III .
An Account of the Appearance of Mercury , passing over the Sun 's Disk , on the 29th of October , 1723 determining the mean Motion , and fixing the Nodes of the Planet 's Orb .
By Edmund Halley , LL. D. Astron. Reg. and R. S. S. THE Transit of the Planet Mercury , over the Disk of the Sun , being one of the most curious and uncommon Appearances that the Heavens afford , our Astronomers , both at home and abroad , made due Preparation to observe , with the utmost Exactness , that which happened on the 29th of October , 1723 , which I had predicted in the Year 1691 ( Phil. Trans. No 193 .
) would be , in Part , visible in England .
And the Sky proving , more than ordinary , favourable at that Time , we were enable to observe the Ingress on the Sun 's Limb , with the greatest Accuracy .
Accordingly , the same Day , Octob. 29 .
still .
vet .
at Greenwich in the Royal Observatory , I first perceived , with my 24 Foot Tube , the Planet making a small Notch in the Sun 's Limb at 2h 41~ 23~ T. app .
And at 2h 42~ 26~ he was wholly entered , making an interior Contact , the Light of the Sun 's Limb just beginning to appear behind his dark Body ; which , notwithstanding the Slowness of the Motion , was , in a Manner , instantaneous .
Then , applying the Micrometer to the said 24 Foot Tube , I opened it so as to take in 16~ 15~ equal to the Sun 's Semidiameter at that time ; and causing the northern Edge of the Sun , to move exactly along one of the Pointers , I waited till the Center of Mercury came to move along the other , as I found it to do at 3h 1~ 16~ T. app .
But Refraction contracting this Difference of Declination about 5 Seconds ( the Sun being then but about 11~ high ) I concluded that the Centers of the Sun and Mercury , were truly in the same Parallel of Declination at 3h 3~ T. app .
proxime .
At Wansted in Essex my worthy Colleague , the Rev. Mr. James Bradly , Savilian Professor of Astronomy , observed with the Hugenian Telescope , of above 120 Foot long , the total Immersion , or interior Contact of the Limbs , at 2h 26~ 45~ T. aeq .
that is 2h 42~ 38~ T. app .
twelve Seconds later than I found it at Greenwich ; most of this Difference being due to the Difference of our Meridians .
And applying the Micrometer to that vast Radius , he measured the Diameter of the Planet 10~ 45~ .
At 2h 48~ 57~ he found the Difference of Declination between the southern Limbs of the Sun and Planet by the Micrometer , in a fifteen Foot Tube , to be 15~ 19~ .
Wherefore , allowing the observed Semidiameter of the Planet , and the Refraction , the said Difference was nearest 15~ 30~ , and consequently , Mercury more southerly than the Sun 's Center in respect of Declination 0~ 45~ .
Mr George Graham , in Fleet-street , London , observed the first Impression on the Sun 's Limb at 2h 41~ 9~ T. app .
and at 2h 42~ 19~ Mercury was entirely within the Disk .
At 3h 6~ 41~ he measured with a Micrometer , in a twelve Foot Tube , the Distance of his Center from the nearest Limb of the Sun 2~ 13~ .
And again , at 3h 25~ 24~ their Distance was found 3~ 57~ .
At 3h 34~ 43~ he measured the Difference of Declination , from the northern Limb of the Sun 14~ 57~ , which , corrected by Refraction , becomes 15~ 4~ , that is , 1~ 11~ more northerly than the Sun 's Center .
In the Observatory at Paris , Signor Maraldi observed the first Appearance of Mercury on the Sun 's Limb at 2h 50~ 13~ T. app .
and the interior Contact at 2h 51~ 48~ .
And Mr. de Lisle , observing apart , concluded the same at 2h 51~ 37~ , but suspects it might have been some few Seconds later .
This Gentleman has communicated his Observation at large , from whence we shall only borrow the following observed Latitudes .
h~~~~ At 2 56 20 Latitudo Borea Mercurii 3 36 3 00 40 3 42 3 10 20 3 46 3 16 12 3 55 At Bononia , in Italy , Signor Manfredi observed Mercury indenting the Sun 's Limb at 3h 26~ 22~ ; and that he was gotten entirely within , at 3h 27~ 45~ .
