I. Experiments and Observations on Bulbous Roots , Plants , and Seeds growing in Water , by Mr. William Curteis .
ABout three Years since , seeing some Bulbous Roots set in Glasses filled with Water in a Shop Window , and being told they would Flower in that manner , I immediately tried a couple of Hyacinths , which blowed very prettily the next Spring : it pleased me much to see that we could have such Things in a close Room in Town , without the help of a Garden to produce them , having lately come out of the Country , and being a Lover of Flowers ; wherefore I began to think if I could contrive a Method to make a Pot full blow together , with a mixture of several sorts of Flowers with a variety of Colours , it would be an Improvement .
The next Year , I took a couple of common penny Garden Pots , and stopped the Holes at the Bottoms with Corks ; and painted the Pots , and puttyed the Corks , that no Water could filtrate through them ; then had a couple of Boards cut to fit the tops of the Pots , bored with seven holes at equal Distances , to place my Bulbs in , and likewise as many small holes for placing of Sticks , to tie the Stems of the Flowers to ; I then planted Hyacinths , Narcissus 's , Tulips and Junquils , and filled the Pots with Water up to the Board , so that the Bulbs stood only upon the Water ; where they blowed very well , and made the best Appearance , as I thought , I had ever seen , beyond any Flower-pot that could be dressed by gathered Flowers .
After the Bloom was over , their Leaves looking green , I set them out in my little Garden , thinking any thing that looked green and made a tolerable Figure , agreeable in a London Garden ; and not depending on the Bulbs again to be of any service to be preserved , I let them stand till toward Midsummer , and took no farther care , but now and then giving them fresh Water as it perspired or evaporated , and when the Rains filled the Pots , I emptied them down to the Boards again ; but the Bulbs shrinking , some of them slipped through the Holes down to the Bottom of the Pot , and about Midsummer , when their Leaves began to grow Yellow , I went with a Design to pull them up and throw them away , I was surprised to find that the Bulbs which were buried in the Water were grown firm , and too large to be drawn back through the Holes , being sound and fit for blowing the next Year , and increased in Off-sets .
This occasioned me the next Year ( which was the last ) to try another Experiment of blowing my Bulbs under Water , which I found answered beyond what could be expected , for they rather out-do those that grow in the Ground , in the strength of their Stalks , the clearness of their Blossoms , the lasting of their Bloom , and likewise , the Difference of their Seasons , which may be so managed , according to the warmth of the Rooms they are kept in , as to have the same Sorts in flower from Christmas , till the natural Time of their Bloom in the open Ground , which is March and April .
But finding it very troublesome to keep the Boards fixed under Water , I thought Lead might answer the Purpose better ; whereupon , I got some sheet Lead , of about four pounds to the Foot , cut fit to my Pot , and made holes in it proportionable to the bottoms of my Bulbs , and likewise small holes to fix sticks for the support of the Leaves and Stems of the Flowers ; I put a little coarse Sand in the bottoms of my Pots , thinking it would support the Sticks , and keep them steady ; but when I came to make use of the Sticks , the Sand gave way ; I then made false bottoms with Lead , and cut Holes opposite to those at the Top , which answered my purpose .
Upon taking up the Bulbs to put in these false bottoms , I found the Sand had corroded the Fibres , and changed them all like Ironmould , that I thought they were spoiled ; but rinsing them in two or three Waters , it came clear off , and on fixing my false Bottoms , and placing the Bulbs in their holes , and filling them up with fresh Water , they recovered , and never changed again in the clear Water , but thrived and put forth their Flowers very kindly , although by the Experiments which I had tried , before I could fix them right , I had often planted and transplanted them .
But I found afterwards that Glass Jars of the Form as represented in the Plate , were the most convenient , both for seeing the Progress the Roots made , and for knowing when they want to be cleaned .
At Fig. I. is represented one of these Glass Jars , containing the following Flowers .
1 .
Golden Sun , Narcissus 's .
