a+2 will be = ~n n-1 .
~n n-9 .
~n n-25 , continued to such a Number of double Factors as are expressed by a+1 , or half the Index , which in this case is an even Number .
So 2~/ n+2a ( 2a+1 will be equal to n. ~n n-4 .
~n n-16 .
~n n-36 , and so on , where there are to be so many double Factors as with one single one ( n ) will make up the Index 2 a+1 , which is an odd Number .
If the common Difference ~ be an Unit , it is omitted : Thus , ~n(6 is = n.~n-1 .
~n-2 .
~n-3 .
~n-4 .
~n-5 , containing 6 Factors .
So ~6(6 is = 6.5.4.3.2.1 , and the like for others .
If the common Difference ~ be nothing , then the hook is omitted , and it becomes the same with the Geometrical Power : So 0~/ n+a ( m is = ~n+~ ~m according to the common Notation .
PROPOSITION I. An Arch less than a Semicircle being given , with a Point in the Diameter passing through one of its Extremities ; to find , by means of the Sine of a given Part of the Arch less than one half , the Area of the Sector subtended by the given Arch , and comprehended in the Angle made at the given Point .
Let PNA be a Semicircle described on the Centre C , and Diameter A P , and let PN be the given Arch less than a Semicircle , and S the given Point in the Diameter AP passing thro ' one of the Extremities of the Arch NP in P. Then taking any Number n bigger than 2 , let PK be an Arch in Proportion to N the given Arch P N , as K Unity to the Number n ; and let it be required to find by means of the AP MCSL Sine of the Arch P K , the Area of the Sector NSP subtended by the given Arch N P , and comprehended in the Angle NSP made at the given Point S. From N and K let fall on the Diameter AP the Perpendiculars NM and K L , and join CN and C K. Then let t stand for CP the Semidiameter of the Circle ; f for CS the Distance of the given Point S from the Centre ; p for SP the Distance of it from the Extremity of the Arch through which the Diameter AP passes ; and y for KL the Sine of the Arch KP in the given Circle .
These Substitutions being presupposed , the Problem is to be divided into two Cases ; one when SP is less , and the other when it is greater than the Semidiameter C P. CASE I. If SP be less than C P , then take an Area H equal to the Sum of the Rectangles expressed by the several Terms of the following Series continued ad libitum : pie / 1 + t+2~/ ~+1~2xf/ ~3~3 x)3/ t2 + 9t-2~/ n+3~4xf/ ~5~5 x)5/ 24 + 9x25t+2~/ ~+5~6xf/ ~7~7 x y7/ 26 + &amp;c. And the Area 1/ 2n xH will determine the Area of the Sector NSP ad libitum .
For the Sector PS N , being the Excess of the Sector NCP above the Triangle NC S , will be the Difference of two Rectangles : 1/ 2 CPxPN 1/ 2 CSxN M ; but PN is the Multiple of the Arch P K , namely nxP K ; and NM is the Sine of that multiple Arch : Wherefore if for CP be put t , for C S , f , according to the Supposition ; and if for PK be substituted : y/ 1 + 1/ ~3~3 x)3/ ~2 + 9/ ~5~5 x)5/ ~4 + 9x25/ ~7~7 x ~7/ ~6 + &amp;c. by Cor. 2 .
Lem .
2 ; and for N M : ny/ 1 n. 2~/ n+1~2/ ~3~3 x ~3/ ~2 + n. 2~/ n+3~4/ ~5~5 x ~5/ ~4 n. 2~/ n+5~6/ ~~~7 x ~7/ ~6 + &amp;c. according to Cor. 1 .
Lem .
1 .
the Area of the Sector will appear in a Series , as is above determined .
But since the Number n is greater than 2 , and the given Arch PN is less than a Semicircle , and consequently KL or y , the Sine of the Submultiple Arch P K , is less than the Semidiameter CP or t ; it may thence be easily proved , that the Series will approximate to the just Quantity of the Area , ad libitum .
Corollary 1 .
