III .
Remarks upon some~ Experiments in Hydraulics , which seem to prove , that the Forces of equal moving Bodies are as the Squares of their Velocities .
By Mr. John Eames , F. R. S. THE Result and Substance of these Experiments is , That the Velocities of any Fluid , for Instance Water , issuing out at equal Orifices made in the Sides of Tubes , or Vessels filled up to different Heights , and kept full at those Heights , above the Orifices , are found to be as the square Roots of those Heights respectively , Thus , when the different Heights above the Orifices are as the Numbers 1 , 4 , 9 , 16 , &amp;c. the Velocities of the Particles of Water , issuing out , are found to be as the Numbers 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , &amp;c. The Argument drawn from these Experiments , in Favour of the Opinion , that the Forces of equal Masses , or moving Bodies , are proportional to the Squares of their Velocities , runs thus .
All the Particles of Water , being of the same Nature , and uniform , every single Particle issuing out with Two Degrees of Velocity , must move with 4 Times the Force of any other single Particle , that moves but with One Degree of Velocity ; because the Force with which it moves , is the Effect of a Cause 4 Times greater ; namely , the Pressure of a Column of Water , whose Height is 4 Times greater .
Thus , again , a Particle of Water running out , with 3 Degrees of Velocity , must move with 9 Times the Force of a Particle moving with but 1 Degree of Velocity ; because that Force is the Effect of a Cause 9 Times greater , viz. the Pressure of a Column 9 Times higher .
Since no less than a Column 9 Times higher , is found , by Experience , necessary to make the several Particles of Water issue out with 3 Degrees of Velocity .
So that , in these Two Instances , it seems to be certain , that the Forces communicated , are as the Squares of the Velocities .
And that it is so universally , is argued thus : The Pressures are as the Altitudes , and the Altitudes as the Squares of the Velocities of every single Particle ; therefore the Pressures are as the Squares of the Velocities ; but the Pressures are the Causes of the Forces , with which the several Particles of Water issue out , or move ; and therefore since Effects are proportional to their Causes , the Forces with which the several Particles issue out , and move , are as the Squares of the Velocities .
REMARK I. The Fault committed in this Reasoning , and which quite runs through it , is the mistaking a Part of the Effect for the Whole .
The entire Effect of any of these Pressures is , not barely a certain Number of Degrees of Velocity , in any single Particle , but certain Degrees of Velocity in a certain Number of Particles , and that certain Number of Particles , in a given Time , is , confessedly , as the Degrees of Velocity .
REMARK II .
And this leads me to a Second Remark , which is , That the entire Effect of these Pressures being taken into Consideration , seems to overturn this new Rule in Mechanicks for computing the Forces of moving Bodies , which is , That the Forces are as the Quantities of Matter multiplied by the Squares of the Velocities .
And this I shall endeavour to make out thus : The Gentlemen who advance this new Rule , at the same Time that they assert the Velocities , in the Cases of the Experiment above mentioned , to be as the Square Roots of the Altitudes , do also confess , that the Quantities of the Fluid , pressed out in equal Times , are as those Velocities .
For thus an ingenious Professor abroad tells us in his Epitome Element .
Phys. Math. Part .
2da .
Cap.iv .
p.665 .
` ` Quantitates fluidorum ex utroque vase exeuntium in eodem tempore sunt inter se velut celeritates , adeoque in subduplicata ratione altitudinum fluidorum supra foramina .
Now if this be true , that the Quantities of Water flowing out in equal Times , are as the Velocities , then the Forces cannot be as the Quantities of Matter multiplied by the Squares of the Velocities : For then the Effects , instead of being proportional , would be more than in Proportion to their Causes .
Thus , the Effect of a Pressure of a Column of any Fluid , as Water , 9 Inches high , instead of being but 9 times greater than that of 1 Inch above the Orifice , will be no less than 27 Times greater .
For the Velocity being at this Height triple , the Quantity of Matter in a given Time will also be triple ; which last , multiplied by the Square of the Velocity , gives 27 for the Force communicated by a Pressure of 9 Inches in Altitude , while the Force communicated by the Pressure of 1 Inch , is but as 1 .
So that the moving Forces produced will be as 27 to 1 , while the Causes producing these Forces , are but as 9 to 1 , i. e. Three Times too little for such a Purpose .
Thus again , if the Velocities be as 1 and 4 , the Quantities of Water issuing out will be as 1 and 4 ; but the Effects , or Forces produced , according to the new Rule , will be as 1 and 64 ; though the Pressures , which communicate them , are but as the Altitudes , which are as 1 and 16 .
Whereas , to produce such Effects , the Altitudes of the latter Column ought to have been as 64 ; i.e. 4 Times greater than by Experience it is found to be .
REMARK III .
I cannot but observe , in the last Place , that the common Rule of estimating the Forces of moving Bodies by the Quantities of Matter multitiplied by their Velocities , is rather confirmed by these very Experiments .
For then , according to the old Maxim , Effects are proportional to their Causes , the Forces communicated will be as the Forces communicating , or Pressures .
Thus let the Altitude , and consequent Pressure of any Column of Water be 9 Times greater than the Altitude of another ; then the Velocity of every single Particle of Water pressed out will be triple , and the Number of Particles issuing out in a given Time will likewise be triple ; therefore the Force resulting from these Two multiplied together , according to the common Rule , will be 9 , proportional to the Pressure , as it ought to be .
So again , if the Altitude be 16 Times greater , the Velocity will be quadruple , and the Number of the Particles quadruple , and the Force produced the Product of these Two ; i.e. 16 , still proportional to the Altitude , or Pressure .
And universally , the Forces communicated , according to the old Rule , are in a Ratio compounded of Two others , One of the Quantities of Matter , and the other of the Velocities : The Ratio of the Velocities , by the Experiments , is the Subduplicate Ratio of the Heights , and the Ratio of the Quantities of Matter is , by Confession , likewise the Subduplicate of the Heights : Therefore the Compound of these 2 is the Ratio Integra , or simple Ratio of the Heights ; in which Ratio are the Pressures themselves , which produce these moving Forces : So that , according to the common Rule , the Effects are always , as they ought to be , proportional to their Causes .
After the same Manner the ingenious Mr.'sGravesande once argued ; for thus he reasons in Paragraph 355 of Physices Elem .
Mathematica , First Edition .
Non tamen eandem cum profunditate proportionem sequitur Velocitas , licet pressio , ex qua Velocitas oritur , in eadem ratione cum profunditate crescat .
Quantitas motus quae in liquido producitur , est effectus totus pressionis , &amp; haec quantitas ad instar pressionis augetur .
Ratio autem quantitatis motus est composita ex ratione Velocitatis , &amp; quantitatis materiae motae , hic materia mota est aqua , quae ex foramine exit , cujus quantitas , manente tempore , cum celeritate crescit ; dupla erit , si haec dupla fuerit , in quo casu motus quantitas est quadrupla , id est , augetur ut quadratum celeritatis , quod posita celeritate quacunque semper obtinet ; crescit ergo hoc quadratum ut pressio , id est , ut altitudo liquidi supra foramen ex quo profluit aqua .

