Pl .
I. c c b c f a d e n f ~ q FIG. ~ .
VIII .
A Letter from John Phil. Breyne , M.D. F. R. S. to Sir Hans Sloane , Bart. Pres. R. S. with Observations , and a Description of some Mammoth 's Bones dug up in Siberia , proving them to have belonged to Elephants .
SIR , YOUR very learned and instructive Accounts of Elephants Teeth and Bones found under Ground , I saw with great Pleasure in the Philosophical Transactions , No 403 .
and 404 .
In the PhilposoYear , to wit 1728 .
I was busied about the very same Matter , especially to prove , that the extraordinary large Teeth and Bones found under Ground , and digged up in several Places of Siberia , by the Name of Mammoth 's , or Mammut 's , Teeth and Bones , were , I. True Bones and Teeth of some large Animals once living ; and , II .
That those Animals were Elephants , by the Analogy of the Teeth and Bones , with the known ones of Elephants .
III .
That they were brought and left there by the universal Deluge .
I made likewise several useful Inferences about this Matter .
At the same time there flourished in our City a Society of some learned and ingenious Gentlemen , who met once a Week in a certain Place : In one of those Meetings in the Month of March , I had the Honour to read and communicate my Thoughts and Observations about this Subject ; which , as I believe , they will not be disagreeable to you , I have translated into the English Tongue , and joined to this present Letter .
After that , viz. in the Year 1730 , Dr. Messerschmidt returned to Dantzick , from his Travels thro ' Siberia , and was pleased to communicate to me some curious Draughts of a Part of a Skeleton , to wit , of a very large Skull , Dens exsertus &amp; molaris , with the Os femoris , belonging to the Animal commonly called Mammoth , found in Siberia ; by which our Assertion , that the Teeth and Bones , called in Rusland Mammoths Bones , are the true Teeth and Bones of Elephants , is not only , as you wished in your first Account , put in a greater Light , but , if I am not mistaken , demonstrated beyond all Doubt .
Therefore I cannot forbear sending you these Draughts copied , for your Inspection , with the Explications and the Testimony added .
Being with true Respect , SIR , Dantzick , Your most humble and most Sept. 28 , 1735 .
obliged Servant , J. P. Breyne .
Observations on the Mammoth 's Bones and Teeth found in Siberia : Read in a Meeting of some learned Gentlemen at Dantzick in the Year 1728 .
by J.P.B. THAT learned and curious Gentleman Dr. Daniel Gottlieb Messerschmidt , who was sent some Years ago , by his late Czarish Majesty , Peter the Great , into Siberia , to search after the Products of Nature in this uninhabited and cold Country , was pleased to send me in the Year 1722 , amongst some other Samples of Natural Things out of Siberia , two very large Teeth , called there , Mammoth or Mammut 's Teeth , with the following Inscription : Dens molaris , ut videtur , diluvianus , Belluae cujusdam hactenus incognitae , nisi pro Elephantino habendus sit , cujus jam penes Te esto arbitrium , Russis Mammoth , repertus in Montium altissimis jugis ad Thomam fluvium .
Alterum est frustum aliud Eboris Denti exerto Elephantis non absimile , ab aliis repertum in Thomae Montibus .
After I had made an accurate and nice Examination of them , I thought it worth my Pains , Gentlemen , to show you the same here .
One is a Dens Molaris , or Grinder , a Foot broad , half a Foot long , and three Inches thick , weighing 8 th and ~iij .
pretty entire , except that it is broken in two Pieces , and the Extremities of the Roots spoiled .
The Substance is between that of a Bone and Stone , except that on the upper part of the Outside some parallel undulated Lines appear , which have still preserved the Enamel of the Tooth .
The other is a Piece of a Dens exertus , 8 Inches long and 3 Inches thick , of 1 Pound and 6 Ounces Weight ; in some Places not different from Ivory , but in others calcined like the common Unicornu Fossile .
What Ysbrand Ides ~ mentioneth of the Mammoth 's Teeth and Bones , deserves to be looked at ; as also the Journal of Laurens Lange 's Journey to China * , and the Remarks of Capt. John Bernard Muller ~ .
Those above-mentioned , as far as I know , are the chiefest Authors which have treated of the Mammoth 's Teeth and Bones , as a very remarkable and particular Curiosity of Siberia .