Hence , if the Number n be taken equal to ~5 + ~25 + 9p/ f , the Sector NSP will be = 1/ 2 npy+ n3 t n. ~n n 1 .
p/ 12 tt y3 + **** + n3/ 1120 ~5 ~7 + &amp;c. For the Numerator of the Coefficient of the third Term in the Series , that determines the Area H , namely , 9t-2~/ n+3~4xf is equal to 9t-~n n-1 .
n ~n-9 .
f , which , according to the above Determination of the Number n , will become nothing ; wherefore , if for t-p be put f in the second Term , and the Value of n be substituted for n in the Third and Fourth , the Series for the Area will appear upon Reduction to be as is here laid down .
Corol .
2 .
Hence the Area of the Sector NSP may be always defined nearly by the Terms of a Cubic Equation .
For the Number n , as constructed in the former Corollary , is always greater than the square Root of 10 , and consequently y/ t is always less than the Sine of one third Part of the given Arch ; so that the fourth Term ~3/ 1120t5 ~7 , with the Sum of all the following Terms of the Series , can never be more than a small Part of the whole Sector .
Corol .
3 .
If R stand for 57,2957795 , &amp;c. Degrees , ( or the Number of Degrees contained in an Angle subtended by an Arch of the same Length with the Radius of the Circle ) and M be the Number of Degrees in an Angle which is to 4 right Angles , as the Area NSP to the Area of the whole Circle ; then will M be = np/ t x Ry/ t + n3t-n .
n ~n-1 .
p/ 6t xR y3/ t3 , nearly .
For M/ R x tt/ 2 will appear by the Construction to be equal to the Sector NS P. CASE II .
If SP be greater than C P , then take an Area H equal to the Sum of the Terms in the following Series : pie / 1 + t-2~/ n+1~2xf/ ~3~3 x y3/ t2 + 9t+2~/ n+3~4xf/ ~5~5 x ~5/ t4 + 9x25t-2~/ n+5(6xf/ ~7~7 x ~7/ ~6 + &amp; ~ and the Area 1/ 2n x H , will be the Sector , as before .
For the Point S being on the contrary Side of the Centre to what it was before , it will easily appear , that the Change of +f into f , must reduce one Case to the other , without any other Proof .
Corollary .
Hence , if the Number n be taken .
equal to ~t+f/ f or in this Case ~p/ f then the Series for the Sector will want the second Term , as in the former it wanted the Third .
DEFINITIO N. The Angle called by Kepler the Anomalia Eccentri , is a fictitious Angle in the Elliptic Orbit of a Planet , being analogous to the Area described by a Line from the Centre of the Orbit , and revolving with the Planet from the Line of Apsides ; in like manner as the Mean Anomaly is a fictitious Angle , analogous to the Area described by a Line from the Focus .
Otherwise , if C be the Centre , S the Focus of an Elliptic Orbit described on the transverse Axis A P , and the Area NSP in the Circle be taken in Proportion to the whole , as the Area described in the Ellipsis about the Focus , to the whole : Then is the Arch of the Circle P N , or the Angle NC P , that which Kepler calls the Anomalia Eccentri .
This Angle may be measured either from the Aphelion , or from the Perihelion ; in the following Proposition it is supposed to be taken from the Perihelion .
PROPOSITION II .
The mean Anomaly of a Comet or Planet revolving in a given Elliptic Orbit being given ; to find the ANOMALIAECCENTR I. The Solution of this Problem requires two different Rules ; the first and principal one serves to make a Beginning for a further Approximation , and the other is for the Progression in approximating nearer and nearer ad libitum .
I. The Rule for the first Assumption : Let t , f , and p , stand as before , for the Semi-transverse Axis of the Ellipsis , the Semi-distance of the Foci , and the Perihelian Distance ; then taking the Number n equal to ~5+~ 25 + 9p/ f ; let T stand for 2 t/ n ntnn I.p ; and P for 2p/ n ntnn I.p ( or p/ t T. ) ; which constant Numbers , being once computed for the given Orbit , will serve to find the Angle required nearly by the following Rule .
Let M be the Number of Degrees in the Angle of mean Anamoly tc the given Time , reckoned from or to the Perihelion ; and supposing R , as before , to stand for 57,2957 , ~c .
Degrees ; take the Number N=3~3 T/ n RM and let A be the Angle whose Sine is 33 N~1/ 2+~ 1/ 4 + P3/ N6 + N~1/ 2-~ 1/ 4 + P3/ N6 ; then the Multiple Angle nxA will be nearly equal to the Anomalia Eccentri .
