VI .
A Letter to the Learned Dr. Caleb Cotesworth , F. R. S. of the College of Physicians , London , and Physician to St. Thomas 's Hospital ; containing a Comparison between the Danger of the Natural Small Pox , and of that given by Inoculation .
By James Jurin , M. D. R. S. Secret .
SIR , THE sincere and disinterested Regard for the Good of Mankind , which you have always manifested , as well in your extensive private Practice , as in that public Post , which you have so long and so usefully filled , must affect you , I am sure , with a great and sensible Concern for the Destruction made among us by that terrible Calamity the Small Pox .
We have seen , for some considerable Time past , above 100 Persons per Week in this City and Suburbs , taking one Week with another , to be carried off by this Disease ; a Consideration certainly that ought to dispose us to enter into any Measures , by which we may reasonably hope to put some Stop to the Progress of so cruel a Distemper .
To this Purpose , Sir , the Method of Inoculation , which has lately been introduced among us , is strongly recommended on the one hand , and has been opposed with a great deal of Warmth and Zeal on the other .
I have no Inclination to enter into this Controversy ; it is in better and abler Hands : but , as the Point in Dispute is of the utmost Importance to Mankind , I heartily wish , that , without Passion , Prejudice , or private Views , it may be fairly and maturely examined .
In order to which , if the following Extracts and Computations , concerning the comparative Danger of the Inoculated and Natural Small Pox , may be of any Use to your self , or to other impartial and disinterested Judges , I shall think my Labour well bestowed .
The Number of Persons , who have had the Small Pox by Inoculation here in England , is , by the best Information I have been able to collect , as follows .
Inoculated by Dr. Nettleton 61 Claudius Amyand , Esq ; Serjeant Surgeon 17 Mr. Maitland , Surgeon 57 Dr. Dover 4 Mr. Weymish , Surgeon 3 The Reverend Mr. Johnson 3 Dr. Brady , at Portsmouth 4 Mr. Smith , Surgeon , and Mr. Dymer , ~ 13 Apothecary , at Chichester Mr. Waller , Apothecary at Gosport 3 A Woman at Leicester 8 Dr. Williams at Haverford West 6 Two other Persons near the same Place 2 Dr. French , at Bristol 1 In all 182 Out of this Number the Opposers of Inoculation affirm , that two Persons died of the Inoculated Small Pox ; the Favourers of this Practice maintain , that their Death was occasioned by other Causes .
If , to avoid dispute , these two be allow 'd to have died of Inoculation , we must estimate the hazard of dying of the Inoculated Small Pox , as far as can be collected from our own Experience , to be that of 2 out of 182 , or one out of 91 .
The Reverend Mr. Mather , in a Letter dated March 10 .
1721 .
from Boston in New England , gives an Account , That of near 300 inoculated there , 5 or 6 died upon it or after it , but from other Diseases and Accidents , chiefly from having taken the Infection in the common way by Inspiration , before it could be given them in this way of Transplantation .
If , as we have done before , to avoid all occasion of dispute , we allow 5 out of these 300 to have died of the Small Pox by Inoculation , notwithstanding what Mr. Mather has said of their dying by other Accidents or Diseases ; the hazard of Inoculation will thence be determined to be that of 1 in about 60 .
But here it must be observed , that by all the Accounts from New England , the Operators there appear not to have been so cautious in the choice of their Subjects , as here in England .
For Mr. Mather tells us , that the Persons inoculated were young and old , from 1 Year to 70 , weak and strong ; and by other relations we are informed , that Women with Child , and others even in Childbed , underwent the Operation .
Apparently the Greatness of the Danger they were in , from the Infection in the natural Way , which then raged among them with the utmost Fury , made them the more adventurous .
We come now , Sir , to the second Part of our Design , which is to form an Estimate of the Hazard , which all Mankind , one with another , are under of dying of the natural Small Pox , that , by comparing this with the Hazard of Inoculation , the Public may be enabled to form a Judgment , whether or no the Practice of Inoculation tends to the Preservation of Mankind , by lessening the Danger to which they are otherwise liable .