And these are the Observations most to be depended on , that we have received from abroad .
In order to deduce from this Phenomenon , so accurately observed , what may contribute to the Perfectioning of the Theory of Mercury 's Motion , which ( as appears by the near Agreement of our Numbers with this and many other Observations of him ) seems to need but very little Correction ; I carefully computed , from our Tables , the Motion of the Planet in five Hours , and found his apparent Motion on the Sun , to be in Longitude 29~ 21~ Retrograde , and that his Latitude increased northerly 4~ 171/ 2~ in the same time ; whence the Horary Motion in Longitude 5~ 52~ , and in Latitude 0~ 511/ 2~ , and thence the Angle of the visible Way with the Ecliptic 8~ 19~ , and the Horary Motion in that Way 5~ 56~ .
Again , the Angle of the Ecliptic with the Meridian , being in this Place 73~ 24~ , the visible Way of Mercury , made an Angle of 65~ 5~ with the Meridian passing through the Center of the Sun , whence the Horary Change of Declination becomes exactly 2~ 30~ .
These Data I choose rather to take from the Theory , than from immediate Observation ; because there is always an unavoidable , tho ' small Uncertainty , in what we observe , yet greater than there can be in the Computation for so small a Space of Time , especially now the Theory is , as I said before , so very near the Truth .
This premised , let us now enquire the true Time of the central Ingress , and the Latitude of the Planet at that Time .
And first , by my own Account , Mercury was gotten into the Parallel of the Sun 's Center , 211/ 2 Minutes after the central Ingress , in which Time he ascended to the Northward 0~ 54~ , and so much , therefore , was he more Southerly than the Sun 's Center at his Ingress .
Mr. Bradly , 71/ 2 Minutes after the said Ingress , in which the Planet ascended 0~ 19~ , found his Declination 0~ 45~ South , and therefore at the Ingress , his Declination was 1~ 4~ South .
And by by Mr. Graham 's Observation , Mercury was more northerly than the Sun 's Center 1~ 11~ , 53~ 20~ after the central Ingress ; but in that Time , Mercury ascended 2~ 13~ , wherefore , according to him , at the Ingress the Planet had 1~ 2~ South Declination .
We shall not therefore err above a Semidiameter of Mercury , if we assume his Declination , at that Time , to have been precisely one Minute .
Now the Sun 's Semidiameter being then 16~ 15~ , one Minute is the Sine of 3~ 32~ in the Arch of the Sun 's Limb ; and consequently , the Point of this Ingress was 13~ 4~ more northerly than the Ecliptic ; whence the Latitude of Mercury was then 3~ 40~ North , and Difference of Longitude 15~ 50~ , by how much he , at that Time , follow 'd the Sun 's Center .
If therefore , to the Arch of 13~ 4~ , we add the Double of 8~ 19~ , or of the Angle which the visible Way made with the Ecliptic , we shall have 29~ 42~ for the Point on the Sun 's western Limb , at which the Planet made his Exit , likewise to the North of the Ecliptic .
Hence the Chord , described in the whole Transit , was of 137~ 14~ , and the Chord itself 30~ 16~ ; and the nearest Distance to the Sun 's Center 5~ 56~ .
Now the Horary Motion in this Chord , being 5~ 56~ , the whole Duration of this Mercurial Eclipse becomes 5h 6~ in respect of the Center of the Planet ; and therefore the nearest Approach of their Centers was at 5~ 14~ 30~ at Greenwich , and the Exit at 7h 47~1/ 2 both visible in our American Plantations , had there been any curious Person there qualified to observe them .
It follows likewise , by the observed Diameter of Mercury , 10~ 45~ that he was very little less than two Minutes of Time in passing the Limb ; and , by the given nearest Distance to the Sun 's Center , it is concluded that he was in Conjunction , in Point of Longitude , at 5h 23~ 15~ having then precisely 6~ 00~ North Latitude .
Nor can it be doubted , but that all this would have been found exceeding near to Truth , had not the too early setting of the Sun deprived all Europe of the desirable Sight .