The Truth of which will appear from the Resolution of the Cubic Equation in the last Corollary to the preceding Proposition .
Corollary I. If the Quadruple of the Quantity P3/ N6 be many times greater or many times less than Unity ; or , which amounts to the same , if the mean Anomaly M , be many times less , or many times greater , than the Angle denoted by the given Quantity 2n p/ 3 tR~P ( one or the other of which two Cases most frequently happens in Orbits of very large Eccentricity ) then the Theorem will be reduced to a simpler Form near enough for Use .
Case I. If M be many times less than 2n p/ 3 tR~ P , then the Angle A may be taken for that whose Since is tX M/ n pX R. Case II .
If M be many times greater than 2n p/ 3 tR~ P , then let A be the Angle whose Sine is N P/ N ; and the Multiple Angle nx A , according to its Case , will be nearly equal to the Angle required .
Corollary II .
In Orbits of very large Eccentricity , the Perihelian Distance p is many times less than the Semi-distance of the Foci f , and the Number n=~5+~ 25 +9 ~/ f ; is always nearly equal to ~10 or to the Integer 3 , either of which may be used for it without any material Error in the Orbits of Comets .
II .
The Rule for a further Correction ad libitum .
Let M be the given mean Anomaly , t the Semitransverse Axis , as before ; and let B be equal to or nearly equal to the Multiple Angle nxA before found , then if ~ be the mean Anomaly , and x the Planet 's Distance from the Sun , computed to the Anomalia Eccentri B ; the Angle B taken equal to B+ t/ x xM ~ , will approach nearer to the true Value of the Angle sought ; and by Repetitions of the same Operation , the Approximation may be carried on nearer and nearer , ad libitum .
This last Rule being obvious , the Explication of it may be omitted at present .
SCHOLIU M. In this Solution , where the Motion is reckoned from the Perihelion , the Rule is universal , and under no Limitation : But had the Motion been taken from the Aphelion , the Problem must have been divided into two Cases : One is , when the Eccentricity is less than 9/ 16 ; the other is , when it is not less , but is either equal to , or more than in that Proportion .
If the Eccentricity be not less than 9/ 16 , then the same Rule will hold , as before , only putting the Aphelian Distance , suppose ( a ) instead of the Perihelian Distance ( p ) , and substituting f for +f in the Rule for the Number n. If the Eccentricity be less than 9/ 16 , then take the Number n equal to ~a/ f , and t/ n aX M/ R will be nearly equal to the Sine of the Submultiple Part of the Anomalia Eccentri denominated by the Number n , as before .
It is needless to observe , that the like Rules would obtain in Hyperbolic Orbits , mutatis mutandis .
But that which perhaps may not appear unworthy of being remarked , concerning this sort of Solution from the Cubic Root , is , that although the Rule be altogether impossible , upon a total Change of the Figure of the Orbit either into a Circle , or into a Parabola ; yet it will operate so much better , and stand in need of less Correction , according as the Figure advances nearer in its Change towards either of those two Forms .
That the Use of the Method may better appear , it may not be amiss to add a few Examples .
I have given two for the Orbits of Planets , one the most , and the other the least Eccentrick ; but which are more to show the Extent of the Rule , than to recommend the Use of it in such Cases ; for there are many other much better and more expeditious Methods in Orbits of small Eccentricity .
The other two Examples are adapted to the Orbits of two Comets , whose Periods have been already discovered by Dr. Halley ; the one is to show the Use of one of the Rules in the first Corollary , and the other is to explain the Use of the other Rule .
EXAMPLE I. For the Orbit of Mercury .
If an Unit being put for the Semi-transverse Axis ( t ) , the Eccentricity 0,20589 will become ( f ) , and the Perihelian Distance ( p ) will be 0,79411 ; wherefore by means of the Number R given as before , the constant Numbers for this Orbit will appear to be , n= 3,56755 , T= 0,5857271 , P= p/ t T=0,4651319 , and hence 3 T/ n XR= 0,0085965 .
Example .
Suppose M the mean Anomaly from the Perihelion to be 120~ .
00~ .
00~ , to which it is required to find the Anomalia Eccentri .