With this View I have consulted the Yearly Bills of Mortality , as far back as the Year 1667 , being the Year after the Plague and the Fire of London , comprehending to the present Time the Space of 56 Years , from 42 of which I have given Extracts in the two following Tables .
The first of these takes in the first 20 Years , distinguishing for every Year the total Number of Burials , and likewise the Number that died of the Small Pox , in two separate Columns .
The third Column shows , how many died of the Small Pox out of every Thousand that were buried ; and the fourth Column represents the Proportion between those that died of the Small Pox , and the whole Number of Burials , by the nearest Vulgar Fraction , having always 1 for the Numerator .
The second Table gives the last 22 Years , after the same manner , and at the bottom of each Table is given the Total Number for each Series of Years , and likewise the Number that died each Year , taken at a Medium , one Year with another : by which it appears , that the Proportion between the Number of those that die of the Small Pox , and the whole Number of Burials , is very nearly the same , upon an Average for each Series of Years .
The 14 intermediate Years between 1686 and 1701 are left out , because in the Bills for those Years , the Accounts of the Small Pox and Measles are not distinguished , as in the preceding and following Years , but are joined together in one Article , so that from them no certain Account can be drawn of the Number of Persons , that died of the Small Pox .
TABLE I. Total No Died of the Small Pox .
Years of Burials In all .
In 1000 In Proportion 1667 15842 1196 75 1/ 13 1668 17278 1987 115 1/ 9 1669 19432 951 49 1/ 20 1670 20198 1465 73 1/ 14 1671 15729 696 44 1/ 23 1672 18230 1116 61 1/ 16 1673 17504 853 49 1/ 21 1674 21201 2507 118 1/ 8 1675 17244 997 58 1/ 17 1676 18732 359 19 1/ 52 1677 19067 1678 88 1/ 11 1678 20678 1798 87 1/ 12 1679 21730 1967 91 1/ 11 1680 21053 689 33 1/ 31 1681 23971 2982 125 1/ 8 1682 20691 1408 68 1/ 15 1683 20587 2096 102 1/ 10 1684 23202 156 7 1/ 149 1685 23222 2496 107 1/ 9 1686 22609 1062 47 1/ 21 20 Years 398200 28459 71 1/ 2 1/ 14 Each Year at 19910 1423 71 1/ 2 1/ 14 TABLE II .
Total No Died of the Small Pox .
Years of Burials In all .
In 1000 In Proportion .
1701 20471 1095 53 1/ 19 1702 19481 311 16 1/ 63 1703 20720 898 43 ~ 1704 22684 1501 66 ~ 1705 22097 1095 50 1/ 20 1706 19847 721 36 1/ 28 1707 21600 1078 50 1/ 20 1708 21291 1687 79 1/ 13 1709 21800 1024 47 1/ 21 1710 24620 3138 127 1/ 8 1711 19833 915 46 1/ 22 1712 21198 1943 92 1/ 11 1713 21057 1614 77 ~ 1714 26569 2810 106 1/ ~ 1715 22232 1057 48 1/ 21 1716 24436 2427 99 1/ 10 1717 23446 2211 94 1/ 11 1718 26523 1884 71 1/ 14~ 1719 28347 3229 114 1/ ~ 1720 25454 1440 57 1/ 18 1721 26142 2375 91 1/ 11 1722 25750 2167 84 1/ 12 22 Years 505598 36620 72 1/ 14 Each Year at 22982 1665 72 1/ 14 a Medium .
42 Years 903798 65079 72 1/ 14 Each Year in 42 at a Me21519 1550 72 ~/ 14 By these Tables it appears , that upwards of seven per Cent. or somewhat more than a fourteenth part of Mankind , die of the Small Pox ; and consequently the hazard of dying of that Distemper , to every individual born into the World , is at least that of one in fourteen .