2 .
Bosselman , 3 .
Keysers Jewel , 4 .
Pulchra , Hyacinths .
5 .
Janus , At Fig. II .
is represented the Profile or Section of the same Jar .
a. The Sticks to the up the Leaves and Stems of the Flowers .
b. The upper Lead with Holes to support the Bulbs and Sticks .
c. The under Lead with Holes to keep the Sticks steady .
By several Experiments on dried Bulbs , and those that were taken fresh out of the Ground , I find the dried ones do best ; for those taken growing out of the Ground , being full of moisture , will not so soon upon changing their Element , be acquainted with a new one ; the Fibres they had struck in the Ground , always rot , and they must make new ones in the Water , which makes them require a long Time before they can recover themselves enough to flower .
The Bulbs will not rot , yet they will not be so strong as those put into the Water when dry , which fill themselves with moisture by degrees : Therefore , when I plant my Bulbs , I set them at first on the top of the Water ; for I found by two or three Experiments , that those planted under Water did not push out their Fibres so soon , nor so strong , as those set upon the Water ; the Reason of which I take to be , that they were filled with Water too soon , whereas those set upon Water attracted it by degrees , and so made both the Fibres and the Bulbs grow stronger ; and then about five or six Weeks after planting them , as the Fibres push out , I by degrees fill the Water higher and higher , till the whole Bulb is covered , and so keep them till the Bloom is over , and the Season for drying them returns .
One Observation surprised me , viz. two of my Hyacinths were mouldy , which Mould cankered and eat holes through several of their Coats or Scales ; this I picked and cleaned several times , but still it spread farther and farther ; but soon after they were covered with Water , I could perceive them heal by degrees , till they became perfectly sound and blew their Flowers as kindly , as those that had continued perfectly sound .
By another Experiment , I tried what Bulbs would do if kept all the Year under Water : I left in water a Narcissus , an Hyacinth of Peru , and several Junquils , that were planted in October , 1732 ; which are now as sound and strong , as those I took out and dried , and promise fair for a Bloom ; I observed that their old Fibres do not rot , till they are ready to push out new ones .
Another Observation seems worthy of Notice ; one of my double Hyacinths , commonly called Keysers Jewel , brought two Pods of Seed to maturity ; which I have blowed for fourteen or fifteen Years successively in the Ground , and could never find them make any thing towards seeding ; and I have reason to think that several other Bulbs would have seeded , if I had taken timely care of them , but did not perceive it till too late .
Mr. Miller , in Philos. Trans. No. 418 .
intimates that Bulbs set in Glasses grow weaker , and should be renewed every Year with fresh ones ; but I observe by this way of raising them under Water , that at their taking up , they are as large , and some of them stronger than when they were planted , and if they be dried at the proper Season , will produce a second Year as well as fresh ones .
I planted likewise Ranunculos and Anemone Roots , which grew and shot up the Stems of their Flowers very strong , but the Buds of the Flowers were blasted , which I am apt to think happened from their being crowded too much , having no convenience to give them free Air enough .
I also planted Auriculas and Pinks , the Pinks flowered , but the Auriculas were not strong enough ; they are still both of them growing , and I am in expectation they will blow the next Season .
I have tried also several Shrubs , as Roses , Jasmines , and Honysuckles ; which all grew , and struck out fresh Fibres , and the Rose-tree made six strong Buds for Blossoms , but accidently setting them out in a hot Sun-shiny day in April , they were all scorched up , that they came to nothing ; I observed , that strong Suckers cut off two or three Inches under ground , without any Fibres , grew the best .
By another Experiment , I was willing to try what the Succulent Plants would do in this way ; I took a Leaf of the Opuntia or Indian Fig , and laid it by to dry for three Weeks or a Month , till it had lost all its moisture , and was nothing but a dried Skin ; I then planted it in Water in the beginning of July , and tied it to a Stick that was fixed in one of my Leads , and filled the Pot so , that the Bottom of the Leaf was a quarter of an Inch in the Water ; in about a Month 's time the Leaf filled , struck out Fibres , and put forth a fresh Leaf , which is now growing , and has made as much progress as such a Plant would do in the Earth , in the same space of Time : I had no opportunity of trying other Succulent Plants .
