IX .
Two Chirurgical Questions , stated and answered by John Douglas , Surgeon , F. R. S. Q I. WHether it is not possible in some Measure to relieve those Persons ( who by reason of their great Age , bad Habit of Body , &amp;c. cannot submit to any of the great Operations for the Stone with tolerable hopes of Success ) by making an Artificial Fistula in the Perinaeum ?
A. That a great many Patients offer , both young and old , who are afflicted with the Stone in the Bladder , whom we cannot with any tolerable hopes of Success , advise to submit to the great Operations for the Stone , daily Experience shows .
It is inhuman to cut them , and shows a very great Imperfection in our Art , to say we can give them no Relief .
Is there no Medium yet found out between living in extreme Misery and submitting to a desperate Operation ?
Yes ; Thomas Fienus about 125 Years ago , proposed a Palliative Cure for such Patients , where a radicative Cure could not be expected ; an Operation which may be performed with safety on the most Ancient ; the Wound is so small , and the Parts cut of so little consequence to Life .
An Operation by which we can prevent or alleviate the most lamentable Effects of the Stone , viz. The total suppression of Urine and the cutting Pains they endure in , and after making Water , &amp;c. yet this Operation has been as little minded all this while by the HospitalLi Lithotomists , as Rosset 's most excellent Treatise before I introduced the Hypogastrick Section in 1719 .
Tho ' I admire Fienus 's design in making this Fistula , yet I can by no means approve of his way of doing it .
It ought to be performed thus : Place the Patient as in Marianus 's Operation ; pass a Staff into the Bladder , then cut the Skin and Fat until you lay that Part of the Urethra bare , which reaches from the prostate Gland to the Cavernous Urethra ; then make a small Incision into it with the point of your Knife ; then withdraw the Staff , and pass a small flexible Canula into the Wound of the Urethra ; then dress the Wound S. A. extract the Canula , clean it and introduce it again every Dressing , that so you may leave a Fistula in the room of the Wound .
Through this Fistula the Patient himself or any one about him , may easily pass an Oiled Probe , and push the Stone back whenever he finds himself attacked with a suppression of Urine , or when the Stone presses hard against the Sphincter , when endeavouring to make Water , which otherwise could not be done without the Ceremony of sending for , and staying in misery till a Surgeon comes to pass the Catheter , which in such cases is not always to be done , without a great deal of Pain , and sometimes Danger .
By this Fistula we can also very easily inject any Liquor that may be thought proper either to prevent or allay the Inflammation of the Bladder , or cleanse it from the Gravel , or any other sort of filth that may collect there , by which the increase of the Stone will be prevented , &amp;c. In Females all those advantages are obtained by the natural straitness and shortness of the Urethra , whence they never suffer the tenth part that Males do ; which is an incontestable evidence that when the Passage into the Bladders of Males is made as straight and near as short ( as is done by the forementioned Fistula ) they will reap the same advantages by it .
Therefore Artificial Fistula 's in the Perinaeum ought to be made for those who by reason of their great Age , and bad Habit of Body , &amp;c. cannot undergo any of the great Operations for the Stone , with any hopes of Success .
Q. 2 .
Whether it is not possible to dilate the artifificial Fistula in the Perinaeum of Males , and the Urethra of Females with Spunge or GentianTents gradually increased for some time to such a width , that we may easily pass a pair of Forceps into the Bladder , with which the Stone when small may be extracted , and when large , or of an irregular Figure , broke , and the pieces extracted gradually and at different times , when they cannot be extracted at once , without fatiguing the Patient too much ?
A. To prove that both these Fistula 's may be dilated to a sufficient bigness by the means proposed , ( especially , if the parts are frequently bathed in a Semicupium or otherwise , as the Operator shall think proper , and some warm Oil injected into the Fistula every time the Tent is changed , ( the better to supple and relax the parts , ) I shall only make use of three Arguments , viz. One from common Experience in Analogous Cases ; Another from the Operations of Nature on the same Parts ; And the third from Instances of this Operation being performed after the Method I propose .
1st , Common Experience shows to what a great width Fistula 's in all other parts of the Body , tho ' very small at first , may be dilated by Spunge or Gentian-Tents .
2dly , Nature herself without any Art has frequently performed this Operation on both Sexes ; in Males who have been cut for the Stone after the old way , and had Fistula 's remained in Perinaeo .
It is often found that some considerable time afterwards , Stones of no small size have appeared which had made their way thro ' the Sphincter of the Bladder into the Membranous Urethra , and stuck near the Orifice of the Fistula , whence they were easily and safely extracted .
I saw a Stone lately as big as a Pullet 's Egg that was expelled from the Bladder of a young Woman without any help , as her Physician assured me , and she had no inconveniency afterwards , which certainly would have happened if it had been extracted after the common violent Method .
In the last Philosophical Transaction , Dr. Beard of Worcester gives an Account of a yet larger Stone , that passed after the same manner , but she had the common inconveniency afterwards , viz. an Incontinency of Urine , which was owing more to the roughness than the bigness of the Stone , which had lacerated the Parts as in the common Operation , which might have been prevented had she been assisted in time as above .
3dly .
Mons. Collet in his Traite de la Taille , gives an Account of a Gentleman on whom he performed this Operation three different times , and extracted in all ten Stones .
His Words are as follow : Enfin~ Mons. Usson etant horse de danger &amp; sa play prete a se cicatriser , prevoyant bien ce qui pourroit arriver dans la Suite , je lui conseillai de tenir sa play ouverte , pour y entretenir seulement un petite Canule , qui dans l'occasion donneroit un entiere liberte de saire Injection pour nettoyer la Vessie de toutes les Immondices &amp; pour qu'on put enlever les nouvelles Pierres qui pourroient se former .
Il prit ce parti , &amp; il se trouva bien durant cinque Annees , quil a Vecu depuis avec assez de Sante Mais a trois differents reprises , je me suis vu Oblige de lui tirer jusqu'a dix autres pierres qui s'etoient formees dans laVessie : un petite Tent d'eponge preparee mise pendant quelques heures dans la Fistule ~ la place de la Canule me facilitoit l'Entree d'une tres petite tennette .
Mons. Usson s'habilloit dans ce Moment &amp; il sortoit pour aller par tout ou ses Affairs l'appelloient .
I know a Gentleman that now keeps a Fistula in Perinaeo open for the very same reasons .
Since then it is evident that Fistula 's in all parts of the Body are dilatable to a great width , since Nature is often able of her self to dilate the very parts in dispute , to a very extraordinary Degree ; and since this very Operation I here propose has been successfully performed three times on the same Person , Therefore Artificial Fistula 's in Males and the Urethra of Females may be dilated so as to extract any Stone without cutting the Body of the Bladder , or lacerating any of the Parts .
N. B. This Operation will appear much less surprising , if we consider , that it is only dilating the Sphincter of the Bladder , &amp;c. in a different manner from that daily done in Marianus 's Operation , i. e. By this Method the Parts are dilated gently and gradually , after being well bathed and anointed , the better to relax them .
Whereas in Marianus 's Operation they are dilated quickly and violently , and then the Stone , be it of what Largeness or Figure soever , is forcibly drawn out immediately ; whence Contusions , Lacerations , Haemorrhages , Inflammations , Mortifications , &amp;c.