It would not be worth while , nor our Pains , to detain you with the Refutation of some partly merely fabulous Opinions , quoted by the said Authors , about the Origin of those Teeth and Bones : Therefore I design only to pick out of the Testimonies of Matters of Fact of the foresaid Authors , the following Points to my Purpose : 1 .
That those Teeth and Bones are found in Siberia , chiefly in the Northern Parts , near the Rivers Jenizea , Trugau , Mongam-Sea , Lena , &amp;c. towards the icy Sea ; at the Time when the Ice has broken the Banks of those Rivers , so that part of the adjacent Mountains do fall down ; and that they are found in such Quantity as is sufficient for Trade , and to make a Monopoly for the Czar ~ .
2 .
That sometimes Skeletons of this kind are found very near complete .
3 .
That those Teeth and Bones are not found always of the same Size , but sometimes very large ; as ~ In his Travels from Mosco to China .
*~ To be found in the Present State of Russia .
~ Vid. The Present State of Rusland .
Dentes molares , or Grinders , of 20 or 24 Pound weight ~ , and Dentes exerti , two of which weighed 400 Pound ~ ; sometimes of a middle Size , as mine above-mentioned , and at other times still smaller .
4 .
That of those Teeth , viz. Dentes exerti , some are used as Ivory , to make Combs , Boxes , and such other Things .
Capt. Muller saith ** , that it in every thing resembles the common Ivory , being but a little more brittle , and easily turning Yellow by Weather or Heat .
Out of these quoted Remarks joined to ocular Inspection , I think I may advance three Things .
I. That those Mammoth 's Teeth and Bones are truly natural Teeth and Bones , belonging heretofore to very large living Animals ; because they have not only the external Figures and Proportions , but also the internal Structure analogous to natural Teeth and Bones of Animals .
II .
That those large Animals have been Elephants ; which appears by the Figure , Structure and Bigness of the Teeth , which do accurately agree with the Grinders and Tusks of Elephants .
To be convinced hereof , one needs but to compare these Teeth with the Figures of those which some Years ago were digged up in Ireland , and those which represent the very natural Teeth of Elephants , and consider the accurate Remarks made by Dr. Molineux and other curious Fellows of the Royal Society thereon .
~ Capt. Muller loc. cit. ~ Ysbrand Ides loc. cit. ** Vid. Ysbrand Ides and Capt. Muller loc. cit. Nor needs any body to doubt , that they are true Teeth of Elephants ; from the uncommon Size of the Mammoth 's Teeth before-mention 'd ; because Vertomannus , as the famous Mr. John Ray tells us , has seen in Sumatra a Pair of Elephant 's Tusks of 336 Pound Weight ; and Terzagus , in Museo Septaliano , makes Mention of one two Yards long , and 160 Pound Weight .
III .
That those Teeth and Bones of Elephants were brought thither by no other Means but those of a Deluge , by Waves and Winds , and left behind after the Waters returned into their Reservoirs , and were buried in the Earth , even near to the Tops of high Mountains .
And because we know nothing of any particular extraordinary Deluge in those Countries , but of the universal Deluge of Noah , which we find described by Moses ; I think it more than probable , that we ought to refer this strange Phenomenon to the said Deluge .
In such Manner , not only the holy Scripture may serve to prove natural History ; but the Truth of the Scripture , which says that Noah 's Flood was universal , a thing which is doubted by many , may be proved again by natural History .
Here I must take Notice , that such Teeth and Bones also are to be found in several other Countries besides Siberia , as Poland , Germany , Italy , England , Ireland , and many others ; but less common than in Siberia , and not so well preserved , but more wasted and calcined , without doubt by the greater Warmth of those Climates .
Hither are also to be referred the large Bones found under Ground , or rather Tusks of Elephants , known by the Names of Ebur , seu Unicornu fossile , which are of the same Origin with the Mammoth 's Teeth , but different , as they are better preserved , and therefore , for a great part , have still the natural bony Substance , and may serve the Workmen as natural Ivory , and in some Measure the Physicians and Apothecaries as Ebur , seu Unicornu fossile .