Dr. Mortimer told me he had placed Beans upon Water , which blossomed and podded : This put me upon trying the Experiment with them , and likewise Peas at the same Time .
I planted six Beans in a Pot , and fixed sticks in it to support their Stems as they grew ; they bloomed as freely as those which are planted in the Ground , but did not pod so well , having not above a pod or two on each Plant , which came to perfection , and ripened their Seed ; but this might happen for want of a little more Experience ; the Peas which were of the Dwarf sort , drew a little too much , and only put out three or four Blossoms at the extremity of their Tops , but every Blossom brought a Pease-cod , and ripened its Seed .
This growth of the Beans and Peas , made me imagine that other Seeds would succeed in the same manner , knowing they would chip upon being laid for a little time in Water , or in a moist Place : The only Difficulty was to invent something proper for their support in growing .
The first Thing I tried was boring very little holes in a piece of Lead , fixed in a Pot , and sowing the Seeds thereon ; I found they would sprout , but as the Water evaporated , filling in fresh moved the Seeds from their places , that they could not fix themselves to turn their Radicle down into the Water ; I then tried Tow or Hemp , and spread it on the Lead , which I found answer the Purpose of supporting the Seed , which by that means grew , and the Radicle taking hold of the Tow , it was enabled to throw up its Plume or Shoot ; I then tried several sorts of small Seeds , and found they would all grow ; tho ' I made the Experiment about Christmas ; but I found the Tow discoloured the Water , and gave an offensive smell , and that the Seed did not thrive kindly : I then tried Wool and Cotton , the Cotton being too boyant , would not so well answer the Purpose ; but Wool , when it is just buried in Water , being like a Jelly , and not drying so soon on the Top , even though the Water has left it , entirely answers the Purpose as well as sowing them in the Earth ; and if the Seed be good , will keep clean for two or three Months ; for this way of sowing will discover whether the Seed be mixed with old Seed ( as those bought at a Seed-shop generally are .
) I sowed several sorts of Sallad-Seeds in this way , and they came to as great perfection as those of the same kind raised in Hot-beds : and thus they may be produced in any Room or Garret , early in the Spring , and so on till late in Autumn , till the cold Weather comes in , and afterwards in the middle of Winter , in a Room where a constant Fire is kept .
I had several Salads last Spring , and this Autumn , by sowing different sorts every Week one under another , in small half-penny Pots ; as Lattice , Crosses , White Mustard , Rape , and Raddish , which in a Fortnight after sowing would be fit to cut ; so that keeping a proper Succession , I had every Week a tolerable Salad for two or three Persons .
My way of sowing of these Seeds , is to have a piece of Lead bored full of holes , and made to fit the Pot , about half an inch below the Top ; then filling it with Water , I take a little clean Wool , and spread it even and thin , upon the surface of the Lead , quite home to the sides of the Pot , which will then look like a Jelly ; if there is too much Water , I pour it off , till the Wool only appears covered or filled with Water ; then I sow the Seed pretty thick , and in forty-eight Hours it will begin to chip , and in a Fortnight after sowing will be fit to cut for a Salad .
I observed from several Experiments , that any of these Plants transplanted out of the Earth into Water would not thrive kindly ; but those raised in Water may be transplanted into Earth , so that this Method of raising Seeds in Water may be of use in a dry Season , to be pricked out into the Earth , though they will not come up in such a Season , if sowed in the Ground , yet transplanted from Water they will take as freely to the Earth as if raised in it .