There being a very remarkable Period of the Motion of Mercury in 46 Years , in which Time , he makes 191 Revolutions about the Sun ; this Transit of ours is found to have been preceded by two others at that Interval : The first , in the Year 1631 , when Gassendus at Paris , on the 28th Day of October , still .
vet .
was the first that ever observed this Appearance of Mercury within the Sun 's Disk , and found him to pass off at 10h 28~ mane .
The second was , Octob. 28~ 1677 , when myself had the good Fortune to observe both the Ingress and Egress of the Planet in the Island of St. Helena ; the middle Time , when he was nearest to the Sun 's Center , being there but 3~ 50~ past Noon , and the visible Duration of the Transit of the Center of the Planet 5h 14~ 20~ ; which was some small matter contracted by Parallax , and most likely might have been 5h 15~ 00~ without it .
Now in 5h 15~ , Mercury described the Chord of 146~ 52~ in the Sun 's Limb , being 31~ 9~ , and consequently the nearest Distance to the Center was 4~ 38~ , or the Sine of 16~ 34~ the Sun 's Semidiameter being Radius ; that is , 1~ 18~ less than we found it in 1723 .
Hence also it follows , that the true Conjunction in Longitude was 7 min. of Time later than the nearest Approach of the Centers , viz. at 0h 10~ 50~ at St. Helena , or at 0h 35~ past Noon at Greenwich : and , that the North Latitude of the Planet , at that Time , was 4~ 41~ .
Supposing , therefore , the nearest Distance of the Centers in the Transit of 1631 , to have been 3~ 20~ , that is , 1~ 18~ less than in 1677 , we shall find that Mercury then described a Chord of 156~ 20~ , traversing the Disk of the Sun in 5h 21~ 30~ ; so that supposing his Exit at 10h 28~ at Paris , that is 10h 18~ 40~ at Greenwich , he entered on the Sun at 4h 57~ 10~ in the Morning ; and was nearest his Center at 7h 38~ T. app .
but in the same Longitude with him at 7h 43~ , or Octob. 27~ 19h 43~ T. app .
having then 3~ 22~ North Latitude .
And here , I think I may , without Vanity , advertise the Reader , that above thirty Years since , viz. in Philosoph. Trans. No 193 , for the Month of March , &amp;c. 1690/ 1 , I predicted , by Help of the two former , this last Transit , with a surprising Exactness , even beyond my Hopes , making the Time of the middle , or nearest Approach of the Centers of the Sun and Mercury , Anno 1723 , Octob. 29d 5h 19~ T. app .
which we found by Observation at 5h 14~1/ 2 , only 4~1/ 2 Minutes sooner ; and , in Latitude , Mercury was but six Seconds more southerly than I then had computed it ; the Error , in Longitude , being little more than two Diameters of this exceeding small Planet ; and , in Latitude , but a single Semidiameter thereof .
So , that for the Future , Astronomers may trust my Table of these Transits , in Transact. No 193 , to a few Minutes of Time , and not wait with the Uncertainty of Hours , nay Days , as has lately been done .
But , in order to obtain a yet further Degree of Exactness by Help of this Observation , it may be most expedient to compare with it the Ingress I observed at St. Helena ; because , in that , as well as in this , the Latitudes of the Planet being very small , a little Error in them will not so much affect the Longitudes .
Supposing therefore , that Anno 1677 , Octob. 27~ 21h 26~ 15~ at St. Helena , or 21h 50~ 15~ T. app .
at Greenwich , the Center of Mercury entered on the Sun , and that , at that Time , he was 81/ 4 Degrees on the Sun 's Limb , to the North of the Ecliptic ( according to what is above concluded ) it follows , that he had then 2~ 20~ North Latitude , and 16~ 5~ greater Longitude than the Sun 's Center ; as in this present Transit , Octob. 29~ 2h 41~ 30~ T. app .
at Greenwich , he had 3~ 40~ North Latitude , and 15~ 50~ more Longitude .