An Explanation of the Draughts of the abovemention 'd Antediluvian Bones of an Animal commonly called , The Mammoth of Siberia ; or of the Bones of the fossile Skeleton of an Elephant ; done to the ancient Roman Scale contracted , and exhibited in six Figures .
Translated from the Latin by T. S. M. D. F. R. S. N. B. All the Figures are reversed by the Mistake of the Engraver .
Figure I. exhibits , A Front View of the Head .
It weighs 130 th ~ .
~v .
~j .
Apothecaries Weight , or 152 Russian Pounds .
Its Length or greatest Height is 48 Inches .
Its greatest Breadth near the Ears , 29 Inches , 5 Lines .
Its Thickness from the Forehead to the Nape of the Neck , 22 Inches , 5 Lines .
aa .
The Os frontis .
bb .
The Sutura sagittalis , hardly to be discerned .
c. The bony Septum Nasi , or the external Process of the Os ethmoides , without its Fellow .
dd .
The Coronal Suture appearing imperfect .
ee .
The Ossa Sincipitis .
ff .
The Sutura squamosa of the Temples .
gg .
The Sutura lambdoidea of the Occiput .
h. The external Processus zygomaticus of the Os temporum .
i. The posterior lateral , or zygomatic Process of the Os malae ( or Cheek-bone ) .
k. The upper Process of the Os malae , joined with the outer Process of the Os frontis , and constituting a Part of the Orbit of the Eye .
l. The outer Process of the Os frontis , forming the upper Part of the Orbit .
m. The anterior Process of the Os malae , joined with the Os maxillare .
nn .
The anterior Process of the Os maxillare , forming the Sockets of the foremost Teeth .
oo .
The lower lateral Process of the Os maxillare , constituting the Sockets of the Grinders .
p. A Grinder in its Socket , one on each Side .
q. A surprising Cavity of the Nose , stretching above the Palate , through which , by means of its Proboscis , the Water , upon drinking , is conveyed to the Throat , in the Manner peculiar to the Elephant .
Figure II .
exhibits a View of the Right Side of the Head .
a. The round Process of the Os occipitis , entering into the Pelvis Atlantis .
bb .
The occipital Bone of a monstrous Size .
cc .
The Lambdoidal Suture .
d. The Os petrosum with the Meatus auditorius .
e. The outer Zygomatic Process of the Temple-bone .
f. The Sutura squamosa of the Temple-bone .
g. The Os Sincipitis .
h. The outer Process of the Os frontis , forming the upper Part of the Orbit .
i. The Bottom of the Orbit .
k. The Hole of the optic and pathetic Nerves , pointed to by a pricked Line .
l. The upper Process of the Os malae , joined with the outer Process of the Os frontis , constituting part of the Orbit .
m. The anterior Process of the same Os malae , joined with the Os maxillare .
n. The posterior lateral or zygomatic Process of the same Os malae .
o. Another zygomatic Process of the same Os malae , peculiar to this Skeleton .
p. A Hole near the foregoing Process .
Quaere , if to let a Nerve pass to the Teeth ?
qq .
The anterior Process of the Os maxillare , constituting the Sockets of the Fore-teeth .
rr .
The inferior lateral Process of the Os maxillare , supporting the Socket of an upper Grinder .
ss .
A Grinder fast in its Socket , one on each Side ; which is no small Argument that this Skeleton belongs to an Elephant , and not to the chimerical Behemoth of the Rabbins ; or the Behaemaeth supposed different from the Elephant : of which Buxtorff , the learned Bochart , and others , have treated .
Figure III .
gives the back View of the same Head .
a. The great Hole of the Occipital Bone , for the Passage of the Medulla oblongata to the Spine .
bb .
The Processus globosi of the Occipital Bone covered with a Cartilage , entering into the Pelvis Atlantis .
c. The Os sphenoides ( cuneiforme , or basilare ) .
d. A peculiar and very remarkable Sinus of the Occipital Bone , deeper than an Ostrich 's Egg , serving , in all Appearance , for the Insertion of the Muscles of the Neck .
ee .
The outer Surface of the Occipital Bone entire .
ff .
