II .
Some farther Remarks on P. Souciet 's Dissertations against Sir Isaac Newton 's Chronology , by Edmund Halley , L.L.D. Astron. Reg. In a Letter to Dr. Jurin , Coll. Med. &amp; S.R.Soc .
SIR , WHENI gave you my Paper of Remarks on P. Souciet 's Dissertations against Sir Isaac Newton 's Chronology , I was obliged to take what he was pleased to give us out of Hipparchus 's Comment on Aratus , not having then that Author himself by me .
Since then , by the favour of a very good Friend , having gotten the Florence Edition of Hipparchus , Anno 1567 , I find an Argument very much ad Hominem , which the R. P. must confess will bring the Argonautick Expedition full as low as Sir Isaac Newton makes it .
P. Souciet in his fifth Dissertation , Page 119 , 120 , finds out a Star of the first Magnitude , close adjoining to that we now call the first Star of Aries , as it is in the Catalogue of Ptolemy , where it is said to be in the Horn of Aries , and not in the Ear .
This Star the R. P. supposes long since to have disappeared ; but that being of old very considerable , it was from this first Star of Aries , the Zodiac began , tho ' for Argument-sake he is contented to let it begin as Sir Isaac does , with the aforesaid Star in the Ear or Horn ; which Hipparchus , in the last and 54th Page , tells us , in his time follow 'd the Equinoctial Colure the 20th part of an Hour : And supposing the Star that has disappeared , to have been at that time precisely on the Colure , it must differ but 45 Minutes of Right Ascension therefrom : But how be comes to make the difference of Longitude 40 Minutes no way appears , and is gratis dictum .
In Page 49 of the said Florence-Edition , Hipparchus , treating of the rising and setting of the Constellations , tells us , that that of Aries began to rise with 18 ~ Degrees of Pisces in the Ecliptic , and was wholly risen with the 24th Degree of Aries , whilst the Zodiac past the Meridian from 23 1/ 2 Degrees of Sagittary to 14 Degrees of Capricorn : And again ( Page 52 ) he says , that the Constellation of Aries began to set with the 29th Degree of Pisces , and was wholly set with the 26th Degree of Aries , whilst the Zodiac past the Meridian from 29 Degrees of Gemini to 29 Degrees of Cancer .
He tells us also that it was the very same Star that both rose and set first in that Constellation , calling it ~~~~ ~ , Page 49 : And again , Page 52 it is named ~~~~ ~ , or That in the Fore-feet of the Ram .
This certainly is the Star P. Souciet would place on the Equinoctial Colure , and makes it long since to have disappeared ; without enquiring whether the aforesaid Data were not abundantly sufficient to determine its place in the Zodiac at that time ; and without regard to the odd uncouth Posture he must suppose the Constellation of Aries to be in , when he makes one or both of the Fore-feet so near to , and above the Horn or Ear .
Hipparchus expressly says , that it rose when 23 1/ 2 Degrees of Sagittary was on the Meridian , and set when 29 Degrees of Gemini past it ; and taking the middle between those Points , it is plain , that it culminated with about 26 Degrees of Pisces , and that it had North Declination ; the Excess above 180 Degrees showing that the Ascensional Difference was about 2 3/ 4 Degrees .
But to give the Argument its full Scope , the Right Ascension of 23 1/ 2 of Sagittary ( allowing Hipparchus his Obliquity 23~ 51~ 20~ ) will be found 262~ 54~ .
And that of 29 Degrees of Gemini will be 88~ 54~ : So that this Star was above the Horizon ( in the Latitude of 36 Degrees North ; to which Hipparchus has adapted his Calculation ) 12 Hours 24 Minutes or 186 Degrees ; whence the Right Ascension of the Star is justly concluded 355 Degrees 54 Minutes ; and its Ascensional Difference precisely 3 Degrees ; which in that Latitude makes its Declination 4 Degrees 7 Minutes North .