Here , since the mean Anomaly M is not many times more than the limiting Angle 2np/ 3t R~ P , ( which in this Orbit is about 74 Degrees ) recourse must be had to the general Rule in the Proposition .
The Number N then , which is ~3 3 T/ n RM will be = 1,0104195 ; which found gives N~3 1/ 2+~ 1/ 4+P3/ N6 + 1,0389090 ; and also N~3 1/ 2-~ 1/ 4+P3/ N6 = -0,4477126 .
Wherefore the Sum of both ( under their proper Signs ) viz. 0,5911964 will be the Sine whose Arch 36~,24195 is the Angle A ; the Multiple whereof nxA = 129~,295503 , will be the Angle to be first assumed for the Anomalia Eccentri .
For a further Correction ; this Angle , now called B , whose Sine is suppose y , and its Cosine z , gives , by a known Rule , t+ f/ t z =1,1304 for x the Planet 's Distance from the Sun ; and by another known Rule Bf R/ t ty= 120~,16568 for ~ the mean Anomaly to the Anomalia Eccentri B. Wherefore the correct Angle B=B+ t/ x xM~ will be 129~,14846 = 129~ .
08~ .
54~,5 , erring , as will appear from a further Correction , about 1/ 10 of a Second .
This Angle , being thus determined , will give by the common Methods 137~.48~.33~ 1/ 2 , for the true Anomaly or Angle at the Sun : The Sine of the true Anomaly being in Proportion to the Sine of the Anomalia Eccentri , as the Semi-conjugate Axis to the Planet 's Distance from the Sun .
So that the Equation of the Centre in this Example is 17~ 48~ .
33~ 1/ 2 .
EXAMPLE II .
For the Orbit of Venus .
Supposing , as before , the mean Distance t to be Unity , and the Eccentricity f to be 0,0069855 ; the constant Numbers for this Orbit will be , p=0,9930115 ; n= 6,4116 ; T= 1,562134 ; P= 0,1551217 ; 3 T/ n R= 0,0127571 ; and the limiting Angle 2n p/ 3 tR~ P , will appear to be about 303 Degrees .
Example .
Let M be 120~ .
00~ .
00~ , as in the former Example .
Then , since the ~mean Anomaly is , in this Case , not many times less than the limiting Angle , the general Rule must be used as before ; according to which the Number N will appear to be 1,152585 ; the Sine of A will be 0,3217917 ; the Angle A , 18~,77132 ; and the Multiple nxA , or Angle B ; for the first Assumption of the Anomalia Eccentri will be 120~,35416 .
This Angle B will give , by the Method before explained , the Angle B= 120~,34555 , or 120~ .
2~ 44~ fere , for the Anomalia Eccentri correct ; the Error of which will appear , upon Examination , to be but a small Part of a Second .
In this Example the true Anomaly is 120~ .
41~ .
25~ , 1 ; and consequently the Equation of the Centre no more than 41~ .
25~ , 1 .
EXAMPLE III .
For the Orbit of the Comet of 1682 .
To know the mean Anomaly of this Comet to any given Time , it is to be premised , that it was at the Perihelion in the Year 1682 , on the 4th Day of September , at 21 Ho. 22 Min .
equated Time to the Meridian of Greenwich , and makes its Revolution about the Sun , as Dr. Halley has discovered , in 75 1/ 2 Years .
The Perihelian Distance p is , according to his Determination , 0,0326085 Parts of the mean Distance t. So that the constant Numbers for the Orbit will be , n=3,1676061 ; T=0,2054272 ; P=0,00669867 ; and the limiting Angle 2n p/ 3 t R~P will be about 19 Minutes or 1/ 3 of a Degree .
In the Orbits of Comets , the Rule for the first Assumption of the Anomalia Eccentri is generally sufficient without Correction .
Thus , suppose the mean Anomaly M to be 0,072706 , ( as it was at the time of an Observation made at Greenwhich on the 30th of August 1682 , at 7h .
42~ .
AEq .
T. ) then the general Rule ( which must be here used , since the Angle of mean Anomaly is not above 4 or 5 times less than the limiting Angle ) will give nxA or B= 2~ 12~ .
