A Letter from the Rev. Dr. Samuel Clarke to Mr. Benjamin Hoadly , F. R. S. occasioned by the present Controversy among Mathematicians , concerning the Proportion of Velocity and Force in Bodies in Motion .
SIR , IT has often been observed in general , that Learning does not give Men Understanding ; and that the absurdest Things in the World have been asserted and maintained , by Persons whose Education and Studies dies should seem to have furnished them with the greatest Extent of Science .
That Knowledge in many Languages and Terms of Art , and in the History of Opinions and Romantic Hypotheses of Philosophers , should sometimes be of no Effect in correcting Mens Judgment , is not so much to be wondered at .
But that in Mathematicks themselves , which are a real Science , and founded in the necessary Nature of Things ; men of very great Abilities in abstract Computations , when they come to apply those Computations to the Nature of Things , should persist in maintaining the most palpable Absurdities , and in refusing to see some of the most evident and obvious Truths ; is very strange .
An extraordinary Instance of this , we have had of late Years in very eminent Mathematicians , Mr. Leibnitz , Mr. Herman , Mr. 'sGravesande , and Mr. Bernoulli ; who ( in order to raise a Dust of Opposition against Sir Isaac Newton 's Philosophy , the Glory of which is the Application of abstract Mathematicks to the real Phenomenon of Nature , ) have for some Years insisted with great Eagerness , upon a Principle which subverts all Science , and which may easily be made appear ( even to an ordinary Capacity ) to be contrary to the necessary and essential Nature of Things .
What they contend for , is , That the Force of any Body in Motion , is proportional , not to its Velocity , but to the Square of its Velocity .
The Absurdity of which Notion , I shall first make appear , and then show what it is that has led these Gentlemen into Error .
In the Nature of Things , it is evident , every Effect must necessarily be proportionate to the Cause of that Effect ; that is , to the Action of the Cause , or the Power exerted at the Time when the Effect is produced .
To suppose any Effect proportional to the Square or Cube of its Cause , is to suppose that an Effect arises partly from its Cause , and partly from * Nothing .
In a Body in Motion , there may be considered distinctly , the Quantity of the Matter , and the Velocity of the Motion .
The Force arising from the Quantity of the Matter as its Cause , must necessarily be proportional to the Quantity of the Matter : And the Force arising from the Velocity of the Motion as its Cause , must necessarily be proportional to the Velocity of the Motion .
The whole Force therefore arising from these two Causes , must necessarily be proportional to these two Causes taken together .
And therefore in Bodies of equal Bigness and Density , or in one and the same Body , the Quantity of Matter continuing always the same , the Force must necessarily be always proportional to the Velocity of the Motion .
If the Force were as the Square of the Velocity , all that Part of the Force , which was above the Proportion of the Velocity , would arise either out of Nothing , or ( according to Mr. Leibnitz 's Philosophy ) out of some * Which is just like the Supposition made by those Mathematicians , who have taken it for granted , that ~ is equal to Infinite ; that is , that as 0 to 1 , so 1 is to Infinite ; that is , that Infinite multiplied by 0 , is equal to 1 , or an infinite Number of Nothings equal to Something ; which is palpably false .
The true Proportion is , not as 0 to 1 , so 1 to Infinite ; but as an Infinitesimal is to 1 , so is 1 to Infinite .
And as the Infinitesimal of an Infinitesimal ( that is , a second Fluxion , or the second Power of Infinitesimal ) is to 1 , so is 1 to Infinity of Infinites , or the second Power of Infinite ; that is , ( for Instance ) it is as a finite [ physical ] Line to an Infinite Surface , or as a finite [ physical ] Surface to an infinite Solid .
And as 0 ( which is beyond all Proportion lower than the Infinit'th Power of an Infinitesimal ) is to 1 , so is 1 to that which is beyond all Proportion higher than the Infinit'th Power of Infinite .
Which clearly removes the Foundation of all the ridiculous Consequences , which have been drawn from the Supposition of the fore-mention 'd false Proportion .
living Soul essentially belonging to every Particle of Matter .
Whenever any Effect whatsoever , is in a duplicate Proportion , or as the Square of any Cause ; it is always either because there are two Causes acting at the same Time , or that one and the same Cause continues to act for a double Quantity of Time .
The Resistance made to a Body moving in any fluid Medium , is in a duplicate Proportion to the Velocity of its Motion ; because , in Proportion to its Velocity , it is resisted by a greater Number of Particles in the same Time ; and again , in Proportion to its Velocity , it is resisted by the same Particles singly with a greater Force , as being to be moved out of their Places with greater Velocity .
Light decreases in a duplicate Proportion of its Distance from the Sun ; because the Rays divaricate according to two Dimensions ; according to the Dimension upwards or downwards , and according to the Dimension side-ways .
But according to the third Dimension forwards from the Sun , a Ray of Light undergoes no Alteration ; because the Particles , of which it consists , being emitted all of them with an equal Velocity , continue every where at an equal Distance from each other .
One and the same Cause , acting in a double Quantity of Time , produces the same Effect , as two equal Causes acting in a single Quantity of Time .