Now the apparent Geocentrick Differences of Longitude , are to the real Heliocentrick Differences , as the Planet 's true Distance from the Sun , to his Distance from the Earth ; that is , in both Cases , as 313 to 676 ; wherefore , in 1677 , Mercury wanted 34~ 45~ of the Conjunction with the Sun ; and , in 1723 , but 34~ 13~ , at the Times of his apparent Ingress on the Disk .
And , equating the Times , I find , that the Sun , Anno 1677 , Octob. 27d 21h 34~ 20~ T. aeq .
was , in ~ 15~ 36~ 55~ and , consequently Mercury 's Heliocentrick Pleace ~ 15~ 2~ 10~ : and , Anno 1723 , Octob. 29d 2h 25~ 30~ T. aeq .
the Sun was in ~ 16~ 39~ 43~ , and therefore Mercury , at that Time , in ~ 16~ 5~ 30~ .
Mercury therefore , in 46 Years with 11 Intercalations , and besides 1d 4h 51~ 10~ , has made 191 Revolutions to the Equinoctial Points , and over and above 1~ 3~ 20~ .
But , by the Scholion to Prop. XIV .
Lib. III .
Natur .
Philosoph. Principia Math. the Motion of the Aphelion of Mercury , from the Equinox in that Time , is 40~ 18~ ; so that there remains 23~ 2~ of True Anomaly to be reduced to the Mean : Now the Mean Anomaly of Mercury , in both Cases , being 5 sig .
12~ , 23~ 2~ of True Anomaly gives 15~ 24~ Mean Anomaly ; which added to 40~ 18~ becomes 55~ 42~ , for the Mean Motion above so many Revolutions : and this is to be increased by 8~ to reduce it to the Plane of Mercury 's Orb , in all 55~ 50~ .
Hence , doubling the Interval , in 92 Julian Years 1d 9h 42~ 20~ , the Mean Motion of Mercury from the Equinox is 0s 1~ 51~ 40~ , from which , taking 5~ 44~ 50~ the Motion in 1d 9h 42~ 20~ , we have his Motion in 92 Julian Years 11s 26~ 6~ 50~ , and in 100 Years , 2s 14~ 2~ 13~ , which is but 20~ more than I had some Years since printed it , in my Astronomical Tables shortly to be published , and differs but one Hour 's Motion therefrom in 3000 Years .
The forementioned Proportion of the Distances , viz. 313 to 676 , is also between the Latitudes seen from the Earth and the Inclinations , or Heliocentrick Latitudes of the Planet : so that 2~ 20~ , at the Ingress of 1677 , gives 5~ 2~ ; and 3~ 40~ in 1723 , becomes 7~ 55~ for the Latitudes at the Sun .
And the Inclination of the Orb of Mercury to the Plane of the Ecliptic ( determined by accurate Observations near his northern Limit ) being 6~ 59~ 20~ , we compute the Distance of the Planet from his Node , in the former 0~ 41~ 7~ , and , in the latter , 1~ 4~ 37~ ; which , being deducted from his Heliocentrick Places respectively , leave the Place of the ascending Node , in 1677 , ~ 14~ 21~ 3~ ; and , in 1723 , ~ 15~ 0~ 53~ : So , that in 46 Years the Node is found 39~ 50~ forwarder in the Ecliptic ; which is but 1~ 30~ more than the Praecession of the Equinox in the same Time .
We may therefore safely assume the Plane of the Orb of Mercury to be immovable in the Sphere of fixed Stars , and its ascending Node to be 0s 15~ 41~ from the first Star of Aries .
Nor can so very slow a Motion ( supposing such to be ) be fully defined , but by the utmost Care and Diligence of future Astronomers , after the Observation of many Ages .
As to the rest of the Theory of this Planet 's Motion , I make his mean Distance from the Sun , 38710 such Parts as the mean Distance of the Sun and Earth is 100000 ; and his greatest Equation 23~ 42~ 37~ .
The Epoch of his middle Motion , ineunte Anno 1723 , flyl .
vet .
from the Equinoctial Point , I make ~ 19~ 9~ 31~ ; and that of his Aphelion to the same Time ~ 13~ 3~ 34~ : the Aphelion moving secundum Seriem Signorum , seven Minutes in eight Years .
