Philosoph : Transac : No. 376 .
Pl : I. Fig. 2 .
C DE AB P M. N. F W II .
Animadversions upon some Experiments relating to the Force of moving Bodies ; with two new Experiments on the same Subject .
By the Reverend Dr. Desaguliers , F. R. S. IN a former Paper *I demonstrated , by Reason and Experiments , that the Momentum , or Force of moving Bodies , is always proportionable to their Mass multiplied into their Velocity ; as it is the Opinion of the greatest Part of the Mathematicians and Philosophers .
Now I come to consider the Experiments , that have led some ingenious Men into an Error , in relation to this Proposition .
Polenus in his Book ~ gives an Account of his Experiments relating to this Matter , in these Words : ` ` I took a Vessel , that had in it congealed Tallow six Inches deep , and fixed it to a level Floor , in such manner , that the Surface of the Tallow , which was flat , should every where be equally distant from the Floor .
I had caused to be made two Balls of equal Bigness , the one of Lead , the other of Brass , the last of which was a little hollow in the middle , that it might weigh but one Pound , whilst the other weighed two .
Suspending these Balls from the Ceiling by Threads , in such manner , that the lighter Ball hung over the Surface of the Tallow , from twice the Height that the heavier Ball did ; I cut the Threads , and the Balls falling perpendicularly upon the Tallow , by their * Philosoph. Trans. No. 375 .
~ De Castellis , page .
56 .
No. 118 .
Fall made Pits in the Tallow , that were precisely equal : the Ball of one Pound , from the Beginning of its Fall , till it came to rest , going through a Space expressed by the Number two , produced an Effect equal to that , which the two Pound Ball did produce , in falling thro ' a Space expressed by the Number one .
It follows therefore , that we may look upon it as a settled Truth , That the active Forces ( vires vivas ) of falling Bodies are then equal , when their proper Weights are in a reciprocal Ratio of the Spaces , which the said Bodies describe by their Fall .
And because these Spaces are in the same Ratio , as the Squares of the Numbers expressing the Velocities ; it appears by the Experiment , that the active Force ( vim vivam ) of the falling Body , is that which is made up of the Body itself , multiplied into the Space described in the Fall , or into the Square of the Number , that expresses the Velocity of the Body , at the end of the Motion .
This Experiment I did not only make once , but several times , changing the Balls , the Distances , and the Body on which they fell ; as for example , making use of Clay , or of soft Wax : and notwithstanding these various ways of trying the Experiments , the Effects were constantly the same ; which made me easily conclude , that there was always the same Reason in Nature for this Phenomenon .
Thus far Polenus , whose Mistake lies in this ; that he estimates the Force of the Stroke of the falling Balls , by the Depth of the Impression made in the Tallow , Clay , Wax , or any yielding Substance .
But we must consider , that when two Bodies move with equal Forces , but different Velocities , that , which moves the swiftest , must make the deepest Impression , whilst the slowest Body communicates its Motion to the Clay round about , and therefore does not strike in so deep as the swifter Body , which puts in Motion few Parts of the Clay , besides those that are before it , and which Parts have so much less Time to oppose this Body 's Motion , as its Velocity is greater than the other 's .
To make this plainer , Let us suppose a Door half open , and moving very freely on its Hinges ; if a Pistol be fired against it , the Ball will go thro ' the Door without moving it out of its Place ; but if we take a large Weight of Lead , and throw it against the same Door , with the same Force as the Pistol Bullet moved , the Door will be removed from its Position , and carried out of the Place on its Hinges by the Stroke ; because in the first Case , the Motion of the Ball is communicated but to a few Parts of the Door , and in the last it is diffused all over it .
Nay , the Door will be moved by the Stroke , even tho ' there should be a prominent Part in the Lead , that should be no bigger than a Pistol-Bullet , in order to strike the Door upon no more of its Surface , than the Bullet had done .
For illustrating this farther I contrived the following Experiment .
I caus 'd a Machine to be made , as represented in Pl .
I. Fig. 1 .
consisting of a Base of Wood A B , which could be set horizontal by means of three Screws , such as S S : Upon this Board , or Base , there stood upright two parallel Boards , about four Inches wide , and four Inches asunder , with the Elbow-piece OF sliding behind one of them , so as to raise its upper End F to any Height desired .
Between these Boards , square Frames of Wood GG &amp;c. with Paper extended upon them , could slide in , to the Number of Six , in an horizontal Position .