I do n't know but from the foregoing Experiments in Water , we may come at a better Way of planting in the Earth , especially some Roots , which are apt to rot in the Ground , as Anemones , Ranunculos , and Hyacinths : from an Observation I have frequently made , but never before took notice enough to improve it , which is , that I have often seen a Bulb dropped by chance upon the Ground , strike out Fibres stronger and more numerous than those planted in their usual depth of Earth would do .
The use I would make of this Observation , is , that when I plant my Bulbs , I take out the Earth of the Bed , I design to plant , as deep as the Bulbs or Roots are to stand when planted , and place my Bulbs on the Surface , till the moisture of the Earth shall have attracted their Fibres , and they begin to shoot up their Plume , and then by degrees I cover them over to the thickness of Mould , that they should stand in , by which means they will be in no danger of rotting after they have got strong Fibres ; for when we plant these Bulbs or Roots , it is generally either too wet or too dry ; if it be a wet Season , the Bulbs are too soon saturated with Moisture , which rots them ; and if it be too dry , they lie so long , before they can attract Moisture enough to make them Vegetate , that they grow mouldy , and are rendered dry and hard as a piece of Stick , so that the first Rain infallibly rots them .
N. B. These Experiments were made without the Benefit of any Sun , all my Windows having a Northern Exposition .
As these Experiments have opened a new Scene of Knowledge in the Vegetable World , and may be of great Use in Natural Philosophy , and particularly improve the Art of Gardening ; its to be hoped the Curious will carry on the Inquiry as they have Leisure and Opportunity .
Directions for Planting Bulbous Roots in Pots or Glasses of Water .
When the Leaden false Bottoms are fixed down tight , within two or three inches from the Bottom of the Pots ( which is only designed to hold the Sticks steady that are to support the Leaves and Stems of the Flowers ) lay on the Lead , which is to support the Bulbs , placing the notched Part opposite to that in the false Bottom , as near as the Sticks when placed will suffer it ; then place your Bulbs in each Hole , and fill in Water up to the Lead , which will then touch the Bottom of the Bulb , and as the Water evaporates or perspires , keep it filled to that height , till the Bulbs have struck their Fibres pretty strong into the Water , which may be in a Month or six Weeks ; then fill in Water about half an Inch above the Lead , and by Degrees as the Fibres strengthen , and the Plume or Head sprouts , fill it higher and higher till the Bulbs be entirely buried under Water , which must be continued till the Season for drying them returns .
But you must observe at the Planting the Bulbs to clean them very well from any Foulness they may have at their Bottoms , by scraping them with the Point of a Knife , till the sound part of the Bulb appears , and likewise clear them of all their loose Skins , and even the brown Skin , till they appear White ; which otherwise will discolour and foul the Water that should be kept as clear as possible ; and for this Reason , the Notches in both the Leads are contrived , that upon shifting all the Water out of the Pots , if there happens to be any Sediment , by shaking the Pots once or twice as it is poured off , all the Foulness may come with it ; but this shifting of the Water need not be done but once or twice in a Winter , or when ever you see occasion by the Discolouring or Foulness of it ; and at the same Time it will be necessary with a Painter 's Brush to clean off all Slimyness that will adhere to the Sides of the Pots and Bulbs , and rince them well , by pouring Water on them at a little Distance : By this method they may be kept perfectly clean ; and at any time when the outward Skins of the Bulbs loosen and begin to decay , clear them off , which otherwise would occasion Foulness ; and when ever you see Dust swimming on the surface of the Water , fill the Pot full , and let it run over , which will carry it all off , and then pour off the Water to its usual height .
N. B. Plant Bulbs of equal bigness , at least in height , together in the same Pot , that they may have the same Benefit of the Water ; therefore I plant Narcissus and Hyacinths and Bulbs of that size together ; Tulips and Junquils , &amp;c. by themselves ; and Crocus and Snow-drops , &amp;c. by themselves .
Bangor-Court , Shoe-Lane , Decemb. 19 , 1733 .
Phil. Transact. No 432 22 Fig. I Fig. II 3554 Fig. I Fig. II aaa 18