48~,7 , erring about 7/ 10 of a Second from the true Anomalia Eccentri .
But in these Orbits the Rules in the first Corollary to the second Proposition most frequently take Place , especially the last ; and the Calculation may also be further abreviated , by putting the square Root of 10 , or the Integer 3 , for the Number n. Example .
Suppose the mean Anomaly to be 0~,006522 , or 23~,4792 : Here , since M is 50 times less than the limiting Angle , the Rule in the first Case of the first Corollary may be used ; that is , to take the Sine of the Angle A=tx M/ np x R. Wherefore , if the Number 3 be put for n , the Sine of A , which is t M/ 3 p R , will be = 0.00116367 ; and consequently the Angle A will be 4~.00~,011 ; and the multiple Angle nxA to be assumed for the Anomalia Eccentri will be 12~ .
00~,033 , the Error of which will be found to be about 1/ 30 of a Second .
EXAMPLE IV .
For the Orbit of the great Comet of the Year 1680 .
This Comet , according to Dr. Halley , performs its Period in 575 Years ; and was in its Perihelion on the 7th of December 1680 , at 23h .
09~ AEq .
T. at London ; the perihelian Distance p is 0,000089301 , in Parts of the mean Distance t : Wherefore supposing the Number n to be ~10 , the constant Numbers for the Orbit will be T= 0,2000161 ; P= 0,000017862 , and the limiting Angle 2np/ 3tR~P will be about 1/ 6 of a Second .
Example .
Suppose the mean Anomaly to be 3~,31~,4478 or 0~ , 05873541 , ( as it was at the Time of the first Observation made on it in Saxony , on November the 3d , at 16h .
47~ AEq .
T. at London .
) here , since the mean Anomaly is many times greater than 1/ 6 of a Second , the Rule in the second Case of the first Corollary may be used ; that is , by taking the Sine of A=N P/ N. But the Number N or 3~3 T/ n RM is = 0,05794134 ; and P/ N will be = 0,0030827 ; wherefore ( N P/ N= ) 0,05763307 , will be the Sine whose Arch 3~,30397 is the Angle A ; and the multiple Angle n~A= 10~ .
26~ .
53~,05 , will be the Angle to be first assumed for the Anomalia Eccentri ; the Error of which will be found to be less than a Second .
The true Anomaly , computed from this Angle according to the Rule in the Example for Mercury , will appear to be 171~ .
38~ .
24~ .
from the Perihelion .
By these Examples it appears , that the Solution is universal in all respects ; for the two first , compared with the two last , serve to show that it is not confined to any particular Parts of the Orbit , but extends to all Degrees of mean Anomaly : And by comparing the second with the last , it sufficiently appears to be universal with respect to the several Degrees of Eccentricity ; since in one the Equation of the Centre for the Reduction of the Mean to the true Motion is not so much as the 1/ 170th Part of the whole ; whereas in the other it amounts to almost 3000 times as much as the mean Motion itself .
POSTSCRIP T. UPON reviewing the Reflections on the Quadrature of the Circle in Page 212 , I believe it may be necessary for me , to prevent any Mistake that may arise from the different Opinions that obtain about the Nature of Mathematical Quantity , to explain myself a little upon that head ; as also to add a few Words to show how the Method of Quadrature by limiting Polygons , takes place in other Figures as well as the Circle .
I take then a Mathematical Quantity , and that for which any Symbol is put , to be nothing else but Number with regard to some Measure which is considered as one .
For we cannot know precisely and determinately , that is , mathematically , how much any thing is , but by means of Number .
The Notion of continued Quantity , without regard to any Measure , is indistinct and confused ; and although some Species of such Quantity , considered physically , may be described by Motion , as Lines by Points , and Surfaces by Lines , and so on ; yet the Magnitudes or Mathematical Quantities are not made by that Motion , but by numbering according to a Measure .
Accordingly , all the several Notations that are found necessary to express the Formations of Quantities , do refer to some Office or Property of Number or Measure ; but none can be interpreted to signify continued Quantity as such .