The Surface of the same Occipital Bone broke through , exhibiting deep winding Cells running on every Side .
g. The Os petrosum , with the Meatus auditorius .
h. Quaere , If this be the Place behind the Ears , wherein Elephants are wont to be killed , and here damaged by the Knife ?
i. The outer zygomatic Process of the Temple-bone .
k. The outer Process of the Frontal-bone , constituting the upper Part of the Orbit ( of the Eye ) .
l. The Bottom of the Orbit , and the Hole that gives Passage to the optic and pathetic Nerves , marked by a small Line .
m. The upper Process of the Os malae joined with the Process of the Os frontis , and making up a Part of the Orbit .
n. The posterior lateral or zygomatic Process of the Os malae .
o. Another zygomatic Process of the same Os malae , peculiar to this Skeleton .
p. The lower lateral Process of the Os maxillare , supporting the Socket of an upper Grinder .
q. The tranverse Process of the Maxillary-bone , or the greater Os palati , which is very short in the Skeleton ton of an Elephant ; whose Tongue is scarce longer than a Man 's Hand : Which leaves no room to doubt but this must be the Skeleton of an Elephant .
rr .
The upper Grinders , one on each Side , to which their Opposites answer in the lower Jaw : And as the Elephant 's Grinders are commonly four in Number , this Circumstance is another Proof of our Opinion .
s. The Passage from the Nostrils into the Proboscis , and ending in the Fauces , with the Os vomer very visible : though ill drawn by the Neglect of the Painter .
tt .
The anterior Process of the Os maxillare , constituting the Sockets of the Fore-teeth , which are to be expressed in Figure VI .
Figure IV .
A Grinder , which seems to be the Left one of the lower Jaw , seen on the Outside .
It weighs viij th .
~ix .
~ij .
Apothecaries Weight , or 10 Pound Russian .
Its greatest Length 12 Inches .
Its perpendicular Height 5 Inches .
Its Thickness , or Breadth , 3 Inches .
It is made up of above 20 transverse Lamellae , a Finger thick , perpendicularly erect , lying close to one another , and its Root composed of two Apophyses .
aa .
The plane Surface of the exerted Part of the Grinder , scarce making half the Length of the Tooth , contrary to what is observed in the Grinders of the upper Jaw .
bb .
The Ends of the transverse Lamellae , terminating in the Surface of the exerted Part , and here of the Hardness of Stone .
cc .
The anterior Lamellae not extending to the exerted Part , and , perhaps , lying hid either in the Socket of the Os maxillare , or under the Gums .
d. The anterior Apophysis or Root of the Tooth , not quite entire .
e. The posterior Apophysis or Root , broken as the foregoing .
f. A deep Sinus between the two Apophyses .
Figure V. The Tusk , by some improperly called the Horn , of the Right Side , having a twofold Direction by being bent outward and backward , which is peculiar to the Male Elephant , it being straiter in the Female .
It is the Ebur fossile of the Shops , and weighs cxxxvii th .
~ .
~ij .
~ij .
Apothecaries Weight , or 160 Pound Russian .
Its Length , or the exterior Circumference of its back Part , was 136 Inches , 5 Lines .
The Circumference of the Root , where it got clear of the Socket , was the greatest , being 18 Inches , 5 Lines .
The subtended Arch from one Extremity to the other , 55 Inches .
The same subtended Arch ac .
but bigger , 61 Inches .
a. The Root hollow within , the Cavity extending beyond the Place marked b. b. The Root rising above its Socket , where it was thickest .
c. The Place where the subtended Arch was greatest , 61 Inches .
d. The Point of the Tusk somewhat bent outward and backward , although this Curvature could not be expressed by the Painter in a visible Manner in the lesser subtended Arch of 55 Inches .
The Tusk answering to the foregoing on the Left Side , was entirely like that on the Right , except the contrary Direction of its Curvature , and its less Weight , on Account of having lost its Point ; for it weighed but cxxviij ~ .
~viij .
~ij .
Apothecaries Weight , or 150 Pound Russian : And this small Difference did not seem to deserve a separate Drawing .
FIGURE VI .
The Right Thigh-bone , exhibited to View on its Inner Side , which turns towards the Body .
It weighed xxj ~ .
~vj .
~v .
~ij .
Apothecaries Weight , or 25 ~ Russian .
Its perpendicular Length is 38 Inches , 5 Lines .
The greatest Breadth of its upper Head ( or Apophysis ) 11 Inches .