And these Numbers I presume , may represent the Motion of Mercury , with an Exactness equal to that of any of the other Planets ; perhaps as near as the Sun 's Place by any Tables , or those of the fixed Stars by any Catalo gue yet extant .
It were to be wished , that some good Observation , like this , had been made of the like Transit of Mercury at his other Node in April , where he was seen in1 deed deed April 23~ 1661 , but so imperfectly , that neither Ingress nor Egress was any where observed ; and , though it be certain , that he traversed the Sun on April 26~ , 1674 ; and again April 24 , 1707 , yet we were so unfortunate , that the Conjunction in both happened so near Midnight , that he escaped unseen by all the Astronomers of Europe , excepting singly Mr. Roemer at Copenhagen , whose Observation I have lately received by the Favour of Mr. De l ' Isle the Astronomer , communicated in the Words of the Manuscript Journal of Observations of the said Mr. Roemer .
Body sexto Maii ( Anno 1707 ) hora matutina 4h 19~ , spectabatur Mercurius in extremo margin Solis jamjam exiturus ; altus supra imum solis marginem 1/ 4 diametri solaris , &amp; ad sinistram in Tubo ( sc .
invertente ) Accuratius haec determinare non licuit ob moram nimis brevem .
' ' It was great Pity , that he did not , at least , estimate , how many Diameters of his Body he was distant from the Limb of the Sun , or what Part of a Diameter , if so near : But having examined this Observation , I find that the Sun , at that Time , was but just risen , or rather rising , and soon after entered into a Cloud , so that the Limb of the Sun could not be distinctly seen , it always undulating and sparkling much , when so near the Horizon ; in which Circumstance , a just Observation could hardly be made .
Let us now see how our Numbers , corrected as above , will represent this Observation .
Anno 1707 , April 24~ 16h 19~ at Copenhagen is 15h 28~ at Greenwich , but 15h 24 20~ T. aeq .
To this Time , I find the Sun 's true Place ~ 14~ 50~ I~ , and his Distance from the Earth 101005 .
The correct Epoch of Mercury 's mean Motion , for the Year 1707 , is 3s 13~ 18~ 45~ , to which adding , for the rest of the Time , 3s 19~ 9~ 28~ , we shall have his middle Motion at the Time of the Observation ~ 2~ 28~ 13~ ; and , taking his Aphelion in ~ 12~ 49~ 49~ therefrom , we have his mean Anomaly 10~ 19~ 38~ 24~ , and thereby the Equation to be added 12~ 39~ 41~ , and thence the Place of Mercury in his Orb ~ 15~ 7~ 54~ .
But the correct Place of the descending Node is ~ 14~ 46~ 25~ , and therefore Mercury , being 21~ 29~ past the Node , had 2~ 36~ South Latitude at the Sun ; and his Place , reduced to the Ecliptic , was ~ 15~ 7~ 45~ , that is , 17~ 44~ past the Conjunction of the Sun , which diminished in the Proportion of 5567 to 4533 , or of the Distance of the Planet from the Earth to his Distance from the Sun , becomes 14~ 27~ ; and by so much was he past the Conjunction as viewed from the Earth .
Again , by the same Proportion , his Geocentrick Latitude , at that Time , was 2~ 7~ South ; and therefore , his apparent Distance from the Sun 's Center , was 14~ 37~ ; that is , but 1~ 18~ from his western Limb ; so that he might well be said to be , jamjam exiturus .
But , that Mercury should at that Time be so far northerly , as Mr. Roemer 's Words import , was absolutely impossible ; and , I am apt to believe , that so acute an Astronomer as Mr. Roemer was , could not himself be the Observer , but some Person less acquainted with these Matters ; which the Words spectabatur Mercurius , instead of Mercurium vidi , seem to import .
If he had then had North Latitude , he must needs have been seen in the Sun in April 1720 , which we are assured he was not .
Lastly , it may not be amiss to advertise , that on the last Day of October 1736 , Mercury will again traverse the northern Part of the Sun 's Disk , both Ingress and Egress being visible to all Europe .