And that this Hazard increases after the Birth , as the Child advances in Age , will appear from what follows .
From this Estimate it is demonstrable , that , in the Case of Persons actually having the Small Pox , the Hazard that they run , one with another , of dying of that Distemper , is greater than that of one in fourteen ; or , which is the same thing , there must be fewer than thirteen , that recover , for one that dies of the Small Pox .
For since one fourteenth part of Mankind die of the Small Pox , and the other thirteen parts die of other Diseases ; if these thirteen have all had the Small Pox , and recovered from it , before they fell ill of those other Diseases of which they died , then just thirteen will have recovered from the Small Pox , for one that dies of that Distemper : but , as it is notorious , that great Numbers , especially of young Children , die of other Diseases , without ever having the Small Pox , it .
is plain , that fewer than thirteen must recover from this Distemper , for one that dies of it .
To determine exactly how many of these thirteen Parts of Mankind , die without having the Small Pox , is a very difficult Task : but it is easy to see , that a considerable Deduction is to be made from them .
In the first place , the two Articles of Stilborn and Abortive Children , which are put into the yearly Bills , as part of the Number of Burials , are unquestionably to be deducted .
With these two , Sir , you will not I believe , think it unreasonable to join the following Heads , which , by the best Information I can procure , comprehend only very young Children , or at most not above one or two Years of Age .
Overlaid , Chrysoms and Infants , Convulsions , Horseshoehead , Headmoldshot , Teeth , Water in the Head , Worms , Rickets , Livergrown , ChinCough , and Hooping-Cough , which Articles in the Yearly Bills for 22 Years last past , amount at a medium to 386 in each 1000 , of the whole Number of Burials .
It is true indeed , that , in all Probability , some small part of these must have gone thro ' the Small Pox , and therefore ought not to be deducted out of the Account : but then , on the other hand , as it is certain , that of the remaining 614/ 1000 of Mankind , that are above one or two Years of Age , there are great Numbers , that never have the Small Pox , it will I presume be judged to be no unequal Supposition , if I suppose all that are contained under the Heads abovemention 'd , to have missed that Distemper , when by way of Compensation , I allow all the remainder of Mankind to undergo it ; which Concession is so large , that it will abundantly make up for what I assume too much in the former Supposition .
Allowing therefore , that out of every 1000 Children that are born , 386 die under one or two Years of Age , without having the Small Pox , and 72 do some time or other die of that Distemper ; it follows , that the Hazard of dying of it , to the remainder of Mankind , above one or two Years of Age , who are all supposed to undergo that Disease sooner or later , is that of 72 out of 614 , or nearly 2 out of 17 : so that no more , than between 7 and 8 , can recover from that Distemper , for one that dies of it .
And if any consirable part of the aforesaid remainder of Mankind , more than is allow 'd for above~ do escape having the Small Pox , then the Proportion of those that recover from it , will be still smaller .
This Consideration shows the Fallacy of one plausible Argument , that has been often made use of on occasion of the present Disputes about Inoculation : Which is , that whatever be the Danger of dying of the Small Pox , to those that actually have that Disease , yet , as great Numbers of Persons never have the Small Pox at all , this Danger is what any particular Person may never be in ; and therefore it will be Madness to undergo the hazard of Inoculation , be it great or small , in order to prevent a Disease , which possibly may never besal one .
For if two parts in seventeen of all Mankind , that are above one or two Years of Age , must sooner or later die of the Small Pox , it is plain , that how many parts soever of these seventeen are supposed to escape that Distemper , the Mortality among the remainder , who undergo it , must in proportion be so much the greater .
As for instance , if 7 parts escape having the Small Pox , and 10 undergo it , then 2 out of 10 , or 1 out of 5 , that have the Small Pox , must die of that Disease .
