Philosoph Transact. No. 375 X 4F Fig. 1 .
1C1234 C A 10C 25 B3 2E 1D Fig. 2 .
C AB M g 4f hk3 2e ~ P1d N IX .
An Account of some Experiments made to prove , that the Force of Moving Bodies is proportionable to their Velocities : ( or rather that the Momentum of Moving Bodies is to be found by multiplying the Masses into the Velocities ) In Answer to such who have sometime ago affirmed , that that Force is proportionable to the Square of the Velocity , and to those who still defend the same Opinion .
By the Reverend John Theophilus Desaguliers , LL. D. F.R.S. AS far as I can learn , Monifieur Leibnitz was the first that opposed the received Opinion , concerning the Quantity of the Force of moving Bodies ; by saying , that it was to be estimated by multiplying the Mass of the Bodies , not by their Velocity , but by the Square of it .
But , instead of showing any Paralogism , in the mathematical Demonstrations , which are made use of to prove the Proposition , or any Mistakes in the Reasonings from the Experiments made to confirm it , he uses other Mediums to prove his Assertions a ; and without any Regard to what others had said on that Subject , brings new Arguments , which the Reverend and Learned Dr. Clark has fully answered in his fifth Letter to him .
Messieurs John Bernoulli , Wolfius , Hermannus , and others , have follow 'd and defended ~ Leibnitz 's Opinion , and in the same manner , so that what is an Answer to him , is so to them .
Polenus ( Professor at Padua ) has acted after the same manner in the experimental Way , making some Experiments to defend Monsieur Leibnitz 's Opinion , without having shown those to be false which are made use of to prove the contrary~ ; and now lately , an ingenious Professor abord ( who was of the Opinion commonly received , and in his Writings had demonstrated it in the usful way ~ , confirming it with the common Experiments made in that Case ) happening to make some Experiments like those of Polenus , has drawn Conclusions from them to show the Force of moving Bodies to bo proportionable to the Square of their Velocity ; and being wholly come over to that Opinion , endeavours to deduce it from Physical Principles .
As there can hardly be said any thing new , or better than has been said , to show the Force abovemention 'd to be proportionable to the Mass multiplied into the Velocity ; I only repeat here the Substance of what others have said , and make some old Experiments over again ; but then I consider some Circum~Acte Erudit , ad ann .
1686 .
p. 162 .
~Polenus de Castellis , p.56 , 57 .
&amp; c Gravesande Introductio , Vol. I. No. 132 stances , that perhaps have been overlooked , and at last , by a new Experiment , endeavour to show , what has led into an Error some of those , who defend the new Opinion .
If a Man with a certain Force can move a Weight of fifty Pounds , through a Space of four Feet , in a determinate time ; it is certain he must employ twice that Force to move one hundred Pounds Weight , through the same Space in the same time .
But if he uses but the same Force , he will move the one hundred Pounds Weight but two Feet in the same time .
For as the one hundred Pounds Weight contains two fifty Pound Weights , if each of them has two Degrees of Velocity given to it , it will exactly require the same Force that would give one of them four Degrees of Velocity ; hence it appears , that the Force is proportionable to the Mass multiplied into the Velocity .
EXPERIMENT I. Fig. 1 .
Let the Balance A B , whose Fulchrum , or Center of Motion , is at C , be so divided , that the Brachium AC be but the fourth Part of the Brachium C B ; it is known to all Mechanicians , that a Weight of one hundred Pounds at A , will keep in AEquilibrio a Weight of twenty five Pounds hanging at B , where it will have a Velocity four times greater than that of the Weight at A. For , not only when the Balance is horizontal , there will be anAEquilibrium , but when the Balance is put in Motion , it will return to an AEquilibrium in an horizontal Position ; the equal and contrary Forces applied at each , destroying one another .
Whereas , if the Forces were as the Mass multiplied into the Square of the Velocity , the twenty five Pound Weight should have been suspended at D , only twice as far from C , as the Weight at A ; and in general , let the make of the Engine be what it will , let the mechanical Powers be combined in any manner , when two heavy Bodies , by means of a Machine , act upon one another in different directions , if their Velocities are reciprocally as their Masses , they will destroy each others Forces and come to rest .
As this is true in respect of mechanical Powers , so it is in respect to the Shock or Blow given by falling Bodies .
An heavy Body , falling with an accelerated Motion , goes through a space of one Foot in a quarter of a Second , and acquires a Velocity , which would carry it two Foot in the same Time with an uniform Motion ; the same Body falls through a space of four Foot in half a Second , and acquires a Velocity , that would with an uniform Motion carry it eight Foot in half a Second .
Therefore , as the Time of the fall through a space of four Foot is twice the Time of a fall through one Foot , the Velocity in the latter Case is double that of the first , and consequently the Blow , that the Body will give , will be double .