One and the same Force , in two Parts of Time , will cause a Body in Motion to describe the same Space , as double the Force would do in one Part of Time .
The Space described therefore by a Body in Motion , is not as the Force ; but as the Force and the Time taken together .
A Body , with any the least assignable Force , will move through infinite Space , if it meets with no Resistance , in an infinite Time .
And in Spaces where there is an uniform Resistance to Motion , the Space described before the Motion ceases , must needs be as the Force and as the Time together : Because a double Force will carry a Body twice as far in the same Time , and will also cause the Motion to be twice as long Time in destroying by an uniform Resistance .
The Space described therefore before the Motion ceases , is in this Case demonstrably as the Square of the Force .
A Body thrown upwards with double Force , will be carried four Times as high , before its Motion be stopped by the uniform Resistance of Gravity ; because the double Force will carry it twice as high in the same Time , and moreover require twice the Time for the uniform Resistance to destroy the Motion .
The Case is the same in accelerated Motion ; in Bodies accelerated by a Succession of elastick Impressions , or falling with a Motion accelerated by the uniform Power of Gravity , or by any other uniform Power whatsoever .
The Space described must needs be as the Force , and as the Time wherein the Force operates .
What I have thus demonstrated concerning any Force , considered as the Cause producing an Effect ; and concerning the Time , during which the Force operates ; is on all Hands acknowledged to be true concerning Velocity .
And therefore Velocity and Force , in this Case , are one and the same Thing .
So that to affirm Force to be as the Square of the Velocity , is to affirm that the Force is equal to the Square of it self .
Now from hence appears very clearly the Ground of the Error these Gentlemen have fallen into , and of their Misapplication of the Experiments they build upon .
The Effect of a Force impressed on a moveable Body , is the Motion of that Body from one Place to another .
Now forasmuch as the Effect cannot but be proportional to its Cause , hence Mr. Leibnitz ( whom the other Gentlemen have follow 'd ) contends that the Space described by a Body in falling , is proportional to the Force by which it is impelled during its Fall ; and that the Force acquired by a Body in falling , is proportional to the Space it has described in its Fall .
Which Space being agreed to be as the Square of the Velocity ( as being proportional to the Velocity and to the Time taken together ) hence they infer that the Force likewise is as the Square of the Velocity .
But from what has been said , it is plain , that the Space described in these and all other the like Cases , is not as the Force only , but as the Force and as the Time wherein the Force acts ; that is to say , as the Square of the Force .
For the Cause of the Quantity of the Space described , is not barely the Quantity of the Force , but also the Continuance of the Time wherein the Force acts .
The Force therefore and the Time taken together , being necessarily as the Space described ; as the Velocity and the Time taken together , are on all Hands acknowledged to be ; it follows that the Velocity and the Force are equal , and not the Force as the Square of the Velocity .
When two unequal Bodies fastened at the Ends of the Arms of a Balance of unequal Length , counterpoise each other , and vibrate in equal Times ; as they must necessarily do , being fastened to the Arms of the same Balance : which is an Observation Mr. Leibnitz lays great Stress upon : In That Case indeed the Forces will be as the Spaces described .
But not therefore as the Squares of the Velocities .
For in That Case , the Velocities themselves are as the Spaces described , because the Times are equal .
When a Body projected with a double Velocity , enters deeper into Snow or soft Clay , or into a Heap of springy or elastick Parts , than in Proportion to its Velocity ; it is not because the Force is more than proportional to the Velocity ; but because the Depth it penetrates into a soft Medium , arises partly from the Degree of the Force or Velocity , and partly from the Time wherein the Force operates before it be spent .
In the Collision of hard Bodies , it is ( I think ) agreed on all Hands , that it is demonstrated by Reason , and confirmed by Experience ; that when a perfectly hard Ball , moved with whatever Degree of Velocity , strikes full upon another hard Ball , equal in Bigness and Weight , and without any Motion in it ; if the Balls be unelastick , they will both go on together the same Way , dividing the Motion equally between them , with half the Velocity the first Ball had originally : But if they be perfectly elastick , the moving Ball will communicate its whole Motion and Velocity to the quiescent Ball , and it self lie still in the others Place .
Were it true now , that the Force of the moving Ball was as the Square of its Velocity ; these Experiments would then show ( which is infinitely absurd ) that the Force or vis inertiae in the quiescent Ball , the dead Force , was always proportional to the Square of the Velocity ( which these Gentlemen affect fantastically to call the living Force ) of the moving Ball , whatever its Velocity were .
Or the Force in Both might just as reasonably be supposed to be as the Cube , or the quadrato-quadrate , or any other Power of the Velocity of the moving Ball .
Which is turning the Nature of Things into Ridicule .
Mr. Leibnitz , in some Letters which he wrote into England , intimated that he had a Prospect of a perpetual Motion , founded on the Notion of a Vital Principle , or active Power in Matter .
But from the Experiments now mentioned , it is evident that if the Force of Bodies in Motion could be exalted even to the infinit'th Power of their Velocity ; yet since , to answer the Phenomenon of Nature with Regard to Action and Re-action , the same Force must necessarily be allowed to all quiescent Bodies likewise ; it could be of No Effect .