And as it can never be known , whether or no any particular Person be one of those , that are to have the Small Pox ; his Hazard of dying of that Distemper , being made up of the Hazard of having it , and the Hazard of dying of it , if he has it , will be exactly the same , namely , that of 2 in 17 , or 1 in 8 or 9 , whether the proportion of Mankind , that escape having the Small Pox , be great or small .
But as what has been said concerning the Hazard of the natural Small Pox , is taken from an Account of 42 Years ; whereas the Hazard of Inoculation is estimated only from what has happened in the space of about 18 Months , since which time it had its first Rise among us ; it will perhaps be asked by some Persons , why we do not likewise make the Estimate of the hazard of the natural Small Pox , from the last two Years alone , without running back into so great a number of Years , before Inoculation was begun ?
To which we answer , that the Proportion of those that die of the Small Pox , varies so much in different Years , as appears from the Tables above , that it was impossible to come at any Certainty in this point , from the consideration of the two last Years alone : and if any one suspects us of Partiality in proceeding after the manner we have done , he need only cast his Eyes upon the second Table , where he will find , that the Mortality of the natural Small Pox , for the two last Years , has considerably exceeded the Medium we have determined , from taking in two and forty Years .
There is another Method , which , if it were put in practice in several large Towns , or Parishes , and for a sufficient Number of Years , would enable us to come at a nearer and still more certain Computation of the Proportion between those that recover , and those that die of the Small Pox : which is , to send a careful Person once a Year , from house to house , to enquire what Persons have had the Small Pox , and how many have died of it , in the preceding Year .
This has been done by Dr. Nettleton the last Year , at several Towns in Yorkshire , &amp;c. and the same was done at Chichester for the same Year , to the 15th of October last , by a Person of Credit , whose Account was communicated to me by my learned and ingenious Friend , Dr. Whitaker .
snch another Account has been transmitted to me from Haverford West , in South Wales , by the Learned Dr. Perrot Williams , Physician in that Place .
The Sum of these Accounts is as follows .
Sick of the Small Pox .
Died .
Several Towns in Yorkshire3405 636 Chichester 994 168 Haverford West 227 52 Total 4626 856 From which it appears , that , upon a Medium between these Accounts , there died of the Small Pox almost 19 per Cent. or nearly one in five , of Persons of all Ages , that underwent that Distemper .
Which is the more to be remarked , for that out of 82 Persons , that had the Small Pox by Inoculation , the same Year , and in the Neighbourhood of the same Places , not one miscarried .
Mr. Mather observes , in his Letter mentioned above , that out of more than 5000 Persons that had the Small Pox at Boston in New England , within little more than half a Year , near 900 died , which is more than one in six ; and this Account added to those from Yorkshire , Chichester , andWales , reduces the Proportion of those that die of the Small Pox to somewhat more than 18 per Cent. so that the Hazard of dying of that Distemper , to those who are taken ill of it , is that of one in between five and six , or something above two in eleven .
The Result therefore , Sir , of these Computations is , that , if the same Proportions should still continue , as have hitherto been determined by Observation , we must expect , That of all the Children that are born , there will , some time or other , die of the Small Pox , one in fourteen .
That of Persons of all Ages taken ill of the natural Small Pox , there will die of that Distemper , one in five or six , or two in eleven .
That of Persons of all Ages inoculated , without regard to the Healthiness or Unhealthiness of the Subject , as was practised in New England , there will die one in sixty .
That of Persons inoculated with the same Caution in the choice of the Subjects , as has been used by the several Operators one with another , here in England , ( if we allow in the two disputed Cases abovemention 'd , that the Persons died of the inoculated Small Pox ) there will die one in ninety one .
But if those two Persons be allowed to have died of other Accidents or Diseases , then we shall have reason to think , as far as any Judgement can be made from our own Experience here in England , that none at all will die of Inoculation , provided that proper Caution be used ; as we are informed , on all hands , is the Case in Turkey : where out of many thousands , that , in the space of about forty Years past , have been inoculated in and about Constantinople , by one Greek Woman , who still continues that Practice , notwithstanding her extreme old Age , not so much as one Person has miscarried , as I am assured by the ingenious Dr. le Duc , a Native of Constantinople , who was himself inoculated there under the Care of his Father , an eminent Physician in that City .