EXPERIMENT II .
Fig. II .
Let the Weight P of one Pound , be placed in the Scale suspended at the end A , of the Balance A B , which bears upon the Gnomon , or Iron Supporter , kh i. Then if the Weight C be let fall from D , or one Foot , it will by its Stroke on the end of the Beam B , raise up the opposite end A with the Weight P , so high , that the Spring gh will fly from the Button i , which kept it straight and upright before the Shock .
If the Weight P be of two Pounds , it cannot be raised by the fall of C from any height less than F or four Foot ; whereas , if the force of the Shock was proportionable to the Space , without any regard to the time , as Monsieur Leibnitz and his followers have affirmed , P ought to be raised , when C fails only from E , or two Foot , which never happens ; or , if the Stroke was proportionable to the Mass multiplied into the square of the Velocity , when C falls from F , then P might weigh four Pound , whereas the Experiment will never succeed under those Circumstances .
I know it is objected , that the Blow cannot be always direct , and that the String that goes through the hole in the falling Weight , to guide it in its Fall , causes a sensible Friction , and therefore that something of the Force is thereby lost .
But we are to observe , that if that was all , there would be no need of raising up C in the second Case quite up to F , instead of E , whereas in Fact , it must always be raised beyond F , to allow for the Friction , that hinders it from producing a double Effect in falling from F. For if the Experiment be repeated an hundred times , the Weight , P when of two Pounds , will never be raised by letting C fall from any place between E and F. EXPERIMENT III .
If ( in order to avoid Friction ) instead of a Blow struck upon the end B , by the falling Body , the said Body C be fastned to a pretty long String tied to the button m , as at c , and first lifted up one Foot , and then let fall ; so that in falling one Foot , it may pull down B , and lift up A with the Weight P of one Pound ; whenever P is two Pounds , C must fall from a height greater than f or four Foot , otherwise it will not raise the Brachium A , especially if it be let fall between e and f. EXPERIMENT IV .
I took the Weight C of seventeen Ounces Troy , which was a round ball of Lead with a hole through the middle of it , and having passed the String N-X through it , before it was fastened to the Hook X , I placed the whole Machine in such manner , that the String being stretched by the Weight N , went through the hole of the Weight C , and likewise through the hole of the Brachium B , upon which C lay , without touching the sides of the hole either in the Weight or Balance ; then having put such a Weight P in the opposite Scale , as C falling from the height of one Inch , was able to raise high enough , to let loose the Spring gh from the Button i : I added to P another Weight equal to it , and then letting fall C along the String that guided it , from an heighth of two Inches , then of three , and then exactly of four , it would not raise the double Weight P to the former height , but falling from five Inches , or a little higher , it raised it up .
EXPERIMENT V. Leaving every thing as it was before , I changed the Weight C for another leaden Ball of twice the Weight , which falling from one Inch , raised the double Weight P to the usual height ; then changing the Weight P in any Proportion , whatever height was required for the heaviest Ball C ( or C 2 ) to fall from , in order to raise the Weight at P ; more than four times the height was required for the first Ball C , to raise the same Weight so high .
as to let loose the Spring .
EXPERIMENT VI .
I tried the Experiment with the Weight C hanging at the String mc ( as in Experiment III .
) and a Fall from an height of five , or near five Inches , was required to raise double the Weight in the opposite Scale , that a fall from one Inch would raise ; only here the heighth above four Inches was not so great as in the former Experiment , the Friction being something less .
Then I suspended the great Ball C ( or C 2 ) by the String m c , and when by falling one Inch it raised the Weight P , the little Weight C could not produce the same Effect , without falling from a greater height than four Inches .
It is here to be observed , that which way soever these Experiments are tried , the Objections rising from the Friction do no way serve to confirm the new Opinion , because they show that ( upon account of the Friction ) the Heights must be something more than in a duplicate Proportion of the Velocities , but never less , to give a Blow with the same Body in Proportion to the Velocity .
That the Momentum of Bodies is in Proportion to the Mass multiplied into the Velocity , is also most evidently shown from the Congress of elastic Bodies , as has been demonstrated by Sir Isaac Newton in his Principia , in the Corollaries to his Laws of Motion .
I had often tried the Experiments there mentioned with Balls of Ivory and Balls of Glass , and some of them with two Balls of Steel , of two Ounces each , and found every thing answer , allowing for the want of perfect Elasticity in the Bodies .
But now upon this Occasion , as the Objections to the received Opinion were renewed , I was willing to repeat the Experiments with the utmost Accuracy ; and therefore , as Ivory Balls are not equally dense in all their Parts , and Glass Balls break after two or three strokes ; I caused Balls to be nicely turned of Steel , and made as hard ( as the Workmen call it ) that is , as elastick as possible , and the Weights of them were precisely as follows : Two Balls of twelve Ounces Troy each , one of six Ounces , one of three , one of two , and one of Eight-penny-weight .