These Paper Diaphragms being thus placed , I suspended an Ivory Ball of about one Inch and an half Diameter , weighing something more than an Ounce and an half , by a short Thread , under F , so that its Center of Gravity hung four foot over the first Diaphragm ; then cutting the Thread , the Ball fell upon the Paper , and by its perpendicular Stroke broke thro ' that Diaphragm , and the three next under it .
Then putting so much Lead into the Ball abovemention 'd , ( which was made hollow for that Purpose ) as to make it weigh twice as much as it did before ; and bringing down F , to let it fall but from one foot , it broke thro ' only two Diaphragms by its Fall .
Making the Experiment several times with different Heights , but still keeping the Proportion in Height of four to one , when the Balls were as one and two , the heavy and slowest Ball broke thro ' but half the Number of Papers .
It happened indeed sometimes , that there was some little difference , when the Papers were not equally strong , or equally stretched , but the swiftest Ball always broke through more Papers than the slow one .
Now tho ' this Experiment does at first seem to confirm Polenus 's Theory ; yet , when duly weighed , it proves no such thing .
For the lighter Ball does not break thro ' more Papers , because it has more Force , or a greater Quantity of Motion , but because each Diaphragm has but half the time to resist the Ball , that falls with a double Velocity , and therefore their Resistance being as the time , as many more of them must be broken by the swift Ball , as by the slow one .
P. S. To all the Objectors , that allow the Force of moving Bodies , and their Quantity of Motion to be the same , what has been said in this and my former Paper , seems to be a full Answer ; but as there are now some Philosophers , who distinguish that Force from the Quantity of Motion , I am obliged to say something more for the clearing up of that Point .
If I understand them right , they call vis viva a Force , whose Effect is sensible , as the Force of Gravity , when it accelerates Bodies in their Fall ; and vis mortua a Force , which being destroyed , produces no sensible Effect , as the Force of Gravity acting upon a Weight in one Scale of a Balance , when the Weight cannot descend by reason of a Counterpoise in the other Scale .
But certainly no Man , that considers the thing attentively , would make that Distinction .
However , since Polenus allows , that the Quantity of Motion in Bodies is as the Mass multiplied into the Velocity ( or M V ) ; but says , that the Force , with which they act , which he distinguishes by the Name of vis viva , is as the Mass multiplied into the Square of the Velocity , or MV V : I have made the following Experiment to show his Notion to be inconsistent ; tho all the Phenomenon of unequal Weights applied to a Statera , so as to make an AEquilibrium , might serve for that Purpose , if it had not been objected , that the particular Construction of the Machine hindered it from agreeing with the supposed Theorem , that the Force is as the Matter multiplied into the Square of the Velocity .
EXPERIMEN T. Let two Balls , A and B , ( Pl .
I. Fig. 2 .
) be joined by a String , which going thro ' the smooth Hole C of an even Table , and under the Pulley P , suspends a Weight W. It is plain , that upon letting go the Balls A and B , from the Places A and B , they will move towards C with the same Force , because each of them will be drawn towards C by half the Force of the Weight W , whether the Balls be equal , or unequal .
1 .
The Balls being of two Ounces each ( of Ivory ) were , at the same instant of Time , let loose from A and B , each distant twelve Inches from C , and both came to C at the same Time .
Here the equal Forces will agree with the Product of the Masses into the Velocities , or into the Squares of the Velocities ; because Ax 12 =Bx 12 , as well as Ax 144 is equal to Bx 144 .
2 .
If A be taken of four Ounces Weight , and let go from D , or six Inches , whilst B , still equal to two , moves from 12 Inches ; both Bodies will again meet at C : therefore here the equal Forces must be expressed by the Masses into the Velocities , and not into their Squares ; for tho ' Ax6 be equal to Bx 12 ( 4 x6=2x 12 ) , Ax6x 6 , or 144 is but half of Bx 12 x 12 , or 288 .
Whereas if the Forces had been as Polenus affirms , B should have been let loose only from 8.4 Inches .
3 .
When A is six Ounces , it is let loose only from E , or 4 Inches , to meet at C with B let loose from 12 ; for then Ax4=Bx 12 , whilst Ax4x 4 , or 96 , is three times less than Bx 12 x 12 , or 288 .
So that according to Polenus , B must have been let loose from 7 ; but in that Case it comes sooner to C than A. N. B. The Weight W must be greater than the Weight of both Balls , least the Friction of the Table should spoil the Experiment .