We have therefore gotten both the Right Ascension and Declination of this supposed first Star of Aries .
Let us now see what Longitude and Latitude results from the aforesaid Right Ascension with 4 Degrees 7 Minutes North Declination , assuming the Obliquity with Hipparchus , to have been 23~ 51~ 20~ ; and we shall by a just Computation , find the Star at that time to have been in 27~ 53~ of Pisces , with 5~ 24~ North Latitude , which therefore was reckoned the place of the Star at that time by Hipparchus .
Add 2~ 40~ , for 265 Years between Hipparchus and Ptolemy , and we shall have its place , in Ptolemy 's Account , Aries O~ 33~ , with 5~ 24~ North Latitude .
But the 22d Star of Pisces in Ptolemy 's Catalogue has the same Longitude and Latitude , with sufficient exact actness , viz. Aries O~ 40~ , with North Latitude 5~ 20~ , and is Media trium in Lino Boreo Piscium ( ~ Bayero .
) Hence it cannot be doubted but that this Star which P. Souciet takes to have been once a Star of the first Magnitude , was no other than the said 22th of Pisces , which in the British Catalogue , fitted to the Year 1690 , is put down in Aries 22~ 29~ ~ with North Latitude 5~ 21~ .
How Hipparchus came to reckon this Star to be in the Fore-foot of Aries , does not at present appear ; but it is not unlikely that these Commentaries of his upon Aratus were written some time before he set about making his Catalogue of the fixed Stars ; when he might change his Opinion , and replace it in the Line of the Fishes , to which it seems more properly to belong .
Be that as it will , we will for once , suppose with P. Souciet , this Star to have been in the beginning of the Zodiac , or of the Constellation of Aries , and that at the time of the first fixing the Colures , that of the Vernal Equinox past 15 Degrees in Consequence thereof .
Now anno ineunte 1690 , this Star being in Aries 22~ 29~ ~ , if we add thereto 15 Degrees , we shall have Taurus 7~ 29~ 1/ 3 for the Point in the Ecliptic that was then the beginning of the Zodiac .
Now 37 ~ Degrees , at 50 Seconds per Annum , gives 2700 Years ; from which deducting 1690 , we shall have 1010 Years before Christ .
But this Star having 5~ 21~ North Latitude , the Colure , when it past over it , intersected the Ecliptic in 2~ 20~ less Longitude , which gives the time 168 Years later , or but 842 Years before Christ .
So that malgre cette grande decouverte , the new System of Chronology is so far from being refuted , that it seems to be very much confirmed thereby , at least in the Opinion of the R. Pere .
I have assumed the Latitude to which Hipparchus might have adapted his Calculations , to be 36 Degrees ; because I find in Page 14 .
of the aforesaid Edition that he makes the longest Tropical Day 14 h. 30~ : And in Page 29 , he tells us , that the Southern Star in the left Foot of Boots ( ~ Bayero ) having 27~ 20~ North Declination , was above the Horizon , 14 h. 57~ ; whence it follows , that the Latitude must be 36~ 5~ .
He also tells us , in the same Page 29 , that this Star set when 22~ of Capricorn culminated , and 6~ of Taurus ascended ; repeating the same thing in Page .
39 , which leaves no room to suspect that those Numbers are not the same that Hipparchus had computed .
I therefore thought it worth while to enquire in what Latitude 6 Degrees of Taurus rises when 22 Degrees of Capricorn is on the Meridian ; and with the Obliquity of the Ecliptic , as now we have it , the Latitude resulting is 35~ 1/ 2 North ; but with the Obliquity allowed by Hipparchus , it will be found less than 35~ .
This I say , only to obviate any Objection that may be made by P. Souciet to the aforegoing Argument ; tho ' if he please to examine it , he will find that an Error of a Degree in the assumed Latitude , will by no means invalidate the Proof here given that this First Star of Aries could be no other than the middle Star in Lino Boreo Piscium , marked ~ by Bayer .