Then making Pendulums of these Balls , and hanging them upon the Machine contrived by Mariotte for the Congress of Bodies , and lately improved by Dr. Gravesande a , I measured 57 1/ 4 Inches between the Center of Suspension and the Center of Gravity of the Balls , and then every Degree of the Circle they described in their Oscillation was one Inch , and the Degrees being marked upon a line of Chords on a Brass Ruler above the Balls , by their Strings successively covering the cross Lines of Division , the Degrees that the Balls fell from , and those to which they rose , were very discernable to an Eye placed at a convenient Distance .
EXPERIMENT VII .
I took the two Balls 12 , and removing each from the lowest Point of their equal and respective Circles , up to 4 Inches , or 4 Degrees , I let them fall so that they met at bottom , and were both reflected again to 4 , the Place from whence they fell .
EXPERIMENT VIII .
Every thing else being as before , instead of one of the Balls 12 , I took the Ball 6 , then letting 6 go from ~ Introd .
No. 170 .
Vol. ~ 8 Degrees , and 12 from 4 , after Reflection 12 was driven up again to 4 , as before .
EXPERIMENT IX .
The Ball 3 falling from sixteen Degrees met the Ball 12 that fell still from 4 , and after Reflection 12 went up again to 4 .
EXPERIMENT X. The Ball 2 falling from ~ and 12 from ~ , 12 was reflected to 1 , and when 2 fell from 12 Degrees , and the Ball 12 from 2 , the 12 was reflected to 2 .
EXPERIMENT XI .
The Ball of eight Penny Weight ( which weighed but 1/ 30 of the Ball 12 ) falling from fifteen Inches or Degrees , raised up 12 ( that fell from half a Degree ) to the same Place again .
In all these Experiments the Error , or want of perfect Reflection , was greater in the little Balls than in the great ones , on account of their going thro ' a greater Arc of a Circle , whereby they deviated more from a Cycloid than the great ones ; as likewise on Account of the Resistance of the Air , which must be greater because of the little Balls going through a greater Arc , moving with more Velocity , being suspended by a String as thick as that of the great ones , and having more Surface in Proportion to their Weight .
But all the Errors do not bring the Phenomenon any thing near what they ought to be , ifthe Force of the Bodies was as the Square of their Velocities multiplied into their Masses , for then the Ball 12 would have been driven to Heights very different from what it rose up to .
In the eighth Experiment , the Ball 12 should have risen to near five Inches and three quarters , for the Ball 6 falling with the Velocity , 8 must have had its Force =8~8~6= 384 ; and then , that the Ball 12 might have the same Force or Quantity of Motion , it must rise near to 5 , 7 because 5,7 ~ 5,7 ~ 12 = 389,88 .
In the ninth , 12 should have risen to 8 ; for the Ball 3 must have had its Force = 16 ~ 16 ~3= 768 , and if 12 received its whole Force it must have risen to 8 because 8~8~ 12 = 768 .
In the second Part of the tenth Experiment , 12 should have risen to near 5 , because 12 ~ 12 ~2= 288 , and 5~5~ 12 is but 300 .
In the eleventh , the Ball 12 ( thirty times heavier than the little one ) must have gone to 2 3/ 4 Inches , because the Momentum of the little Ball being = 15 ~ 15 ~1= 225 , that of the Ball 12 must be = 2,75 ~ 2,75 ~ 12 = 226 &amp;c. It may be here alleged , that one ought to subtract the Momentum , with which the great Ball comes upon the little one ; but that wo n't mend the Matter much , tho ' indeed the Difference will be less .
For , In the eighth Experiment , if we subtract 4~4~ 12 = 192 from 389,88 there will remain 197,88 , and the Ball 12 will go but to 4 ; but then in Experiment 9 , if we subtract the same No 192 from 768 , we shall have 576 , which would carry 12 to near seven Degrees , because 7~7~ 12 = 588 .
In the tenth Experiment , there is only 48 to be subtracted ; and in the eleventh only 15 ; and therefore the Velocity of 12 will very much fall short of what is agreeable to the new Opinion .
After the Experiments made , and what has been said , till these Consequences are overthrown , no notice ought to be taken of any Objections , or new Experiments .
ments .
But to give the Objectors all possible Satisfaction , I shall , in another Paper , endeavour to show the Fallacies of the Arguments , and solve the Phenomenon of the Experiments made ; showing , both by Reason and Experiment , that the Facts ought to be as they are , in consequence of the received Opinion and Laws of Resistance .