Its Circumference at the Middle of the Bone , about 13 Inches .
a. The Head covered with a Cartilage , placed on its Neck , and inserted in the Socket of the Os Ischium , and fastened by means of two Ligaments .
b. The Cervix or Neck of the Bone .
c. The upper external or greater Trochanter .
d. The lower internal or lesser Trochanter .
e. The Place in the Middle of the Bone , where the Circumference measured 13 Inches .
f. The Sinus facilitating the free Motion of the Patella .
g. The other Process or inward Head , covered with a Cartilage , together with its Fellow .
h. Two vertical Sinuses in the Tibia answering to the external Trochanter .
The Bones of this Skeleton , with the Ribs , Vertebrae , and others thereto belonging , were found in the sandy Side of a steep Hill , on the Eastern Bank of the River Indigirska , which falls into the Northern Ocean , not far from the Mouth of the Rivulet Wolockowoi ~ .
The River Indigirska to the East of the River Jena , where it runs in its own Channel , has not been laid down by Mr. Witsen in his Map of the North-East Part of Asia : But its Course is described by Isbrand Ides in the Map of his Travels .
And some of these Bones are found now and then not only in these Parts , ( which are so dangerous on Account of the excessive Cold , and continued Chains of inaccessible Mountains , that to us Europeans , who have the Happiness to live in a milder Climate , it would be present Death to travel through them ) but likewise in the Sand-hills on the Rivers Chatanga .
Thomas , Tobol , Irtisch , &amp;c. which are all at a good Distance from the Sea ; though neither Elephants , nor chimerical Behemoths , have been ever seen in those Countries , nor could they live therein by reason of the Inclemency of the Air .
Wherefore the best Judges follow the Opinion of the learned Dr. Woodward , the Scheuchzers , and others , ( whose Arguments , which are well known and of great Weight among the Literati , I think needless here to repeat ) in taking them for the Bones of Antediluvian Animals , or of such as were conveyed thither in the universal Deluge .
And lest the Truth of what I have said above be called in Question by such Persons as are prone to Envy , Calumny and Falsehood , and detract the contrary Virtues in others ; I thought proper to give a Copy of the original Certificate of a Person who was an Eyewitness to the digging it up .
WHereas Mr. Messerschmidt entreated me to let him know where the Head of the Mammoth with its Teeth and other Parts were found ; as I was an Eye-witness to the digging it up , I thought proper to give him this short Account thereof in Writing : That Head was found by a certain Russian Soldier Wasile Erlow , on the Eastern Bank of the River Indigirska , not far from the Mouth of the Rivulet Wolockowoi-~ .
After it was discovered , I , being at Leisure , was present , and an Eye-witness to the digging up of this Skeleton or Bones .
And further likewise , on the other Bank of the same River , which Bank is named Sztanoijahr , I saw a Piece of Skin putrified , appearing out of the Side of a Sand-hill , which was pretty large , very thick , and covered with long Hair , pretty thick set and brown , somewhat resembling Goats Hair : Which Skin I could not take for that of a Goat , but of the Behemoth ; in as much as I could not appropriate it to any Animal that I knew .
This I certify by this Latin Testimonial for the present , and can safely , and even hold it my Duty to give a more circumstantial verbal Account thereof , whenever her Imperial Majesty shall be graciously pleased to lay her Royal Commands on me .
Signed , Dated at Irkutskoe , Michael Wolochowicz .
Feb. 10 .
1724 .
Philosoph. Transact. No. 446 .
d a scale of 3 feet 5/ 10 123 c c 61~ 55~ e FIG. V. FIG. VI .
h ba g Pl .
III a b cd e f h g ascale of 2 Roman Feet Philosoph. Transact. No. 446 .
c FI G. IIII of e d bbb c hgk i ~ ~n m ~ o p c rrt c c c FI G. III .
t~ t~ Ascale of 4 Inches or 4/ 10 ~1234 Pl .
~ .
a b ~ b b b ~ b ~ a c c c c c ~ Philosoph. Transact. N~ .
446 Ascale of 2 ancient Roman ~ gg ~/ 10 12 for FI G. ~ .
~ .
~ .
c bc e g gddc ~ b aa f b f~ h lk hn ~mo p~~ f nnq FIG. I. q FIG q