I am , &amp;c. POSTSCRIP T. SINCE this Paper was drawn up and communicated to the Royal Society , the following Account of the Success of Inoculation in and about Boston , in New England , was procured at my Desire , by my Ingenious Friend Dr. Nesbitt , from Capt. John Osborne , who resided in that Town and Neighbourhood during the whole time of that Practice .
I think proper to insert it here , as it confirms the Extract given above from Mr. Mather 's Relation , and is a more particular Account of the Matter of Fact , than any that I have yet seen .
In May , 1721 .
the Small Pox was , by the Providence of God , brought into the Town of Boston ; in June it began to spread pretty much , and in the Month of July it was got into most parts of the Town , and a considerable Number of People died of it .
At this time Inoculation was first put in practice by Dr. Boyleston , who then performed it upon his own Child and a Negro-Servant , who both did well ; notwithstanding which , this Attempt gave great Uneasiness to the Neighbours .
However the Practice went on , to the Number of about 40 Persons , one of which was a Woman ~ of about 40 or 45 Years of Age , who got well over the Small Pox , as her Husband publicly declared , but had been before troubled with Hysteric Fits , of which she died some little time after .
When about 70 Persons had passed under the Operation , myself and Wife , who had hitherto been at a Place called Roxbury , a Mile from Boston , went into * Mrs. Dixwell .
Town and received the Small Pox by Inoculation .
We had it with all the Gentleness and Moderation that was possible , neither of us having an hundred Pustules , or being sensible of any Fever worth mentioning ; so that we did not find it necessary to keep our Beds for it .
In August the Small Pox in the natural Way proved more mortal , and Inoculation made a greater Progress , the People continuing to come into the Practice of it .
A second Person that died after Inoculation , was an Apothecary 's Housekeeper , that was out of Town , till an Indian Maid got the Distemper in the same House , and removed , and died .
Upon which this Woman coming to Town , her Master undertook to perform the Operation upon her , which by the Way was the first and last that he ever performed ; and on the third Day after the Inoculation , the Small Pox came out upon her very full ; from which it was plain , that she had taken the Infection before , in the common way .
The third Person that died after being inoculated , was a~ Gentleman , that lodged in the same House with my Wife and self at Roxbury , who was under great and extreme Infirmity of Body , as myself was Witness , that we feared he would have lived but a short time under it .
His Friends much persuaded him to make use of Inoculation , believing that it would have carried off his Illness ; but when he made the Experiment , he had not Strength to go thro ' with it .
He was about 45 Years of Age , and by the way was a Gentleman of great Worth and Piety .
His Sister ~ was the fourth Person that died upon this Operation .
She was about forty Years of Age , ~ John White , Esq ; ~ Mrs. Wells .
of great Indisposition of Body , and weak , as was her Brother .
The fifth , that died upon Inoculation , was a Woman Servant in a House , where the whole Family , to the number of eight , were inoculated at the same time .
She lay in a cold upper Room during her Illness , and was much neglected , the whole Family being down together , so that she died merely for want of a little Attendance .
This was in the Town of Roxbury , where observe , that 13 Men , Masters of Families , got the Small Pox , and all died ; which inclined the People to make use of Inoculation , having before been much against it , and there were 43 Men inoculated there , who all did well .
The * Minister of the Town was the first , that put it in Practice there , much against the Mind of his People at first , though afterwards they were very well pleased with it , seeing with what great Success it was attended ; and then whole Families came into it , and underwent the Operation .
There were in all at least 280 Persons inoculated , that I knew of , and I suppose there might be about 20 or 30 more , but of those I can give no certain Account .
John Osborne .
* The Reverend Mr. Walter .

