III .
Some Reflections on Mr. de Lisle 's Comparison of the Magnitude of Paris with London and several other Cities , printed in the Memoirs of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris for the Year 1725 .
Communicated in a Letter to Dr. Rutty , Secretary to the Royal Society , by Peter Davall , of the Middle Temple , Esq. MR. de Lisle in the Account he gives of his Method of making an exact Plan of Paris , and comparing it with London , and other Cities , first shows , by what Means he proceeded in determining , and laying down the true Situation of the several Places in Paris : After which he explains his Manner of drawing a true Meridian Line through that City ; whereby he was enabled to divide it by Meridians and ` Parallels , as is practised in a general Map : And then he goes on in the following Words ; I traced the Parallels from 15 to 15 Seconds , and the Meridians from 20 to 20 .
And , as under the Parallel of Paris , 15 Degrees of Latitude are equivalent to 20 of Longitude , and the like is true of Minutes and Seconds ; by allowing 5 Seconds more to the Intervals of the Meridians , than to those of the Parallels , I formed perfect Squares .
' ' He says , the chief Use he intended to make of these Squares , was to compare the Magnitude of Paris with that of London , and gives an Account of what Method he took to procure a just Plan of this City , which he reduced to the same Scale as that of Paris , and proceeds thus : I traced upon it in like Manner , Squares from 15 to 15 Seconds of a great Circle , and then I was prepared to compare the Greatness of the two Cities .
' ' The Result of this Comparison is , that Paris contains 63 of these Squares , which makes for its Superficies 3538647 square Toises : And that London contains only 60 of those Squares , or 3370140 square Toises .
' ' And from hence he concludes , that Paris is one twentieth Part greater than London , tho ' he says he has excluded several Gardens , contained within Paris , out of this Mensuration , which would have made it bear still a greater Proportion to London .
Upon reading this Account of Mr. de Lisle 's , it immediately occurred to me , that the Method which he has here taken of comparing the Magnitudes of Paris and London , from whence he infers that the first of these Cities is one twentieth greater than the latter , is founded on a false Supposition , viz. That under the Parallel of Paris 20 Degrees of Longitude are equal to 15 of Latitude , and consequently that by drawing Meridians from 20 to 20 Seconds , and Parallels from 15 to 15 , the Figures formed by their Intersection will be perfect Squares : For the Equator and its Parallels are to each other as the Sines of their respective Distances from the Pole .
Whence , as the Radius , or Sine of 90 Degrees , is to the Sine of the Distance of any Parallel from the Pole , or Cosine of its Latitude : : so is a Degree or any other Part of the Equator , or of any great Circle , to the like Part of the given Parallel .
Therefore taking the mean Latitude of Paris at 48o .
51 ' , the Proportion of the Degrees of a great Circle to those of the Parallel of Paris will by a Table of Sines be found to be as 1 to.6580326 .
Whereas according to Mr. de Lisle , that Proportion is only as 20 to 15 , or as 1 to.75 .
The Figures therefore which Mr. de Lisle calls Squares , are not such , but Rectangles , whose longest Side containing 15 Seconds of a great Circle , bears the same Proportion to the shortest , containing 20 Seconds of the Parallel of Paris , as.75 does to.658 , &amp;c. or nearly as 8 to 7 .
And the Intervals , which he ought to have allowed to the Meridians , to make perfect Squares of these Figures , ought to have ben 15/ 658 &amp;c. Seconds , or nearly 22''4/ 5 or 22 ' ' .
48 ' ' ' of the Parallel of Paris .
Now Mr. de Lisle says , these Figures are perfect Squares , and has computed them as Squares , whose Side was 15 ' ' of a great Circle ; for he says Paris contains 63 of these Squares , which makes 3538647 square Toises , which last Number being divided by 63 , the Quote 56169 will be the Number of square Toises contained in each Square , whose square Root gives 237 Toises for the Side of each Square , which is just 15 ' ' or 1/ 240 of a Degree of a great Circle .
Mr. de Lisle hath therefore by this Account made the superficial Content of each Rectangle , and consequently of the whole City of Paris too great by near one seventh .
To confirm which beyond Contradiction we have Mr. de Lisle 's own Testimony , who in the Plan he himself has drawn and published of Paris , and which he refers to in this very Account , has not made Squares of the above-mentioned Figures , but has given to their respective Sides the Proportion of 8 to 7 , which is as near the true one as can well be expressed by Lines , in a Plan of no larger a Scale than this .
Now in the Account we have been considering , Mr. de Lisle says himself , that in his measuring of London he drew Squares , whose Sides contained 15 Seconds of a great Circle , and of these he says , London contains sixty .
Therefore to compare Paris with London , we ought for the foregoing Reasons to make an Abatement out of the 63 Rectangles which Paris contains , nearly in the Proportion of 8 to 7 ; but because that is a little greater than the true one , let us make such Abatement only in the Proportion of 9 to 8 , which is pretty considerably less than the just one .
By which Abatement the Number of Squares , whose Side is 15 Seconds of a great Circle contained in Paris , will be reduced from 63 to 56 .
And consequently , acccording to Mr. de Lisle 's own Way of measuring , the Magnitude of London will be to that of Paris as 60 to 56 , or as 15 to 14 ; or London will be one fourteenth greater than Paris .
But to determine what Proportion these two Cities really bear to each other , requires a more exact Mensuration of London than any we yet have , which whoever would undertake , I think he cannot follow a better Method than that Mr. de Lisle has taken , and would advise him to consult the Account upon which the foregoing Reflections are made , which he may find in the Memoires of the Royal Academy of Sciences , for the Year 1725 .