Thus some Notations are found requisite to express Number in its ordinal Capacity , or the Numerus Numerans , as when one follows or precedes another , in the first , second or third Place from that upon which it depends ; as the Quantities x , x , x , x , x , referring to the principal one x. So , in many Cases , a Notation is found necessary to be given to a Measure as a Measure ; as for Instance , Sir Isaac Newton 's Symbol for a Fluxion x ; for this stands for a Measure of some kind , and accordingly he usually puts an Unit for it , if it be the principal one upon which the rest depend .
So some Notations are expressly to show a Number in the form of its Composition , as the Index to the Geometrical Power xn denoting the Number of equal Factors which go to the Composition of it , or what is analogous to such .
But that there is no Symbol or Notation but what refers to discrete Quantity , is manifest from the Operations , which are all Arithmetical .
And hence it is , there are so many Species of Mathematical Quantity as there are Forms of composite Numbers , or Ways in the Compoposition of them ; among which there are two more eminent for their Simplicity and Universality than the rest : One is the Geometrical Power formed from a constant Root ; and the other , though well known , yet wanting a Name as well as a Notation , may be called the Arithmetical Power ; or the Power of a Root uniformly increasing or diminishing , and is that whose Notation is designed in Page 213 : The one is only for the Form of the Quantity itself , the other is for the Constitution of it from its Elements .
Now from the Properties of either of these it would be easy to show how the Quadratures of simple Figures are deducible from the Areas of their limiting Polygons .
I shall just point out the Method from the Arithmetical Power , as being the shortest and readiest at hand .
Let z , z , z &amp;c. or z , z , z , &amp;c. be Quantities in Arithmetical Progression , diminishing or increasing by the common Difference z , and let , as before explained , ~ signify the Arithmetical Power of z , denominated by the potential Index m , namely , z~z~z , &amp;c. whose first Root is z and last zm1~ z ; which being supposed , the Element of the Arithmetical Power will be mz~ z. that is , the Product made from the Multiplication of the two Indices , and the next inferior Power of the next Root in Order .
For the first Arithmetical ~ Power z is = z. z , and the next z is =z~zm z , wherefore the Difference will be as is explained .
And consequently , since the Sum of these Elements or Differences , taken in order from the first to the last , do make up the Quantity according to its termini ; hence , if z be the Absciss of a curvilinear Figure whose Ordinate y is equal to m zm-~ , a Demonstration might easily be made that the [ Form of the Quantity for ] the Area will be zm ; that is , the same Multiple of the next superior Power of z divided by the Index of that Power .
For since the Arithmetical Powers do both unite and become the same with the Geometrical Power , when the differential Index z is supposed to be nothing ; the Magnitude of the Geometrical Figure will be implied from the Magnitudes of the two Polygons made up of Rectangles , one from the increasing Arithmetical Power , the other from the diminishing , although it be true , that the Elements of the Polygons cannot be summed up , when z , the Measure of the Absciss z , is supposed to be nothing .
In like manner , in any other Case where z and z are two Abscisses whose Difference as a Measure is z ; and y , y the two Ordinates ; the Magnitude of the Figure will be implied by the Magnitudes of the two Polygons which are made from the Sum of the inscribing and circumscribing Elements zy and z y , although the Figure itself is not to be resolved into any such primogenial rectangular Elements .
And thus , I think , the Symbol z , considered as a component Part of the Rectangle z y , may bear a plain Interpretation ; viz. that it is the Measure according to which the Quantity z is measured ; nor can I see that any other Interpretation need to be put upon a Symbol , which , like a Measure , is used only to make other things known , but is of itself for nothing but a Mark .
And what is said of the Elements of the first Resolution , is easily applied to those of a second or third , and so on ; the last may always be considered as the Measure of the former and indivisible , although , in respect of the following , it be taken as the Part according to which the Measure was made , and therefore divisible .
The candid Reader is desired to strike out a Remark of mine , about the Comet of 1556 , subjoined to an Observation of the late Comet made at Lisbon , printed in Page 123 of the last Transactions , No. 446 .
The Note was there inserted by some Accident , without my Intention ; for I had soon afterwards informed the Society , that the Remark was ill-founded .
According to Mr. Bradley 's Observations at Oxford , which were not then communicated , the Place at the Time mentioned ought to have been in Long. ~ .
13~ .
21~ .
1/ 2 .
Lat. 0~ .
29~ .
South .
So that in all probability there happened some Mistake in making this

